The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. 06.2022 that he had resigned from the said post and he also gave the name of the new MD, Mr. Manoj Vasudev Pardasani. A show cause notice dated 18.06.2022 was also then sent to said Manoj Vasudev Pardasani and in one email address said mail was also shown received by the recipient and another letter sent alternatively by registered post was also delivered to him, but the PIA did not respond. [5] It is also alleged that since the PIA was not responding, file was sent to the Law Department for legal advice and Law Department advised to serve a demand notice to the PIA for fund recovery and in case the demand notice fail to elicit response from the PIA, then TRLM might initiate legal action against the said party by filing suitable suit in the jurisdictional Court. [6] Thereafter, a 30 days’ notice was also issued to the said PIA for terminating the project and after such 30 days’ period, it was accordingly terminated. File was sent to the learned Government Advocate, High Court of Tripura to file suitable suit but thereafter as per advice of learned G.A., an FIR was lodged after collecting the materials. It was also found by TRLM that said company (PIA) was also stroke off and the Directors of the company were Zuzar Ahmedally Kathawala, Durriya Zuzer Kathawala and Manoj Vasudev Pardasany. However, the signatory in the MoU initially executed between the parties was the present pet…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
AB No.18 of 2026
Shri Sanjay Rajvanshi,
S/O Om Prakash Rajvanshi,
Of Amrapali Royal, 503,
Urvashi – 1, Vaibhav Khand,
Indirapuram, Ghaziabad,
Uttar Pradesh, 201014.
……Petitioner(s).
Versus
The State of Tripura
……Respondent(s).
For Petitioner (s) :
Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder, Senior Advocate.
Mr. Kishor Kumar Pal, Advocate.
Mr. Samrat Sarkar, Advocate.
For Respondent(s):
Mr. Raju Datta, PP.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
Order
30/03/2026
Heard learned counsel of both sides.
The petition for pre-arrest bail has been filed by the accused
petitioner, Sanjay Rajvanshi in connection with NCC PS Case No.25 of 2024
registered under Section 420/409 of Indian Penal Code.
[2]
The allegations in the FIR lodged on 27.3.2024, are that Tripura
Rural Livelihood Mission (for short, TRLM) sanctioned a project namely
Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Grameen Kaushalya Yojana ( for short, DDU-GKY
project) vide order dated 19.02.2014 which is under the Ministry of Rural
Development (for short, MoRD). For implementing the same, a MoU was
signed
amongst
TRLM,
the
implementing
authority
namely
CTSA
NABCONS and their agent namely M’Cons Media Marketing Pvt. Ltd.
(hereinafter referred as ‘PIA’) on 14.10.2014 and accordingly, said PIA was
given first installment for the same amounting to Rs.1,22,94,031/- (Rupees
One Crore Twenty Two Lakhs Ninety Four Thousand Thirty One) on
28.02.2015 by said MoRD through NABCONS with a break-up of 90:10
central and state share without any Bank Guarantee as there was no such
provision of Bank Guarantee.
[3]
It is also stated therein that the PIA then commenced the
training programme under said contract on 10.04.2015 and as on
19.04.2018, there was shortfall of imparting training to the beneficiaries to
the extent of 64.1% and 100% shortfall in their placements. On the basis of
various defaults including the same, the NABCONS also submitted a report
to TRLM against the said PIA on 22.05.2018. A personal hearing was also
done and PIA was penalized for Rs.2,00,000/- and thereafter PIA also paid
the said penalty amount to TRLM. Thereafter, in a review meeting conducted
on 21.06.2019 under the Chairmanship of Secretary, R.D & Panchayat
Deptt., no representatives of said PIA was present and hence in the said
meeting, it was decided that 25% of the 1st installment released to said PIA
has to be recovered in full as per the programme guidelines and it should be
recovered through State Recovery Act, Tripura and as per the DDU-GKY
guidelines, the PIA would be asked to repatriate the amount released as 1st
installment amounting to Rs.1,22,94,031/- only to the TRLM account.
[4]
Thereafter, TRLM issued a letter on 16.11.2019 to the said PIA
regarding initiation of Closure Proceedings and in response to that, the PIA
sent a letter on 02.12.2019 assuring to comply but no such compliance was
done thereafter. Another letter was also issued to them on 15.02.2021
regarding initiation of Closure Proceedings for DDU-GKY project but the PIA
did not respond to the letter. Then show cause notice was also issued to
them on 06.06.2022 and in response to the said notice, one Mr. Zuzar
Ahmedally Kathawala, Managing Director of the said PIA sent an email on
16.06.2022 that he had resigned from the said post and he also gave the
name of the new MD, Mr. Manoj Vasudev Pardasani. A show cause notice
dated 18.06.2022 was also then sent to said Manoj Vasudev Pardasani and
in one email address said mail was also shown received by the recipient and
another letter sent alternatively by registered post was also delivered to him,
but the PIA did not respond.
[5]
It is also alleged that since the PIA was not responding, file was
sent to the Law Department for legal advice and Law Department advised to
serve a demand notice to the PIA for fund recovery and in case the demand
notice fail to elicit response from the PIA, then TRLM might initiate legal
action against the said party by filing suitable suit in the jurisdictional Court.
[6]
Thereafter, a 30 days’ notice was also issued to the said PIA for
terminating the project and after such 30 days’ period, it was accordingly
terminated. File was sent to the learned Government Advocate, High Court
of Tripura to file suitable suit but thereafter as per advice of learned G.A., an
FIR was lodged after collecting the materials. It was also found by TRLM
that said company (PIA) was also stroke off and the Directors of the
company were Zuzar Ahmedally Kathawala, Durriya Zuzer Kathawala and
Manoj Vasudev Pardasany. However, the signatory in the MoU initially
executed between the parties was the present petitioner Sanjay Rajvanshi,
the then CEO of said PIA. Accordingly, the FIR was lodged against all of
them.
[7]
Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder, learned senior counsel submits that
it is totally a case of civil nature, and even the Law Department had also
instructed the TRLM to file a suit for recovery of the amount. However,
despite the same, an FIR has been lodged against the present petitioner and
others by initiating criminal action against them. Learned senior counsel also
contends that even if it is presumed that any criminal offence was
committed, still there is no contribution of the present petitioner in alleged
criminal activities, as he was not a member of the Board of Directors of PIA,
rather he was the CEO of the said organization for the time being, who had
acted merely on the desire and directions of the Directors when the
agreement was entered between the parties. Moreover, he also resigned
from the said post long ago, on 23.09.2016, by submitting his resignation
letter (Annexure-5 of the additional affidavit submitted by the petitioner), and
therefore, if at all there is any default from the side of the said PIA in
returning the money, the present petitioner has no responsibility in this
regard. Learned senior counsel further submits that the petitioner is a
permanent resident of the given address and he will cooperate with the
investigation on all scores and will also face the trial, if so requires, and
therefore, bail may be granted to him on any condition.
[8]
Mr. Raju Datta, learned PP, however, opposes the bail prayer,
submitting that huge amount of public money was paid to the said PIA, but
they
defaulted
in
discharging
their
contractual
obligations
and
misappropriated the said amount. However, on asking by this Court, learned
PP submits that there is no direct material in the case diary to show that the
present petitioner was the defaulter in returning the money or that he has
misappropriated the said amount, but there are materials available in the
case diary in support of the allegations what are averred in the FIR.
[9]
Considered the submissions of both sides. As it appears that
long after the resignation given by the present petitioner on 23.09.2016 from
the post of CEO, only on 24.04.2019, a personal hearing with the PIA was
done by TRLM and a penalty of Rs.2,00,000/- was imposed which also,
according to the informant, they paid. Thereafter again, further scope was
given to the PIA to discharge their such contractual obligations. Finally
closure of the proceedings was done only on 15.02.2021 and thereafter,
show cause notice was issued to one Zuzar Ahmedally Kathawala, the then
Managing Director of the PIA.
[10]
It also appears that the present petitioner has no complicity in
the communications or transactions made between the parties during or
after the imposition of penalty of Rs.2,00,000/- on 24.04.2019 and in the
subsequent happenings, for he had already submitted his resignation long
prior to said date, i.e., in the year 2016. Allegation against him in the FIR is
that he only singed the MOU on behalf of the PIA. According to the
petitioner, he is ready to cooperate in the investigation and during the trial.
Therefore, considering the totality, this Court finds that it is a fit case to grant
pre-arrest bail to the petitioner.
[11]
In view of above, it is ordered that in the event of arrest of the
petitioner, namely Sri Sanjay Rajvanshi in connection with NCC PS Case
No.25 of 2024, he shall be released on bail on furnishing a bond of
Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh) with one surety of like amount to the
satisfaction of the arresting authority, on conditions that:
(i) he will appear before the Investigating Officer as and when required and
will also regularly appear before the Court to face trial;
(ii) he will not anyway try to influence or terrorize any witness of the case or
distort any evidence of the case;
(iii) he will furnish his address of residence with his email address and the
cell phone number to the arresting officer and will not change or hand over
SIM of said cell phone to any other person till the trial is completed;
(iv) he will not go abroad without previous permission of the Jurisdictional
Magistrate, till the trial is completed.
With such observation(s) and direction(s), the bail application is
disposed of.
Return the CD along with copy of this order to learned PP.
Re-consign the LCR along with copy of this order.
JUDGE
signed
MUNN Digitally
by MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2026.03.30
A SAHA 16:57:28 +05'30'
Dinashree
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review