Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 75 of 2015 with
WP(C) No. 76 of 2015
Date of Decision: 19.03.2021
Shri. Nikiru War & Anr.
Smti. Meskhera Dkhar & Anr.
Vs.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv.
Mr. A.H. Hazarika, GA. for R 1-4.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Adv. for R 5, 6, 8,
9 & 10.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
1.
Yes/No
Yes/No
These two sets of petition being identical and pertaining to the same
subject matter, it is deemed expedient and convenient to take them up together
and to dispose the same vide this common judgment and order.
2.
Vide advertisement No DSC.3/ADVT/2012/14 dated Jowai, the 1st
November, 2012, the Office of the Respondent No. 4 has issued an
advertisement for recruitment to various posts in different State Government
offices/departments in West Jaintia Hills District, which posts includes 6(six)
posts of Sericulture Demonstrator lying vacant in the office of the Respondent
No. 3.
3.
In the said advertisement dated 01.11.2012, for the post of Sericulture
Demonstrator, the minimum educational qualification and other qualifications
prescribed is Matriculate with 15th Months’ Certificate Course in Sericulture.
4.
While the said advertisement dated 01.11.2012 was still subsisting,
Respondent No. 4 issued a Corrigendum to the same vide Office Corrigendum
No. DSC.3/ADVT/2012/18 dated Jowai the 28th November 2012 to the extent
that the original advertisement was modified to increase the number of posts
of Sericulture Demonstrator from 6 to 10 with minimum qualification of
15(fifteen) months’ course at Sericulture Training Institute Ummulong with
two years’ experience.
5.
The Petitioners herein in response to the said advertisement applied for
the said post of Sericulture Demonstrator even though their qualification is
matriculation having also completed the 15(fifteen) months’ course training
in Sericulture Training Institute Ummulong, West Jaintia Hills District. The
Petitioners were then allowed to appear in the aptitude written test which was
held on 10.01.2014 and having cleared the same, they were called to appear
in the personal interview held on 07.07.2017.
6.
The District Selection Committee (DSC) published the final result on
21.07.2014 and 12(twelve) candidates who have qualified have been
recommended for appointment by Respondent No. 3 vide letter dated
28.07.2017. In the said result and recommendation, the name of Petitioner
Shri Nikiru War figured at Sl. No. 2, that of Petitioner Smti Lasankiru
Manners at Sl. No. 7, Petitioner Smti Meskhem (Meskhera) Dkhar at Sl. No.
10 and Petitioner Smti Rafflecia Challam at Sl. No. 11.
7.
The Petitioners on 20.08.2014 submitted a representation to
Respondent No. 2 seeking intervention in the matter with a request to issue
the appointment order in their favour, however, till date no appointment order
was issued to them in terms of the recommendation dated 28.07.2014.
However, it is learnt that some persons have been appointed on an officiating
and temporary basis, thus depriving the Petitioners of their rightful
entitlement.
8.
Being aggrieved by the action of the official Respondents, the
Petitioners have preferred these two writ petitions with similar prayer before
this Court for a direction to be issued upon the Respondents to appoint them
to the post of Sericulture Demonstrator and also to set aside and quash the
appointment of the private Respondents herein who are said to be occupying
the said posts in an officiating capacity.
9.
At this juncture, it may be mentioned that this matter has come before
this Court the second time around, the first being the disposal of the same vide
order dated 04.11.2016 whereby, this Court has dismissed the prayer of the
Petitioners, but has however also directed that Respondent No. 11 to 16
therein may be removed from service since they are adhoc appointees.
10.
The Petitioner herein being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the said
order of the Hon’ble Single Judge dated 04.11.2016 had preferred an intraCourt appeal being W.A No. 90/2016 and the Appellate Court vide order dated
20.06.2017 had disposed of the appeal inter alia, by remanding the matter for
reconsideration by this Court. The order as regard the Respondent No. 11 to
16 have however not been disturbed by the Appellate Court and the
appointment of Respondent No. 5 to 10 on the post of Sericulture
Demonstrator was also not interfered with and stand affirmed. The Petitioners
were however advised to amend the writ petition for effective consideration
by this Court.
11.
Accordingly, the Petitioners moved for amendment of their respective
writ petitions which was allowed. In the amended writ petition, the prayer
portion was amended to inter alia, pray that the impugned Corrigendum dated
28.11.2012 to the effect of enhancing the minimum qualification be quashed.
12.
Heard Mr. Philemon Nongbri, learned Counsel for the Petitioners who
has submitted that the main issue canvassed by the Petitioners herein is that
by way of corrigendum dated 28.11.2012 whereby the minimum qualification
required for the post of Sericulture Demonstrator, apart from the criteria of
‘matriculation with 15(fifteen) months’ certificate course’ has been enhanced
to also include two years’ experience, is totally illegal in the absence of any
rules governing the service and providing for the same.
13.
Learned counsel for the Petitioners has further submitted that changes
by way of corrigendum is permissible, however any change in criteria putting
any one in disadvantage is not permissible in law. The rule of the game cannot
be changed after the game is under process. The case of Rakesh Kumar v.
High Court of Delhi and Anr: (2010) 3 SCC 104 at paragraphs 14 to 18 and
also the case of State of Orrisa v. Mamata Mohanty: (2011) 3 SCC 436 at
paragraphs 50 and 51 has been cited to prove this point.
14.
On the question of estoppel, the learned counsel has submitted that the
contention of the Respondents that after taking part in the selection process,
the Petitioners cannot come before this Court to challenge the process, thereby
invoking the doctrine of estoppel. However, it is submitted that the doctrine
of estoppel would be applicable if a person has taken part in the process and
fails, he cannot come around and challenge the process. In this case, this is
distinguishable, inasmuch as, the Petitioners herein have not failed, but have
been declared successful after being allowed to participate in the process.
15.
It is also submitted that there is no bar by the doctrine of estoppel to
challenge the process when glaring illegality have been committed in the
procedure. In this case, the Petitioners were the successful candidates, but for
the impugned corrigendum, their appointment have been denied. The case of
Ramjit Singh Kardam & Ors v. Sanjeev Kumar & Ors: (2020) SCC Online
SC 448 at paragraphs 39-41 have been relied upon in this regard.
16.
On a query by this Court, Mr. Nongbri has submitted that in the absence
of rules, but the department has to function, then the Government by
notification can prescribed the minimum qualification in the notification. But
in this case, neither are there any rules, nor was there any notification
prescribing the minimum qualification. The prescription of the minimum
qualification and the subsequent issuance of the said corrigendum was done
at the District level unilaterally. Recently, the Respondents have brought out
an advertisement, wherein the same post of Sericulture Demonstrator was
sought to be filled up and there is no minimum qualification of two years
required. The case of Ramesh Prasad Singh v. State of Bihar & Ors: (1978)
1 SCC 37 at paragraph 5 was referred to in this regard.
17.
Per contra, Mr. A.H. Hazarika, learned GA has submitted that the
advertisement No. DSC.3/ADVT/2012/14 dated Jowai, the 1st November,
2012, was for various posts in different departments including the Sericulture
Department, for which at that point of time there were vacancies for 6(six)
posts of Sericulture Demonstrator. The last date for submission of application
was on 17.12.2012. In the meantime, the authority concerned has issued the
said corrigendum dated 28.11.2012 wherein at paragraph 3 of the same, the
number of vacancies in the post of Sericulture Demonstrator was increased to
10(ten) from the original 6(six) and minimum qualification of 15(fifteen)
months’ course training, Sericulture Training Institute Ummulong with 2
years’ experience was added indicating that the requisite qualification was
modified to the extent that two years’ experience is now required above the
benchmark set vide the original advertisement dated 01.11.2012.
18.
Learned GA has also submitted that the Petitioners did not possess the
requisite qualification as per the corrigendum and as such, their candidature
was not accepted for appointment.
19.
It is also further submitted that the District Selection Committee, Jowai
is an independent autonomous body with its own set of procedure as far as
conduct of written and aptitude test is concerned and has accordingly allowed
even the unqualified candidates including the Petitioners herein to participate
in the process and has also declared the results on 21.07.2014, whereby
12(twelve) candidates were recommended for appointment as Sericulture
Demonstrator including the Petitioners herein. It is however contended that
the Appointing Authority in the Sericulture and Weaving department is not
bound to accept the recommendation made by the DSC, more particularly if
unqualified candidates were recommended.
20.
The next limb of argument advanced by Mr. Hazarika is that the
Petitioners were fully aware of the fact that the required qualification for the
said post of Sericulture Demonstrator is 15(fifteen) months’ training course in
Sericulture and two years’ experience, however they did not raise any
objection at the relevant time and has submitted their application forms as
follows: 1. Shri Nikiru War.
2. Smti Lasankiru Manners
3. Smti Meskhera Dkhar
4. Smti Rafflecia Challam
-
05.12.2012
17.12.2012
14.12.2012
13.12.2012
which applications were filed after the said corrigendum has been issued. The
case of Vijendra Kumar Verma v. Public Service Commission, Uttarakhand
& Ors: (2011) 1 SCC 150 at paragraphs 24, 27, 28, 29 & 31 was referred to
by the learned GA in this regard.
21.
Yet another submission made by Mr. Hazarika is that even assuming,
but not admitting that this Court accepts that contention of the Petitioners that
the rule of the game cannot be changed after the game is over and that change
of criteria in the midst of selection process is not permissible and
consequently, the said corrigendum is set aside and quashed, then what
remains is that the original advertisement with the number of posts at 6(six)
will have to be accepted for which, from the set of four Petitioners in these
proceedings, only the Petitioner figuring at Sl. No. 2 in the final results for the
post of Sericulture Demonstrator issued by the DSC, West Jaintia Hills
District vide notification No. DSC.4/2013/17, dated Jowai the 21 st July 2014
will be eligible for appointment and the other Petitioners would have no case
at all.
22.
On consideration of the submissions and contention of the parties, what
is to be considered by this Court is whether the Respondents could have issued
the impugned corrigendum dated 28.11.2012 when the selection process has
already been initiated by the said advertisement dated 01.11.2012 and whether
by such process the rules of the game have been changed after the game is
over thereby putting the Petitioners herein at a disadvantageous position to the
extent that their appointment have not been affected till date and as such, an
illegality have been committed by the Respondents.
23.
Facts mentioned above reiterated would show that the criteria
mentioned in the said advertisement dated 01.11.2012 has enabled the
Petitioners herein to qualify for application for the said post of Sericulture
Demonstrator. However, by the said corrigendum dated 28.11.2012, the
criteria have been revised to show the addition of two years’ experience
required apart from the basic educational qualification and the completion of
15(fifteen) months’ training at the Sericulture Training Institute Ummulong.
The number of posts has also increased from 6(six) to 10(ten). This, according
to the Petitioners is the aspect of changing the rules of the game after the game
is over which is not permissible in law as the Petitioners have been put at a
disadvantage. In the case of Ramjit Singh Kardam (supra) relied upon by the
learned counsel for the Petitioners, particularly at paragraphs 39 to 41, where
the Apex Court had discussed the principle of estoppel as applicable to the
Petitioners therein, it is seen that the Apex Court has held that the petitioners
who had participated in the selection are not estopped from challenging the
selection in the facts of the present case, since the selection criteria which
was followed was never notified till the declaration of final result, whereas in
this instant case, the revised selection criteria was known to the Petitioners
herein even before they had filed their application forms and as such, the
above judgment would not help the Petitioners herein as far as application of
the principle of estoppel is concerned.
24.
It is also pertinent to mention herein that the Petitioners have filed their
applications forms on dates after the said corrigendum has been issued, i.e
between 05.12.2012 to 17.12.2012. The learned counsel for the Petitioners on
a query by this Court have not been able to specifically state as to whether the
Petitioners were aware or not aware of the said corrigendum at the time of
filing their application forms. Inference therefore has to be made that the
Petitioners were aware of the said corrigendum at the relevant time. On
perusal of the said corrigendum it is also noticed that wide publicity has been
given to the same. There is nothing to prevent the Petitioners to assail the said
corrigendum before the competent authorities before the last date fixed in the
said advertisement which is 17.12.2012, but no action was taken at the
relevant time.
25.
On the above premise, what is required to be ascertained is whether the
Petitioners knowing fully well that they are not qualified for the post for lack
of two years’ experience, yet have taken a chance and took part in the selection
process are estopped from raising any objection as regard the selection
process. The authority cited by the learned GA in this regard i.e the case of
Vijendra Kumar Verma (supra) at paragraph 24 of the same has relevance in
this connection, the same is reproduced herein below as:
“24. When the list of successful candidates in the written
examination was published in such notification itself, it was also
made clear that the knowledge of the candidates with regard to
basic knowledge of computer operation would be tested at the
time of interview for which knowledge of Microsoft Operating
System and Microsoft Office operation would be essential. In the
call letter also which was sent to the appellant at the time of
calling him for interview, the aforesaid criteria was reiterated
and spelt out. Therefore, no minimum benchmark or a new
procedure was ever introduced during the midstream of the
selection process. All the candidates knew the requirements of
the selection process and were also fully aware that they must
possess the basic knowledge of computer operation meaning
thereby Microsoft Operating System and Microsoft Office
operation. Knowing the said criteria, the appellant also
appeared in the interview, faced the questions from the expert of
computer application and has taken a chance and opportunity
therein without any protest at any stage and now cannot turn
back to state that the aforesaid procedure adopted was wrong
and without jurisdiction.”
26.
Though it is not a disputed fact that the Petitioners even while taking
part in the selection process have come out successful, as submitted by the
learned GA, their appointment could not be affected as they are not qualified,
there is no legal duty cast upon the Appointing Authority to appoint them and
the Petitioners have no legal right to be appointed as the power of appointment
is the prerogative of the Appointing Authority.
27.
In the case of Jai Singh Dalal & Ors v. State of Haryana & Anr: 1993
Supp (2) SCC 600 the Hon’ble Supreme Court dealing with a similar case as
the present one, has at paragraph 7 held as under: “ 7. ..... An examination was held by the HPSC and 40 candidates
passed the said examination with the required minimum 45 per
cent marks. Their names were published in the Government
Gazette. The State Government, the appointing authority, made
seven appointments out of the said list in the order of merit.
Respondents, who ranked 8, 9 and 13 respectively in that list, did
not get an appointment although there were vacancies. The
reason for not appointing the respondents was that in the view of
the State Government, which was incidentally identical to that of
the High Court, candidates getting less than 55 per cent marks
in the examination should not be appointed as Subordinate
Judges in the interest of maintaining high standards of
competence in judicial service. Respondents 1 to 3 challenged
this decision on the ground that the State Government was not
entitled to pick and choose only seven out of them for
appointment, because to do so tantamounted to prescribing a
standard which was not contemplated. The State Government on
the other hand contended that the rules did not oblige them to fill
in all the vacancies and it was open to them to appoint the first
seven candidates in the interest of maintaining high standards. It
was further contended that there was no question of picking and
choosing and since the rules did not preclude it from selecting
from the list the candidates for appointment to set a higher
standard, the State Government could not be said to have
infringed any legal right of the selectees for appointment. In the
background of these facts this Court came to the conclusion that
the mere fact that the candidates were chosen for appointment in
response to the advertisement did not entitle them to
appointment. To put it differently, no right had vested in the
candidates on their names having been entered on the select list
and it was open to the Government for good reason not to make
the appointments therefrom and fill in the vacancies. In a recent
decision in Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India,(1991) 3 SCC 47
the Constitution Bench of this Court reiterated that even if a
number of vacancies are notified for appointment and adequate
number of candidates are found fit, the successful candidates do
not acquire any indefeasible right to appointment against the
existing vacancies. It was pointed out that ordinarily the
notification merely amounts to an invitation to qualified
candidates to apply for recruitment and on their selection they
do not acquire any right to the post. The State is under no legal
duty to fill up all or any of the vacancies by appointing
candidates selected for that purpose. Albeit, the State must act in
good faith and must not exercise its power mala fide or in an
arbitrary manner. The Constitution Bench referred with
approval the earlier decision of this Court in Subash Chander.
Therefore, the law is settled that even candidates selected for
appointment have no right to appointment and it is open to the
State Government at a subsequent date not to fill up the posts or
to resort to fresh selection and appointment on revised
criteria…”
28.
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
Petitioners herein have not been able to make out a case for writ of mandamus
and accordingly, their respective petitions are hereby dismissed.
29.
Before parting with this case, this Court has noted the fact that the
Petitioners herein have brought on record the subsequent development in this
case, inasmuch as, vide Advertisement No. DSC.3/ADVT/2012.117 dated
Jowai, the 3rd November, 2020, the Deputy Commissioner & Chairman,
District Selection Committee, West Jaintia Hills District, Jowai had called for
applications to various posts, including 11(eleven) posts of Sericulture
Demonstrator with the qualification and experience required being
Matriculate with 15(fifteen) months’ Certificate Course Training in
Meghalaya Sericulture Training Institute, Ummulong, West Jaintia Hills
District, the last date being 11.12.2020.
30.
This instant case having travelled for almost six years, the Petitioners
have lost precious time to enable them to be considered for alternative
employment within the permissible age limit in the event of the case going
against them, this Court moulding the reliefs suitably, hereby directs the
Respondents herein to consider their fresh application to suitable posts on
being duly qualified by relaxation of the age limit if any, such application is
filed within one year from today.
31.
In the light of the foregoing reasons, these instant writ petitions stand
disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
19.03.2021
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review