The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. In the light of the above discussions, I find merit in this appeal, and accordingly, the judgment and decree and other directions, as passed by the learned trial court, are interfered with.
19. Consequently, the judgment and decree dated 29.06.2019 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court no.2, West Tripura, Agartala, in case no. T.S. 47 of 2017, cancelling the Gift deed no. I-4487 dated
27. 05.2015 (Exbt.-4) stands set-aside and quashed. The Gift deed no. I-4487 dated 27.05.2015 is held to be valid and executable. The directions, as passed by the learned trial court upon the Sub-Registrar to enter the cancellation of the Gift deed no. I-4487 dated 27.05.2015 also stands setaside and quashed. The Sub-Registrar shall restore the Gift deed no. I-4487 dated 27.05.2015 to its original status, if it is already marked „cancelled‟. Registry is directed to draw the decree accordingly. Send down the LCRs. Saikat
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA 26 of 2019
Sri Papan Ghosh
son of Sri Sambhu Ghosh, resident of Majlishpur, P.S. Ranirbazar,
District- West Tripura
....Defendant-Appellant
VERSUS
1.(a). Smt. Sonali Datta (Sen) alias Ruma Datta,
wife of Dr. Sujan Sen, resident of P-22, Mitra Colony, Behala
P.O. Behala, Kolkata-700034, West Bengal
1.(b) Smt. Kakali Datta,
wife of not known, daughter of late Kali Bhusan Datta,
resident of Kazipara road, Parnasree, P.O. Behala,
Kolkata-700034, West Bengal
... Plaintiff-Respondents
For Appellant (s )
:
Mr. SM Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate
Ms. A. Pal, Advocate
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Advocate
For Respondent (s)
:
None
Date of hearing & delivery
:
31.05.2022
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
1.
The present appeal has been filed by the appellant challenging the
legality and validity of the judgment and decree dated 29.06.2019 passed by
the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court no.2, West Tripura, Agartala,
in case no. T.S. 47 of 2017, whereby and whereunder the learned Civil
Judge, Senior Division, Court no. 2 had cancelled the registered Gift Deed
no. I-4487 dated 27.05.2015 in favour of the defendant, Papan Ghosh .
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties in this appeal have been
referred to according to their original status in the suit.
3.
Briefly stated, the plaintiff, Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta) of the instant suit
was the sole-owner of the land described in the schedule of the plaint. It is
pertinent to mention here that she, being the second wife, was the widow of
one late Kali Bhusan Datta. Undisputed fact is that, late Kali Bhusan Datta,
had married Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta) after the death of his first wife. Late
Kali Bhusan Datta had two daughters out of his first wife. Smt. Sefa Rani
Ghosh (Datta) was issueless. Said Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta) died on
10.09.2021 during pendency of the present appeal leaving behind said two
daughters, who were accordingly substituted on 04.01.2022. Thereafter,
notices were served upon them, but, the notices returned unserved
compelling the defendant-appellant to issue notice upon the said
daughter/respondents through newspaper publication dated 19.04.2022. This
court vide order dated 24.05.2022 had passed an order making it clear that if
the respondents fail to appear and participate in the hearing on the next date,
the matter would be heard and disposed of ex parte in their absentia, but, till
today the respondents i.e. the two daughters did not turn up. This is a matter
of the year 2019. Hence, this court as per order dated 24.05.2022 has taken
up the matter for hearing and final disposal.
4.
It will be relevant to mention here that the said two daughters, namely,
Smt. Sonali Datta (Sen) and Smt. Kakali Datta, had relinquished their right,
title and interest by a Deed of Relinquishment (Exbt.-2) in favour of late
Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta) during her lifetime. Ultimately, there is no dispute
that late Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta) was the sole owner of the land and
building for which she executed the Gift Deed dated 27.05.2015 which was
registered on 28.05.2015. The plaintiff executed the said Gift Deed in favour
of the defendant, Papan Ghosh. However, in the year 2017, Sefa Rani Ghosh
(Datta) had instituted a suit under Section 31 of the Specific Relief Act for
cancellation of the said Gift Deed vide no. I-4487 dated 27.05.2015 on the
ground that the said Gift Deed was the outcome of committing fraud by the
defendant, Papan Ghosh.
5.
Being summoned, said Papan Ghosh, as defendant, appeared and
contested the claims of the plaintiffs by filing written statement where he
denied all the allegations which were levelled against him. After exchange of
pleadings, the learned trial court framed the following issues:
“i) Whether the suit of the plaintiff is maintainable in its present form
and nature?
ii) Whether the plaintiff has cause of action for filing the instant suit?
iii) Whether the suit of the plaintiff is barred by law of limitation?
iv) Whether the registered deed of gift vide no. 1-4487, dated 27-05-2015
specifically described in Schedule-A is a void instrument? If so, whether
the same is liable to be delivered up and cancelled?
v) Whether plaintiff is entitled to get the decree as prayed for?
vi) To what other relief / reliefs the parties are entitled to?”
6.
The parties to the suit had adduced their respective evidences and
introduced the relevant documents. Thereafter, arguments were heard. The
learned trial court after considering the evidences on record held that the
plaintiffs had been able to substantiate the plea of fraud taken by her in
execution of the Gift Deed dated I-4487 dated 27.05.2018 (Exbt.-4), and
decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs cancelling the said Gift Deed .
While decreeing the suit, the learned trial court ordered that:
“27. In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed on contest with cost.
The registered deed of gift vide no. I-4487 dated 27- 05-2015 executed by
the plaintiff Smt. Shefa Rani Ghosh (Datta) in favour of the defendant Sri
Papan Ghosh is adjudged to be voidable and accordingly liable to be
delivered up and cancelled.
28. Draw up the decree accordingly and place before me for signing
within 15 days from today.
29. Send a copy of the decree to the District Sub-Registrar, West Tripura,
Agartala for taking note on the copy of the gift deed in his books the fact
of its cancellation as per Section 31 (2) of the Specific Relief Act.
30. Make necessary entry in the concerned T.R. and the CIS.”
7.
Being aggrieved by and dis-satisfied with the judgment and decree
dated 29.06.2019 passed by the learned trial court, the appellant has
preferred this appeal before this court.
8.
I have heard Mr. SM Chakraborty, learned Senior Counsel assisted by
Ms. A. Pal and Ms. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel for the defendantappellant. I have also meticulously gone through the judgment passed by the
learned trial.
9.
Mr. SM Chakraborty, learned senior counsel has candidly drawn
attention of this court that the learned trial court had observed that the Gift
Deed was executed in accordance with law. It was placed before the SubRegistrar for registration. The Sub-Registrar put question about the
authenticity of the execution to which Smt. Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta) had
agreed that in her conscious mind and good health and after going through
the contents of the deed, she put her signature and executed the said Gift
deed in favour of the defendant. So, there is no dispute regarding the
execution and registration of the Gift deed. However, learned senior counsel
appearing for the defendant submits that the learned trial court had cancelled
the Gift deed (Exbt.-4) only on the ground that from the evidences it appears
that the defendant made a proposal to the plaintiff to execute the Gift Deed,
and according to the learned trial court, such proposal initiated by the
defendant had constituted the factum of fraud.
10.
In view of the above submissions of learned senior counsel, I have
scrutinized the evidences let in by the scribe of the Gift Deed as well as the
attesting witness.
11.
The scribe appearing before the court adduced that he prepared the
Deed as per version and dictation of the parties. After preparation of the Gift
Deed, it was read over and explained to the donor, Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta),
and also had given a copy of the same to her for perusal and consent. Finding
the willingness and consent of the parties, the scribe (CW-1) sent for
requisition and purchased the stamp paper alongwith required fees for the
same. In his cross-examination, the scribe denied the suggestion put forth by
the plaintiff side that the contents of the Gift Deed was not read over and
explained to the plaintiff. In his chief-examination, the scribe has
categorically stated that the plaintiff has signed every pages of the Gift Deed
on being satisfied to the contents of the same, and thereafter, he presented
the said Deed for its registration before the concerned Sub-Registrar.
Similarly the two attesting witnesses had also deposed that the contents of
the Deed were read over to the plaintiff and they put their signatures after
being asked by the doner i.e. Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta). It is also revealed
from the evidences that at the time of execution of the said Deed of Gift
(Exbt.-4) Sefa Rani Ghosh (Datta) was in sound health and mind and she
was a literate lady and served as Office Superintendent in the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura.
12.
After perusal of the Gift Deed (Exbt.-4) it comes to fore that there is
an endorsement from the Sub-Registrar to the effect that “the vendor has
read over the entire contents to this Deed of Gift by herself, on admitting it
to be true and correct she has executed this Deed. The defendant, Papan
Ghosh also accepted the said Gift”.
13.
From the judgment of the learned trial court, it further reveals that the
learned trial court had disbelieved the theory of undue influence caused upon
the plaintiff as tried to be introduced by the plaintiff because there was no
such averment in the plaint. The findings of the learned trial court, in the
opinion of this court, are imaginary. He came to a finding that the plaintiff
had full faith and trust upon the defendant and she blindly believed whatever
was told by the defendant to her regarding the contents of the Gift Deed. It is
the plaintiff‟s case that she told the defendant to make a Deed of Gift for
50% of the total land, but, the defendant, according to her, had prepared the
Deed for the entire land. When it is apparent on the face of the Gift Deed
that the plaintiff before execution of the Deed had gone through the entire
contents of the Deed and having been satisfied with such contents, she
signed the document and appeared before the Sub-Registrar and put her
signature without raising any objection to the contents of the Deed. In my
opinion, the same should not be suspected. In this situation, the proposition
made by the learned trial court is unacceptable to this court. If the proposal
is made by a beneficiary of the Gift Deed, it does not mean that he has
committed fraud when evidences regarding execution and registration of the
Gift Deed affirming the contents therein are overwhelming and further the
execution of the deed is confirmed by the attesting witnesses.
[Emphasis supplied]
14.
„Fraud‟ has been defined in Section 17 of the Indian Contract Code,
1872, which says:“Fraud means and includes any of the following acts committed by a party
to a contract, or with his connivance, or by his agent, with intent to
deceive another party thereto or his agent, or to induce him to enter into
the contract:—
"(1) the suggestion, as to a fact, of that which is not true, by one who
does not believe it to be true;
(2) the active concealment of a fact by one having knowledge or belief
of the fact;
(3) a promise made without any intention of performing it;
(4) any other act fitted to deceive;
(5) any such act or omission as the law specially declares to be
fraudulent”.
Explanation—Mere silence as to facts likely to affect the willingness of a
person to enter into a contract is not fraud, unless the circumstances of
the case are such that, regard being had to them, it is the duty of the
person keeping silence to speak, or unless his silence is, in itself,
equivalent to speech”.
15.
In the perspective of evidence of PW-1, she has failed to prove the
elements of “fraud” alleged against the defendant. It has been settled under
section 34(3) of the Registration Act, that there is no scope in normal course
for revocation of a gift deed when the said deed of gift was executed by the
donor and accepted by the done and registered by the registering authority.
The learned trial court came to the findings without looking into the entire
evidence.
16.
As discussed in the preceding paragraphs, there is absolutely no
evidence of PW-1 to show that the Gift of Deed was executed on account of
fraud being practiced by the defendant.
17.
As I said earlier, mere making a proposal by the donee, in no way
attracts the ingredients of fraud as alleged by PW-1. To reiterate, in her
evidence, PW-1 admitted that at the time of execution of the Gift deed she
went to the office of the Sub-Registry. The evidence, if collectively read, and
the provisions of the Registration Act, the summary shows that PW-1
executed the deed (Exbt.-4) vide Deed no. I-4487, dated 27.05.2015, on her
own will and volition and in conscious mind. Needless to say, there is no
dispute regarding execution and registration of the Gift deed, as held by the
learned trial court.
18.
In the light of the above discussions, I find merit in this appeal, and
accordingly, the judgment and decree and other directions, as passed by the
learned trial court, are interfered with.
19.
Consequently, the judgment and decree dated 29.06.2019 passed by
the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court no.2, West Tripura, Agartala,
in case no. T.S. 47 of 2017, cancelling the Gift deed no. I-4487 dated
27.05.2015 (Exbt.-4) stands set-aside and quashed. The Gift deed no. I-4487
dated 27.05.2015 is held to be valid and executable. The directions, as
passed by the learned trial court upon the Sub-Registrar to enter the
cancellation of the Gift deed no. I-4487 dated 27.05.2015 also stands setaside and quashed. The Sub-Registrar shall restore the Gift deed no. I-4487
dated 27.05.2015 to its original status, if it is already marked „cancelled‟.
Registry is directed to draw the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
Saikat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review