The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. Heard and perused the evidence on record. In terms of the judgment cited and argument placed by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant-herein, this Court is convinced that the matter herein needs to be remanded back to the learned Tribunal below for re-consideration of the same on its merit. Accordingly, the appeal stands allowed and the impugned Judgment and order of the learned Tribunal below is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the learned Tribunal below. The learned Tribunal below shall decide the matter of compensation, if any, on merits in accordance with law as expeditiously as possible.
11. As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stand closed. suhanjit
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP NO.34 OF 2022
Shri Pranab Debnath
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
Shri Laxman Paul and ors.
……. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. A. Saha, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.C. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 19.04.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
This present application has been filed under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 against the
impugned Judgment and Award dated 10.01.2022, passed by
the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.1, West
Tripura, Agartala in T.S.(MAC) No.183 of 2017.
2.
The facts of the case of the claimant-petitioner-
appellant, in brief, is that on 22.10.2015 he was coming towards
Agartala by riding his motorbike bearing no. TR-01-U-6753
along with his friend namely, Sri Litan Debnath as pillion rider
after visiting puja pandal. When he reached near a fast food
shop by the side of Amtali Police Station, at that time, a Maruti
Van bearing no. TR-01-AK-0603 coming from the opposite
direction in a rash and negligent manner dashed his motorbike
and they met with an accident. As a result, he sustained
grievous fracture injuries on his head, left leg, right hand, face,
and other parts of the body. Immediately after the accident, he
was taken to Tripura Medical College & Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
Memorial Teaching Hospital for his treatment wherein he got
admitted as an indoor patient w.e.f. 22.10.2015 to 16.11.2015.
During the period of his treatment, an operation was done on
his left leg. Thereafter, again on 11.01.2016, he got admitted to
the said hospital wherein further operation was also done on his
left leg and he was discharged on 18.01.2016 and by this way,
he spent Rs.5,95,000/- for his medical treatment. Concerning
the said accident a police case was registered at Amtali Police
Station vide Amtali P.S. Case No.150/2016 (maybe 150/2015
according to FIR) under Sections 279/337/338 I.P.C. As stated,
he was a private job holder having a monthly income of
Rs.7,000/- and was 25 years old at that time. Thus, the said
petition was filed claiming compensation of Rs.38,95,000/-.
3.
O.P. No.1 therein i.e., the owner-respondent in his
written objection formally denied the age, occupation, and
monthly income of the petitioner. In his written objection he
admitted the accident but pleaded that the said accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the motorbike
bearing No. TR-01-U-6753 driven by the petitioner himself
accompanied by Sri Litan Debnath as a pillion rider. He also
pleaded that the Maruti Van bearing no.TR-01-AK-0603 was not
responsible for the said accident. He further pleaded that his
vehicle was duly insured with the National Insurance Company
Ltd. covering the date of the accident and the vehicle had its all
valid documents at that time. So, if any compensation is
awarded that should be paid by the insurer of the said vehicle.
4.
O.P. No.2, National Insurance Company Ltd. in
their written statement formally denied the involvement of the
Maruti Van bearing no. TR-01-AK-0603 in the accident which
took place on 02.10.2015 (maybe 22.10.2015) near Amtali
Police Station, registration of Police Case vide FIR No.150/2016
(maybe FIR no.150/2015) under Sections 279/337/338 IPC and
Section 184 of M.V. Act, sustaining of injuries, admission and
undertaken treatment at Tripura Medical College and Dr. B.R.
Ambedkar Memorial Hospital, age, the income of the petitioner
etc. O.P. No.2 in their written statement stated that the claim of
the petitioner is highly excessive. Lastly, O.P. no.2 stated that
the Insurance Company is not liable to pay any compensation as
the vehicle had no valid vehicular documents like Driving
Licence and Insurance Policy, etc., and as such the claim of the
petitioner is liable to be dismissed in limine.
5.
O.P. No.3, Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
in their written objection formally denied the rash and negligent
riding of the motorbike bearing No. TR-01-U-6753 by its rider,
income, occupation, age, etc. However, the petitioner is put to
strict proof thereof. O.P. No.3 in their written objection stated
that the matter of the accident was not reported by the owner of
the Motorbike bearing No. TR-01-U-6753 in collusion with the
petitioner with a view to sustain loss to the Insurance Company.
They also
stated that the compensation claimed by the
petitioner is highly excessive. Lastly, they prayed for the
dismissal of the case.
6.
To prove the case, the appellant herein adduced
2(two) witnesses including himself and on the other side, the
respondents did not adduce any evidence. After hearing the
parties, learned Tribunal below dismissed the claim petition
holding that the accident took place due to rash and negligent
driving of the appellant as held in the police report.
7.
Aggrieved by the impugned Judgment and award
dated 10.01.2022, passed by the learned Member, Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala in
T.S.(MAC) No.183 of 2017, the appellant has preferred this
present appeal to set aside the impugned judgment and award
dated 10.01.2022 passed by the learned Member, Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala.
8.
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel assisted by Ms.
A. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the appellant as well as
Mr.
K.C
Bhattacharjee,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
respondent No.2.
9.
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
submits that the learned Tribunal failed to appreciate the
evidence on record and passed the impugned judgment and
award. The learned Tribunal below at the time of passing the
impugned judgment and award relied on the police report but
the learned Tribunal has not appreciated the deposition of P.W.1 and P.W.2. P.W.2 is the eyewitness of the case. Apart from
these two no other witnesses turned up, and the respondents
failed to shake the deposition of the claimant-petitioner. The
claimant-petitioner in clear and unambiguous terms narrated
about the accident. The learned Tribunal below failed to
appreciate the same and disbelieved the depositions of P.W.1
and P.W.2 and passed the impugned Judgment and order.
Hence the same is liable to interfere.
In support of his argument that the findings of the
charge sheet, police report, and FIR cannot be relied upon to
discard the evidence witnesses, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel
placed reliance upon Paras-5 and 5A of the Judgment of this
Hon’ble Court reported in (2014) 2 TLR 14 titled as Puspa
Das and ors. Vs. Sankar Deb and ors which is reproduced
herein-under:“5. Though the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal is not a
Court and is not required to conduct an enquiry in accordance to the strict
rules of evidence, it must follow the basic principles of law and the basic
rules of natural justice. Any procedure to be legal and valid must be a
procedure which gives the effected party a right to put forth his or her own
case. I have no doubt in my mind that evidence recorded in some other
case or the statement recorded by the police or Magistrate cannot be used
in Motor Accident Claims Tribunal proceedings unless it is proved that the
person who made the statement is dead or for some other reason his
presence cannot be procured in Court. Reference in this behalf may be
made to Section 33 of the Evidence Act, which reads as follows :
“ 33. Relevancy of certain evidence for proving, in subsequent proceeding,
the truth of facts therein stated– Evidence given by a witness in a judicial
proceeding, or before any person authorized by law to take it, is relevant
for the purpose of proving, in a subsequent judicial proceeding or in a later
stage of the same judicial proceeding, the truth of the facts which it states,
when the witness is dead or cannot be found, or if his presence cannot be
obtained without an amount of delay or expense which, under the
circumstances of the case, the Court considers unreasonable: Provided–
that the proceeding was between the same parties or their representatives
in interest; that the adverse party in the first proceeding had the right and
opportunity to cross examine; that the questions in issue were
substantially the same in the first as in the second proceeding.
Explanation– A criminal trial or inquiry shall be deemed to be a proceeding
between the prosecutor and the accused within the meaning of this
section.”
5. One of the pristine rules of our jurisprudence is that the witness
examined by one party should be permitted to be cross examined by the
other party. It is, therefore, obvious that a statement made before the
police or a Magistrate or other judicial authority cannot be read in evidence
against some other affected party without giving that affected party a right
to cross examine the said witness. Therefore, the Tribunal was right in
holding that without examining any of these witnesses, the petitioner could
not prove the accident.
On the same point, learned counsel also relied
upon the Judgment and Order of this Hon’ble Court reported in
(2016) 2 TLR 975 titled as Rampati Chakma and Sunil
Kumar Ram and ors.
10.
Heard and perused the evidence on record. In
terms of the judgment cited and argument placed by the learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellant-herein,
this
Court
is
convinced that the matter herein needs to be remanded back to
the learned Tribunal below for re-consideration of the same on
its merit. Accordingly, the appeal stands allowed and the
impugned Judgment and order of the learned Tribunal below is
set aside and the matter is remanded back to the learned
Tribunal below. The learned Tribunal below shall decide the
matter of compensation, if any, on merits in accordance with
law as expeditiously as possible.
11.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stand closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review