Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
A.B. No. 90 of 2021
Sri Ramu Saha @ Ramdas Saha & Ors.
……..Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
……..Respondent(s)
Along with
A.B. No. 91 of 2021
Sri Nipu Ghosh
……..Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
……..Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General.
Mr. R. Datta, P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Order
12/01/2022
Since these applications arise out of the same occurrence,
they are taken up together for hearing and disposal by a common
order.
[2]
Petitioners
are
accused
in
East
Agartala
PS
case
No.2021EAG160 registered under sections 341,325,384,307 read with
section 34 IPC and section 25(1)(d) of the Arms Act, 1959.
[3]
Apprehending arrest in the case, they have filed these
applications seeking pre arrest bail under section 438 Cr.P.C.
[4]
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners. Heard Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General as well as
Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P representing the State.
[5]
The Factual context of the case is as under:
One Subrata Kar, son of Late Swapan Kumar Kar of
Dhaleswar, Agartala lodged a written FIR with the officer in charge of
East Agartala police station alleging, inter alia, that on 21.11.2021 at
about 8 O’ clock in the night when he was crossing the road adjacent to
Gedu Miah Masjid at Shibnagar on his motor bike, accused petitioner
Nipu Ghosh detained him at the point of his pistol and snatched away a
gold chain weighing about 15gm from his neck. The other three
petitioners namely Debu Ghosh, Ramu Saha and Sajal Bardhan who
were then accompanying accused Nipu Ghosh started assaulting the
informant. Having received injuries from such assault, the informant
collapsed on the ground. The accused petitioners then robbed him of a
sum of Rs.10,000/- in cash. Following his cry, the neighbouring people
rescued him and brought him to AGMC and GBP hospital for treatment.
He was then having bleeding injuries in his skull and other parts of his
face. He was also having severe pain across his body. The informant
alleged that the accused petitioners intended to kill him.
[6]
Based on such FIR, East Agartala PS case No.2021EAG160
under sections 341,325,384,307 read with section 34 IPC and section
25(1)(d) of the Arms Act, 1959 was registered by police and
investigation of the case was taken up.
[7]
Apprehending
arrest,
the
accused
petitioners
have
approached this court for pre arrest bail by means of filing these
applications under section 438 Cr.P.C.
[8]
Appearing for the petitioners, Mr. Lodh, learned advocate
contends that petitioners are innocent who have been implicated in a
false case for detention and harassment. Counsel submits that on the
same day the Secretary of Deshbandhu Chittaranjan Club lodged a
complaint with the officer in charge of East Agartala police station
alleging that a huge number of people in mask and helmet came in a
procession to the Masjid road near Chittaranjan Club on their motor
bikes and assaulted 4/5 persons of the locality. They terrorized the
people of the entire area particularly the women who fled in fear.
Counsel submits that the first informant was one of the members of the
group of bikers who subsequently lodged a false FIR against the
accused
petitioners,
all
of
whom
are
members
of
Deshbandhu
Chittaranjan Club. Counsel contends that no action has been taken by
the investigating agency on the said complaint lodged by the Secretary,
Deshbandhu Chittaranjan Club, even though the complaint was received
at the police station on the same day. It is also contended by Mr. Lodh,
learned counsel that the investigating agency who should have acted
impartially
without
any
malice
towards
the
accused
petitioners,
promptly registered a case on the FIR lodged by Subrata Kar who
actually created terror at the place of occurrence whereas no action has
yet been taken
on the
complaint
lodged
by
the
Secretary of
Deshbandhu Chittaranjan Club. It is also contended by Mr. Lodh,
learned counsel that a plain reading of the FIR lodged by Subratra Kar
would demonstrate that he lodged a completely false and fabricated FIR
because he came from a far away place and he was not supposed to be
aware about the identity of the accused petitioners. Therefore, it is not
understandable as to how he filed a FIR with the full particulars
including the fathers’ names of all the accused petitioners. Counsel
submits that all the accused petitioners are absolutely innocent. They
do not have any criminal antecedent. The present case has been lodged
by the informant out of political rivalry. Counsel, therefore, urges the
court to protect the liberty of the accused petitioners by granting pre
arrest bail to them.
[9]
Learned P.P appearing for the State respondent vehemently
opposes the bail application. It is contended by Mr. R. Datta, learned
P.P that after the FIR was lodged, the petitioners were served notice
under section 41A Cr.P.C. But none of them complied with the terms of
the said notice. Learned P.P submits that a fair investigation would not
be possible in the case if protection from arrest under section 438
Cr.P.C is granted to the petitioners. Relying on the decision of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Arnesh Kumar Vs. State of Bihar & Anr.
reported in (2014) 8 SCC 273 counsel submits that in terms of the
provision laid down under section 41A Cr.P.C as well as observations
made by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the said judgment, notice under
section 41A Cr.P.C was issued to the petitioners. The petitioners
disregarded the said notice. Their arrest has become necessary since
they did not cooperate with the investigating agency and the materials
available on record against them support the charges brought against
them. Learned P.P submits that chance of success in interrogation of an
accused is remote when the accused knows that he is well protected
and insulated by a pre arrest bail order. In support of his contention
learned P.P has relied on the decision of the Apex Court in State Rep.
by the C.B.I. Vs. Anil Sharma reported in (1997) 7 SCC 187
wherein the Apex Court in paragraph 6 of the judgment has held as
under:
“6. We find force in the submission of the CBI that custodial
interrogation is qualitatively more elicitation-oriented than
questioning a suspect who is well ensconded with a favorable
order under Section 438 if the code. In a case like this
effective interrogation of suspected person is of tremendous
advantage in disinterring many useful information and also
materials which would have been concealed. Succession such
interrogation would elude if the suspected person knows that
he is well protected and insulted by a pre-arrest bail during
the time he interrogated. Very often interrogation in such a
condition would reduce to a mere ritual. The argument that
the custodial interrogation is fraught with the danger of the
person being subjected to third degree methods need not be
countenanced, for, such an argument can be advanced by all
accused in all criminal cases. The court has to presume that
responsible Police Officers would conduct themselves in task
of disinterring offences would not conduct themselves as
offenders.”
[10]
Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P argues that curtailment of freedom
of the accused in order to enable the investigating agency to proceed
without hindrance and protect the witnesses including the victim of the
crime may be necessary in certain circumstances. Learned P.P submits
that in the given case there are adequate incriminating materials
against the petitioners which justify their arrest and interrogation in
detention for protecting the witnesses of the case including the victim
and to collect evidence with regard to motive, preparation, commission
and aftermath of the crime. Counsel has relied on the decision of the
Apex Court in Adri Dharan Das Vs. State of W.B. reported in (2005)
4 SCC 303 wherein the Apex Court in paragraph 19 of the judgment
has held as under:
“19. Ordinarily, arrest is a part of the process of investigation
intended to secure several purposes. The accused may have
to be questioned in detail regarding various facets of motive,
preparation, commission and aftermath of the crime and the
connection of other persons, if any, in the crime. There may
be circumstances in which the accused may provide
information leading to discovery of material facts. It may be
necessary to curtail his freedom in order to enable the
investigation to proceed without hindrance and to protect
witnesses and persons connected with the victim of the crime,
to prevent his disappearance to maintain law and order in the
locality. For these or other reasons, arrest may become
inevitable part of the process of investigation. The legality of
the proposed arrest cannot be gone into in an application
under Section 438 of the Code. The role of the investigator is
well-defined and the jurisdictional scope of interference by the
Court in the process of investigation is limited. The Court
ordinarily will not interfere with the investigation of a crime or
with the arrest of accused in a cognizable offence. An interim
order restraining arrest, if passed while dealing with an
application under Section 438 of the Code will amount to
interference in the investigation, which cannot, at any rate, be
done under Section 438 of the Code.”
[11]
Appearing for the State, Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate
General contends that bail stands at the cross road of individual liberty
and social security and a delicate balance is required to be maintained
between the two. Counsel submits that the case diary maintained by
the investigating agency would demonstrate that there are sufficient
prima facie incriminating materials against each of the petitioners and
as such they are debarred from claiming the benefit of custodial
immunity under section 438 Cr.P.C. Learned Advocate General submits
that in the greater interest of society, the safeguard provided under
section 438 Cr.P.C should be denied to the petitioners in the present
case to enable the investigating agency to carry out a free and fair
investigation of the case. Counsel has relied on the decision of the Apex
Court in P. Chidambaram Vs. Directorate of Enforcement reported
in (2019) 9 SCC 24 wherein the Apex Court in paragraph 72 of the
judgment has held as under:
“72. We are conscious of the fact that the legislative intent
behind the introduction of Section 438 Cr.P.C. is to safeguard
the individual’s personal liberty and to protect him from the
possibility of being humiliated and from being subjected to
unnecessary police custody. However, the court must also
keep in view that a criminal offence is not just an offence
against an individual, rather the larger societal interest is at
stake. Therefore, a delicate balance is required to be
established between the two rights - safeguarding the
personal liberty of an individual and the societal interest. It
cannot be said that refusal to grant anticipatory bail would
amount to denial of the rights conferred upon the appellant
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.”
[12]
Considered the submissions made at the Bar. Perused the
entire case diary and the prosecution papers placed before this court.
[13]
In the case in hand, serious charges have been brought
against the petitioners. The first informant has lodged his written FIR
bringing specific allegations against them. Each of them have been
named in the FIR as the assailants of the first informant. The injury
report which has been pointed out by the Public Prosecutor in the case
diary indicates that X-Ray conducted at the hospital has shown grievous
injury in the body of the informant. This apart, the accused has
categorically stated in his FIR that while crossing the road he was
detained at the point of pistol by the accused petitioners near their club
house at Masjid road. Police statements recorded under section 161
Cr.P.C during investigation also support the charges. There are
sufficient prima facie materials against the petitioners to constitute the
offence alleged against them. In these circumstances, the investigating
agency should be given a free hand to conduct a fair investigation of the
case. This apart, admittedly the petitioner were served with a notice
under section 41A Cr.P.C to appear at the police station to face
interrogation. They did not comply with the terms of the said notice.
Argument of learned counsel of the petitioner that they did not report to
the police station in fear of arrest is not acceptable.
[14]
Anticipatory bail under section 438 Cr.P.C. is an extra
ordinary relief. The Apex Court in the case of Siddharam Satlingappa
Mhetre vs State of Maharashtra & Ors. reported in (2011) 1 SCC
694 has laid down the parameters for granting or refusing the
anticipatory bail which are as under:
“112………. The following factors and parameters can be taken
into consideration while dealing with the anticipatory bail:
(i) The nature and gravity of the accusation and the exact role
of the accused must be properly comprehended before arrest
is made;
(ii) The antecedents of the applicant including the fact as to
whether the accused has previously undergone imprisonment
on conviction by a Court in respect of any cognizable offence;
(iii) The possibility of the applicant to flee from justice;
(iv) The possibility of the accused’s likelihood to repeat similar
or the other offences.
(v) Where the accusations have been made only with the
object of injuring or humiliating the applicant by arresting him
or her.
(vi) Impact of grant of anticipatory bail particularly in cases of
large magnitude affecting a very large number of people.
(vii) The courts must evaluate the entire available material
against the accused very carefully. The court must also clearly
comprehend the exact role of the accused in the case. The
cases in which accused is implicated with the help of sections
34 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code, the court should
consider with even greater care and caution because over
implication in the cases is a matter of common knowledge and
concern;
(viii) While considering the prayer for grant of anticipatory
bail, a balance has to be struck between two factors namely,
no prejudice should be caused to the free, fair and full
investigation and there should be prevention of harassment,
humiliation and unjustified detention of the accused;
(ix) The court to consider reasonable apprehension of
tampering of the witness or apprehension of threat to the
complainant;
(x) Frivolity in prosecution should always be considered and it
is only the element of genuineness that shall have to be
considered in the matter of grant of bail and in the event of
there being some doubt as to the genuineness of the
prosecution, in the normal course of events, the accused is
entitled to an order of bail.”
[15]
Further in Jai Prakash Singh vs. State of Bihar reported in
(2012) 4 SCC 379 the Apex Court further elucidated the principles for
consideration of anticipatory bail which are as under:
“19. Parameters for grant of anticipatory bail in a serious
offence are required to be satisfied and further while granting
such relief, the court must record the reasons therefor.
Anticipatory bail can be granted only in exceptional
circumstances where the court is prima facie of the view that
the applicant has falsely been enroped in the crime and would
not misuse his liberty. (See D.K. Ganesh Babu v. P.T.
Manokaran & Ors., (2007) 4 SCC 434, State of Maharashtra
v. Mohd. Sajid Husain Mohd. S. Husain, (2008) 1 SCC 213,
and Union of India v. Padam Narain Aggarwal, (2008) 13 SCC
305).”
[16]
In the given facts and circumstances of the case and in view
of the decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court cited to Supra, this court is of
the view that accused petitioners do not deserve pre arrest bail under
section 438 Cr.P.C in this case.
[17]
In the result, their bail applications stand rejected and the
petitions are disposed of accordingly.
Return the case diary to Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P.
JUDGE
Rudradeep
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review