Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
I.A. No.01/2023 in W.A. No.49/2023
Smt. Sarmistha Roy
……… Appellant/Applicant(s).
VERSUS
The State of Tripura & others
………Respondent(s).
I.A. No.01/2023 in W.A. No.47/2023
Shri Jayan Debbarma
……… Appellant/Applicant(s).
VERSUS
The State of Tripura & others
………Respondent(s).
I.A. No.01/2023 in W.A. No.48/2023
Shri Soumitra Debnath
……… Appellant/Applicant(s).
VERSUS
The State of Tripura & others
………Respondent(s).
For Appellant/Applicant(s)
: Mr. C.S. Sinha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Order
02/07/2024
I.A. No.01/2023 in W.A. No.49/2023;
I.A. No.01/2023 in W.A. No.47/2023;
I.A. No.01/2023 in W.A. No.48/2023:
Heard Mr. C.S. Sinha, learned counsel for the appellant/applicants,
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate appearing for the
State respondents and Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the
private respondent.
2.
All these 3(three) appeals [W.A. No.47/2023; W.A. No.48/2023
and W.A. No.49/2023] arise out of common impugned judgment dated
01.12.2022 passed by the learned Writ Court in WP(C) No.622/2021 [Sri Jayan
Debbarma vrs. The State of Tripura & others], WP(C) No.624/2021 [Sri
Soumitra Debnath vrs. The State of Tripura & others] and WP(C) No.623/2021
[Smt. Sarmistha Roy vrs. The State of Tripura & others]. These three appeals
got segregated in course of time and two of the other appeals [W.A.
No.47/2023 and W.A. No.48/2023] which could not be taken up yesterday have
been notified to be heard together today with consent of the parties.
3.
All these appeals suffer from a delay of 128 days for condonation
of which I.A. No.01 of 2023 in W.A. No.47/2023, I.A. No.01 of 2023 in W.A.
No.48/2023 and I.A. No.01 of 2023 in W.A. No.49/2023 have been preferred.
Since common legal issue is involved in all these appeals and the delay is not
inordinate and further due to explanation urged by the appellants in the
respective interlocutory applications, delay of 128 days in preferring the
connected appeals is condoned without any serious objection on the part of the
respondents.
W.A. No.49/2023;
W.A. No.47/2023;
W.A. No.48/2023:
4.
Since all these appeals arise out of common impugned judgment
and involve identical legal issues, they have been heard together and would be
disposed of by this common order. For convenience sake, facts borne out from
the record of W.A. No.49 of 2023 are being referred to hereinafter.
5.
Appellants have been appointed on the basis of an advertisement
dated 07.03.2015 after facing a practical test and an interview before the
selection committee to the post of Jr. DTP Operator. So far as their appointment
is concerned, it is not in question or in dispute. Petitioners approached the Writ
Court on the question of fixation of their seniority. According to them, the
advertisement did not stipulate that seniority would be determined on the basis
of their marks. The petitioners and other candidates got selected only on the
basis of the interview and practical marks. No written test was held. Therefore,
the seniority list should have been prepared on the basis of the respective age of
the candidates as there are no rules prescribing fixation of seniority. The
respondents contested their prayer. They relied upon the "General Principles for
Determination of Seniority of Various categories of Persons Employed under
Tripura Administration" (Annexure-R/2 to the counter affidavit), Clause-4
whereof provides as under:
"4. DIRECT RECRUITE:
Notwithstanding the provision of para-3 above, the relative seniority
of all direct recruits shall be determined by the order of merit in which they
are selected for such appointment on the recommendations of the UPSC or
other selecting authority, persons appointed as a result of an earlier selection
being senior to those appointed as a result of a subsequent selection.
Provided that where persons recruited initially on a temporary
basis are confirmed subsequently in an order different from the order of merit
indicated at the time of their appointment, seniority shall follow the order of
confirmation and not the original order of merit."
6.
The seniority list prepared on the basis of combined marks
obtained in practical test and interview were also furnished by the respondents
in their counter affidavit which has been extracted in the impugned judgment.
Appellant Smt. Sarmistha Roy got 28 marks, appellant Sri Soumitra Debnath
got 27 marks and appellant Sri Jayan Debbarma (ST) got 21 marks in their
respective categories. Learned Writ Court on consideration of the rival
submission and pleadings has been pleased to dismiss the writ petitions as
being bereft of merits, inter alia, holding as under:
"I have gone through the different clauses of the said office order as
annexed therewith under the caption “General Principles for Determination of
Seniority of Various categories of Persons Employed under Tripura
Administration”. Clause 4 is relevant to answer the question posed by learned
counsel for the petitioners and is extracted here-in-below in extenso, for
convenience:
"4. DIRECT RECRUITE:
Notwithstanding the provision of para-3 above, the relative
seniority of all direct recruits shall be determined by the order of
merit in which they are selected for such appointment on the
recommendations of the UPSC or other selecting authority, persons
appointed as a result of an earlier selection being senior to those
appointed as a result of a subsequent selection.
Provided that where persons recruited initially on a temporary
basis are confirmed subsequently in an order different from the order
of merit indicated at the time of their appointment, seniority shall
follow the order of confirmation and not the original order of merit."
Admittedly, proviso to Clause 4 has no relevance to decide the
question raised.
Firstly, I have taken into consideration the submission of Mr. Sinha,
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners that there was no proper
selection process in the appointment of the petitioners. I am really surprised to
the said submission of learned counsel of the petitioners for the reason that the
petitioners themselves have stated in the above writ petitions that in response
to the advertisement, dated 07.03.2015, they appeared in the selection process,
faced interview and got selected on the basis of merits. In view of this, it
cannot be said that they were not appointed through proper selection process
where many candidates appeared and participated in the process. Appearing
before the selection process and being appointed through marks they obtained
in the said selection process, now, they cannot take the plea that there was no
proper selection process. All the participants appeared before the selection
process knowing fully the contents of the advertisement and the criteria
stipulated therein. It is not the grievance of the petitioners that there were
irregularities and illegalities in their appointment. As such, this submission of
learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, according to me, is frivolous and
bereft of any merit.
Second main contention of the learned counsel of the petitioners is that
the seniority should be determined on the basis of the age of the selected
persons. In the context of the same, I am not in agreement with this
submission of the learned counsel. When there is specific rule of
determination of seniority of the persons employed under the Tripura
Administration including respondent-departments, then, no other criteria for
determination of seniority will be applicable, and thus, the respondents have
not committed any error in following the general principles for determination
of seniority as applicable in the State of Tripura Administration.
In view of this, I do not find any illegalities and irregularities in
determining the seniority of the petitioners and other similarly situated
persons on the basis of their marks in order of merit in compliance of Clause 4
of General Principles for Determination of Seniority of Various categories of
Persons Employed under Tripura Administration as enumerated in the
Annexure enclosed with the office order dated 18.05.2006.
With the above observations, the instant writ petitions stand dismissed
being bereft of merit. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed."
7.
Learned counsel for the appellants has sought to question the
preparation of seniority list on the basis of Annexure-R/1 at page-39 in W.A.
No.49 of 2023 which contains the mark-sheet of the practical examination of 23
candidates submitted by the Committee members to the Director, G.A. (Ptg. &
Sty) Department, Government of Tripura. This Annexure-R/1 does not reflect
the name of appellants Smt. Sarmistha Roy and Sri Soumitra Debnath but does
reflect the name of Sri Jayan Debbarma who got 15 marks in the practical
examination. However, this alleged discrepancy has been explained by learned
counsel for the State and the private respondent relying upon paragraph-12 of
the counter affidavit of the State respondents.
8.
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the State, has pointed out that Annexure-R/1 does not reflect the
total marks obtained on the basis of practical test and interview by those 23
candidates. In fact, as per paragraph-13 of their counter affidavit, 247
candidates have participated and based upon the aggregate marks obtained by
each such candidate in practical test and interview, the combined merit list was
prepared in consonance with the General principles for determination of
seniority of various categories of persons employed under the Government of
Tripura under memorandum dated 18.05.2006 (Annexure-R/2).
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the private
respondent, submits that name of the private respondent appear at Sl. No.1 of
the seniority list.
9.
We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties.
The position in law so far as fixation of seniority is concerned, in
such circumstances, is laid down in the decision rendered by the Apex Court in
the case of D.P. Das vrs. Union of India & others reported in (2011) 8 SCC
115, relevant paragraphs-18 to 21 whereof are extracted hereunder:
"18. The law is clear that seniority is an incidence of service and
where the service rules prescribe the method of its computation, it is squarely
governed by such rules. In the absence of a provision ordinarily the length of
service is taken into account. The Supreme Court in M.B. Joshi v. Satish
Kumar Pandey [1993 Supp (2) SCC 419 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 810 : (1993) 24
ATC 688 : AIR 1993 SC 267] has laid down that it is the well-settled principle
of service jurisprudence that in the absence of any specific rule the seniority
amongst persons holding similar posts in the same cadre has to be determined
on the basis of the length of the service and not on any other fortuitous
circumstances.
19. Determination of seniority is a vital aspect in the service career of
an employee. His future promotion is dependent on this. Therefore, the
determination of seniority must be based on some principles, which are just
and fair. This is the mandate of Articles 14 and 16.
20. In Govt. Branch Press v. D.B. Belliappa [(1979) 1 SCC 477 : 1979
SCC (L&S) 39 : AIR 1979 SC 429] , a three-Judge Bench of this Court
construing Articles 14 and 16 interpreted the equality clause of the
Constitution as follows: (SCC pp. 485-86, para 24)
“24. … The executive, no less than the judiciary, is under a general
duty to act fairly. Indeed, fairness founded on reason is the essence of the
guarantee epitomised in Articles 14 and 16(1).”
(See AIR para 24 at p. 434.)
21. Another three-Judge Bench of this Court in Bimlesh
Tanwar v. State of Haryana [(2003) 5 SCC 604 : 2003 SCC (L&S) 737] ,
while dealing with the question of absence of a rule governing seniority, held
that an executive order may be issued to fill up the gap. Only in the absence of
a rule or executive instructions, the court may have to evolve a fair and just
principle of seniority, which could be applied in the facts and circumstances
of the case. (See para 47 at p. 619.)"
10.
The present case is not one of those where rules are absent in the
matter of fixation of seniority. The memorandum dated 18.05.2006 does
provide for General principles for determination of seniority of various
categories of persons employed under Tripura Administration. Petitioners are
direct recruits. As such, Clause-4 of the Annexure quoted above provides that
the relative seniority of all direct recruits shall be determined by the order of
merit in which they are selected for such appointment on the recommendation
of the UPSC or other selecting authority, persons appointed as a result of an
earlier selection being senior to those appointed as a result of a subsequent
selection. Therefore, the contention of the petitioners that their appointment
was made only on the basis of interview and, therefore, in absence of any
statutory rules their seniority ought to have been fixed as per their age is not
tenable in law. Moreover, challenge to the impugned seniority list is belated
raised in the year 2021 while their appointments have been made way back in
2015.
11.
As such, we do not find any merit in their plea. Needless to say,
the department is obliged to follow the principles laid down in the
memorandum dated 18.05.2006 for the purposes of preparing the inter se
seniority list of the candidates appointed under the advertisement dated
07.03.2015 to the post of Jr. DTP Operator.
12.
The writ appeals [W.A. No.49/2023, W.A. No.47/2023 & W.A.
No.48/2023] being devoid of merit are accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
PULAK BANIK
Date: 2024.07.06 18:16:57 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review