Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/20
GAHC040002402019
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/344/2019
SMTI TSERING CHOJOM
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF DIRANG VILLAGE, PO/PS DIRANG, WEST
KAMENG DISTT, AP
2: SMTI KUNGMA
Age:
Occupation :
W/O PHURPA TSERING
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF DIRANG VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
WEST KAMENG DISTT
AP
3: SHRI DOR GOMBU
Age:
Occupation :
S/O LT CHOCHUNG PHUNTSU
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF DIRANG VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
WEST KAMENG DISTT
A
VERSUS
STATE OF AP and ORS
REPRESENTED BY CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT OF AP, ITANAGAR.
2:THE COMMISSIONER
Age: 0
Occupation :
LANG MANAGEMENT
GOVT OF AP
ITANAGAR
3:THE DIRECTOR
Age: 0
Page No.# 2/20
Occupation :
LANFD MANAGEMENT
GOVT OF AP
ITANAGAR
4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Age: 0
Occupation :
WEST KAMENG DISTT
PO/PS BOMDILA
AP
5:THE ADC
Age: 0
Occupation :
DIRANG
WEST KAMENG DISTT
AP
6:THE UNION OF INDIA
Age: 0
Occupation :
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
SENA BHAVAN
GOVT OF INDIA
NEW DELHI-11001
Advocate for the Petitioner
: G T Gonpapa, MR.B Picha,Ojing Pada,G Loyi,M Likha
Advocate for the Respondent : MrM Kato, GA (AP),SC, CGC
Linked Case : WP(C)/345/2019
SHRI NIMA TSERING
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:S/O SANG KHANDU
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF LISH VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
WEST KAMENG DISTT
AP
2: SHRI PEMA TSERING
Page No.# 3/20
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:S/O LEKI SANGJA
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF LISHI VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
WEST KAMENG DISTT
AP
3: SHRI KARCHUNG
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT PASSANG
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF LISH VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
WEST KAMENG DISTT
AP
4: KEJANG NORBU
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT. SANG KHANDU
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF LISH VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
A P.
5: DAWA
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O LT. NIMA DONDU
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF LISH VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
A P.
6: RINCHIN KHANDU
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT. TASHI TSERING
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF LISH VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
A P.
7: TASHI CHOJOM
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O LT. SANG KHANDU
Page No.# 4/20
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
8: JAMBA TSUTTRIM
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT. LAMA TASHI
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
9: DROIMA CHOIJOM ALIAS PEM CHOJEM
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O SANGEY TSERING
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
10: DORJEE NGODUP
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT. SANGEY BOO
PERMANENT RESIDENT OF LISH
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
11: SANGE TSERING
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:REPRESENTIVE OF LT. NIM BUTI
S/O LT. KESANG TSEWANG
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
12: RINCHIN DREMA
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O LT. DORJEE TSERING
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
Page No.# 5/20
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
13: AAIPULA ALIAS PULOO
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O LT. LOPEE
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
14: LEKI DROMA
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O BISHNU
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
15: NIMA DREMA
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:D/O LT. TOPGENDOO
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
16: THUPTEN TSERING
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:REPRESENTATIVE OF LT. LAMA KUKPA TASHI
S/O LT. LAMA KUKPA TASHI
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF RAMA CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
17: NIMA DONDU
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:REPRESENTATIVE OF LT. PASSANG NGAREY
S/O LT. PASSANG NGAREY
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF LISH VILLAGE
PO/PS DIRANG
DIST. WEST KAMENG
Page No.# 6/20
A P.
18: GEN DONDU ALIAS KEN DANDU
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT. KHENTSE
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF SAPPER CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
19: TASHI CHHOIJOM
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O LT. RINCHIN LETA
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF SAPPER CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
20: WANGCHEN CHOMU
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O LT. LOBSANG
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF SAPPER CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
21: NGOCHUNG BAPU
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT. DORJEE PEMA BAPU
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF SAPPER CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
22: LEIKI GOMBU
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT. TSORMU
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF SAPPER CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
23: YESHI TSERING
Page No.# 7/20
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:S/O LT. KUNSANG DORJEE
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF SAPPER CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
24: TSOWANG DREMA
Age: 32
Occupation :
Address:W/O LT. GELAK CHEJANG
PERAMENT RESIDENT OF SAPPER CAMP
PO/PS DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
AP.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF A.P.
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:REPRESENTED BY CHIEF SECRETARY
GOVT OF AP
ITANAGAR
2:THE COMMISSIONER/SECRETARY
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:LANG MANAGEMENT
GOVT OF AP
ITANAGAR
3:THE DIRECTOR
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:LANG MANAGEMENT
GOVT OF AP
ITANAGAR
4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:BOMDILA
WEST KAMENG DISTT
PO/PS BOMDILA
AP
5:THE ADDITIONAL DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Age: 0
Page No.# 8/20
Occupation :
Address:DIRANG
DISTRICT WEST KAMENG
PO/PS DIRANG
AP.
6:THE UNION OF INDIA
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
SENA BHAWAN
GOVT. OF INDIA
NEW DELHI.
7:THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF BORDER RAODS
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:NARAINA
KIRBY PLACE
DELHI CANTONMENT
NEW DELHI
DELHI.
8:THE COMMANDER
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:42 BORDER ROADS TASK FORCE (BRTF)
C/O 99 APO
HEAD QUARTER
AP.
9:THE OFFICER -IN-COMMAND
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:97 ROAD CONSTRUCTION COMPANY (RCC)
C/O 99 APO
MUNNA-CAMP
DIRANG
AP.
-----------Advocate for : G T Gonpapa
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for THE STATE OF A.P.: Advocate ,
,
,
Page No.# 9/20
,
,
,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9, respectively.
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
: N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 21.08.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
Page No.# 10/20
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. O. Pada, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Ms. G.
Ete, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate for State respondent Nos.
1 to 5, and Mr. G. Riba, learned Central Government Counsel for respondent
Nos. 6 to 9.
2.
By filing these writ petitions, the petitioners seek a direction to the
respondent authorities for release of compensation in their favour as per the reassessment valuation report, along with 100% solatium, in terms of the
provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
3.
Having considered that the issues involved in both these writ petitions are
connected and similar on facts and law, same are heard analogously and
disposed of by this common judgment and order.
4.
The case of the petitioners, in brief, is that for construction of 2-lane
Trans-Arunachal Highway from Balipara-Chardwar-Tawang (BCT), passing
through Dirang Circle of West Kameng District, the district administration, along
with representatives of 97 Road Construction Company (RCC), General Reserve
Engineer Force (GREF), had initially undertaken survey and assessment of the
loss caused to the land and properties affected by the said project. On the basis
of such assessment, compensation was determined and released to the
Page No.# 11/20
petitioners and other land-affected persons. However, subsequently, on coming
to know about the alleged irregularities in the valuation undertaken by the
Compensation Board and upon obtaining the relevant valuation reports through
applications under the Right to Information Act, the petitioners, along with the
villagers, came across alleged discrepancies and undervaluation of their
properties. Accordingly, the petitioners, along with certain affected persons,
approached this Court by instituting WP(C) No. 153(AP)/2012, and WP(C) No.
154(AP)/2012, which were allowed and disposed of by this Court vide judgment
and order dated 09.08.2012, whereby, inter alia, direction was issued for CBI
inquiry and constitution of a fresh Compensation Board for correct assessment
of the value of the properties.
5.
Pursuant thereto, a Committee was constituted under the Chairmanship of
the Deputy Commissioner, Bomdila, for re-assessment of the valuation of
buildings situated along the BCT Road under the Trans-Arunachal Highway in
Dirang Sub-Division. Insofar as the petitioners in WP(C) No. 344/2019 are
concerned, their properties fall within the chainage of 167.000 KM to 174.000
KM pertaining to Dirang village, whereas the properties of the petitioners in
WP(C) No. 345/2019 fall within the chainage of 183.037 KM to 189.640 KM
pertaining to Ramacamp and Sappercamp villages. It is the specific case of the
petitioners that the re-assessment undertaken by the Committee was confined
to the damages caused to the house properties and did not include solatium.
6.
The petitioners contend that, meanwhile, the executing agency released
additional amounts towards compensation for the respective stretches of the
Page No.# 12/20
road to the Deputy Commissioner, West Kameng District, Bomdila, which
amounts were received by the authority concerned on 29.05.2017. Thereafter,
the Secretary, Land Management, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, issued
notification dated 09.12.2017, declaring that the acquisition and compensation
would be paid as per the provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (for
short, “RFCTLARR Act, 2013”).
7.
It is the case of the petitioners that despite the re-assessment of the
properties, the compensation determined on such re-assessment was not
uniformly released to all the affected persons. In WP(C) No. 344/2019, the
petitioner No. 5 was paid the amount determined on re-assessment, but without
the benefit of 100% solatium. The remaining petitioners in the said writ petition
were not paid the compensation determined on re-assessment. In WP(C) No.
345/2019, the petitioners have stated that none of them was paid the reassessed compensation along with 100% solatium. However, the respondent
authorities, in a discriminatory and arbitrary approach, have paid compensation
to certain other similarly situated beneficiaries in the same area on the basis of
the re-assessed valuation together with 100% solatium.
8.
Thereafter, the petitioners have submitted representations dated
21.08.2019 and 30.08.2019 before the respondent authorities seeking release of
compensation in terms of the re-assessment valuation report along with 100%
solatium. However, despite such representations, the respondent authorities
failed to release the amounts claimed by them. Hence, these writ petitions.
Page No.# 13/20
9.
Mr. O. Pada, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that the
properties of the petitioners had admittedly been re-assessed pursuant to the
judgment and order dated 09.08.2012, passed by this Court in WP(C) No.
153(AP)/2012, and WP(C) No. 154(AP)/2012, and therefore, the respondent
authorities cannot withhold the compensation determined pursuant to such reassessment. More so, the respondent authorities have already received the
requisite funds from the executing agency towards payment of compensation
for the concerned stretches of the highway. He submits that the petitioners are
entitled to the benefit of 100% solatium in terms of Section 30 of the RFCTLARR
Act, 2013 and such benefit cannot be selectively extended to some beneficiaries
while being denied to others whose properties have been similarly acquired for
the same project. However, the respondent authorities, in a very arbitrary and
discriminatory manner, have paid the re-assessed compensation together with
100% solatium to the similarly situated land-affected persons on a selective and
pick and choose basis while denying the same benefit to the petitioners. He
submits that once the re-assessment valuation has been made and the amount
has been made available by the executing agency, the petitioners cannot be
deprived of the compensation legitimately payable to them. Therefore, he
submits that appropriate direction may be issued to the respondent authorities
to release, in favour of the petitioners, the compensation determined pursuant
to the re-assessment valuation, together with 100% solatium as contemplated
under Section 30 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013.
10. Ms. G. Ete, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate, submits that
the initial assessment of compensation was made under the provisions of the
Page No.# 14/20
Land Acquisition Act, 1894, under which 30% solatium was applicable only to
the value of the land. However, pursuant to the judgment and order dated
09.08.2012, passed by this Court in WP(C) Nos. 153(AP)/2012 and WP(C)154
(AP)/2012, a fresh Board was constituted under the Chairmanship of the Deputy
Commissioner, West Kameng, and re-assessment of the affected properties was
thereafter undertaken, but the re-assessment report prepared by the fresh
Board did not provide for solatium. Subsequently, the Government directed
preparation of a comparative assessment of the compensation payable under
the earlier assessment and under the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. Pursuant thereto, a
comparative assessment incorporating 100% solatium was prepared and
submitted to the competent authority and the Government approval for
payment of compensation to the left-out beneficiaries was thereafter conveyed.
11.
This Court, on an earlier occasion, had granted time to the learned State
Counsel to obtain instructions. Pursuant thereto, Ms. G. Ete, learned Additional
Senior Government Advocate, while placing the instruction/communication
dated 20.08.2026 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, West Kameng District,
Bomdila, submits that, as per the records available, all the petitioners in WP(C)
No. 344/2019 are affected beneficiaries falling within chainage KM 167.00 to KM
174.00 of the BCT Road. She further submits that the comparative assessment
included 100% solatium on the actual estimated compensation amount.
However, upon verification of the records, certain variations have been noticed
between the beneficiaries included in the original re-assessment and those
included in the subsequent comparative assessment. Therefore, she submits
that the matter may be considered in the light of the records and the
Government approvals available in respect of
the re-assessment and
Page No.# 15/20
comparative assessment.
12.
Mr. G. Riba, learned Central Government Counsel, submits that the
compensation was released by the Central authorities on the basis of the
estimates furnished by the competent authorities of the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh. The additional amount towards re-assessment of the
building properties was also released to the Deputy Commissioner, West
Kameng District, for disbursement to the concerned beneficiaries. However, he
submits that insofar as the petitioners in WP(C) No. 344/2019 are concerned,
the amounts paid to petitioners Nos. 1 to 4 were already in excess of the
amounts reflected in the re-assessment, whereas the amount payable to
petitioner No. 5 on re-assessment was higher than the amount initially paid and
the balance amount was accordingly released to him. The payments were made
without solatium in terms of the assessment made under the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894. Therefore, he submits that the respondents/ Union of India have
acted on the estimates and directions furnished by the competent authorities of
the State Government and the question regarding entitlement to any further
amount, including solatium, may be considered in accordance with the
applicable law and the records of the case.
13.
Due consideration has been extended to the submissions of learned
counsel for the parties and also perused the materials placed on record.
14.
The facts, as borne out from the pleadings and the materials placed on
record, reveal that the properties of the petitioners were affected on account of
construction of the Balipara-Chardwar-Tawang (BCT) Road under the Trans-
Page No.# 16/20
Arunachal Highway Project. Initially, assessment of the compensation payable to
the affected persons was made and on the basis of such assessment,
compensation was disbursed to several beneficiaries. Subsequently, upon certain
irregularities being brought to the notice of this Court, this Court, vide judgment
and order dated 09.08.2012 passed in WP(C) Nos. 153(AP)/2012 and
WP(C)154(AP)/2012, inter alia, directed constitution of a fresh Compensation
Board for re-assessment of the properties affected by the highway project.
15.
Pursuant to the aforesaid direction, a fresh Board was constituted under
the Chairmanship of the Deputy Commissioner, West Kameng District, Bomdila,
and the properties affected by the highway project were re-assessed. The
petitioners in the present writ petitions are admittedly among the beneficiaries
whose properties fall within the respective stretches of the BCT Road covered by
such re-assessment. The second assessment/re-assessment reports prepared by
the fresh Board are also not in dispute.
16. The stand of the State respondents is that, after the re-assessment, the
matter was considered at the Government level and a comparative assessment
was prepared for the purpose of determining the compensation payable to the
left-out beneficiaries under the provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
The State respondents, vide communication dated 03.08.2015, have themselves
stated that the Government approval was conveyed for the estimate of
compensation of the properties as re-assessed by the fresh Board and in
accordance with the provisions of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. Thereafter, special
Page No.# 17/20
approval for disbursement of the remaining compensation was conveyed vide
communication dated 09.02.2018.
17. This Court, vide order dated 17.08.2026, directed the State respondents to
place on record the instructions. Pursuant to which, today, the learned State
Counsel has placed the instruction dated 20.08.2026 by the Deputy
Commissioner, West Kameng District. Perusal of the same reveals that after the
re-assessment, a comparative assessment incorporating 100% solatium on the
actual estimated compensation amount was prepared and submitted to the
Commissioner, Land Management, on 31.07.2015 and the same was approved
by the Government. Thus, the records placed before this Court indicates that
the issue of payment of compensation on the basis of the second assessment,
along with the solatium, had already been considered and approved at the
appropriate level.
18. It is true that the initial assessment was made at a time when the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 was stated to be applicable and under the then prevailing
position, 30% solatium was applicable to the land value. However, the subject
matter in the present writ petitions does not relate merely to the correctness of
the initial assessment. The issue is as to the entitlement of the petitioners to the
compensation determined pursuant to the subsequent re-assessment and the
benefit of 100% solatium, particularly when the State authorities themselves
proceeded to undertake a comparative assessment under the RFCTLARR Act,
2013 and the same was approved by the Government.
Page No.# 18/20
19. From the contention of the respondents/Union of India, it appears that the
compensation amounts, including the additional amount towards re-assessment,
were released to the Deputy Commissioner, West Kameng District, for
disbursement to the concerned beneficiaries. The respondents have also placed
on record the amounts reflected in the initial assessment and the second
assessment. Therefore, the question that survives for consideration is essentially
with regard to disbursement of the compensation payable to the petitioners on
the basis of the second assessment, along with 100% solatium.
20. The contention of the petitioners that similarly situated beneficiaries have
been extended the benefit of compensation on the basis of the re-assessed
valuation along with 100% solatium also finds support from the materials placed
on record. Once the respondent authorities have themselves undertaken a
second assessment pursuant to the earlier judgment of this Court and the
Government has thereafter approved the comparative assessment incorporating
100% solatium, there can be no justification for denying the same benefit to the
petitioners whose properties were subjected to the very same process of reassessment for the very same highway project.
21. Thus, this Court is of the view that the petitioners cannot be deprived of
the benefit of compensation from the second assessment merely on the ground
that they had earlier received compensation on the basis of the first
assessment. The amount already received by any of the petitioners would,
naturally, be liable to be duly adjusted while determining the balance amount
payable on the basis of the second assessment. However, such earlier payment
Page No.# 19/20
cannot operate as a bar to payment of the differential amount found payable
pursuant to the second assessment, together with the applicable 100%
solatium.
22. Insofar as the petitioner No. 5 in WP(C) No. 344/2019 is concerned, the
records indicate that the amount determined on the second assessment was
higher than the amount initially paid to him and the difference was accordingly
released. However, the benefit of 100% solatium has not been extended to him.
Similarly, in respect of the other petitioners, the materials indicate that the
compensation payable pursuant to the second assessment has not been
uniformly
released.
Such
differential
treatment,
particularly
when
the
comparative assessment with 100% solatium had been approved by the
Government, cannot be sustained.
23.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered view
that the petitioners are entitled to receive compensation on the basis of the
second assessment/re-assessment made by the fresh Compensation Board,
along with 100% solatium. Accordingly, the respondent authorities are directed
to release the compensation payable to the respective petitioners on the basis
of the second assessment/re-assessment of their properties, together with
100% solatium, after adjusting the amounts already paid to the respective
petitioners, if any. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of 3
(three) months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment and
order.
Page No.# 20/20
24.
Writ petitions stand allowed and disposed of accordingly. No order as to
cost(s).
JUDGE
Lipak Rime, Private Secretary
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review