Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
LA. App. No. 115 of 2019
1. Shri Nirmal Debnath LR of Lt. Narayan Debnath, Narayan Debnath
having died, represented by his Legal Representative namely- Shri
Nirmal Debnath, S/O Late Narayan Debnath residents of Village Hatileta
of Surjyamaninagar, P.S.- Amtali, District- Sepahijala Tripura.
2.Shri Biplab Debnath (Son), S/O Late Narayan Debnath, residents of
Village Hatileta of Surjyamaninagar, P.S.- Amtali, District- Sepahijala
Tripura.
3.Smt. Namita Debnath (Daughter) D/O Late Narayan Debnath,
residents of Village Hatileta of Surjyamaninagar, P.S.- Amtali, DistrictSepahijala Tripura.
4.Smt. Kiranbala Debnath (Wife) W/O Late Narayan Debnath,
residents of Village Hatileta of Surjyamaninagar, P.S.- Amtali, DistrictSepahijala Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1.The State of Tripura (Represented by the Secretary), Department of
Revenue, Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. and P.S.New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura, Pin No. 799010.
2.The Land Acquisition Collector, Office of the District Magistrate
and Collector ,West Tripura, Agartala, P.O.- Agartala, P.S. - West
Agartala, District - West Tripura, Pin No. 799001.
3.The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction), N.F.Railway, of
Siddhi Ashram, P.S. - Amtali, District - West Tripura, Pin No. 799003.
-----Respondent(s)
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
LA. App. No. 116 of 2019
1.Shri Nirmal Debnath LR of LT. Narayan Debnath. Narayan Debnath,
having died, represented by his legal representative namely- Shri Nirmal
Debnath (Son),S/O Late Narayan Debnath,
2.Shri Biplab Debnath (Son) S/O Late Narayan Debnath.
3.Smt. Namita Debnath (Daughter) D/O Late Narayan Debnath.
4.Smt. Kiranbala Debnath (Wife) W/O Late Narayan Debnath, all are
residents of Village Hatileta of Surjyamaninagar, P.S.- Amtali, DistrictSepahijala Tripura.
-----------Appellant(s)
Versus
1.The State of Tripura (Represented by the Secretary), Department of
Revenue, Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. and P.S.New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura, Pin No. 799010.
[
2.The Land Acquisition Collector, Office of the District Magistrate
and Collector , West Tripura, Agartala, P.O.- Agartala, P.S. - West
Agartala, District - West Tripura, Pin No. 799001.
3.The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction), N.F.Railway of Siddhi
Ashram, P.S. - Amtali, District - West Tripura, Pin No. 799003.
--------Respondent(s).
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. A. Nandi, Adv.
Mr. P. Gautam,Adv.
Ms. A. Banik, Adv.
Date of hearing
Date of delivery of
Judgment/Order
:
:
29.11.2022
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES/NO
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
21.12.2022
JUDGMENT
[1]
This is an appeal against the common judgment and award
dated 08.05.2019 passed by the learned Land Acquisition Judge (LA
Judge hereunder) of West Tripura Judicial District, Agartala in case No.
Misc(LA) 196 of 2011 and Misc(LA) 42 of 2013. Among the two appeals
presented before this Court, LA Appeal No.115 of 2019 is arising out of
Misc.LA 42 of 2013 in which the learned LA Judge by the impugned
judgment awarded compensation of a sum of Rs.2,09,500/- towards
loss of rubber trees of the claimant appellants and LA Appeal No.116 is
arising out of the impugned judgment passed by the LA Judge in LA 196
of 2011 in which the learned LA Judge enhanced the compensation for
acquisition of land of the claimant appellants from Rs.1,26,000/- per
kani to Rs.3,00,000/- per kani along with other statutory benefits. Since
the facts and law involved in both the appeals are identical and the
parties are also same, both the appeals are taken up together for
disposal by a common judgment.
[2]
In LA Appeal No.116 of 2019 arising out Misc (LA)196 of
2011, 1.96 acres of tilla land in Madhuban Mauja recorded under
Khatian No 2835 in plot No.1463/7530(P) and 1463/8745 was acquired
by the LA Collector of West Tripura District (as it was then) under
notification No.F.9(8)-REV/ACQ/XIV/09 dated 16.07.2009 issued under
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act,1894 (LA Act, hereunder) for
extension of new railway line from Agartala to Sabroom.
[3]
For
assessment
of
compensation,
the
LA
Collector
examined 14 sale instances produced by the parties interested in the
land. He considered sale deed No.1-188 and deed No.1-1884 both dated
08.06.2007 as the most ideal deeds and on the basis of those deeds
assessed the rate of acquired land at the rate of Rs.1.25 lakh per kani
owing to the proximity and similarity of the land of those deeds to the
acquired land.
[4]
The claimant appellants raised objection against the said
assessment made by the LA Collector and by written application made
to the collector, they sought for reference to Court for determination of
fair compensation. Accordingly, the LA Collector made the reference
under Section 18 of the LA Act to the LA Judge and the claim was
registered as Misc.(LA)196 of 2011 before the LA Judge. The claimant
appellants claimed enhancement of the compensation for the acquired
land and in addition Rs.10,000/- for each of the rubber trees lost by
them for such acquisition. It was stated by the claimants that the
acquired land was situated in close proximity to the national highway
and only 1 km away from the Sekerkote market and it had all
advantages to garner better market price. It was also stated by the
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
claimant appellants that educational establishments, shops, banks etc
were available around the acquired land.
[5]
In their counter statement the respondents pleaded before
the LA Judge that the acquired land had a distance of 6 hundred meters
from NH 44 and it consisted of mainly hillocks and uneven lands and the
LA Collector made a fair determination of the compensation on the basis
of sale deeds submitted by the interested parties.
[6]
The learned LA Judge having gone through the pleadings of
the parties and having appreciated the submissions of the learned
counsel representing the parties framed the following issues in
Misc.(LA)196 of 2011:- (LA Appeal No.116):
(i)Is the award passed by the LA Collector adequate, if not,
what should be the just amount of compensation.
(ii)To what other reliefs the parties are entitled.
[7]
In the course of hearing before the learned LA Judge, the
claimant appellants produced only one sale exemplar which was taken
into evidence and marked as Exbt.1. The learned LA Judge was of the
view that the area of acquired land was much larger than the area of
land covered under Exbt.1 and moreover, no map of the area was
produced by the claimant appellants to prove the distance between the
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
acquired land and the land of the sale exemplar. However, the learned
LA Judge relied on Exbt.1 since it represented the highest value among
the sale instances produced by the parties. Even though Exbt.1
represented 8 lakh per kani, the learned LA Judge, relying on the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Subh Ram & Ors. Vs. State of
Haryana & another reported in (2010) 1 SCC 444, viewed that the
range of deduction for the purpose of ascertainment of value of
acquired land in comparison to value of the sale exemplars may vary
from 20% to 75% considering the distance of acquired land from the
exemplar, difference in potentiality and expenditure likely to be incurred
to make the acquired land almost of similar value like the exemplar
etc.(emphasis supplied) On such consideration, the learned LA Judge,
deducted 70% of the value of the sale exemplar [Exbt.1] produced by
the claimant appellants. After 70% deduction, price of the land of
Exbt.1 came down from Rs.8,00,000/- per kani to 2,40,000/- per kani.
Considering the fact that there were matured rubber trees on the
acquired land, the learned LA Judge enhanced compensation from
Rs.1.25 lakh per kani to Rs.3 lakh per kani for the acquired land in
Misc.(LA)196 of 2011. The relevant extract of the observation of the
learned LA Judge is reproduced hereunder from the impugned
judgment:
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
“17. Let us first take up the matter of compensation in respect of Case No.
Misc. (L.A) 196 of 2011 wherein total 1.96 acre of tilla class of land was
acquired. To claim higher compensation the claimants proved only one Sale
Deed in this case bearing No.1-573 dated 23.08.2008 (Ext.1) wherein 0.05
acre of viti (tilla) class of land was sold out for Rs.1,00,000/- i.e.
@Rs.8,00,000/- per kani. No map was submitted by the claimants to show
the distance of Ext.1 from the acquired land. From the side of the L.A.
Collector one Sale Deed bearing no.1- 1585 dated 7.11.2006 was proved as
Exbt.A wherein 0.58 acre of lunga class of land was sold out at
Rs.1,80,000/- i.e. @ Rs.1,24,137/- per kani. Said lunga class of land is much
inferior in quality than the acquired tilla class of land. Thus, same cannot be
relied upon. The L.A. Collector also proved another Deed bearing no.1- 908
dated 14.03.2007 (Ext.B) which is a deed of partition. So, same also cannot
be taken into consideration as sale exemplar. The next Sale Deed proved by
the L.A. Collector was Deed No.1-1888 dated 8.6.2007 (Ext.C) wherein 1.5
acre of land of jungle tilla class was sold out @ Rs.1,25,066/- per kani. On
the boundary description of said deed it is mentioned that said land was
connected to the village road through a lunga. This fact itself indicates that
the location and potentiality of said land was much inferior. The fourth Sale
Deed proved by the L.A. Collector was Sale Deed No.1-1884 dated 8.6.2007
(Exbt.D) wherein it appears that similar jungle tilla class of land from the
same vendor was purchased by one Subhra Bhattacharjee having similar
location that to connect to the village road one is required to go through a
lunga. Thus, said Sale Deed under Exbt.D also cannot be safely relied upon.
Now to ascertain the value of the acquired land, comparatively more
reliable deed is Exbt.1 proved by the claimants which shows that 0.05 acre
of viti (tilla) class of land was sold @ Rs.8,00,000/- per kani. As per
boundary description of said deed on the north side, one 6 feet wide village
katchha road is situated which means it is directly connected to a village
road. However, as already stated above, the claimants did not submit any
document to show that the said land was nearer to the acquired land and
more so, viti (tilla) class of land is abit superior quality land than the normal
tilla class of land. Due to non submission of map normal presumption will be
that the land under Exbt.1 was situated at a considerable distance from the
acquired land. More so, the area of acquired land is much larger than the
area of land under Ext.1. As per law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Mahrawal Khewaji Trust, Faridkot & ors., v. State of Punjab & ors., AIR 2012
SC 2721, when there are several exemplars with reference to similar lands,
it is the general rule that the highest of the exemplars, if it is satisfied that
it is a bonafide transaction, has to be considered and accepted. On that
score also, Ext.1 is required to be relied upon than Ext.C and Ext.D. As per
another decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in Subh Ram & Ors. V.
State of Haryana & another, (2010) 1 SCC 444, the range of deduction for
the purpose of ascertainment of value of acquired land in comparison to
value of the sale exemplars may vary from 20% to 75% considering the
distance of acquired land from exemplar, difference in potentiality and
expenditure likely to be incurred to make the acquired land almost of
similar value like the exemplar etc.
18. Thus, considering the distance of the acquired land from the land under
Exbt.1 and also considering the abit inferior quality of acquired land and
also considering larger are of the acquired land, total (30% + 15% + 25%)
= 70% deduction is found to be just and proper. Thus, the value of the
acquired land without the value of the trees standing therein, is assessed at
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
Rs.2,40,000/-. In Raja Niranjan Singh v. State of U.P., (1979) 3 SCC 758,
Hon’ble Apex Court held that when the value of the acquired land is
determined, the standing trees therein cannot be separately assessed as
separate unit rather same is required to be taken into consideration as a
single unit along with valuation of the land. The relevant portion of the said
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is extracted below :“6. It is unnecessary in view of this factual position to consider
the legal submission of the appellants’ counsel that the land and
the trees should have been valued separately by reason of the
provisions of the Land Acquisition Act cited by him. Were it
necessary to consider this contention we would have preferred to
hold that since the land was acquired as a forest, it would have to
be valued as a forest and that value would depend upon the kind
of trees and the number of trees standing in the forest on the
date of acquisition. If the value of trees is taken into
consideration while valuing the forest, the trees cannot be valued
once again for arriving at the total compensation payable to the
owners of the forest.””
[8]
In LA Appeal No.115 arising out of Misc.(LA)42 of 2013 the
claimant appellants have claimed that they had 8 years old latex
yielding rubber plantation over the entire area of land measuring 1.96
acre which has been acquired by the respondents and due to the
damage caused to those latex yielding rubber plantation as a result of
the acquisition of their land they suffered huge loss. But the LA Collector
assessed the compensation towards such loss of plantation at
Rs.63,896/- and the learned LA Judge without assigning any reason
granted a lumpsum amount of compensation of Rs.2,09,500/-.
Therefore, they also challenged the award passed by the LA Judge in
Misc.(LA)42 of 2013 which is LA Appeal No.115 of 2019 on the following
grounds:
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
(i)Learned LA Judge should have valued each of the latex
yielding rubber trees at Rs.7143/- for the purpose of determination of
fair compensation.
(ii)Learned LA judge should have appreciated the fact that
the rubber plantation was the only source of livelihood of the claimant
appellants and as a result of they lost their livelihood.
(iii)Learned LA Judge did not appreciate the fact that the
matured rubber trees were damaged as a result of the acquisition of
land and the claimant appellants were entitled to compensation at the
rate of Rs.7153/- per tree.
[9]
Heard Mr.A.Nandi, learned counsel appearing for the
claimant appellants and Mr.P.Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the
Respondent No.2 as well as Ms. A.Banik, learned counsel appearing for
the Respondent No.3 .
[10]
Mr.Nandi, learned counsel appearing for the claimant
appellants has contended that despite a specific finding in paragraph 19
of the impugned judgment that there were 300 rubber trees over the
acquired land, the learned LA Judge assessed a lumpsum amount only
for 82 rubber trees instead of determining value of each of the rubber
trees, as a result of which the claimant appellants were deprived of a
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
fair compensation for the loss of those latex yielding rubber trees.
Counsel has also challenged the assessment of compensation for the
acquired land on the ground that despite relying on the sale exemplar
representing the highest value the learned LA Judge did not assess the
compensation at the rate covered by the said sale exemplar. He
arbitrarily deducted 70% of the price of the land covered under the said
sale exemplar without assigning any justifiable reason. Counsel,
therefore, urges the court to set aside the award passed by the learned
LA Judge and enhance the compensation for the acquired land as well
as for the loss caused to the claimant appellants due to the loss of 300
latex yielding rubber trees.
[11]
Mr. Nandi learned counsel has also contended that since
the land value has been determined with reference to compensation
awarded for nearby land, the LA Collector as well as the learned LA
Judge should have assessed adequate compensation for the rubber
trees separately. To nourish his contention, counsel has referred to the
decision of the Apex Court in the case of Ambya Kalya Mhatre & Ors
vs. The State of Maharashtra reported in(2011)9 SCC 325 wherein
the Hon’ble Apex Court in para 35 has held as under:
“35. We are afraid that the High Court has misread the said decision in
regard of valuing the land and trees separately. If the land value had
been determined with reference to the sale statistics or compensation
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
awarded for a nearby vacant land, then necessarily, the trees will have
to be valued separately. But if the value of the land has been
determined on the basis of the sale statistics or compensation awarded
for an orchard, that is land with fruit-bearing trees, then there is no
question of again adding the value of the trees. Further, if the market
value has been determined by capitalizing the income with reference to
yield, then also the question of making any addition either for the land
or for the trees separately does not arise. In this case, the
determination of market value was not with reference to the yield. Nor
was the determination of market value in regard to the land with
reference to the value of any orchard but was with reference to vacant
agricultural land. In the circumstances, the value of the trees could be
added to the value of the land.”
[12]
Counsel submits that the compensation assessed by the
learned LA Judge for the acquired land as well as for the rubber trees is
grossly inadequate which should be enhanced.
[13]
Mr.P.Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the LA
Collector [Respondent No.2] has argued that the LA Collector
considered as many as 14 sale instances and determined the market
value of the land at Rs.1.25 lakh per kani on the basis of the relevant
sale instance which does not call for any interference. Counsel has also
submitted that after a spot verification, the LA Collector awarded
Rs.63,896/- to the claimant appellants for loss of rubber trees which
was raised by the Learned LA Judge to a lumpsum amount of
Rs.2,09,500/-. It is further submitted by Mr. Gautam learned counsel
appearing for Respondent No.2 that the LA Judge committed no error in
determination of compensation for the acquired land and therefore, the
same does not warrant any interference in appeal.
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
[14]
Ms. A.Banik learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No.3 [Dy Chief Engineer, Construction, NFR] has submitted that
adequate compensation has been given to the claimant appellants for
acquisition of his land. Even though the appellants claimed that there
were 1463 matured rubber trees on the acquired land, he could not
establish his stand by adducing sufficient proof. Counsel submits that in
these circumstances there is no reason to interfere with the findings of
the learned LA Judge.
[15]
Considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel
representing the parties and perused the record.
[16]
In the scheme of LA Act, land acquisition authority is to
protect the interest of the owner of the acquired land by giving
adequate compensation to him. It is also the duty of the claimant to
produce relevant materials before the LA Collector for fair determination
of the market value of the acquired land. If the claimant appellants fail
to produce such documents before the LA Collector and seek reference
to the court for determination of fair price of the land, he must produce
relevant evidence for determining the market value of the land as well
as for determination of compensation owning to such acquisition.
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
[17]
It is true that no straight jacket formula can be laid for
arriving at an exact market value of the land under the LA Act. The
factors which are taken into consideration by the court exercising
jurisdiction under the LA Act are the nature and position of the land,
adaptability and advantages, the purpose for which the land can be
used in the most lucrative way, damages caused to the properties
situated on the land, the locality, the potential value of the land, size of
the land, its accessibility from main road and amenities like hospital,
schools, shops, and police stations etc.
[18]
Certain guess work is not impermissible for determination
of the value of the acquired land. But such guess work cannot be
fanciful. It must have a rational basis. In Trishala Jain and Another
vs. State of Uttaranchal and Another reported in AIR 2011 SC
2458 the Hon’ble Apex Court held that in case the parties do not lead
any evidence on record, it is difficult for the court to award
compensation merely on the basis of imagination / conjecture etc.
[19]
In the present case none of the parties could produce any
sale exemplar proximate to the acquired land in terms of its size
location, .and time of acquisition. The trial court therefore, relied on a
sale exemplar [Exbt.1] which represented the highest value i.e. Rs.8
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
lakh per kani. But the learned LA Judge deducted 70% of the price of
the sale exemplar which according to the LA Judge was likely to be
incurred for development of the acquired land. After such deduction, the
price of the land determined by the LA Judge was worked out at Rs.2.40
lakh. But the LA Judge viewed that since there were 310 rubber trees
on the acquired land, it would be appropriate to raise the value of the
land at Rs.3 lakh per kani. Accordingly he determined the value of the
land at Rs.3 lakh per kani and for the loss of rubber trees he separately
awarded a lump-sum of Rs.2,09,500/- in Misc.(LA 42 of 2013)[LA
Appeal 115 of 2019]
[20]
The learned LA Judge did not commit any wrong by relying
on the sale exemplar [Exbt.1] produced by the claimant appellant which
represented the highest value. But the deduction made by the learned
LA Judge at the rate 70% towards development charges appears to be
unreasonable. Keeping a view to the purpose for which the land was
acquired and all other parameters, 40% deduction for development
charges would have been appropriate.
[21]
Since the sale exemplar [Exbt.1] submitted by the claimant
appellant represented the value of Rs.8 lakh per kani a deduction of
40% there from for development charges would make it 4,80,000/- per
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
kani. Therefore, the claimant appellant shall be entitled to compensation
at the rate of Rs.4,80,000/-(Four Lakh Eighty Thousand) per kani along
with other statutory benefits which have been granted by the learned
LA Judge. The impugned judgment is modified to this extent. With
regard to compensation for the loss of rubber trees it is found that the
claimant could not produce reliable evidence in support of his claim for
such loss. Therefore, lump-sum compensation awarded by the learned
LA Judge does not call for any interference in appeal. Rest of the
findings of the learned LA Judge including the finding with regard to
apportionment of compensation is not interfered with.
[22]
The entire exercise of payment of compensation to the
claimants after deduction of compensation already paid, if any, shall be
made within a period of 3 months from the date of receipt of the copy
of the judgment by the respondents.
[23]
With the above observations and directions, the instant
appeals stand disposed of.
Send down the LCR.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Saikat Sarma
LA App No.115 & 116 of 2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review