Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 1
Supp. List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 203 of 2015 with
WP(C) No. 204 of 2015
WP(C) No. 205 of 2015
Date of Decision: 11.07.2022
__________________________________________________________
Shri. Heron Roy Manner & Ors.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Smti. Airona Lyngdoh & Ors.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Shri. Pyntngen Mukhim & Ors.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S.M.Suna, Adv. with
Mr. L.Shongwan, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. R.Gurung, Addl. Sr. GA with
Ms. A.A.Sangma, Adv.
i)
ii)
:
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
These three writ petitions being filed on the same cause of action
and on similar facts, will be disposed of by this common judgment and
order.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the writ petitioners in these
petitions are stated to have been appointed by the competent authority in
their respective Sub-Divisions sometime in the year 1995 to 1997, after
being successful in the selection process conducted by the state
respondents and on their appointment, the petitioners were posted in
different schools run and managed by Religious Institutions and Minority
Communities. Prior to their appointments, the State of Meghalaya for the
purpose of taking over the primary schools run by the District Councils in
the state, had enacted an Act known as the Meghalaya (Taking Over of the
DCLP Schools) Act, 1993 which came into force on 02-06-1994. For
implementation of this Act, the State Government had constituted a
committee to examine the list of District Council Lower Primary (DCLP)
Schools in the state, deemed to have been taken over and vest with the State
Government and while constituting the said committee, 24-09-1982 was
fixed as a cut-off date for calculating the length of service of the LP School
Teachers as Government Teachers in the Jowai Autonomous District. The
committee by its report recommended that the LP School Teachers be
placed into two categories, those appointed by the District Council as well
as the Deputy Inspector of Schools, Administrator/Assistant Administrator
and posted in DCLP Schools were to be treated as Government Teachers,
whereas those appointed by the same authority but posted in
Religious/Minority Institutions shall be treated as Non-Government LP
School Teachers.
3.
In WP(C). No. 203 of 2015, there are altogether 11 petitioners and
they are stated to have been appointed by the then Deputy Inspector of
Schools, Amlarem Sub-Division sometime in the year 1995 after being
duly selected. In WP(C). No. 204 of 2015, there are 38 petitioners, all are
matriculates and some also possess the added qualification of having
passed the District Elementary Education Eligibility Test and some have
passed the Basic Teachers Training/Junior Basic Training. They are stated
to have been appointed by the then Deputy Inspector of Schools, Jowai
Sadar Sub-Division in the years 1995 to 1997 after being duly selected.
The petitioners in WP(C). No. 205 of 2015 are 31 in number and possess
similar qualifications such as the petitioners in the other writ petitions.
These petitioners have been stated to be appointed by the then Deputy
Inspector of Schools, Khliehriat Sub-Division sometime in the year 1995,
after being duly selected. It is to be noted that after the selection, the
petitioners in all these three writ petitions were posted in different schools
run and managed by Religious Institutions and Minority Communities.
4.
Before coming to the questions that have been raised in the instant
writ petitions, it is important to note that the issues in these petitions were
before this Court in three writ petitions fronted by the same writ petitioners
herein, which were numbered as WP(C). No. 301, 302 and 303 of 2013.
This Court by order dated 03-07-2014, was pleased to dispose of the said
writ petitions by allowing the writ petitioners therein, to prefer fresh
representations mentioning all the relevant facts for consideration by the
state respondents. Thereafter, under the Orders of the Governor by
Notification dated 24-09-2014, a Committee was constituted to examine
the grievances of the petitioners, which after hearing the petitioners and
recording their statements and examination of relevant documents and
records, submitted a report and findings dated 21-10-2014 to the
respondent No.2, holding the petitioners ineligible to be given the status of
Government L.P. School Teachers.
5.
The state respondents on receipt of the detailed report, then vide
order dated 04-05-2015, rejected the representations and while rejecting
the prayers of the petitioners had also ascribed reasons for the same. The
writ petitioners being dissatisfied with the said report and order, are
therefore once again before this Court.
6.
Mr. S.M. Suna, learned counsel for the petitioners in all the writ
petitions submits that the petitioners after appointment, were deputed to
serve in Private Institutions and in Government Aided Schools and after
the enactment of the Meghalaya (Taking Over of the DCLP Schools) Act,
1993, by virtue of Section 3 of the Act, the government had proceeded to
take over the management of all the existing DCLP Schools by fixing a
cut-off date to determine the status of a teacher who was to be considered
for absorption as a Government LP School Teacher. Learned counsel
admits that all the petitioners were appointed after the cut-off date and after
the implementation of the Act. He however submits that the petitioners are
entitled to be treated as Government Teachers, inasmuch as, their
appointment was made against sanctioned posts by the competent authority
at that time, who was exercising such powers. In this regard, learned
counsel referred to an observation made in the case of Ferisha Phalley vs.
State of Meghalaya decided on 23-08-2002, which he submits the
erstwhile jurisdictional High Court i.e., the Gauhati High Court, had held
in para 19 of the judgment that, “It will be illogical to infer that only
because accidentally, someone got appointed as a teacher in the DCLP
Schools, his/her services were protected and those, who by coincidence,
got appointed in the Minority or Private Schools, their services were not
protected. Any other interpretation will lead to an anomalous situation,
where a person will be denied that right to continue as a teacher only
because of coincidence or accidental factors.”
7.
It is also submitted by learned counsel that other teachers who were
appointed in a similar situation and in the same nature and by a common
appointment order, have been considered and have been treated and
approved as Government L.P.School Teachers and as such, therefore, the
petitioners too are entitled to be recognised/treated and approved as
Government L.P.School Teachers, irrespective of the fact whether they
were serving in a DCLP School or in a Private or Minority School. The
learned counsel has also referred to a list of the alleged similarly placed
teachers, who by virtue of being posted in a Government L.P.School have
been accorded Government L.P.School Teacher status. With regard to the
observations of the Committee which had considered the representations,
the learned counsel submits that as per the parameters laid down by the
said Committee, the petitioners are covered by para 2 and 3 of the said
parameters and should have been considered to be eligible to be treated as
Government teachers. The learned counsel submits that the findings of the
Committee as well as the final order dated 04-05-2015, cannot be termed
to be a fair conclusion.
8.
It is also contended that the state respondents, by an act of artificial
distinction between the Government L.P.Schools and Non-Government
L.P.Schools, have arbitrarily deprived the petitioners of their legitimate
service benefits, simply because they were serving in Non-Government
L.P.Schools. In concluding his arguments, learned counsel submits that the
instant case calls for intervention by this Court, to direct the state
respondents to pass appropriate orders according the status of Government
L.P. School Teacher to the petitioners as well as all consequential service
benefits.
9.
Mr. R.Gurung, learned Addl. Senior GA in reply, submits that the
writ petition is firstly barred by the principles of res judicata, inasmuch as,
on the same set of facts and circumstances, under orders passed by this
Court, the state respondents had constituted a Committee to examine the
case of the petitioners and the said committee had rendered conclusive
findings. He submits that after examination, the Committee, found the writ
petitioners to be not eligible as they were appointed after 02-06-1994, the
date on which the Meghalaya (Taking Over of DCLP Schools) Act, 1993
came into force, and were posted in Non-Government L.P.Schools and
continued to serve therein till date. Learned counsel submits that a plain
reading of the Act of 1993, shows that it was enacted to take over only
those Lower Primary Schools which were under the management of the
District Council and it is not an Act to take over any and every category of
Schools. Section 3 of the Act, he submits, clearly states that the provisions
of Sub-Section 2 (a) and (b) shall also apply to a DCLP School Teacher
who is deputed or transferred by the State Government to serve in a School
not being a DCLP School. The petitioners, he contends, being appointed
after 02-06-1994 and posted in Non-Government L.P.Schools and who
continue to serve in such Schools are not eligible to be treated as
Government Teachers as they do not come within the meaning of SubSection 3 (3) of the Act.
10.
With regard to the parameters for examining the appointment of
those teachers the learned counsel has placed the state’s affidavit wherein
the same has been categorized as follows:
a) Teachers appointed by District Councils and serving in NonGovernment Schools shall be treated as Government School
Teachers on deputation to Non-Government Schools and the post
ceases to be a government post on retirement of a teacher.
b) In cases such as (a) above, the vacancy arising is to be filled by a
Managing Committee and in cases where the Administrator or
Deputy Inspector of Schools has issued appointment orders
against such vacancies, the teacher thus appointed is not treated
as a Government Teacher.
c) Teachers appointed by Administrator or Deputy Inspector of
Schools in Government Schools but transferred to NonGovernment Schools along with the post shall be treated as
Government School Teachers and their services shall be treated
as a deputation and on retirement, the vacancy created remains a
government post.
d) Teachers appointed by Administrator or Deputy Inspector of
Schools in Government Schools but transferred to a vacant post
in a Non-Government School, the concerned teacher is a
Government Teacher, but the post remains a non-Government
post.
11.
It is submitted that the appointments of the writ petitioners are not
on the same footing with the appointments of the other teachers who are
already considered and recognised by the state respondents as Government
Teachers as they were appointed after the Act 1993 came into force, in
those Schools which had not been taken over by the Government and as
such, were outside the ambit of the Act of 1993. Learned counsel reiterates
and clarifies that the Act of 1993 which came into force on 02-06-1994, is
meant only for those teachers who were serving in Schools run by District
Councils (DCLP Schools) and for those DCLP School Teachers who were
deputed or transferred by the State Government to serve in a school not
being a DCLP School. It is also contended that the judgment rendered in
the case of Smti. Ferisha Phalley vs. State of Meghalaya is not applicable,
inasmuch as, the said Ferisha Phalley was appointed along with other 39
teachers by order dated 21-07-1982 and the Act of 1993 came into force
on 02-06-1994, when she was already in service and further, she was
appointed by the District Council authority and was posted in a Non-DCLP
School. The petitioners on the other hand, he submits, were appointed after
the Act came to force and as such, there is no similarity with the cited case
as the teachers appointed after 02-06-1994, at Non-DCLP Schools are not
considered as Government Teachers.
12.
With regard to the contention of the petitioner that 60 teachers under
Williamnagar Sub-Division were given the status as Government
Teachers, learned counsel submits that on examination by the Committee
constituted on 24-09-2014, it has been found that these 60 teachers were
not eligible to be treated as Government Teachers as they were appointed
after 02-06-1994. This he admits is an error as there was no basis for the
first Committee constituted on 16-03-2003 by the Government to approve
the case of the said 60 teachers. This error, he submits, committed by the
earlier Committee cannot be replicated and the petitioners cannot claim
negative equality. Learned counsel has placed reliance on the following 2
decisions namely; Secretary, Jaipur Development Authority, Jaipur vs.
Daulat Mal Jain & Ors. (1997) 1 SCC 35 and Union of India & Anr. vs.
International Trading Co. & Anr. (2003) 5 SCC 437, to impress upon the
point of negative equality and that Article 14 does not contemplate
repetition of a wrong action.
13.
On other subsequent contentions raised by the petitioners by way of
additional affidavits, it is submitted that the teachers referred to by the
petitioners therein were all appointed prior to 02-06-1994, whereas other
teachers such as the petitioners who were appointed after 02-06-1994, are
considered as Non-Government Teachers. Learned counsel submits that
there being no justifiable ground made out for any interference, these writ
petitions deserve no consideration and are liable to be rejected.
14.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after perusal of the
materials on record, this Court notes that the issues raised herein have, as
observed earlier, been gone into by this Court in the earlier writ petitions,
subjected to scrutiny by the Committee and final orders passed thereon,
and as such, the scope of re-examination of the issues therefore is limited.
The writ petitioners by this second round of litigation, have re-agitated the
points raised earlier which has been gone into and decided by the
Committee constituted on the orders of this Court. What remains is limited
only to examine as to whether all relevant aspects were considered, while
rejecting the case of the petitioners. At this juncture, it would be
worthwhile to refer to the relevant provisions of the Meghalaya (Taking
Over of the DCLP Schools) Act, 1993, more particularly, Sections 2, 3 and
4 which are reproduced herein below:
“MEGHALAYA ACT 6 OF 1994
THE MEGHALAYA TAKING OVER OF DISTRICT
COUNCIL LOWER PRIMARY SCHOOLS, ACT, 1993.
(as passed by the Meghalaya Legislative Assembly)
(Received the Assent of the Governor on the 2nd June,
1994. Published in the Gazette of Meghalaya, Extraordinary issue dated 2nd June, 1994)
AN ACT
to provide for the taking over of Primary Schools of the
District Councils in Meghalaya by the State Government
and for matters connected therewith.
Be it enacted by the Legislature of the State of Meghalaya
in the forty fourth year of the Republic of India as follows:-
Definitions. 2.
In this Act, unless there is anything
repugnant to the context(a)
“Act” means the Meghalaya (Taking
over of District Council Lower Primary
Schools) Act 1993;
(b)
“appointed day” means the date
appointed by the State Government
under sub-section (2) of section 1;
(c)
“autonomous district” means the
autonomous district, as the case may be,
of Khasi Hills, Garo Hills or Jaintia
Hills;
(d)
“cut-off-date” means the cut-off date
referred to in section 4;
(e)
“DCLP School” means any Lower
Primary School including a Junior Basic
School managed by the District Council;
(f)
“District Council” means a District
Council in the State of Meghalaya
constituted under the Sixth Schedule to
the Constitution;
(g)
“Section” means a section of the Act;
(h)
“State
Government”
means
the
Government of the State of Meghalaya;
and
(i)
“taking over” means the taking over of
DCLP Schools by the State Government
as referred to in section 3.
Taking over of 3. (1) On and from the appointed date all
DCLP Schools
DCLP Schools in the autonomous
districts shall stand taken over by and
vest in the State Government.
(2)
On the taking over of the schools under
sub-section (1) the liability on account
of :(a)
salary and allowances, including
any arrear thereof, of a teacher
who immediately before the
twentieth day of December, 1993 is
a teacher of such school shall pass
on the State Government; and
(b)
gratuity and pensionary benefits of
a DCLP school teacher, including
any arrear thereof, for any period
commencing from the cut- off date
shall be borne by the State
Government.
(3) The provisions of clauses (a) and (b) of
sub-section (2) shall also apply to DCLP
school teacher who is deputed or
transferred by the State Government to
serve in a School not being a DCLP
School.
Cut-off date. 4.
For calculating the length of service of a
DLCP school teacher for the purpose of
gratuity, pension, retirement benefits and
for other purposes of this Act the State
Government may by order fix a cut-off
date which shall not be date later than the
twentieth day of December, 1993 and
different cut-off dates may be fixed for
different autonomous districts.”
15.
A perusal of the above referred provisions, clearly shows that the
Act was enacted to provide for the taking over of Primary Schools of the
District Councils in Meghalaya, by the State Government. Section 2 (d)
speaks of a cut-off date which in relation with Section 4 is for the purpose
of calculating the length of service of a DCLP School Teacher for the
purpose of gratuity, pension and other retirement benefits. Section 3 (3)
provides for the coverage to those DCLP L.P. School teachers who were
deputed to serve in a School not being a DCLP School. The scheme of the
Act therefore, was to secure the services of those teachers who were
appointed by the respective Administrators or Deputy Inspector of Schools
before the commencement of the Act and a cut-off date was prescribed for
the different Autonomous Districts as per Section 4, for calculating the
length of service. The Act nowhere envisages the coverage of teachers
appointed after the commencement of the Act and posted in NonGovernment Schools.
16.
The Committee after hearing the writ petitioners, by its report had
examined the cases of the petitioners and the parameters, findings and
conclusion are reproduced herein below:
Parameters:
1. All Primary School teachers appointed originally by the
Executive Committees of the three District Councils and
posted in DCLP Schools or transferred to Non Govt. LPS
before the cut off date i.e. 2nd June 1994 are eligible to be
treated as Govt. teachers.
2. Teachers appointed by the Administrator/D.I. of Schools
after the cut off date i.e. 2nd June 1994 and posted in
DCLP/Govt. L.P. Schools but later transferred to Non
Govt. LPS along with the post shall be treated as Govt.
teachers. The post remains a Non-Govt. post after the
retirement of the concerned teacher.
3. Teachers appointed by the Administrator/D.I. of Schools
after the cut off date i.e. 2nd June 1994 posted in Non
Govt. Schools and continue serving in Non Govt. Schools
till date are not eligible to be treated as Govt. teachers.
Findings of the Committee: The details and particulars of
the all the teachers as per terms of reference of the
Committee constituted by the Govt. have been adhered to
and the following are the finding of the Committee SubDivision- Wise.
(a) Amlarem Sub Division
1.
The detail statement of all the 11 (eleven) Petitioners
was compiled along with the appointment order and
enclosed at Annexure VI.
2.
The statement of Shri Heron Roy Manner
representative of WP(C) 301/2013 (annexed as Annexure
VII). After examination of the statement and verification
from the
records available in the Office, it is found that
his contention
at Para 2 & 3 is unjustifiable as the
teachers appointed vide order No. APA/E-2/94-95 dt.
25/1/1995, dt. 18/5/1995, dt
26/9/1995, dt. 11/3/1996 and
dt. 28/11/1997 have not been considered earlier and at
present also as they are not eligible to be treated as Govt.
teachers as they were appointed by the
D.I. of Schools
nd
after cut off date of 2 June 1994 and posted
in Non
Govt. I.P.S till date.
(b) Khliehriat Sub Division
1.
The details of all the 29 Petitioners was compiled in
the statement along with the appointment orders is enclosed
as Annexure VIII.
2.
The Statement of Shri Pyntngen Mukhim
representative of the above Petitioners in WP(C) No.
302/2013 was recorded and enclosed at Annexure IX.
In his statement at Para 2 he contested that out of 41
teachers appointed by the D.I. of Schools, Khliehriat vide
Order No. A-01/PRY/K/94-95/3237-297 dtd 25/1/1995 some
were considered as Govt. teachers and some were left out.
On scrutiny and verification from the records available in
the Office, it is found that the contention is not true and
justifiable as the list of teachers appeared in the above
appointment order have never been considered by the
previous committee as they were appointed after the cut off
date and posted in Non-Govt. LPS till date.
(c) Jowai Sub Division
1.
There are 38 Petitioners under this Sub Division. The
details statement of the particulars of the above petitioners
was compiled along with the appointment order is enclosed
at Annexure X.
2.
The Statement of Smt. Airona Lyngdoh,
representative of WP(C) No. 303 of 2013 was recorded and
enclosed as Annexure XI.
The petitioner Smt. Airona Lyngdoh contested at Para
2 that out of 81 teachers appointed in different appointment
order, 38 teachers were left out by the Govt. for
consideration as Govt. teachers by the previous Committee.
As such they pray that their case also should be considered.
At Para 3, the petitioners contested that 60 teachers under
Williamnagar Sub Division were considered as Govt.
teachers
vide
Order
No.
DEME/GA/APPT/COM/11/2006/249 dtd 2/7/2007. As such
their case also should be considered. The above order is
enclosed as Annexure XII.
On scrutiny of the records and documents available in
the Office vis-à-vis the order issued by the Directorate dtd
2/7/2007 it is found that the contention appears to be true as
the said 60 number of teachers were appointed by the D.I. of
Schools Williamnagar and posted in Non Govt. LPS.
Conclusion- On the above facts narrated,
Committee concludes its findings as below:-
the
(1) It is found that most of the teachers/petitioners
has already presented their case before the earlier
Committees constituted by the Govt. but their case was not
considered as they were not eligible to be treated as Govt.
teachers as they were appointed by the concerned
Administrator/D.I. of schools after the cut off date i.e 2nd
June 1994. In the instant case also it appears that all the
teachers/ petitioners were appointed after the cut off date
and posted in Lower Primary schools and continue to serve
till date.
(2) Regarding the contention of petitioners that 60
teachers
under Williamnagar Sub-Division were
considered as Govt. teachers which is a fact, the present
Committee found that the above 60 teachers were not
actually eligible to be treated as Govt. teachers as they were
appointed after the cut-off date i.e 2nd June, 1994. It is not
known on what basis the above teachers were considered to
be treated as Govt. teachers by the first Committee
constituted
by
the
Govt.
vide
Notification
th
No.EDN.223/2003/122 Dated 16 March, 2006 and
approved by the Govt. This particular case is referred to the
State Govt. for decision.
(3) As per records available, it also appears that the post
sanctioned in the above schools was issued after the cut off
date which clearly indicates that new posts were sanctioned
by the Govt. after the primary schools in the state were taken
over by the Govt. The sanction order is enclosed as
Annexure XIII.
17.
The examination of the cases of the petitioners by the Committee
and the parameters as set by the Committee therefore, cannot be faulted
with, as it has been clearly spelt out therein, that teachers appointed by the
Administrator/Deputy Inspector of Schools after the cut-off date and
posted in Non-Government Schools and who continue serving in the NonGovernment Schools till date, are not eligible to be treated as Government
Teachers.
18.
The impugned order dated 04-05-2015, which followed the
Committee’s findings at para 7 (b) and 8 (e) had noted as follows:
“7(b) The report of the Committee on the above
contentions of the above petitioners has been seen and
the appointment orders examined. It is found that
some teachers appointed vide the above mentioned
appointment orders were treated as Government
teachers while some others have not been treated as
Government teachers. On further examination it is
found that all those teachers who have been treated as
Government teachers vide the above mentioned
appointment orders were appointed in DCLP Schools
which had been taken over by the Government under
the Meghalaya (Taking over of the District Council
Lower Primary Schools) Act, 1993 while those who
were not treated as Government teachers were
appointed in Schools which had not been taken over
by the Government.”
“8(e) The argument of the petitioners that they are
“similarly situated” with the sixty teachers of
Williamnagar Sub-Division cannot be accepted
because that earlier Committee had erred in its
recommendations. The petitioners are not “similarly
situated” with the 50 other teachers recommended by
the earlier Committee in whose case regularization
has been correctly done as per Notification No.
LL(B)/130/92/103 Dated 2/6/94. An error committed
by an earlier Committee cannot be replicated. Hence,
it is not possible to accept the contention of the
petitioners.”
19.
It is noted therefore, that the Committee had examined the entire
matter from all angles after hearing the petitioners and as such, the findings
and resultant final order dated 04-05-2015 do no call for any interference.
20.
On the aspect of the teachers of Williamnagar Sub-Division being
accorded Government teacher status, the final order has also noted that the
criteria in respect of those teachers seems to have not been followed. As it
is undisputed that the grant of Government L.P. School Teacher status was
incorrectly done and not based on the prescribed criteria, I find force in the
submissions of the learned counsel for the respondents that other teachers
similarly situated cannot claim the same benefit on the ground of equality.
In this context, on the concept of negative equality, the judgments cited by
the learned counsel for the respondents are relevant and the extracts of the
paragraphs thereof, are quoted herein below.
Extract of para 24 in Secretary, Jaipur Development Authority,
Jaipur vs. Daular Mal Jain & Ors. (supra) reads as follows:
“24. ……… Article 14 proceeds on the premise that
a citizen has legal and valid right enforceable at law
and persons having similar right and persons
similarly circumstanced, cannot be denied of the
benefit thereof. Such person cannot be discriminated
to deny the same benefit. The rational relationship
and legal back-up are the foundations to invoke the
doctrine of equality in case of persons similarly
situated. If some persons derived benefit by illegality
and had escaped from the clutches of law, similar
persons cannot plead, nor the court can countenance
that benefit had from infraction of law and must be
allowed to be retained. Can one illegality be
compounded by permitting similar illegal or
illegitimate or ultra vires acts? Answer is obviously
no.”
Paragraph 13 in Union of India & Anr. vs. International Trading
Co. & Anr. (supra) reads as follows:
“13. What remains now to be considered, is the
effect of permission granted to the thirty two vessels.
As highlighted by learned counsel for the appellants,
even if it is accepted that there was any improper
permission, that may render such permissions
vulnerable so far as the thirty two vessels are
concerned, but it cannot come to the aid of the
respondents. It is not necessary to deal with that
aspect because two wrongs do not make one right. A
party cannot claim that since something wrong has
been done in another case direction should be given
for doing another wrong. It would not be setting a
wrong right, but would be perpetuating another
wrong. In such matters there is no discrimination
involved. The concept of equal treatment on the logic
of Article 14 of the Constitution of India (in short “the
Constitution”) cannot be pressed into service in such
cases. What the concept of equal treatment
presupposes is existence of similar legal foothold. It
does not countenance repetition of a wrong action to
bring both wrongs on a par. Even if hypothetically it
is accepted that a wrong has been committed in some
other cases by introducing a concept of negative
equality the respondents cannot strengthen their case.
They have to establish strength of their case on some
other basis and not by claiming negative equality.”
21.
The judgment rendered in Ferisha Phalley will have no application
in the instant case as there is no similarity to her appointment with that of
the petitioners as they were all appointed after the commencement of the
Act of 1993.
22.
In view of the discussions above, no grounds have been made out to
revisit the circumstances or the situation to warrant a reversal or
interference in the findings of the Committee and there being no infirmity
in the impugned order, these writ petitions are accordingly dismissed.
23.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
11.07.2022
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review