Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary
List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 285 of 2016
Date of Decision: 01.12.2022
Shri Rakesh Kumar
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Nath, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, DSG. with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
Being aggrieved by the impugned order No. I.11012/A/Discp
Offr/2015 dated 05.01.2015 conveying imposition of penalty of
compulsory retirement from service upon the petitioner herein as well as
by the discharge certificate No. 18/2015 dated 05.01.2015, conveying
compulsory retirement from service of the petitioner and finally, by the
Order No. I.11011/A-RK/Appeal/2015/1083 dated 26.08.2015 whereby
the appeal of the petitioner was rejected by the Director General Assam
Rifles (DG AR), the petitioner has preferred this writ petition under Article
226 of the Constitution of India with a prayer to set aside and quash the
abovementioned communication and orders.
2.
Background details and facts would reveal that the petitioner was
selected through the Central Police Organizations for the post of Assistant
Commandant (Medical Officer) and was appointed as Assistant
Commandant (MO) in Assam Rifles Combatant branch on 27.10.2004.
3.
The petitioner had applied for leave in the month of August, 2010
on account of illness of his mother and the same was granted to him w.e.f.
23.08.2010 to 08.09.2010, but even after the expiry of his leave due to
serious illness of his mother, he was not able to resume duty and could do
so only on 06.10.2010. No show cause or warning was issued to him for
the 28 days of overstayed leave.
4.
In the year 2012, the petitioner applied for earned leave w.e.f.
14.02.2012 to 03.03.2012 for 19 days with permission to suffix 04.03.2012
on the ground that his mother was seriously ill being a patient of
Osteoarthritis and Osteoporosis for many years. According to the
petitioner, the condition of his mother deteriorated and she took time to
recover, compelling him to fail to join duty at the end of his stipulated
leave. The petitioner then informed the Adjutant over phone that he
requires extension of his leave for another 20 days followed by an
application dated 05.03.2012. However, on 12.03.2012, he was informed
by the Commandant 3(NH) Bn Assam Rifles that he failed to report for
duty on 05.03.2012. No reply was given as regard his application for
extension of leave.
5.
It is also the case of the petitioner that due to the prolonged illness
of his parents, he has to remain at home and for this, he has informed the
Commandant that he will report for duty as soon as the health of his old
aged parents improve. In the meantime, the family has changed their place
of residence and the petitioner informed the Commandant of the same
through a fresh representation dated 03.02.2013.
6.
Vide letter No. I.6000062/ARMO/2013/1138 dated 14.03.2013,
the respondent No. 3 issued apprehension roll addressed to the SSP,
Gautam Budh Nagar, Noida, U.P. to which the petitioner responded vide
letter dated 07.05.2013 assuring the authority that he will report for duty
by 16.05.2013 and accordingly, he resumed duty on the said date and after
his joining, he was posted at 3(NH) Bn. Assam Rifles.
7.
On 31.08.2013, the respondent No. 3 issued a convening order of
Court of Inquiry enclosed with a tentative charge sheet. The charge was
read out before the petitioner. The tentative charge sheet framed under
Rules 46 and 54(3) of the Assam Rifles Rules containing two charges that
is, charge No. 1, relates to the failure of the petitioner to rejoin duty after
the expiry of the leave granted to him w.e.f. 23.08.2010 to 08.09.2010 and
has instead joined only on 06.10.2010 after 28 days and charge No. 2
relates to his overstaying of leave granted to him pertaining to the period
of leave w.e.f. 14.02.2012 to 03.03.2012, but the petitioner had instead
rejoined duty only on 16.05.2013, the total days of unauthorized absence
being 439 days.
8.
Mr. S. Nath, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
on the basis of the tentative chargesheet filed against the petitioner, a Court
of Inquiry was ordered to find out the truth of the matter in which the
petitioner has also participated and has shown cause as to why he could not
join duty in time. The summary of evidence in the said inquiry was
concluded on 26.09.2013, however the inquiry report was not forwarded to
the petitioner to enable him to file his representation. This is clearly a
violation of the rights of the petitioner as far as the principle of natural
justice is concerned and any statutory rules which deny furnishing of the
report to the employee are against the principles of natural justice. The case
of Managing Director, ECIL, Hyderabad & Ors v. B. Karunakar & Ors:
(1993) 4 SCC 727, para 20, 29, 30, 31, 50 & 57 was strongly relied upon
by the learned counsel for the petitioner who has further submitted that the
impugned order of compulsory retirement from service cannot be sustained
on this ground alone.
9.
The learned counsel has also submitted that against the said order
dated 05.01.2015 whereby the petitioner was compulsorily retired from
service, an appeal was filed before the Director General, Assam Rifles,
Shillong (respondent No. 2) on 23.02.2015, submitting therein that the
disciplinary proceedings conducted by the General Assam Rifles Court
(GARC) did not take cognizance of the compelling circumstances and
justification offered by the petitioner and has meted out a very harsh
sentence of compulsory retirement, which quantum of punishment far
exceeds natural justice. It is prayed that the findings of the GARC be
quashed. However, vide communication dated 26.08.2015, the respondent
authority has informed the petitioner that his appeal was rejected as devoid
of merits.
10.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has also submitted that the
petitioner on the date of his discharge from service had completed 10 years
of service, but the same would be counted as less than 10 years if the
number of days in which he has overstayed his leave is to be counted and
therefore, the penalty could not be termed as compulsory retirement, but
removal from service. The penalty is therefore disproportionate to the
alleged offence of overstay of leave. The case of Chairman-cumManaging Director, Coal India Ltd. & Anr v. Mukul Kumar Choudhuri
& Ors: (2009) 15 SCC 620, para 19, 20 & 21 and the case of Krushnakant
B. Parmar v. Union of India & Anr: (2012) 3 SCC 178, para 20, 21 & 24,
have been referred to support this contention.
11.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has finally submitted that
the impugned order of compulsory retirement from service be set aside and
quashed and the report of inquiry be furnished to the petitioner and
thereafter, the proper procedure to be followed.
12.
Per contra, Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSG appearing on behalf of
the respondents/Union of India has submitted that the admitted fact is that
the petitioner has overstayed his leave for 439 days as regard his
application for earned leave w.e.f. 14.02.2012 to 03.03.2012. This is not
the first instance where the petitioner has overstayed his leave, earlier, he
has applied for 15 days casual leave which was granted to him w.e.f.
23.08.2010 to 08.09.2010, but he failed to join duty after the expiry of the
same and rejoined duty only on 06.10.2010, again after overstaying for 28
days. Though disciplinary proceedings was not initiated for the said
infringement at the relevant period, however, the present proceedings
would include charges related to the said period of 2010 as well as for the
latest lapse for which the authority has proceeded against him
departmentally and in accordance with due procedure.
13.
On the twin contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner,
the learned DSG has submitted that on the issue that the penalty is
disproportionate to the misconduct proved, the same cannot be accepted as
the petitioner being a member of a disciplined force, he is expected to
maintain the highest form of discipline and any deviation from this should
invite heavy penalty. In this regard, the following judgments were cited to
support this contention:
i)
Union of India & Ors v. Datta Linga Toshatwad: (2005) 13
SCC 709, para 5,6, & 8;
ii)
Union of India & Ors v. Ghulam Mohd. Bhat: (2005) 13
SCC 228, para 9 and
iii)
Pradip Kumar Tomer v. Union of India & Ors: (2003) GLR
171, para 9.
14.
As to the second issue, that is, that non-issuance of the Inquiry
Report to the petitioner has resulted in violation of the principles of natural
justice as far as the petitioner is concerned, the learned DSG would submit
that initially on 25.04.2012, a Court of Inquiry was ordered by the
respondent No. 3 to investigate the circumstance under which the petitioner
failed to rejoin duty on expiry of the sanctioned leave and on the
proceedings of the Court of Inquiry being concluded, it was recommended
that the petitioner be declared a deserter w.e.f. 05.03.2012. The petitioner
did not rejoin his duty, instead on 07.02.2013, he has applied for extension
of his leave, to which the HQ, IGAR (E) directed him to rejoin duty
forthwith. An apprehension Roll was also issued in this regard and the
petitioner having acknowledged the same, has accordingly rejoined duty
on 16.05.2013.
15.
After convening of the Court of Inquiry to ascertain the facts, the
Court, has inter alia, come to the conclusion that the petitioner has absented
himself from duty by overstaying leave granted to him in excess of 439
days and accordingly, it was recommended that suitable disciplinary action
be taken against him which entails that he be tried by a General Assam
Rifles Court (GARC).
16.
The Court of Inquiry then framed two charges against the
petitioner being the following, with recommendation for the same to be
taken up by the General Assam Rifles Court.
First Charge
AR Act Section 26 (b)
WITHOUT SUFFICIENT CAUSE
OVERSTAYING LEAVE GRANTED TO HIM
in that he,
at field, on 09 Sep 2010 having been granted leave of
absence from 23 Aug 2010 to 08 Sept 2010 with
permission to prefix on 22 Aug 2010, interfix on 29 Aug
2010 and 05 Sep 2010 being Sunday to proceed to his
home town, failed without sufficient cause, to rejoin at
duty station on 09 Sep 2010, on the expiry of the said
leave.
Second Charge
AR Act Section 26(b)
WITHOUT SUFFICIENT CAUSE
OVERSTAYING LEAVE GRANTED TO HIM
in that he,
at field, on 05 Mar 2012, having been granted leave of
absence from 14 Feb 2012 to 03 Mar 2012 with
permission to suffix on 04 Mar 2012 being Sunday to
proceed to his home town, failed without sufficient
cause to rejoin at duty station on 05 Mar 2012, on the
expiry of the said leave.
Sd/(Rakesh Kumar Bhardwaj)
Colonel
Commandant
3 Assam Rifles
Dated: 29 Aug 2014
17.
It is also submitted that the petitioner pleaded guilty to both
charges following which the GARC then sentenced him to face the penalty
of ‘compulsory retirement from service’. It is also reiterated that during the
Court of Inquiry proceedings, the petitioner was given ample opportunity
to cross-examine the witnesses, but he declined to do so.
18.
The learned DSG has also submitted that the case of Managing
Director, ECIL (supra) cited and relied upon by the petitioner would not
be applicable to the case of the parties herein as in that case, the
departmental proceedings is governed by the Central Civil Services (CCS)
rules, where there is a provision for the inquiry report to be supplied to the
delinquent, but in the present case, the proceedings conducted is under the
provisions of the Assam Rifles Act and Rules and as such, there is no
requirement of furnishing of the copy of the inquiry report to the petitioner.
19.
Upon hearing the learned counsels for the parties, what could be
understood is that the petitioner has assailed the proceedings against him
primarily on the ground that the report of the proceedings of the Court of
Inquiry has not been furnished to him to enable him to prepare his defence.
The case of Managing Director, ECIL (supra) particularly para 20, 29 &
30(i) was relied upon to prove his case. The said paragraphs are reproduced
as under: “20. The origins of the law can also be traced to the principles of
natural justice, as developed in the following cases: In A. K. Kraipak
v. Union of India, (1970) 1 SCR 457: it was held that the rules of
natural justice operate in areas not covered by any law. They do not
supplant the law of the land but supplement it. They are not embodied
rules and their aim is to secure justice or to prevent miscarriage of
justice. If that is their purpose, there is no reason why they should not
be made applicable to administrative proceedings also especially when
it is not easy to draw the line that demarcates administrative enquiries
from quasi-judicial ones. An unjust decision in an administrative
inquiry may have a more far-reaching effect than a decision in a
quasi-judicial inquiry. It was further observed that the concept of
natural justice has undergone a great deal of change in recent years.
What particular rule of natural justice should apply to a given case
must depend to a great extent on the facts and circumstances of that
case, the framework of the law under which the inquiry is held and the
constitution of the Tribunal or the body of persons appointed for that
purpose. Whenever a complaint is made before a Court that some
principle of natural justice has been contravened, the Court has to
decide whether the observance of that rule was necessary for a just
decision on the facts of that case. The rule that inquiry must be held
in good faith and without bias and not arbitrarily or unreasonably is
now included among the principles of natural justice.
29. Hence it has to be held that when the enquiry officer is not the
disciplinary authority, the delinquent employee has right to receive a
copy of the enquiry officer's report before the disciplinary authority
arrives at its conclusions with regard to the guilt or innocence of the
employee with regard to the charges levelled against him. That right
is a part of the employee's right to defend himself against the charges
levelled against him. A denial of the enquiry officer's report before the
disciplinary authority takes its decision on the charges, is a denial of
reasonable opportunity to the employee to prove his innocence and is
a breach of the principles of natural justice.
30. Hence the incidental questions raised above may be answered as
follows:
(i) Since the denial of the report of the enquiry officer is a denial
of reasonable opportunity and a breach of the principles of
natural justice, it follows that the statutory rules, if any, which
deny the report to the employee are against the principles of
natural justice and, therefore, invalid. The delinquent employee
will, therefore, be entitled to a copy of the report even if the
statutory rules do not permit the furnishing of the report or are
silent on the subject…”
20.
There can be no quarrel with the proposition of law as indicated
above, inasmuch as, in a departmental or disciplinary proceeding, when an
inquiry has been instituted, on the conclusion of the same, the delinquent
employee has to be given copy of the report so as to enable him to file a
representation if any, before the appellate authority before any penalty or
punishment is imposed upon him. This speaks of a system where initially
there is an inquiry and on completion of all formalities after the report is
filed, the appointing or disciplinary authority, on the basis of the inquiry
report would pass its final order.
21.
The relevant rules governing this procedure would be evident
from a reading of Rule 14, 15, 16 & 17 of the Central Civil Services (Class
Control & Appeal) Rules, 1965.
22.
The petitioner herein however, is a member of the Assam Rifles,
a para-military force being governed by its own Act i.e., the Assam Rifles
Act of 2006 as well as by the relevant Assam Rifles Rules, 2010. As to the
case of the petitioner, Section 84 of the said Assam Rifles Act provides that
a court of inquiry shall be assembled when any person (employee) has been
absent from duty without due authority for a period of 30 days. The
provision as to how the Court of Inquiry is to be conducted is found under
Chapter XV through Rules No. 181 to 189. In the context of this case, Rule
187 merits reproduction herein:
“187. Copies of court of inquiry proceedings. - A person
subject to the Act against whom the court of inquiry has
given an opinion or who is being tried by a Force Court on
a charge relating to matter investigated by the court of
inquiry, shall be entitled to copies of the proceedings of the
court of inquiry except the findings and opinion thereon,
unless the Director-General for reasons recorded by him
orders otherwise.”
23.
The proceedings against the petitioner did not end with the Court
of Inquiry but as per procedure, the matter then proceeded to be taken up
by the General Assam Rifles Court, apparently on being recommended by
the Court of Inquiry with the two charges framed against the petitioner as
indicated at paragraph 16 above. The petitioner by his own admission has
appeared before the General Assam Rifles Court and at that point of time
there was no prayer or demand made by him for the Inquiry Report to be
furnished to him. Having taken part in the complete proceedings, at this
point of time, he is therefore estopped from making a claim that the Inquiry
Report was not furnished to him. Infact, on being communicated with the
order dated 05.01.2015, wherein, the respondent authority has informed the
petitioner that he is found guilty of the charges against him and was
accordingly sentenced to a penalty of compulsory retirement from service,
the petitioner had preferred an appeal against the said sentence vide
communication dated 23.02.2015 which was considered and rejected by
the authority concerned vide communication dated 26.08.2015.
24.
This Court as a writ court applying the principles of judicial
review does not find anything wrong or improper with the procedure
adopted by the Assam Rifles authorities as far as the proceedings against
the petitioner is concerned. The contention of the petitioner that the
principle of natural justice in his case has been violated cannot be sustained
in the light of the above findings and observations.
25.
The other issue canvassed by the petitioner is that the penalty of
compulsory retirement imposed is disproportionate to the alleged offence
since the petitioner even though he has admitted to have overstayed his
leave, has, however explained that it was because of the serious illness of
his parents that he could not rejoin duty in due course, but this plea was
never considered since the Inquiry Report was never furnished to him. The
case of Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Coal India Ltd. (supra), para
19, 20 & 21 was cited in this regard. The same reads as follows:“19. The doctrine of proportionality is, thus, well-recognized
concept of judicial review in our jurisprudence. What is otherwise
within the discretionary domain and sole power of the decisionmaker to quantify punishment once the charge of misconduct
stands proved, such discretionary power is exposed to judicial
intervention if exercised in a manner which is out of proportion to
the fault. Award of punishment which is grossly in excess to the
allegations cannot claim immunity and remains open for
interference under limited scope of judicial review.
20. One of the tests to be applied while dealing with the question
of quantum of punishment would be: would any reasonable
employer have imposed such punishment in like circumstances?
Obviously, a reasonable employer is expected to take into
consideration measure, magnitude and degree of misconduct and
all other relevant circumstances and exclude irrelevant matters
before imposing punishment.
21. In a case like the present one where the misconduct of the
delinquent was unauthorized absence from duty for six months but
upon being charged of such misconduct, he fairly admitted his
guilt and explained the reasons for his absence by stating that he
did not have any intention nor desired to disobey the order of
higher authority or violate any of the Company's Rules and
Regulations but the reason was purely personal and beyond his
control and, as a matter of fact, he sent his resignation which was
not accepted, the order of removal cannot be held to be justified,
since in our judgment, no reasonable employer would have
imposed extreme punishment of removal in like circumstances.
The punishment is not only unduly harsh but grossly in excess to
the allegations.”
26.
Needless to say, the petitioner is a member of a discipline force
and it is incumbent upon him to uphold this standard even to the point of
sacrificing self, notwithstanding the fact that he is also entitled to the
privileges and benefits which comes with the service conditions. In the case
of the petitioner, being a highly intelligent and educated person and a
medical officer at that, he is expected to exhibit prudence, discipline and
common sense in his attitude to life and work. The fact that he remained
absent without any recorded intimation for almost 439 days after
sanctioned leave was granted to him for a period of only 19 days with effect
from 14.02.2012 to 03.03.2012 speaks volume about his intent. In such a
situation, it is the opinion of this Court that no leniency can be allowed to
such a person. The case of Pradip Kumar Tomer(supra) cited by the
respondent would be relevant as the facts and circumstances therein are
almost identical and similar to the case in hand. The same is respectfully
endorsed by this Court. At para 9 of the said judgment, the Hon’ble Gauhati
High Court has held as under:“9. Here is a case of overstay after the expiry of the period of
leave. The petitioner remained absent without authority for 40
days. Obviously, the offence committed by him cannot be taken
lightly since he belongs to a disciplined force. Atleast he should
have before expiry of the leave sent appropriate fillers requesting
for extension of leave. He called somebody at Agartala on
30.12.1999 on phone, i.e., after expiry of leave and, thereafter,
sent a telegram on 2.2.2000. The copy of the telegram is also not
available. The respondent-authority denied having received any
such communication. On earlier occasions also, he had
committed two offences for which he was awarded 28 days
rigorous imprisonment and confined to lines. Situated thus, this
court is unable to agree with Mr. Sarma, learned senior counsel
for the petitioner that the punishment of discharge awarded to the
petitioner is harsh and disproportionate to the offence committed.
Unauthorised absence from duty for 40 days without any
intimation, for whatsoever reason it may be, if condoned and set
a precedent to the other members of the force to follow suit and
this would inevitably disturb the discipline sought to be
maintained by the Organisation. This Court is, therefore, not
inclined to interfere with the penalty of discharge.”
27.
Without going to the other aspects of the matter or the other
authorities cited by the parties, suffice it to say that this Court on a
conspectus of the facts and circumstances of this case hereby finds that the
petitioner has not been able to make out a case for interference by this
Court. This petition is accordingly rejected.
28.
Petition disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
01.12.2022
“N. Swer, Stenographer.”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review