Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.32 of 2023
1.
Sri Narayan Chakraborty,
son of late Brajendra Chakraborty,
2.
3.
4.
Sri Bikash Chakraborty,
Sri Nibash Chakraborty,
Sri Suman Chakraborty,
-all are sons of Sri Narayan Chakraborty, all are
residents of village-Palatana, P.O. Palatana, P.S.
Kakraban, District- Gomati, Tripura, PIN799105
……… Appellant (s)
–Versus–
Smt. Jaygun Bibi,
wife of Shri Kashem Ali,
resident of village-Palatana, P.O. Palatana,
District- Gomati, Tripura, PIN-799105
…….. Respondent (s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Ms. P. Shil, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Banerjee, Adv.
Ms. R. Majumder, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
12.09.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
17.12.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The appeal arises out of the judgment dated 17.07.2023
passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Gomati, Tripura, in
Title Appeal No.02 of 2019 and related decree thereof by upsetting
the judgment of the learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Court No.2,
Gomati, Udaipur in Title Suit No.03 of 2017.
[2]
The respondent [hereinafter referred to as the plaintiff]
instituted the suit bearing Title Suit No.03 of 2017 praying for
declaration of her right, title and interest over the suit land and also
for recovery of possession. The suit land measure 0.18 acres of CS
Plot No.2772 (P) corresponding to RS Plot No.4504/6175 of chara
class, of Mouja-Palatana, Udaipur.
[3]
Her claim is that the original owner of the suit land was
one Fayjan Bibi who sold out the same to her by registered deed of
sale
No.1-1289
dated
25.04.1987
(Exbt.1)
and
delivered
the
possession of the same to her. Her name was accordingly mutated in
the related ROR and a separate Khatian was prepared after due field
inquiry by the revenue authority. Later on, the plaintiff came to know
that the boundary description of her purchased land as reflected in the
said sale deed was not proper and therefore, on her request, the
transferor executed one registered deed of rectification bearing No.IV120 dated 07.12.2016 (Exbt.4). The boundary description of suit land
tallies with the boundary description as mentioned in deed of
rectification. It is the grievance of plaintiff that on 05.09.2013, the
appellants
[hereinafter
referred
to
as the
defendants]
illegally
dispossessed her therefrom and despite her repeated request, they
did not vacate the same in her favour and therefore, the suit was
instituted.
[4]
The defendants in their pleadings admitted that said
Fayjan Bibi was the original owner of the suit land but in the year
1987 vide sale deed no.1-1288 (Exbt.A), she sold out 0.16 acres to
one Arjan Ali, with specific boundary by a registered sale deed and
handed over the possession of said land to him. Said Arjan Ali in his
turn, sold out his said entire purchased land to one Sankar
Chakraborty, vide registered sale deed no.1-3112 dated 21.12.1992
(Exbt.B) and handed over the possession to him and till date Sankar
Chakraborty is possessing the same but no mutation as yet been done
in the name or in the name of his vendor in respect of said land. It is
also stated that said original owner of the suit, Fayjan Bibi again sold
out 0.10 acres of land to one Milan Chakraborty (wife of defendant
no.1) from RS Plot No.4505 by registered deed No.1-1235 dated
29.04.1994 (Ext.C) through her attorney and since then, said Smt.
Milan Chakraborty is also possessing her said purchased land.
[5]
According
to
the
defendants,
the
plaintiff
actually
purchased her land with specific boundary as was reflected in her
deed of purchase and she has been possessing the same according to
the said boundary description and thereafter, in the year 2016 when
some boundary disputes occurred between the said plaintiff on one
side and said Milan Chakraborty and said Sankar Chakraborty on
other side, said Milan Chakraborty inquired about the same and learnt
that in their purchased deeds, wrongly plot number was mentioned as
4505 in place of 4504, though their boundary descriptions were
correct. It is further stated that in the purchased deed of the plaintiff,
the plot number was wrongly mentioned as 4504 in place of 4505 but
the boundary description was properly reflected but despite the same,
the plaintiff in connivance with said Fayjan Bibi got the said deed of
rectification executed with an intention to grab the purchase land of
Sankar Chakraborty and Milan Chakraborty.
[6]
During trial, both parties led their respective evidences
and the learned trial court ultimately dismissed the suit. While
appreciating the evidences more particularly, the map and the
purchased deeds of the plaintiff and said Arjan Ali, the learned trial
court observes that the land under purchased deed of the plaintiff
[Exbt.1] actually appertains to R.S. Plot No.4505 and not R.S. Plot
No.4504 and similarly, the land of Arjan Ali is found to be in R.S. Plot
No.4504. The learned trial court also observes that from the
admission of the plaintiff that her present homestead land is on the
eastern side of the suit land followed by a canal and from the
admission of PW-5 that the land of Sankar Chakraborty and Milan
Chakraborty and the defendant No.1 are situated on the southwestern side of the present homestead land of the plaintiff, fortified
the claim of the defendants that both Sankar Chakraborty, Milan
Chakraborty and the defendant No.1 were in possession of the land
under Plot No.5404 for last 25 years and the land purchased by the
plaintiff under Exbt.1 was her present homestead land. The learned
trial court also took exception of the fact that the land of the plaintiff
was mutated in her name in the year 1991 whereas the deed of
rectification was executed in the year 2016 and therefore, mutation
was actually done based on the boundary description of her original
deed. The learned trial court further observes that there was misdescription of plot number in the purchased deed of the plaintiff.
Learned trial court also held that as both the purchased lands of
Sankar Chakraborty and Milan Chakraborty appertain to R.S. Plot
No.4504 i.e. the suit plot, they were the necessary party in the suit.
[7]
The learned first appellate court however did not accept
such reasonings of the learned trial court and set aside the judgment.
According to learned first appellate court, said Sankar Chakraborty
and Milan Chakraborty were not necessary party as no relief was
sought by the plaintiff against them in respect of the suit land. The
learned first appellate court also observes that, as per Order VII Rule
3 CPC, the suit land can also be identified by plot number and in the
case in hand, the purchased land of the plaintiff was properly
mentioned in the related ROR by creating a butted R.S Plot
No.4504/6175. However, while granting decree in favour of the
plaintiff, the first appellate court passed the decree both in respect of
plot number and the boundary description.
[8]
Being aggrieved thereby, the present appeal has been
preferred by the defendants. The appeal was admitted on the
following substantial questions of law:
[i] To treat a party to be necessary party, is any relief
required to be claimed against that person by the
plaintiff, as observed by learned First Appellate Court?
[ii] When both boundary and plot nos. of suit land are
disputed, can a decree be passed without specific
findings on correctness of any of the same, by the
Court?
[9]
During argument, Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel
appearing
for
the
appellants
submits
that
both
said
Sankar
Chakraborty and Milan Chakraborty were the necessary parties in this
suit as their interests are going to be affected by the decree. Mr.
Bhattacharjee,
learned
counsel
also
submits
that
the
present
appellant No.1, Narayan Chakraborty is the elder brother of said
Sankar Chakraborty and Milan Chakraborty is his wife and all are
residing in the suit land. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel contends
that though the purchased deed of the plaintiff and said Arjan Ali were
executed on the same day but prior registration was of the deed of
Arjan Ali. According to learned counsel, the boundary descriptions of
suit land as given by PWs-1, 2 & 5 in their cross-examination also do
not tally with the boundary description of the suit land given in the
plaint. Learned counsel with all emphasis submits that the rectification
deed was done after 3[three] years of alleged dispossession just to
grab the lands of said Sankar Chakraborty and Milan Chakraborty.
Learned counsel further points out that PW-5 in his cross-examination
admitted that the defendants were living in the suit land for last 25
years and therefore, the question of dispossession of the plaintiff in
the year 2016 as alleged does not arise. More so, in her evidence, the
plaintiff did not mention her date of dispossession. Therefore, the
story of such dispossession was not proved.
[10]
Referring
to
Section
of
the
Limitation
Act,
Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel further argues that the date of
dispossession
must
be
proved
by
the
plaintiff
properly
and
satisfactorily. Finally, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel also relies on
a decision of the Apex Court rendered in Subhaga & Ors. vs.
Shobha & Ors., 2006 Legal Eagle (SC) 517 and at para 6 of the
judgment,
it
was
observed
that
when
generally
there
are
discrepancies between the boundary or any other specific description,
boundary should prevail.
[11]
Mr. B. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff
contends that the plaintiff purchased the suit land from RS Plot
No.4504 whereas the lands purchased by Sankar Chakraborty and
Milan Chakraborty were from R.S. Plot No.4505 and as per the map,
both the plots were clearly separable and identifiable and therefore, if
the boundary description for any reason is ignored, the decree may be
passed based on the plot number. Mr. Banerjee, learned counsel also
submits that the date of dispossession was clearly mentioned in the
examination-in-chief
of
the
plaintiff.
Regarding
non-joinder
of
necessary parties, Mr. Banerjee, learned counsel submits that when
no relief has been claimed against said Sankar Chakraborty and Milan
Chakraborty, there is no necessity to make them party. Learned
counsel further argues that at the time of purchase by the plaintiff,
there was no canal in that locality, rather it was made later on, by
acquiring the land by the Government. However, such submission
does not appear to be very convincing as in the purchased deed of the
plaintiff itself, there was specific mention of a canal situated on the
eastern side of said purchased land.
[12]
Mr. Banerjee, learned counsel also relies on a decision of
this court in case of Biswajit Deb vs. Usha Rani Das [RSA No.28
of 2022] decided on 30.09.2023 by a Coordinate Bench of this Court
wherein reference was made to a decision of the Apex Court to the
effect that that the description of the suit property must be sufficient
to identify it and it can be identifiable either by boundaries or by
survey plot number. Applying said principle, this Court in said case
further observed that when there is contradiction in mentioning the
plot numbers and the boundary description, the principle that
boundary will prevail over the plot number, will not apply. Mr.
Banerjee, learned counsel also makes reference of another decision of
another coordinate Bench of this Court rendered in Sadhan Ch. Bal &
ors. vs. Swapan Datta & ors. [RSA No.60 of 2005] decided on
09.04.2014 wherein it was observed that where the suit property can
be ascertained either by boundary or by survey plot, there is no bar to
decree a suit on the basis of the survey plot.
[13]
So far the matter of submission of the learned counsel of
the plaintiff that when the boundary is disputed, decree may be
passed on the plot number of the suit land, is concerned, this Court
has no difference opinion in the matter of application of said principle,
but in that case, it should be ascertained first that description of such
plot number is correct and it has correct reflection in the survey map.
[14]
On perusal of the purchased deed of the plaintiff dated
25.04.1987 [Exbt.1], it is found that the said original owner, Fayjan
Bibi sold out 0.18 acres of land from R.S Plot No.4504 of class-Chara
to the plaintiff. On the same day prior to registration of the said deed,
the said vendor also sold out 0.16 acres of land, Class-Nal to one
Arjan Ali from R.S. Plot No.4505. No dispute has been raised by any
of the parties regarding correctness of the description of land
purchased by Arjan Ali [Exbt.A]. In the deed of rectification, as
executed by the said vendor in favour of the plaintiff on 07.12.2016,
the said purchased land of Arjan Ali is shown on the north side of the
purchased land of the plaintiff. According to the plaintiff, the boundary
description of her purchase land as per recital of the deed of
rectification is correct. If it is presumed so, the purchased land of the
plaintiff would be on the southern side of the said purchased plot of
Arjan Ali but as per the map [Exbt.3], RS plot no.4504 is not situated
on the southern side of the R.S. Plot No.4505, rather R.S Plot No.4506
is situated on the southern side. In other words, if the original owner
actually transferred the land to the plaintiff from Plot No.4504, land of
Plot No.4505 would be on the eastern side of that plot and in that
case, name of Arjan Ali would come on eastern side, but, neither in
the original deed or in the deed of rectification, name of Arjan Ali has
been shown on the eastern side of purchase land of plaintiff. That
apart, as per the mutated khatian of the plaintiff [Exbt.2] her own
land has been shown on the northern side of her purchased land
whereas as per her deed of rectification, on this northern side, name
of Fayjan Bibi [at present Arjan Ali] is mentioned. In the boundary
description of her original purchase deed, on the northern side the
land of the plaintiff is mentioned but on the eastern side existence of
a canal is shown. If the canal is treated to be on the eastern side then
the plot number of the purchased land of the plaintiff would be on Plot
No.4506 as per the map. Therefore, there are serious contradiction
between the plot numbers and the boundary description of the
purchased land of the plaintiff both in her original deed and also in her
deed of rectification and one cannot be reconciled with the other.
Therefore, correctness of description of the plot number in the
purchased land of the plaintiff becomes doubtful and hence, it will not
be safer to pass any decree based on such survey plot.
[15]
Now, coming to the boundary description of the purchased
land of the plaintiff, as per said deed of rectification, land of Narayan
Chakraborty (Defendant no.1) and his wife Milan Rani Chakraborty are
situated on the southern side and also on the western side. As it
appears from the purchase deed of Milan Rani Chakraborty (Exbt.C),
said Fayjan Bibi, original owner sold out 0.10 acre from plot no.4505
to Smti Milan Rani Chakraborty from the southern portion of that plot
no.4505. As per recitals of purchase deed of Arjan Ali (Exbt.A.), said
Faijan Bibi had ownership of total 0.26 acre of land in that plot
no.4505 out of which from the northern portion, she transferred 0.16
acre to Arjan Ali who in turn re-transferred the same to Shankar
Chakraborty and from the southern portion of that plot, Fayjan Bibi
sold out rest 0.10 acre to Smti Milan Rani Chakraborty and therefore,
there is no scope for existence of any plot of land in between the land
of said Shankar Chakraborty and Milan Rani Chakraborty. It is also not
explained by the plaintiff asto how her purchase land, as per the deed
of rectification, has been shown to be located in between the land of
Arjan Ali and Milan Rani Chakraborty.
[16]
The deed of rectification [Exbt.4] was executed by the
original owner in favour of the plaintiff after about 29 years of her
transfer to the plaintiff. In the contents of said rectification deed, it is
further noted that prior to execution of the said deed of rectification,
earlier on 14.09.2007, another such deed of rectification was
executed by the said vendor in favour of the plaintiff but again they
detected error in the said deed and therefore, the said Exbt.4 was
executed. There is a long time gap between the execution of the
original deed and those deeds of rectification. Initially, when the name
of the plaintiff was mutated in the Khatian in the year 1991 after
necessary field inquiry, the plaintiff appeared to be satisfied with the
boundary description of her purchase deed and did not feel any
necessity for such rectification and said Exbt.4 was executed only
after her alleged dispossession by the defendants.
[17]
For the reasons discussed above, it is also not safe to rely
on the boundary description of the purchase land of the plaintiff as
reflected in her deed of rectification.
The plaintiff has sought for
declaration of her right, title and interest in the suit land and as it
appears, a cloud has already been created regarding the title of the
plaintiff over the suit land, and granting of any such declaratory
decree in favour of the plaintiff may go to affect the interests of said
Shankar Chakraborty and Milan Rani Chakraborty as according to said
deed of rectification, they are the contiguous plot holders.
No
document has been proved from either side to show that defendant
Narayan Chakraborty has any land contiguous to the land of the
plaintiff, rather said Shankar Chakraborty and Milan Rani Chakraborty
have their respective purchase lands there.
But they are not made
party in the suit despite specific plea was taken by the defendants in
their written statement regarding non-joinder of necessary party for
non-impleading those two persons in the suit. Without hearing those
two persons, no elaborate scrutiny is permissible regarding their
respective purchase deeds and consequently, due adjudication is not
possible regarding the title of the plaintiff without they being made
party in the suit. In their absence, Court is not in a position to
examine the correctness of description of their purchase lands in their
respective purchase deed.
[18]
To determine who are necessary parties, the Apex Court in
Kasturi vs Uyyamperumal & Ors, (2005) 6 SCC 733, has evolved
the principle of twin test which are as follows:
[i] There must be a right to some relief against such party
in respect of the controversies involved in the proceeding.
[ii] No effective decree can be passed in absence of such
party.
The relevant paragraph No.7 of the said decision is further
quoted below:
“7. In our view, a bare reading of this provision
namely, second part of Order 1 Rule 10 sub-rule (2)
CPC would clearly show that the necessary parties in a
suit for specific performance of a contract for sale are
the parties to the contract or if they are dead, their
legal representatives as also a person who had
purchased the contracted property from the vendor. In
equity as well as in law, the contract constitutes rights
and also regulates the liabilities of the parties. A
purchaser is a necessary party as he would be affected
if he had purchased with or without notice of the
contract, but a person who claims adversely to the
claim of a vendor is, however, not a necessary party.
From the above, it is now clear that two tests are to be
satisfied for determining the question who is a
necessary party. Tests are - (1) there must be a right
to some relief against such party in respect of the
controversies involved in the proceedings; (2) no
effective decree can be passed in the absence of such
party.”
[19]
Nowhere from the pleadings of the parties, it appears that
the cloud on the title of the plaintiff over the suit land has been
created by any alleged title of the defendant No.1 or his sons who are
made parties in the suit as the defendants, but the basic controversy
of the plaintiff in respect of her claim of title over the suit land is
against the claim centering round purchase deeds of the wife of the
defendant No.1, Milan Rani Chakraborty and his brother, namely
Sankar Chakraborty and in such a situation, the plaintiff has/had
obviously her right to seek redress against both the said two persons
and due to the controversies of title being involved for such execution
of different deeds of transfer by the original owner or her transferee,
no effective decree
can be passed without hearing said Sankar
Chakraborty and Milan Rani Chakraborty.
[20]
Learned first appellate Court committed error by observing
that to be a necessary party the plaintiff must seek relief against the
concerned party and as no relief was sought against said Shankar
Chakraborty and Milan Rani Chakraborty, they were not necessary
party. The twin tests, as laid down by the Apex Court to ascertain as
to who are the necessary party, must be applied by the courts to
decide the challenges regarding non-joinder of necessary party. Said
twin-tests principle nowhere contemplates that to be necessary party
in a suit, specific relief has to be sought against him by the plaintiff.
[21]
From the above said discussions, it appears that the
learned first appellate court has failed to appreciate all the relevant
facts and evidences involved in the suit leading to a perverse decision
and therefore, the judgment and decree passed by the learned first
appellate court are not sustainable in the eye of law.
[22]
In the result, the appeal is allowed with cost in favour of
the appellants.
The impugned judgment passed by the learned Additional
District Judge, Gomati, Tripura on 17.07.2023 in Title Appeal No.02 of
2019 and related decree thereof, are set aside.
Return the trial court’s records.
Registry is to prepare the decree accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2024.12.17 19:18:19 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review