Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 146 of 2015
Shri Satya Narayan Roy
Date of Decision: 06.04.2021
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Vs.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Nongbri, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A.H. Hazarika, GA. for R 1-4.
_______________________________________________________________
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
1.
Yes/No
Yes/No
The factual aspects of this case as culled out from the materials on
record is that the Petitioner was appointed as UB/Constable in the Meghalaya
Police w.e.f. 15.02.1990 vide appointment Order No. 1584 dated 15.02.1990
issued by the Superintendent of Police, East Khasi Hills District, Shillong.
2.
On 26.03.1999 the Petitioner was promoted as Assistant Sub-Inspector
of Police. Thereafter, in the year 2004, the post of Assistant Sub-Inspector
was abolished and he was then promoted to the rank of Sub-Inspector vide
D.O. No 3157 dated 20.09.2004 issued under the authority of the Director
General of Police, Meghalaya.
3.
In the year 2011, the Petitioner was placed under suspension and
disciplinary proceedings were initiated against him allegedly on the charge
of availing 30 days earned leave without obtaining prior permission from the
competent authority. The said proceedings culminated in penalty of stoppage
of 3(three) increments, but however he was reinstated in service.
4.
The Petitioner then received another Show Cause notice dated
29.11.2011 appended thereto includes the Statement of Allegation, wherein
it has been alleged that he was involved in a criminal case being Laitumkhrah
P.S. Case No 18(3) 2011 under Section 365/366 A IPC which included a
charge that he has indulged in immoral activities which amounts to moral
turpitude, thereby tarnishing the department as a whole.
5.
Departmental Proceedings No. 13 of 2011 was then drawn up against
the Petitioner and an Enquiry Officer, Shri S.A. Rynjah, MPS, Additional
Superintendent of Police (Traffic), East Khasi Hills, Shillong was appointed
to take up the proceedings.
6.
The Enquiry Officer has then examined 12(twelve) witnesses and
apparently, on completion of the same, the Petitioner, vide Memo No.
RE/GEN/PT-III/2013/5443 dated Shillong, the 01.07.2013 (Annexure-18 of
the writ petition) was served with the second Show Cause notice along with
a copy of the Enquiry Report, directing him to show cause within 5(five) days
as to why the sternest punishment as laid down in Rule 66 of Part III of Assam
Police Manual should not be inflicted on him.
7.
The Petitioner then filed his show cause and the Superintendent of
Police, East Khasi Hills, Shillong vide D.O. No 1993 dated 10.08.2013
(Annexure-21 of the writ petition) issued the order discharging the Petitioner
from service with immediate effect. This order was later modified vide D.O.
No. 2013 dated 13.08.2013 (Annexure-22 of the writ petition) to modify the
penalty imposed from that of ‘Discharge’ to one of ‘Dismissal’.
8.
Aggrieved by the said order of dismissal from service, the Petitioner
then preferred an appeal before the Appellate Authority/ Deputy Inspector
General of Police(ER), who vide Memo No MRF/IV-278/9-A dated
08.01.2014 rejected the appeal. This prompted the Petitioner to prefer another
appeal before the Hon’ble Governor of Meghalaya which was not accepted
since an appeal was already preferred before the Appellate Authority.
9.
Finally, the Petitioner has approached this Court with this instant
petition with a prayer to set aside and quash the impugned Show Cause notice
dated 29.11.2011, the Inquiry Proceedings and related report and the
Termination Letter dated 13.08.2013.
10.
It may be mentioned that the Petitioner was released from suspension
vide D.O. No 4102 dated 13.08.2012 and was allowed to join his duties,
however the condition is that departmental proceedings against him will
continue.
11.
Heard Mr. P. Nongbri, learned counsel for the Petitioner who has
submitted that at the time when the Show Cause was issued to the Petitioner,
no copies of the documents to be relied on by the Respondents were furnished
to him, nor was the list of witnesses to be examined by the Respondents made
known to him, thus hampering his preparation of the written statement of
defence. Inspite of this, the Petitioner has filed his statement of defence. The
case of Committee of Management, Kisan Degree College v. Shambhu
Saran Pandey & Ors: (1995) 1 SCC 404, paragraph 5 and the case of
Chandra Tiwari v. Union of India: (1987) Supp. SCC 518, paragraphs 4, 9
was relied upon by the Petitioner in this connection.
12.
According to the Petitioner, the relevant documents required to be
inspected by him includes (1) Copy of the FIR in Laitumkhrah P.S Case No.
18(3) 2011 under Section 365/366A IPC (2) Entry of the Hotel Register of
Hotel Assembly dated 17.03.2011 (3) Statements of witnesses recorded
under Section 161/164 Cr.P.C (4) Forwarding Report of the I/O (5) Order
sheet of the Court of Laitumkhrah P.S Case No. 18(3) 2011 under Section
365/366A IPC (6) Case Diary of Laitumkhrah P.S Case No. 18(3) 2011 under
Section 365/366A IPC (7) Confessional Statements made by any accused
person and (8) D.P. No. 2/11. However, only the report of the O/C
Laitumkhrah Police Station and letter No. MG/XX-37/2008/88, dated
21.11.2011 were made available to him. This according to the Petitioner has
caused serious prejudice to his case as far as his written statement of defence
is concerned.
13.
The next contention of the Petitioner is that he was not given an
opportunity to cross-examine the 12(twelve) witnesses produced on behalf of
the department and also the fact that the alleged victims were not called for
examination in the proceeding, which has seriously affected the cause of the
Petitioner, inasmuch as, he was not able to confront the witnesses with his
side of the story. On this issue, the Petitioner has relied on the following case
laws;
(i)
Hardwari Lal v. State of U.P: (1999) 8 SCC 582, paragraphs 3 &
5.
(ii)
Bhupinder Pal Singh v. Director General of Civil Aviation:
(2003) 3 SCC 633, paragraph 3.
(iii)
A. Sudhakar v. Postmaster General, Hyderabad & Anr: (2006) 4
SCC 348, paragraphs 25 & 26.
14.
On the second Show Cause notice dated 01.07.2013, the Petitioner has
submitted that he was denied an opportunity to represent against the findings
in the enquiry report and was asked to Show Cause as to why the sternest of
punishment as laid down under the rules should not be inflicted on him which
is an empty formality since the disciplinary authority has already prejudged
his case. Nevertheless, the Petitioner has submitted his Show Cause dated
10.07.2013. Thereafter, the impugned order of dismissal was issued against
him. The case of Babulal Das v. State of Assam: (2004) 2 GLT 259,
paragraph 13 was cited in this regard.
15.
Mr. Nongbri has submitted that it is the contention of the Petitioner
that the entire disciplinary proceedings initiated against him is vitiated and
not maintainable, inasmuch as, the alleged incident happened in the year
2011 and by that time, the Meghalaya Police Act, 2010 which has repealed
the Police Act which is prevalent in the State of Meghalaya, had come into
force vide Notification dated 07.02.2011. The said disciplinary proceeding
against the Petitioner was initiated in exercise of power under Section 7 of
the Police Act, 1861 read with Rule 66 of the Assam Police Manual Part II
and as such, the purported exercise of the said powers was a nullity from its
inception. The case of Meytush Ch. Sangma v. State of Meghalaya & Ors
in W.P. (C) No. 96 of 2016 was referred to by the learned counsel wherein
this Court vide order dated 05.04.2018 has held that the old police Act was
amended in the year 2010 by the Meghalaya Police Act, 2010 and as such,
any inquiry to be done should be under the Meghalaya Police Act, 2010 and
not under the old repealed Act.
16.
Another contention raised by the Petitioner according to Mr. Nongbri
is that there has been a violation of the provisions of Article 311 (1) of the
Constitution of India, inasmuch as, the Petitioner was initially appointed as
Constable by the Superintendent of Police, East Khasi Hills, Shillong.
Subsequently, he was promoted to the rank of Sub Inspector of Police under
the orders of the Director General of Police, Meghalaya and as such, the
Director General of Police being the Appointing Authority for the Petitioner
in the post of Sub-Inspector, the Superintendent of Police being inferior in
rank to the Director General of Police does not have the competence to
discharge or dismiss the Petitioner from service. The case of Gojendra
Chandra Bora v. State of Assam: (1987) 2 GLR 183 was cited in support of
this contention.
17.
Finally, Mr. Nongbri has submitted that because of the arbitrary action
of the Respondents as far as the conduct of the disciplinary proceedings
against the Petitioner is concerned, the rules of procedural natural justice has
been violated and therefore, the entire proceeding is liable to be set aside and
quashed. The case of Dr. Rash Lal Yadav v. State of Bihar: (1994) 5 SCC
267, paragraph 6 was relied upon on this point.
18.
The counter of Mr. A.H. Hazarika, learned GA with regard to the
contention of the Petitioner that the entire proceeding in exercise of the power
under Section 7 of the Police Act, 1861 read with Rule 66 of the Assam Police
Manual is a nullity from its inception since the said Police Act of 1861 was
repealed by the Meghalaya Police Act, 2010, is that it is not correct as the
relevant Notification dated 09.07.2015 No. HPL.181/2003/140 conveyed the
order of the Governor that pending finalization of the Meghalaya Police
Manual, Part I to VI of the Assam Police Manual as adopted by the State of
Meghalaya shall continue to remain in force with effect from the date of
coming into force of the Meghalaya Police Act, 2010 and until further orders.
This Notification has not been challenged by the Petitioner at the relevant
time and as such, the provisions of the Assam Police Manual as stated above
is still in force in the State of Meghalaya and the Petitioner has rightly been
dismissed under the said provisions.
19.
Mr Hazarika has further submitted that it is not a fact that the Petitioner
was not allowed to cross-examine the witnesses. On the contrary, he has
clearly declined to cross-examine the witnesses and his signature has also
been noted in the depositions, being an educated police officer, he is very
much aware of the procedure and as such, he cannot come at this stage and
say that he was forced to sign by the Enquiry Officer.
20.
On the contention of the Petitioner that the copies of the documents
relied upon by the department at the Enquiry was not supplied to him, the
learned GA has submitted that all the documents have been supplied to the
Petitioner, except the privileged documents which are documents from the
criminal case against the Petitioner and here too, he was advised to apply for
the same from the concerned court as he is the accused in the said case and
there is no difficulty for him to get the said documents.
21.
Mr. Hazarika has also submitted that the contention of the Petitioner
that he was promoted by the Director General of Police and hence the
Superintendent of Police who is inferior in rank could not have dismissed
him from service is not correct as Rule 11 and 30 of the Assam Police Manual
Part III provides that the Superintendent of Police is the Appointing
Authority of Sub-Inspector of Police.
22.
In support of the case of the Respondents, Mr. Hazarika has cited the
following cases:
(i)
Tage Habung v. State of Arunachal Pradesh & Ors: (2003) 3
GLR 657, paragraphs 37, 41-45.
(ii)
Sarva Uttar Pradesh Gramin Bank v. Manoj Kumar Sinha:
(2010) 3 SCC 556, paragraphs 28, 29, 36, 37, 38 & 39.
(iii)
Union of India & Ors v. Bishamber Das Dogra: (2009) 13 SCC
102, paragraphs 21, 22, 31-36.
23.
In his reply, Mr. Nongbri has submitted that the Notification No. HPL
181/2003/140 dated 09.07.2015 as regard the applicability of the Part I to VI
of the Assam Police Manual to the State of Meghalaya in view of the repeal
of the Police Act, 1861 has no relevance in the case of the Petitioner as the
impugned notification clearly states that the action initiated was according to
section 7 of the Police Act, 1861, which has since been repealed.
24.
That the contention that the Superintendent of Police is the Appointing
Authority is not correct asserts Mr. Nongbri, since the related communication
being copy of the D.O. No 3157 dated 20.09.2004 (Annexure-4 of the writ
petition) has clearly indicated that it was the Director General of Police who
has promoted the Petitioner and others from the post of Assistant SubInspector of Police to Sub-Inspector of Police.
25.
Again, on the contention of the Respondents that the Petitioner was
supplied with all the documents relied upon by the Department at the Enquiry
and was further advised to approach the Court for the privileged documents,
Mr. Nongbri has submitted that this statement was refuted in the Rejoinder
Affidavit of the Petitioner at paragraph 7 when he averred that inspite of
reminders issued to the department being letter dated 13.12.2011 and
20.01.2012, the same was never supplied to the Petitioner.
26.
I have carefully considered the argument advanced by the respective
counsels for the parties and having done so, what is required to be dealt with
by this Court to come to a proper finding is to examine the main issue of
contention between the parties.
27.
Without going back to the submission of the parties which has been
enumerated above, the first point to be considered is whether the disciplinary
proceeding against the Petitioner was rightly and properly initiated under the
relevant provision of the laws and rules. Admittedly, vide related Memo No.
RE/GEN/PT-III/2011/912, dated Shillong the 29.11.2011 which is the Show
Cause notice issued to the Petitioner in connection with D.P No. 13 of 2011,
the Superintendent of Police in exercise of power conferred under Section 7
(seven) of the Police Act (Act V of 1861) read with Rule 66 of Assam Police
Manual Part III, as adapted by the Government of Meghalaya has called upon
the Petitioner to Show Cause as to why penalty specified in Rule 66 of the
Assam Police Manual Part III should not be inflicted on him. The Petitioner
has referred to the Meghalaya Police Act, 2010 which came into force in the
State of Meghalaya vide notification dated 07.02.2011 and leading this Court
to Section 136 of the same has submitted that the Police Act, 1861 have been
repealed by the said Meghalaya Police Act and as such, any exercise of
powers under the old Act was a nullity right from inception thereby rendering
the proceedings against the Petitioner null and void.
In reply to this, the State Respondent has submitted that vide
Notification No. HPL 181/2003/140, dated 09.07.2015, the Assam Police
Manual Part I to VI as adopted by the Government of Meghalaya shall remain
in force from the date of coming into force of the Meghalaya Police Act, 2010
until further orders, this, pending finalisation of the Meghalaya Police
Manual.
28.
At this juncture, it would be proper to take a look at sub-Section 2 of
Section 136 of the Meghalaya Police Act, 2010 which reads as follows:
(2) Notwithstanding such repeal, anything done or any action
taken under the Acts so repealed shall be deemed to have been
done or taken under the corresponding provisions of this Act.
The above, read conjointly with the contents of the said Notification
No. HPL.181/2003/140 dated 09.07.2015 would show that at the time when
the disciplinary proceeding was initiated against the Petitioner, Part I to VI
of the Assam Police Manual is still applicable. It may be mentioned that this
Court with due respect would say that had this Notification been brought to
the notice of the then Hon’ble Judge in the case of Meytush Ch. Sangma
(supra), the outcome would have been different. The objection raised by the
Petitioner on this point is therefore not sustainable.
29.
The next contention of the Petitioner is that he was not supplied with
copies of the relevant documents sought to be relied upon by the Department
before the enquiry, this too, inspite of seeking for the same in writing and on
non receipt of the same, reminders were issued to no avail. This action of the
Department has greatly prejudiced his case and is thus a violation of the
principles of natural justice which has resulted in the entire Enquiry to be
vitiated.
30.
On this issue, the Petitioner has admitted that some of the documents
were furnished to him, however other documents were not supplied to him.
The learned GA has however maintained that all the relevant documents were
supplied to the Petitioner except some privileged documents which are part
of the police papers and documents of the said Laitumkhrah P.S. case No.
18(3)2011. The learned GA has however not been able to convince this Court
that such privileged documents were never used against the Petitioner in the
Enquiry. In fact, records would show that one of the witnesses on behalf of
the Department is the learned Magistrate who has recorded the statements of
the alleged victims under section 164 Cr. P.C. The same has figured in the
Enquiry Report as part of the findings and this has indeed prejudiced the
Petitioner, inasmuch as, he was not made aware beforehand as to what was
the contents in the said statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. to enable him to
defend himself.
31.
The case of Committee of Management, Kisan Degree College
(supra) at paragraph 5 extract from the same being … It is settled law that
after the charge-sheet with necessary particulars, the specific averments in
respect of the charge shall be made. If the department or the management
seeks to rely on any documents in proof of the charge, the principles of
natural justice require that such copies of those documents need to be
supplied to the delinquent. If the documents are voluminous and cannot be
supplied to the delinquent, an opportunity has got to be given to him for
inspection of the documents. It would be open to the delinquent to obtain
appropriate extracts at his own expense. If that opportunity was not given, it
would violate the principles of natural Justice. At the enquiry, if the
delinquent seeks to support his defence with reference to any of the
documents in the custody of the management or the department, then the
documents either may be summoned or copies thereof may be given at his
request and cost of the delinquent. If he seeks to cross-examine the witnesses
examined in proof of the charge he should be given the opportunity to crossexamine him. In case he wants to examine his witness or himself to rebut the
charge, that opportunity should be given. In this case, at the earliest, the
delinquent sought for inspection of the documents. It is now admitted in the
affidavits filed in this Court and in the letter written by the enquiry officer,
that some of the documents were seized by the police after the murder of the
Manager of the appellant-institution on 31-7-1980 for investigation. In that
case the respondent was also one of the accused charged for the offences
under Section 302 read with Section 120-B IPC. It is now an admitted fact
that in Sessions Trial No.228 of 1981 dated 31-7-1986 he was convicted for
the said offence and was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life. It would
appear that he filed an appeal in the High Court and bail was granted to
him.” and also the case of Chandra Tiwari v. Union of India (supra) at
paragraphs 4 and 9 cited by the Petitioner in this regard has some weight and
are relevant to the case in hand.
32.
In a similarly situated case, the Supreme Court in the case of State of
Uttar Pradesh & Ors v. Saroj Kumar Sinha: (2010) 2 SCC 772 dealing with
the issue of application of the principle of natural justice vis-à-vis non-supply
of documents, has at paragraphs 20-23 and 32 held that :
“20. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. We
have noticed at some length the sequence of events and the
efforts made by the respondent to receive copies of the
documents which were relevant for the preparation of his
defence in the departmental enquiry. As noticed earlier all the
requests made by the respondent fell on deaf ears. In such
circumstances, the conclusions recorded by the High Court
were fully justified.
21. Copies of the documents which formed the foundation of the
charge-sheet against the respondents have been denied to the
respondent on the lame excuse, as projected in the pleadings of
the appellant, at different stages before the High Court as well
as this Court, that the respondent, at the relevant time, was
posted in the same division and the documents could have been
received by him and the reply could have been given. According
to the appellant all the documents concerned were with the
division in which the petitioner (the respondent herein) was
posted as Executive Engineer.
22. In the counter-affidavit filed in the High Court it is
specifically mentioned that the documents pertain to the same
division in which the respondent had been posted as Executive
Engineer and therefore he being in knowledge and custody of
the said documents, there was no requirement for the said
documents to be supplied to the respondent. The very same
submission has been reiterated before us by the learned counsel
of the appellants. In our opinion, the submission is without any
basis as the respondent had been suspended on 5-2-2001.
23. Even if the respondent had continued in the same
department it would not have been possible for him to take the
custody of the documents as he would no longer be in charge of
the office. Furthermore, it is evident from the letter dated 19-112003 that the documents had to be collected from different
offices and made available to the respondent. This fact is so
mentioned in the letter of the Executive Engineer. In such
circumstances, we are unable to accept the submission of the
learned counsel for the appellants that it was possible for the
respondent to make an effective representation against the
charge-sheet.
32. The affect of non-disclosure of relevant documents has been
stated in Judicial Review of Administrative Action by De Smith,
Woolf and Jowell, 5th Edn., p.442 as follows:
"If relevant evidential material is not disclosed at
all to a party who is potentially prejudiced by it, there is
prima facie unfairness, irrespective of whether the
material in question arose before, during or after the
hearing. This proposition can be illustrated by a large
number of modern cases involving the use of undisclosed
reports by administrative tribunals and other
adjudicating bodies. If the deciding body is or has the
trappings of a judicial tribunal and receives or appears
to receive evidence ex parte which is not fully disclosed,
or holds ex parte inspections during the course or after
the conclusion of the hearing, the case for setting the
decision aside is obviously very strong; the maxim that
justice must be seen to be done can readily be invoked."
In our opinion the aforesaid maxim is fully applicable in the facts and
circumstances of this case.”
33.
As to the other contentions raised by the Petitioner, that is, on the issue
of being dismissed from service by an Officer who is inferior in rank to that
of the Appointing Officer, the allegation that no opportunity for crossexamination of the witnesses not being afforded to the Petitioner, also that no
Presenting Officer was appointed in the inquiry, this Court is of the view that
these issues are not necessary to be dealt with at this juncture given the fact
that an opinion is arrived at on the vital issue, that of violation of natural
justice and as such, the case laws cited in this regard need not be discussed
here.
34.
The case laws cited by the State Respondent relates to the issue of
interference of the High Court with the findings arrived at by the Enquiry
Officer (Tage Habung) (supra), which is not the case here as the grievance
is mostly against the manner in which the proceeding was conducted.
35.
In the case of Sarva Uttar Pradesh Gramin Bank (supra) as well as
the case of Bishamber Das Dogra (supra), the issue is about non-supply of
the inquiry report which, under the facts and circumstances of the case, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that there has not occurred any violation of
natural justice, whereas, in this case, there is no grievance about the inquiry
report.
36.
Considering the magnitude of the allegation against the Petitioner, it
would be prudent for a proper enquiry against the Petitioner to be conducted,
provided he is afforded every opportunity to defend himself.
37.
Consequently, the impugned Termination Letter under D.O. No 2013
dated 13.08.2013 is hereby set aside and quashed and the Petitioner is
directed to be reinstated in service with consequential financial benefit, albeit
to the extent of 50% of the same, considering the fact that he has been out of
active service for the said number of years since his termination.
38.
The competent authority is also hereby directed to initiate fresh
disciplinary proceedings against the Petitioner from the stage of supply of
documents and as stated above, by affording him all available opportunity to
defend himself in accordance with law.
39.
To the extent indicated above, this petition is hereby disposed of. No
cost.
Judge
Meghalaya
06.04.2021
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review