Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A. 121 of 2021
Sri Sailen Malakar, Range Officer
son of late Sashi Malakar, resident of Dharmanagar Range
Office, District- North Tripura, Pin-799253
… APPELLANT
(Petitioner in the writ petition)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
Forest Department, having his office at New Capital Complex,
Agartala, Khejurbagan, District- West Tripura, Pin-799010
2. Principal Chief Conservator of forests & HOFF
Government of Tripura, having his office at Aranya Bhavan,
Pandit Nehru Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, District- West
Tripura
3. District Forest Officer
North Tripura District, Government of Tripura having its office
at Rajbari, Dharmanagar, Pin-799253
4. Sub Divisional Forest Officer
Dharmanagar, Government of Tripura having its office at
Dharmanagar, Rajbari, District- North Tripura, Pin-799253
… RESPONDENTS
(Respondents in the writ petition)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. TD Majumder, Sr. Advocate
Mr. T. Halam, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA
Ms. S.Kar Purkayastha, Adv.
Date of hearing & delivery of judgment :
19.07.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
19/07/2023
(T. Amarnath Goud, J)
Heard Mr. TD Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. T. Halam, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr.
D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA assisted by Ms. S. Kar Purkayastha,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent-State.
Page 2
2.
This intra Court appeal has been preferred by the appellant
challenging
the
judgment
and
order
dated
25.02.2021
(Annexure-2 to this appeal) passed by the learned Single Judge
in Writ Petition No. W.P(C)107 of 2021 whereby, the writ petition
filed by the appellant/writ petitioner has been dismissed.
3.
Briefly stated, the appellant, while serving as Forest Ranger
under the respondent no. 2, the respondent no. 2, being
Disciplinary Authority had issued a Memo of Charge dated
05.12.2020 against the appellant on the expression ‘leading to
public harassment’. Thereafter, the appellant has submitted his
written defence statement before the Disciplinary Authority. On
15.01.2021, the Disciplinary Authority cancelling the Memo of
Charge dated 05.12.2020, had issued fresh charge-sheet against
the appellant on the same set of evidence only after removing
the expression ‘leading to public harassment’ and directed the
appellant to submit his further written statement of defence. It is
the case of the appellant that without deciding or legal conclusion
to the earlier issues relating to the Memo of Charge dated
05.12.2020, the Disciplinary Authority cannot initiate fresh
disciplinary proceeding on the same and identical set of evidence.
With such grievance, the appellant, being petitioner has filed a
writ petition being WP(C) 107 of 2021, and the learned Single
Judge of this Court by its order dated 25.02.2021 had dismissed
Page 3
the said writ petition.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner had
preferred this writ appeal.
4.
Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel appearing for the
appellant has submitted that after receiving the first chargesheet dated 05.12.2020, the appellant has submitted his written
statement
of
defence.
The
Disciplinary
Authority
vide
its
Memorandum dated 15.01.2021 again directed to initiate fresh
disciplinary proceeding against the petitioner and issued fresh
charge-sheet on the same and identical set of evidence, which is
not permissible in law. Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel has
also argued that no reason has been assigned by the disciplinary
authority in cancelling the original charge-sheet prior to issuance
of fresh charge-sheet. In fine, learned senior counsel has urged
this court to quash the disciplinary proceeding dated 15.01.2021.
On this aspect, learned senior counsel has relied upon the
judgments rendered by the apex court in State of Assam and
another vs. J.N. Roy Biswas reported in (1976) 1 SCC 234
(para 4) and also in K.R. Deb vs. The Collector of Central
Excise, Shillong, reported in (1971) 2 SCC 102.
5.
On the other hand, learned GA has fairly submitted that
findings of the learned single Judge in its order dated 25.02.2021
is valid and no interference is called for. Learned GA has
submitted that the respondent no. 2 has only altered/amended
Page 4
the charges during the pendency of the enquiry when enquiry
report has not been submitted till date, thus, it is not the fresh
departmental enquiry but it is the pending enquiry, in which,
certain alteration has taken place. Thus, learned GA has urged
that there was no laches on the part of the respondents and the
second charge-sheet has been issued following the procedure of
law. To support his submission, learned GA has relied on a
decision rendered by the apex
court in
Binod
Chandra
Mazumdar vs. Union of India, through Secretary, Ministry
of works and Supply, New Delhi and another, reported in
AIR 1960 Punjab 147.
6.
We have perused the record and also the judgment of the
learned single Judge.
7.
From the record, it is evident that till the date of issuance of
impugned memo dated 15.01.2021, no enquiry report was
prepared
or
submitted
by
the
disciplinary
authority.
A
comparison of the first and second charge-sheet would reveal
that as far as second charge is concerned, there was alteration in
the sense that the allegation with regard to ‘leading to public
harassment’ has been omitted. The charges are only by way of
alteration, and it is not a case of de novo enquiry.
8.
While disposing of the writ petition being WP(C) 107 of
2021, learned single Judge has held as under:
Page 5
“[5] Comparison of the two charge-sheets would show that in the previous charge-sheet
issued on 05.12.2020, the allegation contained following group of words which were
omitted in the subsequent chargesheet “leading to public harassment”. Thus, in the
impugned charge-sheet, the disciplinary authority has narrowed the scope of the charge
against the petitioner. Originally the allegation was that the petitioner as a Forest Range
Officer of Dharmanagar had showed serious negligence in discharging of his duty by not
processing documents relating to issuance of one FTL in time. This according to the
disciplinary authority, led to public harassment. However, it can be safely presumed that
when the petitioner gave his explanation in response to this charge-sheet, the disciplinary
authority did not find it appropriate to proceed further with this element of charge of the
petitioner’s alleged misconduct leading to public harassment. This is the only conclusion
one can reach upon comparison of the two charge-sheets.
[6] Perhaps the better option with the disciplinary authority was to continue with the
departmental inquiry in connection with the charge-sheet dated 05.12.2020, however
narrow down the scope thereof by asking the inquiry officer to inquire into the charge
minus the element of public harassment. However, he chose to remodel his charge-sheet
and while doing so, he first cancelled the previous charge-sheet and issued a fresh one.
This mere procedure by which the disciplinary achieved the same purpose, cannot a
ground to exonerate the petitioner of a charge which he has yet to face. As a disciplinary
authority it was always open to the Chief Conservator of Forest to accept the explanation
of the petitioner either in entirety nor in part. In the present case, he accepted the
defence of the petitioner in part and has thereafter decided to go ahead with the inquiry
with respect to a truncated charge. The charge-sheet cannot be quashed on the grounds
pressed by the counsel for the petitioner.
[7] Nothing in Rule-14 of CCS(CCA) Rules provides to the contrary. Two Government of
India’s instructions relied upon by the counsel for the petitioner also would not change
my opinion. He had relied on the Government of India’s instructions dated 05.07.1979
wherein it has been clarified that when the departmental proceedings initiated under
Rule- 14 are dropped, the disciplinary authority would be debarred from initiating fresh
proceedings unless reasons of cancellation of the original chargesheet or for dropping the
proceedings are appropriately mentioned and it is stated in the order that the dropping of
the charge is without prejudice to the further action which may be taken.
[8] The present case is not one of dropping of the charge. It is only a question of accepting
the petitioner’s explanation vis-a-vis an element of the charge as initially alleged. The
action of the authority of cancelling the previous charge-sheet and issuance of a fresh
charge-sheet is a one integrated exercise contained in the same order. It is not as if by
one order he dropped the departmental proceedings and sometime later revived it by
issuing a fresh charge-sheet.
[9] The Government of India instructions issued under OM dated 12.03.1981 on which
reliance was placed, merely reinforces my belief. It provides that the disciplinary
authority has inherent power to review or modify the articles of charge or drop some of
the charge or all charges, after receipt and examination of the written statement of
defence by the delinquent. What is stated in the said OM merely flows from the existing
rule position. Once a charge-sheet is issued, the delinquent Government servant is given
opportunity to file his explanation. This is not a stage of mere formality. If the
explanation is found satisfactory, noting prevents the disciplinary authority from
dropping all charges or some of the charges contained in the charge-sheet or even a part
of the charge. Surely a Government servant should not be made to face an inquiry in
relation to the charge where the disciplinary authority finds his explanation satisfactory.
In the present case, this is precisely what has been done by the disciplinary authority. The
charge is originally framed at an additional element of the petitioner’s delay causing
public harassment. This element of public harassment has been dropped in the
subsequent charge-sheet. As noted earlier, he could probably have achieved the same
thing by modifying the charge and continuing with the departmental inquiry in relation
Page 6
with the charge-sheet dated 05.12.2020. However, for such technical reason the
departmental inquiry cannot be quashed.”
8.
We have also gone through the O.M. dated 12th March,
1981 issued by the Government of India, wherein, it has been
clearly stated that disciplinary authority has the inherent power
to review and modify the Articles of Charges after receipt of the
written statement of defence submitted by the delinquent officer.
O.M. dated, 12th March, 1981, clearly stipulates that:
“(4) Whether charges can be dropped at the stage of initial written statement of defence:A question has been under consideration whether Rule 14 (5) (a) of the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965 permits the dropping of charges by the disciplinary authority after
considering the written statement of defence submitted by the accused Government
servant under Rule 14 (4) ibid. The question has been considered in consultation with
the Ministry of Law and the position is clarified as under:(a) The disciplinary authority has the inherent power to review and modify the
articles of charge or drop some of the charges or all the charges after the receipt
and examination of the written statement of defence submitted by the accused
Government servant under Rule 14 (4) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
(b) The disciplinary authority is not bound to appoint an Inquiry Officer for
conducting an inquiry into the charges which are not admitted by the accused
official but about which the disciplinary authority is satisfied on the basis of the
written statement of defence that there is no further cause to proceed with.”
9.
Original Charge under Article I, dated 05.12.2020 is framed
as under:
“Shri Sailen Malakar, Forest Ranger, Range Officer, Dharmanagar Range, Dharmanagar
Forest Sub-Division Dhalai District during his incumbency as Range Officer, Dharmanagar
Range showed serious negligence in his duty by not processing documents relating to
issue of FTL in time leading to public harassment.
Such activity on the part of Shri Sailen Malakar, Forest Ranger, Range Officer,
Dharmanagar Range was highly undesirable which amounts to misconduct. Shri Sailen
Malakar, Forest Ranger is thus charged for misconduct as per Rule 3 of Tripura Civil
Services (conduct) rules, 1988 and its amendments thereof.”
After submission of representation which has been received
by the respondents, on 15.01.2021 another charge has been
framed, which is as under:
Page 7
“Shri Sailen Malakar, Forest Ranger, Range Officer, Dharmanagar Range, Dharmanagar
Forest Sub-Division Dhalai District during his incumbency as Range Officer, Dharmanagar
Range showed serious negligence in his duty by not processing documents relating to
issue of FTL in time.
Such activity on the part of Shri Sailen Malakar, Forest Ranger, Range Officer,
Dharmanagar Range was highly undesirable which amounts to misconduct. Shri Sailen
Malakar, Forest Ranger is thus charged for misconduct as per Page 2 of 6 Rule 3 of Tripura
Civil Services (conduct) rules, 1988 and its amendments thereof.”
In the process of framing charges dated 05.12.2020 and
15.01.2021, a Memo dated 13.01.2021 has been issued while
indicating that Memo dated 05.12.2020 stands cancelled though
the cause of action and the contents in the allegations are one
and same. After receiving the explanation from the petitioner,
subsequent proceeding which has been issued is squarely
covered under Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules.
10.
It is
(supra),
Binod Chandra Mazumdar vs. Union of India
the
Hon’ble
apex
court
has
stated
that
in
a
departmental enquiry against a Government servant, when the
first charge-sheet is dropped and there is a second charge-sheet,
it may be contended that the whole procedure under Rule 15 has
to be followed afresh, but the contention that once an enquiry
has been ordered on a specific set of charges, the Enquiry Officer
is bound to proceed with the same and that those proceedings
cannot be cancelled, withdrawn or dropped, cannot be accepted.
There is no express provision in the Rules that the Disciplinary
Authority is debarred from dropping any charges that it may
have considered fit to frame in the first instance and to frame
Page 8
fresh charges which may on further consideration appear to be
appropriate charges for being preferred. Thus, where the second
set
of
charges
became
necessary
after
there
had
been
investigation by the police into the allegations against the
petitioner, there is no reason or justification for the Disciplinary
Authority not being competent to prefer a fresh charge-sheet
after superseding the first one.
11.
From the OM dated 12.03.1981 it is evident that the
disciplinary authority has inherent power to review or modify the
articles of charge or drop some of the charge or all charges, after
receipt and examination of the written statement of defence by
the delinquent. Applying the aforesaid principles, it appears that
the disciplinary authority has ample power to amend the order of
framing charges and the power to amend the same must be
treated to be available with the disciplinary authority.
12. Taking into consideration the entire circumstances, we are
not inclined to interfere with the judgment and order dated
25.02.2021 passed by the learned Single Judge in Writ Petition
No. W.P(C)107 of 2021. Consequently, the instant appeal stands
dismissed.
JUDGE
Saikat
SAIKA
T KAR
Digitally signed
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2023.07.21
14:56:49 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review