Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Arb.P. No.13 of 2023
Shri Kashinath Bhattacherjee, Contractor
.........Petitioner(s);
Versus
The State of Tripura & others
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. H. Sarkar, Advocate.
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
12/04/2024
Heard Mr. H. Sarkar, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr.
Karnajit De, learned Additional Government Advocate for the respondentsState.
2.
Petitioner approached this Court for appointment of an
independent arbitrator invoking Clause 22 (i) & (ii) of the agreement
[Annexure-2] between the parties under Section 11(6)(a) read with Section 12
of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended.
3.
Pursuant to the order dated 15.03.2024, the proposed Arbitrator
has conveyed his consent and also sent his disclosure statement in terms of
Section 12(1) read with the Sixth Schedule of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 as amended. The said order dated 15.03.2024 is reproduced
hereunder:
“Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. H. Sarkar,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya, learned
Government Advocate appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
Petitioner approached this Court under Section 11(6)(a) read with Section 12 of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended by the Act of 2015 for
appointment of an independent sole arbitrator for adjudication of the dispute as raised by
the petitioner in connection with the agreement. The work was allotted to the petitioner
vide work order dated 06.01.2016 (Annexure-1) and agreement (Annexure-2). The
agreement contains Clause-22 which is an arbitration clause. Clause-22 of the agreement
is quoted in full:
"22. Settlement of disputes:
22.1
If any dispute or difference of any kind whatsoever arises
between the department and the Contractor in connection with, or arising
out of the Contract at stage, whether during the progress of the works or
after their completion and whether before or after the termination,
abandonment or breach of the Contract, it shall in the first place, be
referred to and settled by the Engineer-in-charge who shall, within a period
of twenty days after being requested by the Contractor to do so, give
written notice of his decision to the Contractor. Upon receipt of the written
notice of the decision of the Engineer-in-Charge the Contractor shall
promptly proceed without delay to comply with such notice of decision.
22.2
If the Engineer-In-Charge fails to give notice of his
decision in writing within a period of twenty days after being requested or
if the Contractor is dissatisfied with the notice of the decision of the
Engineer-In-Charge, the Contractor may within fifteen days after receiving
the notice of decision appeal to the concerned Superintending Engineer of
Department who shall after affording opportunity of being heard shall give
notice of his decision within a period of thirty days. After Superintending
Engineer has given written notice of his decision to the Contractor and no
claim to arbitration, has been communicated to him by the Contractor
within a period of fifteen days from receipt of such notice the said decision
shall remain final and binding on both side. If the Superintending Engineer
fails to give notice of his decision, as aforesaid within a period of thirty
days after being requested as aforesaid, or if the Contractor be dissatisfied
with any such decision, then and in any such case the contractor within
thirty days after the expiration of the first named period of thirty days as
the case may be, require that the matter or matters in dispute be referred to
arbitration as detailed below:SETTLEMENT OF CLAIMS:
All disputes or difference arising of or relating to the Contract shall
be referred for the adjudication as follows:
a)
Claims up to a value of Rupees 50,000/-Superintending Engineer of another circle in the same department.
b)
Claims above Rs.50,000/-Another Chief Engineer or Arbitrator appointed by the Chief
Engineer of the same department.
The arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with the provisions of
Indian Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 or any statutory modification
thereof.
The arbitrator shall state his reasons in passing the award.
A reference for adjudication under this clauses shall be made by the
contractor within 6 (six) months from the date of intimating the contractor
of the preparation of final bill or his having accepted payment whichever is
earlier. Only contracts executed in Tripura shall have jurisdiction for any
suit arising out of this contract. More particularly no suit shall be instituted
or entertained in any court outside the state arising out of contract.”
3.
Parties are ad idem on this issue that this clause is an arbitration clause. This is
all the more obvious from the stand of the respondents from the counter affidavit filed by
the respondents, as upon request of the petitioner the Chief Engineer, PWD (R&B), New
Secretariat Complex, Agartala had appointed an arbitrator Mr. Subrata Pal, Grade-I
Officer of Tripura Judicial Service (Retired) from a panel notified under sub-section (3A) of Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 by the High Court.
4.
Petitioner by way of this application seeks appointment of an independent
Arbitrator by invoking Clause 22.2 of the work order dated 06.01.2016 (Annexure-1) and
agreement at (Annexure-2) for adjudication of the dispute between the parties relating to
execution of the work of “Construction of Chief Minister’s Bungalow i/c frisking &
barrack, Type-II quarter [1 unit] and boundary wall at Agartala, West Tripura/SH:
building portion including internal water supply, sanitary installation & internal
electrification works (laying of concealed conduct pipe only).”
5.
According to the petitioner, the stipulated date of commencement of work was
21.01.2016 and the completion date was 20.01.2018. The estimated amount value of
work was Rs.3,57,61,206/-. However, the structural drawings were handed over on
06.10.2016 and sites were handed over for dismantling of the existing structure on
05.10.2016. On account of indecision of the departmental authority, the works remained
stalled. There was delay in handing over the drawings of septic tank, boundary wall etc.
for over one year and also the electrical drawing for ground floor etc. for certain period.
Petitioner raised a grievance regarding non-payment of dues vide letter dated 11.06.2018.
He also intimated vide letter dated 20.02.2020 that completion of the balance work was
not possible. The work was finally executed on 09.02.2021. It led to price escalation of
the tendered value of work which rose up to Rs.5,47,66,425/- approximately. Petitioner
first represented before the Executive Engineer, P.W.D (R&B), Agartala Division No.III,
Agartala, West Tripura (respondent No.3) on 29.08.2023. Subsequently, following the
procedure prescribed under Clause 22.1, he also represented before the Superintending
Engineer, P.W.D (R&B), 2nd Circle, Agartala on 20.09.2023 and finally approached the
Chief Engineer, P.W.D (R&B), New Secretariat Complex, Agartala on 03.11.2023 for
appointment of an independent Arbitrator under Clause 22.2. However, though the Chief
Engineer is disqualified to appoint an Arbitrator due to the amendment introduced in
2015 to the Act of 1996, being an officer of the department, he has appointed one retired
Judicial Officer, Grade-I of Tripura Judicial Service, Mr. Subrata Pal as an Arbitrator to
adjudicate the dispute between the parties by letter dated 30.11.2023 which has been
brought on record through an additional affidavit. This petition has been filed on
06.12.2023. However, since the Chief Engineer was disqualified to appoint an
independent Arbitrator in view of Section 12 of the Act of 1996, any pre-emptive action
by appointment of an Arbitrator before filing of the instant petition could not oust the
jurisdiction of this Court in appointment of an independent Arbitrator.
6.
By order dated 21.12.2023 the respondents-State was allowed four weeks' time
to file counter affidavit. The counter affidavit is in two parts. One part relates to
averments in reply to the merits of the case which need not be gone into in detail. In
substance, the respondents have contended that though the date of commencement of the
work was 21.01.2016 and stipulated date of completion was 20.01.2018 but the work was
completed by 30.10.2020. According to the department, the petitioner was unable to
complete the whole work within time. Averments have been made at paragraphs-4 to 13
regarding the correspondences made between the parties in relation to the execution of
the work.
7.
Respondents, however, do not dispute that certain disputes regarding the
contract work have been raised by the petitioner. He has approached the Chief Engineer,
PWD(R&B), Tripura on 03.11.2023 (Annexure-5) for appointment of an independent and
impartial arbitrator within 30 days to adjudicate the disputes arising between the parties
for the aforesaid work. The Chief Engineer as per Clause-22.2(b) of the agreement
appointed an independent and impartial arbitrator on 30.11.2023 from the recommended
panel by this Court. After the appointment of the arbitrator, the claimant has with an
ulterior motive filed this arbitration petition on 06.12.2023. The arbitrator has also
submitted his declaration in terms of Schedule-VI read with Section 12(1)(b) of the Act
of 1996 as amended by the Act of 2015 disclosing that he has no direct or indirect
relationship with the parties in dispute or in relation to the subject matter in dispute which
may give rise to justifiable doubts as to his independence or impartiality.
8.
On behalf of the respondents, learned Government Advocate has questioned the
bona fide of the petitioner to doubt the impartiality and independence of an arbitrator
appointed under the agreed mechanism by the Chief Engineer under Clause-22.2(b) of
the agreement. He, therefore, submits that this Court may refrain from appointing another
arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the parties.
9.
Learned counsel for both the parties have placed reliance on the following
decisions:
(i)
TRF Limited vrs. Energo Engineering Projects Limited reported in
(2017) 8 SCC 377;
(ii)
Central Organisation for Railway Electrification vrs. ECI-SPICSMO-MCML (JV), a Joint Venture Company reported in (2020) 14 SCC 712; and
(iii)
The order dated 16.08.2022 passed by the Apex Court in the case of
JSW Steel Limited vrs. South Western Railway and another reported in 2022 SCC
OnLine SC 1973, whereby the matter has been referred to a larger Bench on an apparent
conflict between the above two decisions, both by three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court.
10.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner, has further drawn the
attention of this Court to a recent decision rendered in the case of Glock Asia-Pacific
Limited vrs. Union of India reported in (2023) 8 SCC 226. He submits that despite being
conscious of the conflict in the above two decisions, the Apex Court in the case of Glock
Asia-Pacific Limited (supra) by a three-Judge Bench has chosen to follow the ratio in the
case of TRF Limited (supra).
Learned Government Advocate Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya appearing for
the State has also placed the order of the Constitution Bench dated 17.01.2024 in the case
of Central Organisation for Railway Electrification vrs. M/S ECI SPIC SMO MCML
(JV), a Joint Venture Company [Civil Appeal No.9486-9487/2019] wherein the matter
has been posted for 05.04.2024.
11.
The only legal issue contested between the parties is whether in view of the
provisions under Section 12(5) read with Schedule-V and VII of the Amendment Act,
2015, the Chief Engineer is ineligible or technically disqualified to appoint an arbitrator
under Clause-22.2(b) of the agreement in question.
12.
The issue of ineligibility of the designated authority, a party to the dispute, to
appoint an arbitrator was squarely in question in the case of TRF Limited (supra). The
Apex Court held that once the designated authority becomes ineligible to act as an
arbitrator by virtue of the 2015 amendment, the arbitrator appointed by him also becomes
ineligible by operation of law since he cannot nominate another person as an arbitrator.
The Apex Court also held that ineligibility of appointment of an arbitrator can only be
waived in terms of the proviso to Section 12(5) read with Schedule-V and VII of the
Amendment Act, 2015 if the parties have chosen to waive the condition by an express
agreement in writing only after the dispute has arisen between the parties. The principle
embedded in the maxim qui facit per alium facit per se (what one does through another is
done by oneself) gets attracted in such a case.
13.
There has been a divergent opinion by the Apex Court in the case of Central
Organisation for Railway Electrification (supra) wherein it was held that the designated
authority General Manager of the appellant was not ineligible to appoint a retired
Railway Officer from the panel in terms of modified Clause-64(3) of the General
Conditions of Contract. The respondent had failed to select any two railway
electrification officers out of a panel of four suggested by the appellant. It, however,
appears that noticing the divergence in view between the two Benches of co-equal
strength, the Apex Court in the case of JSW Steel Limited (supra) referred the matter to a
larger Bench. The matter is still sub judice. However, there is no restraint upon the High
Court in the meantime to appoint an arbitrator in such circumstances under Section
11(6)(a) of the Act as amended. It further appears that in the case of Glock Asia-Pacific
Limited (supra), a three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court presided by Hon'ble the Chief
Justice of India has found that the arbitration clause in that case enabled a serving
employee of the Union of India, a party to the contract, to nominate a serving employee
of the Union of India as the sole arbitrator. Such an authorization was clearly distinct
from the arbitration clause in Voestalpine Schienen GmbH vrs. Delhi Metro Rail
Corporation Ltd. reported in (2017) 4 SCC 665 and Central Organisation for Railway
Electrification (supra). The Apex Court also took note of the reference to the larger
Bench and held that it will have no bearing on the outcome of the said case. Accordingly,
the Apex Court proceeded to appoint an independent arbitrator, a former Judge of the
Supreme Court, as a sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes arising under and in
connection with the conditions of tender entered into between the parties, subject to
mandatory disclosures under the amended Section 12 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996.
14.
In the present case, the dispute is between the Contractor and the State of
Tripura, in particular the PWD (R&B) Department. Under Clause-22.2(b) the disputes are
referable for adjudication for claims above Rs.50,000/- to another Chief Engineer or
arbitrator appointed by the Chief Engineer of the same department. The Chief Engineer
of the department, i.e. a party to this dispute, has nominated an arbitrator on the request
of the petitioner following the mechanism prescribed under Clause-22.2. However, he
becomes ineligible to appoint an arbitrator even if the named arbitrator is from a panel
constituted by the High Court vide notification dated 03.04.2023 in exercise of powers
under Section 11(3-A) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended, in view
of the provision of Section 12(5) read with Schedule V & VII of the Act of 1996 as
amended. The arbitration clause in the present case is in similar terms as in the case of
TRF Limited (supra) where the Managing Director of the Corporation was named as the
sole arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the parties or by his nominee. Therefore,
this Court deems it proper to follow the decision rendered by the Apex Court in the case
of TRF Limited (supra). The terms of the arbitration clause herein are quite distinct from
that in the case of Central Organisation for Railway Electrification (supra). It is also
important to mention here that a three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court in the case of
Glock Asia-Pacific Limited (supra) has after noticing the apparent divergence in the two
decisions proceeded to appoint an independent arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute
between the parties since the arbitrator appointed by the Secretary, Ministry of Home
Affairs, was ineligible to make such appointment. In the present case, the independence
and impartiality of the arbitrator appointed by the Chief Engineer is not an issue. It is the
ineligibility of the designated authority, i.e. the Chief Engineer of the department, a party
to the dispute, to appoint an independent arbitrator in view of the amended provisions of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 2015, in particular Section 12(5) read with
Schedule-V and VII. It is pertinent to mention that the instant agreement is post 2015
amendment.
15.
As such, this Court proposes to appoint Hon'ble Mr. Justice Akil Kureshi, a
former Chief Justice of this Court, as an arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the
parties. The proposed arbitrator is requested to submit his consent along with a
declaration in form Schedule-VI of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as
amended. The Registry is directed to communicate this order to the proposed arbitrator.
The matter be placed after three weeks upon receipt of the consent and declaration by the
proposed arbitrator.
List the matter on 12.04.2024.”
4.
The proposed arbitrator has submitted his consent along with
declaration which is at Flag-A & Flag-B respectively.
5.
Learned counsel for the parties, therefore, submit that this Court
may appoint him as an arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the parties.
6.
In view of the consent and declaration submitted by the proposed
Arbitrator, I, hereby, appoint Hon’ble Mr. Justice Akil Kureshi, a former Chief
Justice of this Court as an arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the
parties. Learned Arbitrator is requested to take into consideration the Schedule
of Model Fee prescribed under Schedule IV and the timeline prescribed under
Section 29-A of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended.
7.
Registry is directed to communicate the instant order along with a
copy of the entire pleadings of the instant application to the learned Arbitrator
forthwith.
8.
The instant petition stands allowed. Pending application(s), if any,
shall also stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
MUNNA SAHA SAHA
Date: 2024.04.16 12:12:30
+05'30'
Pijush/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review