Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 18 of 2015
Date of Decision: 06.04.2021
Shri Millon Ch. Momin
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S.P. Mahanta, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. D. Dkhar, Adv.
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA for R. 1-3.
Mr. K.Paul, Sr. Adv. For R. 4-7.
Mr. A.G. Momin, Adv. for R. 8-11.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
1.
Yes/No
Yes/No
The case of the Petitioner according to his writ petition is that an
advertisement No. MPSC/ADVT-38/1/2013-2014/1, dated Shillong, the 4th
April, 2013 (Annexure-1 of the writ petition) was issued by the Meghalaya
Public Service Commission, Shillong (MPSC) for filling up of 34(thirty four)
vacancies/posts for Meghalaya Police Service Officers under Home (Police)
Department.
2.
The Petitioner being eligible for the same and being desirous to
response to the said advertisement had accordingly forwarded his application
and was thereafter called for Physical Efficiency Test vide call letter dated
29.11.2013 issued by the Respondent/Chief Controller of Examinations,
MPSC. After successfully completing the said test, he then appeared for the
preliminary written examination held on 15.02.2014, and having passed the
same, he was then qualified to appear for the Mains written examination
which was conducted from 8th to 16th September, 2014. Again, on clearing the
said main written examination, he was called for personal interview which
was conducted from 15th to 17th December 2014 which he appeared on
15.12.2014.
3.
It is also the case of the Petitioner that the result of the personal
interview conducted by the MPSC for the post of Junior Meghalaya Police
Service Officer, Home (Police) Department was declared on 19.12.2014 vide
Notification No. MPSC/Ex-C/31/2013-2014/212. The name of the Petitioner
found no place in the Merit List/Result.
4.
The Petitioner then visited the website of the MPSC on the internet and
downloaded the statement of marks secured by the successful candidates and
there he found that the Respondent No. 8 at Sl. No. 30 with Roll No. 284 had
obtained 867 marks. Respondent No. 9 at Sl. No. 31 with Roll No. 304 had
obtained 820 marks. Respondent No. 10 at Sl. No. 32 with Roll No. 308 had
obtained 815 marks and Respondent No. 11 at Sl. No. 33 with Roll No. 140
had obtained 814 marks. Again the Petitioner located his own details, wherein
it is found that he is listed at Sl. No. 20 with Roll No. 21 and that he had
secured 674 marks in the Mains examination and 200 marks in the personal
interview, thus securing a total number of 874 marks, higher than the total
marks obtained by Respondents No. 8, 9, 10 and 11 respectively.
5.
The above reproduced in a chart would appear as follows:
Petitioner/Respondent
Petitioner
Respondent No.8
Merit List No.30
Respondent No.9
Merit List No.31
Respondent No.10
Merit List No.32
Respondent No.11
Merit List No.33
Sl. No. in Roll No. Total Mains Personal Total
Statement
Examination Interview Marks
of Marks
Marks
Marks
Secured
(Annexure10)
6.
Thereafter, the Petitioner lodged a complaint dated 22.12.2014 before
the Respondent/Chief Controller of Examination, MPSC with a prayer for
necessary and urgent action but since no action was taken, he was compelled
to approach this Court by way of a Writ petition being WP(C) No. 2 of 2015,
however in the meantime, the Respondent Government authorities had
appointed the Respondents No. 8, 9, 10 and 11 respectively vide Notification
No. HPL.303/2014/93 dated 09.01.2015 (Annexure-14 of the writ petition)
and as such, the Petitioner withdrew the said Writ Petition No. 2 of 2015 with
liberty to file afresh which was allowed by this Court.
7.
It is also the averment of the Petitioner that as per Reservation Policy
of the State of Meghalaya, 40 percent of the post are reserved for Garo
candidates and as such, he has impleaded only those candidates at Sl. No. 30,
31, 32 and 33 of the Merit List as party Respondents in this case being
Respondents No. 8-11 respectively as they belonged to the Garo community.
8.
The main grievance of the Petitioner is that he is more meritorious than
the Respondents No. 8, 9, 10 and 11 but for the action of the
Respondents/MPSC who by bringing out the Merit List dated 19.12.2014 and
the subsequent appointment orders of Respondents No. 8-11 dated 09.01.2015
which is highly illegal, discriminatory and arbitrary, the Petitioner has been
denied his due right.
9.
The action of the Respondents being violative of the principle of natural
justice as well as Articles 14, 16, 39 and 41 of the Constitution of India, the
Petitioner has approached this Court with a prayer, inter alia to set aside and
quash the impugned Merit List dated 19.12.2014 and the appointment order
09.01.2015 as far as it relates to Respondents No. 8, 9, 10 and 11 respectively
and also to call upon the Respondents/MPSC to re-examine the selection
process and to make necessary correction in the Merit List as far as the
statement of marks obtained by the Petitioner is concerned.
10.
Mr. S.P. Mahanta, learned Sr. counsel arguing on behalf of the
Petitioner has strongly contended that according to the “Statement of Marks
secured by candidates in the Mains and Personal Interview” published in the
Website of the MPSC, the name of the Petitioner figured at Sl. No. 20 with
Roll No. 21 and as mentioned above, he secured 674 marks in the mains and
200 marks in the Personal Interview. However, the Respondents/MPSC at
paragraph 5 of their Affidavit-in-Opposition has stated that the marks secured
by the Petitioner in the Personal Interview was incorrectly entered through
human error on account of the wrong entry made by a staff of the MPSC,
actually the same marks given by the 1 st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th Member of the
Interview Board to the candidate at Sl. No. 65 with Roll No. 238 was also
inadvertently entered as marks obtained by the Petitioner. This according to
Mr. Mahanta is a misleading statement to cover up the fault of the
Commission as the consideration of the Petitioner’s case will come under the
Garo category for which 14(fourteen) seats were allocated, while Roll No. 238
is one Shri Ivan Benson Diengdoh from the Khasi- Jaintia Category for which
14(fourteen) seats was allocated separately and as such, there could not have
been any mix up. The Reservation Policy which eventuated the Merit List
stands as under:
11.
Unreserved Category
- 5 (five) vacancies
Khasi-Jaintia Category
- 14 (fourteen) vacancies
Garo Category
- 14 (fourteen) vacancies
OST Category
- 1 (one) vacancy
It is further submitted that at page 35 of the petition, the details of the
said candidate from the Khasi –Jaintia category at serial No. 65 with Roll No.
238 was shown to have secured 979 marks in the Mains Examination and 202
in the Personal Interview, however the total marks obtained by the Petitioner
in the Personal Interview was said to be 200 and as such, if there is a mistake
in entry of the marks obtained in the Personal Interview of the Petitioner with
those of the marks obtained by the said candidate at Roll No. 238, the marks
of the Petitioner should have been reflected as 202 and not 200 which clearly
indicate that there was no mistake in entering the said marks in the Website.
12.
Yet another contention raised by Mr. Mahanta to counter the assertion
of the Respondents/MPSC is that if the marks allotted by the 1st , 2nd , 3rd and
4th Member in the personal interview to Roll No. 238 are 42, 40, 40 and 41
and the marks given by the Expert Member is 39 and the marks allotted by the
said 1st , 2nd , 3rd and 4th Member to the Petitioner in the personal interview
are 22, 20, 20 & 21 and the marks allotted by the Expert Member is 37, then
if there was a wrong entry made, how did the marks of the Expert Member
allotted to the Petitioner remains at 37 and not 39. This according to Mr.
Mahanta has debunk the statement of the Respondents/MPSC as far as the
assertion of wrong entry in the Website is concerned.
13.
Learned Sr. counsel for the Petitioner has submitted that the Petitioner
after his complaint was filed and on being called by the Commission to inspect
the records has also noticed that the Expert Member has marked the marks in
the score sheet both with pen and pencil. The said Expert Member has also
not given any individual marks under the five heads, totaling 50 marks in
contrast to the other four Members who had given marks under the respective
heads.
14.
The Expert Member has also not given his name and date below his
signature and it is evident that the Expert Member wrote something in the
score sheet which was later erased, which has created some doubt and leaves
scope for manipulation submits Mr. Mahanta.
15.
The learned Sr. counsel has also submitted that this Court on perusal of
the records of the MPSC as called for and not being satisfied with the contents
thereon had directed for a preliminary inquiry by the CBI which order was
assailed before the Division Bench of this Court, which vide order dated
26.10.2016 had directed that the entire matter with records be placed before
the Single Judge Bench who may examine such matter and after returning
final or prima facie findings, to take an appropriate decision in accordance
with law. Therefore, this Court is called upon to peruse the said records and
to pass necessary orders in this regard.
16.
Lastly, learned Sr. counsel has fairly submitted that it is a settled law of
the land that having participated in the process and having been unsuccessful,
the candidate is estopped from challenging the process of the personal
interview. However, due to the peculiar facts and circumstances emerging
from the placement of marks of the Commission (MPSC) as regard the case
of the Petitioner, this Court may be pleased to interfere with the said process.
17.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Sr. counsel for the Respondents No. 4, 5, 6 &
7(MPSC) in his reply has initially taken this Court to paragraphs 6, 7 & 8 of
the writ petition and has submitted that
the response of the
Respondents/MPSC to the averments made in the said paragraphs is found at
paragraph 5 of the counter affidavit of the MPSC.
18.
At paragraph 5 as stated above, the MPSC has given in great details the
process carried out by the Commission as regard the tabulation of the total
marks by the candidates to the post of Junior Meghalaya Police Service. It is
said that after the completion of the personal interview, the marks given by
the individual members to the candidates were handed over to the Chief
Controller of Examination on 18.12.2014. The Chief Controller of
Examination then entered the marks by hand in a blank typed format, prepared
for the purpose. Thereafter, the marks were entered in the excel sheet to
facilitate row-wise addition of marks for each candidate. The marks thus
entered and the total score for each candidate were checked and matched
against the said hand written document. The merit list was then prepared after
perusal of the hand written documents, statement prepared in the excel sheet,
statement of marks obtained in the written examination and the original
personal interview score sheet. The statement was then printed and signed by
the Chief Controller of Examination and was scanned and forwarded to the
National Informatics Centre for uploading in the website of the MPSC.
19.
It is further submitted that while uploading on the said website, the staff
entrusted with this responsibility made a mistake while entering the marks
obtained by the Petitioner to show that he secured 200 marks in the personal
interview and 874 marks in total, when actually he had secured only 120
marks in the personal interview and 794 marks in total. The fact is that the
error occurred when the same set of marks secured by the candidate at Roll
No. 238 who was allotted 42, 40, 40 and 41 marks by the 1st, 2nd 3rd and 4th
Member of the Interview Board was erroneously entered against the name of
the Petitioner at Roll No. 21, who was actually allotted 22, 20, 20 and 21
marks by the 1st 2nd 3rd and 4th Member respectively.
20.
It is the stand of the Respondents/MPSC that on the complaint of the
Petitioner, the Commission along with the Petitioner and his wife had a joint
scrutiny of the records on 03.01.2015 and it was found that the Petitioner
secured the 16th position in the Garo merit list.
21.
Mr. Paul has also submitted that from the written argument of the
Petitioner, the observations made on the examination of the records by the
Controller of Examination, MPSC jointly with the Petitioner under the
heading “ Points to be Noted” and “ Points emerging after Inspection, Marks
given in Viva” has been elaborately spelt out, however there are no pleadings
in this regard, nor has the Petitioner sought leave of this Court to amend his
petition after the said joint inspection as to what manipulation has occurred in
the score sheet.
22.
Asserting that this Court cannot go into this aspect of the argument of
the Petitioner as it is a settled principle of law that the decision of a case cannot
be based on grounds outside the pleadings of the parties as was held in the
case of Trojan & Co. Ltd. v. RM. N.N. Nagappa Chettiar: 1953 SCR 789 and
repeated in the case of Manohar Lal v. Ugrasen: (2010) 11 SCC 557 at
paragraphs 30 to 34, by observing that the Court cannot grant a relief which
has not been specifically prayed by the parties. Without an amendment of the
plaint, the court was not entitled to grant the relief not asked for and no prayer
was ever made to ament the plaint so as to incorporate in it an alternative case.
In this case, the Petitioner has made no prayer for amendment of the writ and
no rejoinder was also filed.
23.
As to the prayer of the Petitioner for evaluation of the answer scripts of
the candidates, it is submitted that the Apex Court in the case of Himachal
Pradesh Public Service Commission v. Mukesh Thakur & Anr: (2010) 6
SCC 759, has held that “it was not permissible for the High Court to examine
the question papers and answer sheets itself, particularly, when the
Commission had assessed the inter se merit of the candidates…”
24.
The last submission made by the Respondents in this regard is by
referring to the settled principle of law that once a person has taken part in the
selection process and is found not fit for appointment, the said person is
estopped from challenging the process of selection.
25.
Mr. A.G. Momin, learned counsel for the Respondents No. 8-11 in his
submission has endorsed the submission of Mr. Paul, inasmuch as, it was
submitted that the Respondents No. 8, 9, 10, and 11 as well as the Petitioner
have taken part in the entire selection process and from the records, it is
apparent that they have secured total marks higher than that obtained by the
Petitioner and as such, at this stage the Petitioner cannot challenge the
selection process.
26.
In this regard, the cases cited below have been relied upon by these
Respondents:
i)
Dr. G. Sarna v. University of Lucknow & Ors: (1976) 3 SCC
585, paragraph 15
ii)
Madan Lal & Ors. v. State of Jammu & Kashmir & Ors: (1995)
3 SCC 486, paragraph 9
iii)
Manish Kumar Shahi v. State of Bihar: (2010) 12 SCC 576,
paragraphs 23 & 24.
27.
Another limb of argument advanced by these Respondents is that in
matters relating to opinion of Selection Body, the Court should be slow to
interfere and the decision made by the expert body should be given due
weightage by Courts. The case of The University of Mysore & Anr v. C.D.
Govinda Rao & Anr: AIR 1965 SC 491 in which the Constitution Bench
unanimously held that normally the Courts should be slow to interfere with
the opinion expressed by the experts particularly in a case when there is no
allegation of malafides against the experts who had constituted the Selection
Board. The Court further observed that it would normally be wise and safe
for the Courts to leave the decisions of academic matters to the experts who
are more familiar with the problems they face than the Courts generally can
be. Another case cited in this connection is that of Dalpat Absaheb Solunke
& Ors v. Dr. B.S. Mahajan & Ors: (1990) 1 SCC 305, at paragraph 12
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed thus:
“12. …It is needless to emphasise that it is not the function of
the court to hear appeals over the decisions of the Selection
Committees and to scrutinize the relative merits of the
candidates. Whether a candidate is fit for a particular post or not
has to be decided by the duly constituted Selection Committee
which has the expertise on the subject. The court has no such
expertise. The decision of the Selection Committee can be
interfered with only on limited grounds, such as illegality or
patent material irregularity in the constitution of the Committee
or its procedure vitiating the selection, or proved mala fides
affecting the selection etc. It is not disputed that in the present
case the University had constituted the Committee in due
compliance with the relevant statutes. The Committee consisted
of experts and it selected the candidates after going through all
the relevant material before it. In sitting in appeal over the
selection so made and in setting it aside on the ground of the so
called comparative merits of the candidates as assessed by the
court, the High Court went wrong and exceeded its jurisdiction.”
28.
It is then prayed that the writ petition filed by the Petitioner should be
dismissed in the light of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
29.
In reply, the learned Sr. counsel for the Petitioner has submitted that the
prayer of the Petitioner is basically in respect of the Respondents No. 8-11
contending that the marks obtained by the Petitioner i.e. 674 in the written
examination and 200 in the personal interview, being 874 in total is higher
than the total marks obtained by the said Respondents No. 8-11 and as such,
the Petitioner’s name should have been included in the merit list and should
have been considered for appointment on the basis thereof.
30.
As to the contention of the learned Sr. counsel for the
Respondents/MPSC that there are no specific pleadings and the writ petition
has not been amended to that extent to assail the findings and observations
post the meeting with the Chief Controller of Examination, MPSC on
03.01.2015, the learned Sr. counsel for the Petitioner has submitted that there
are specific pleadings in this regard at paragraphs 12, 13 and 14 of the writ
petition in which the Petitioner has specifically assailed the manner in which
the result and the merit list has been issued by the Respondents/MPSC.
31.
On consideration of the case of the Petitioner, what is required to be
decided is whether there has been a deliberate act of bias and fraud on the part
of the Respondents/MPSC particularly against the Petitioner herein resulting
in his being left out of the merit list which made him ineligible to be appointed.
32.
To resolve the controversy and dispute as far as the merit of the
Petitioner is concerned, what has to be determined is whether the actual marks
obtained by the Petitioner in the personal interview are 42, 40, 40, 41 given
by the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th Member and 37 by the Expert Member or is it 22,
20, 20, 21 given by the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th Member and 37 by the Expert
Member.
33.
At this point, reference is made to the initial order of this Court dated
08.04.2015 whereby the records of the Respondents/MPSC was produced
before the Court in sealed cover and vide order dated 01.06.2016, this Court
has broken the sealed cover containing the said record in the presence of the
parties and has also requested the parties to go through the documents in the
presence of the Court Master.
34.
Upon hearing the parties and on being led to the contents of the records
mentioned above, it is seen that this Court vide order dated 16.06.2016 had
inter alia directed the In-charge Superintendent of Police, CBI to conduct a
preliminary inquiry and has also caused the Registry to hand over thirteen
bunch of viva-voce score sheets, tabulation sheets, etc. to Mr. N.G.
Khamrang, In-charge Superintendent of Police, CBI.
35.
The order dated 16.06.2016 was assailed by the Respondents/MPSC
before the Division Bench of this Court in W.A. No. 67 of 2016 and the same
was disposed of vide order dated 26.10.2016, the relevant portion of the said
order being the conclusion part which is as follows:
“…….the report made by the CBI and the entire material is now
in the sealed covers. We have not opened such covers nor find
any necessity to do so in this appeal. In the given set of
circumstances, we are of the view that interest of justice shall be
served if the entire material with the record of the writ petition
is placed before the learned Single Judge, who may examine such
material as deemed necessary and take a considered decision in
the matter in accordance with law.
Obviously, after returning final or at least prima facie
finding on the contentious issues, the aspects relating to CBI
report may also be examined by the learned Single Judge and
appropriate decision thereupon could be taken in accordance
with law.
Having regard to the circumstances and for appropriate
further proceeding in the writ petition, it is considered
appropriate that the order dated 16.06.2016 and directions
therein be treated to be in abeyance until specific finding is
reached in the writ petition as indicated hereinbefore. As
observed, after such finding, appropriate orders shall follow in
accordance with law…….”
36.
Thereafter, on being remanded, this Court has heard the parties and the
relevant records and materials have been placed before this Court as directed
by the Division Bench. In course of hearing, for proper adjudication of the
matter, it is deemed necessary that some of the materials kept in sealed covers
may be opened. This Court accordingly with the consent of the parties have
agreed that the sealed covers/package containing the score-sheets, marks of
Main exam, etc., as well as those containing the answer scripts of Respondents
No. 8, 9, 10 & 11 be opened in presence of the parties in open court, which is
done so vide order dated 05.03.2021. In the said order, this Court has observed
“which were kept in sealed covers are required to be opened at this stage”,
which indicate that a prima facie findings have been reached to necessitate
opening of the said materials mentioned above to facilitate full and proper
adjudication of the matter between the parties.
37.
On perusal of the records, this Court has noticed that the mark sheet for
15.12.2014, the date of Personal Interview of the candidates, including the
Petitioner at Roll No. 21 who figured at Sl. No. 4 of the same, the marks given
by the 1st 2nd 3rd and 4th Member are 22, 20, 20 and 21 respectively and the
Expert Member has also given 37 marks to him, in total being 120, while those
given to Shri Ivan Benson Diengdoh at Roll No. 238 are 42, 40, 40 and 41and
39 marks by the Expert Member, the total being 202. The same set of marks,
as far as the Petitioner is concerned, are found recorded in the score sheet,
wherein only the name of the candidates under the Garo category were
entered. Again, the same set of marks were also found in the score sheet,
wherein the names of all the candidates who had appeared for the personal
interview were entered. Here the seal, signature and date, being 18.12.2014
was stamped with the word “Confidential” at the top of every page. In the
same manner, the total marks, that is, the marks obtained in the Mains
Examination and Personal Interview combined was entered in another sheet
properly stamped with seal and with signature and date, being 18.12.2014,
wherein the name of the Petitioner appeared at Sl. No. 54 with Roll No. 21
and the marks entered are 674 and 120, the total being 794 was clearly
indicated. On this observation, this Court is convinced that the Petitioner has
received 120 marks in the Personal Interview and 674 marks in the Mains
Examination and the total is 794 and that there is no indication of any
manipulation of the marks as alleged.
38.
Of course, as far as the score sheet of the Expert Member is concerned,
it is true that there has not been any entry of specific marks under the head of
‘Personality’, ‘Capacity Command and Confidence’, ‘Intelligence’, ‘General
Knowledge’ and ‘Special Knowledge’ but total marks was entered under the
head ‘Total’. This Court would direct the Respondents/MPSC to ensure that
in future the same should not happen again. However, in the context of the
contention of the Petitioner, this would not really matter as the same format
was followed in the case of all the candidates and the Petitioner was not
singled out as far as no entry of marks against each head is concerned. As
submitted by the learned Sr. counsel for the Petitioner, even if one takes the
total marks to be given by the Expert Member as 50 and hypothetically
speaking, if the Petitioner ought to be given the maximum marks by the Expert
Member and the marks given to the rest of the candidates, including the
Respondents No. 8, 9, 10 and 11 remains the same as was given by the Expert
Member in the said score sheet, the final tabulation of marks obtained in the
Personal Interview would still be 22, 20, 20 and 21 and 50 which equals 133
plus 674 obtained in the Mains, the total of 807 will not help the Petitioner
whose marks would still fall short of the total marks obtained by the
Respondent No. 11 who had secured the least marks from amongst the
Respondents No. 8, 9, and 10 herein being 814 marks in total (paragraph 7 of
the writ petition).
39.
The primary issue, that is, the factual aspect of the matter having been
decided, this Court does not find it necessary to cause the report of the
preliminary inquiry by the Central Bureau of Intelligence (CBI) to be opened
at this stage. The same is however kept on record in sealed cover.
40.
In view of the findings and observation made above, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the Petitioner has not been able to make out a case for
interference by this Court and the same is hereby dismissed as devoid of
merits.
41.
Consequently, the case law and authorities cited by the Respondents are
not required to be discussed in depth as this Court has reached the conclusion
it has as above.
42.
Any interim order passed in this instant petition is hereby discharged.
43.
Since the relevant records of MPSC are no longer required in this case,
Registry is directed to return the same to the Chief Controller of Examination,
MPSC.
44.
Petition disposed of. No cost.
Judge
Meghalaya
06.04.2021
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review