Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010281742025
2026:GAU-AS:5246
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP(IO)/529/2025
SHRI LAL BAHADUR SINGH CHETRI
S/O- LATE HARI SINGH CHETRI, RESIDENT OF LABACPAR PART-II,
POILAPOOL, P.S. LAKHIPUR, DIST.- CACHAR, ASSAM
VERSUS
KRISHNA SINGH
W/O- DURGA SHANKAR SINGH, D/O- LATE DUDNATH SINGH CHETRI @
DUDHNATH SINGHA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE LALANGKITTA LABAKPAR
PART-II, P.O.- PAILAPOOL, P.S.- LAKHIPUR, DISTRICT- CACHAR, ASSAM,
PIN- 788098
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. P K DEKA, J MEDHI,R BORAH,MR. P DAIMARY,MR. R.
KARIM,MS. N M LONGKENG
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. L R MAZUMDER, MR. A ISLAM
Linked Case : CRP(IO)/470/2025
LAL BAHADUR SINGH CHETRI
S/O LATE HARI SINGH CHERI
R/O LABACPAR PART II
POILAPOOL
P.S. LAKHIPUR
DIST. CACHAR
ASSAM.
Page No.# 2/7
VERSUS
SMTI KRISHNA SINGH
W/O DURGA SHANKAR SINGH
D/O LATE UDNATH SINGH CHETRI @ DUDHNATH SINGHA
R/O VILL. LALANGKITTA LABAKPAR PART II
P.O. PAILAPOOL
P.S. LAKHIPUR
DIST. CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN 788098
-----------Advocate for : MR. I H LASKAR
Advocate for : MR. L R MAZUMDER appearing for SMTI KRISHNA SINGH
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
07.04.2026
Heard Mr. P. K. Deka, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. L. R.
Mazumdar, learned counsel for the respondent, in both the Civil Revision Petitions.
2.
It is to be noted here that in CRP(IO) No. 470/2025, the petitioner has
challenged the order, dated 21.12.2023, passed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.),
Lakhipur, Cachar, in connection with Petition No. 323/7, in Title Suit No. 07/2020.
2.1
It is to be noted here that vide impugned order, dated 21.12.2023, the
learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Lakhipur, Cachar, (hereinafter, learned Trial Court), has
dismissed the petition No. 323/7, filed by the petitioner, by holding that the Title
Suit is not barred by the principle of Res Judicata.
3.
Further, in CRP(IO) No. 529/2025, the petitioner has challenged the order,
dated 11.02.2025, passed by the learned Trial Court in Petition No. 132/8, in Title
Page No.# 3/7
Suit No. 07/2020; and the order, dated 01.08.2025, passed by the learned Trial
Court in Misc. (C) Case No. 06/2025, in Title Suit No. 07/2020.
3.1
It is to be noted here that vide impugned order, dated 11.02.2025, the
learned Trial Court has rejected the prayer of the petitioner to call for certain
important records in respect of previous litigations between the same parties,
arising out of the same suit land.
4.
Mr. Deka, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner herein
is the principal defendant in Title Suit No. 07/2020 and he has filed one petition,
being Petition No. 323/7, stating that said Title Suit No. 07/2020 is barred by the
principle of Res judicata, as there was a previous title suit, being Title Suit No.
90/1992, between the same parties and also arising out of the present suit land
and other lands and the findings of such previous litigations were recorded in
favour of the present petitioner. But, the said petition of the petitioner was rejected
by the learned Trial Court, vide impugned order, dated 21.12.2023, even without
verifying the concerned record.
4.1 It is the further submission of Mr. Deka that the petitioner has also filed one
petition in Title Suit No. 7/2020, being Petition No. 132/8, to call for certain judicial
and other records in connection with the previous title suit, being Title Suit No.
90/1992; which was a suit between the same parties. But, said prayer of the
petitioner for calling such vital records was rejected by the learned Trial Court, vide
order, dated 11.02.2025, which is impugned in CRP(IO) No. 529/2025.
4.2
Mr. Deka also submits that the petitioner herein has also filed one Review
Petition, upon which, Misc (C) Case No. 06/2025, in Title Suit No. 07/2020 was
registered and the learned Trial Court has rejected the said petition, vide impugned
order, dated 01.08.2025, and being aggrieved, the petitioner has approached this
Court by filing the present petition.
Page No.# 4/7
4.3 Mr. Deka, taking this Court to the prayers and Schedule-II of the plaint of the
present Title Suit No. 7/2020, and to the plaint and Schedule-II of the earlier Title
Suit No. 90/1992, and also the prayer portion and the Schedule-II of the said suit,
submits that the Dag Number, Patta Number and description of the schedule land
in both the suits are same, barring one or two descriptions of the boundary; and
that, the learned Trial Court, without calling for the records of Title Suit No.
90/1992, has decided the petition No. 323/7 and also, the petition No. 132/8.
4.4
Referring to one decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Sajjadanashin Sayed Md. B.E. Edr. (D) by L.Rs Appellants Vs. Musa
Dadabhai Ummer and others Respondents, reported in AIR 2000 SUPREME
COURT 1238, especially to paragraph Nos. 12 & 18; Mr. Deka submits that if the
matter was in issue directly and substantially in a prior litigation and decided
against a party then the decision would be res-judicata in a subsequent
proceeding. And, judicial decisions have however, held that if a matter was only
'collaterally or incidentally' in issue and decided in an earlier proceeding, the finding
therein would not ordinarily be res-judicata in the latter proceeding; and in the
instant case, and the issue raised in the present suit is directly and substantially an
issue in the earlier suit.
4.5 Referring to another decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Lakshmi and Anr. Vs. Chinnammal @ Rayyammal & Ors., reported in AIR
2009 SUPREME COURT 2352, especially in paragraph No. 12; Mr. Deka submits
that if, bringing on record a document is essential for proving the case by a party,
ordinarily the same should not be refused; the Court’s duty being to find out the
truth. The procedural mechanics necessary to arrive at a just decision must be
encouraged.
4.6 Mr. Deka, further submits that though, the petitioner herein has filed an
Page No.# 5/7
application for calling the record of the earlier title suit, being Title Suit No.
90/1992, and some other records, the learned Trial Court has dismissed the same
and decided the other petition without considering the record, and as such, the
impugned order, dated 21.12.2023, in CRP(IO) No. 470/2025; and the impugned
orders, dated 11.02.2025 and 01.08.2025, in CRP(IO) No. 529/2025; are illegal and
arbitrary and are liable to be set aside and quashed.
5.
Per contra, Mr. Mazumdar, learned counsel for the respondent in both the
petitions submits that even though, the Dag Number, Patta Number and the
description of the Schedule-II land, in Title Suit No. 07/2020 and Title Suit No.
90/1992, are same; yet, the boundaries in the western and the northern side are
different in both the title suits and further, referring to Schedule-II of the plaint of
the Title Suit No. 90/1992, he submits that in the said suit, the parcel of land
involved was 9 Kathas and 7 Chataks, whereas, in the Title Suit No. 07/2020, the
parcel of land was only 4 Kathas and the said 4 Kathas was different land from that
of the 9 Kathas and 7 Chataks, as described in the Schedule-II of the Title Suit No.
90/1992.
5.1 However, Mr. Mazumdar submits that in order to ascertain as to whether, the 4
Kathas of land of the Title Suit No. 07/2020 was part of the 9 Kathas and 7
Chataks of land, in Schedule-II of the earlier Title Suit No. 90/1992, the same can
be ascertained only after verification of the record and in that view of the matter,
he has no objection in the event of interfering with the impugned orders in both
the civil revision petitions and to remand the matter to the learned Trial Court to
call for the record and to ascertain the facts and thereafter, to pass necessary order
on the petition filed under Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, by the
petitioner herein.
6.
Mr. Deka, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that he has no objection if
Page No.# 6/7
such an order is being passed by this Court in both the civil revision petitions.
7.
Having heard the submission of the learned counsel for both the parties, this
Court has carefully gone through the petition and the documents placed on record,
and also perused the impugned order, dated 21.12.2023, passed in CRP(IO)
470/2025, and the impugned orders, dated 11.02.2025 and 01.08.2025, passed in
CRP(IO) No. 529/2025; and also gone through the prayer portion and Schedule-II
of the plaint of the Title Suit No. 07/2020, and also the prayer portion and
Schedule-II of the plaint of the Title Suit No. 90/1992.
8.
It is not in dispute that the Dag Number, Patta Number of the Schedule-II
land are the same in both the petitions. However, perusal of the description of the
boundary reveals that the northern and the western side are different. Further, the
parcel of land is also different in Title Suit No. 07/2020, while the parcel of land is
4 Kathas in Title Suit No. 07/2020, in the earlier Title Suit No. 90/1992, the parcel
of land is 9 Kathas and 7 Chataks; and whether, the 4 Kathas of land in Title Suit
No. 07/2020, is the part of the 9 Kathas and 7 Chataks of land described in the
Title Suit No. 90/1992, the same can only be ascertained after due verification of
the record. And in that view of the matter and as agreed upon by the learned
counsel for both the parties, this Court is inclined to dispose of both the civil
revision petitions, by interfering with the impugned order, dated 21.12.2023,
passed in CRP(IO) No. 470/2025 and the impugned orders, dated 11.02.2025 and
01.08.2025, passed in CRP(IO) No. 529/2025. Accordingly, all the impugned orders
stands set aside and quashed.
9. The matter stands remanded to the learned Trial Court, with a direction to call
for the records, as mentioned in the Petition No. 132/8 and thereafter, to hear both
the parties and decide the Petition No. 323/7, by passing a speaking and seasoned
order.
Page No.# 7/7
10. Let the aforesaid exercise be carried out within a period of 4 (four) weeks
from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order.
11. The parties of both the civil revision petitions are directed to appear before the
learned Trial Court, with a certified copy of this order, on or before 08.05.2026.
12. In terms of the above, these two civil revision petitions stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review