Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
ARB P No.10 of 2023
Sri Jahar Sur Choudhury, Contractor
......... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
The State of Tripura and others
...... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. H. Sarkar, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. De, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
_O_R_D_E_R_
14.12.2023
This petition is for appointment of an Independent Arbitrator in
terms of Section 11(6)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as
amended. This Court, by order dated 23.11.2023, after hearing the parties and
on consideration of pleadings on record, proposed to appoint Sri Subash Sikdar,
retired Grade-I Judicial Officer of Tripura Judicial Service, Sankar
Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, West Tripura, as the Arbitrator to adjudicate the
dispute between the parties. Order dated 23.11.2023 is extracted hereunder :
“Petitioner seeks appointment of an Independent Arbitrator by invoking Clause
22.2 of the agreement [Annexure-2] under Section 11(6)(a) read with Section12 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended. The work order is
dated 19.06.2018 [Annexure-1]. He submits that the work of construction of
District Administration Complex, Sepahijala District, Tripura could not be
completed by 20.08.2020 though it was completed and handed over by
15.10.2021. Thereafter, he has sought refund of the security deposit and
payment of contractual dues etc. He has approached the respondent No.3-the
Executive Engineer, P.W.D. (R&B), Bishramganj Division, Bisramganj,
Sepahijala vide letter dated 27th December, 2022 [Annexure-5]. Thereafter he
has approached the Superintending Engineer, 4th Circle, PWD(R&B), Netaji
Choumohani, PWD Complex, Agartala vide letter dated 03.04.2023
[Annexure-6] and finally has approached the respondent No.2-the Chief
Engineer, PWD, (Building), Capital Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala vide letter
dated 19.04.2023 [Annexure-7]. Since there is no response, the petitioner has
approached this Court for appointment of an Independent Arbitrator.
[2] The respondents have filed counter affidavit pursuant to the order dated
14.09.2023 inter alia taking the following stand to oppose the prayer for
appointment of an independent arbitrator:
(i) That the arbitration petition is barred by delay as the work was completed
on 15.10.2021 while the request for appointment of an arbitrator has been made
before this Court on 4th August, 2023 that is after lapse of about 21 months.
The scheduled date for completion of the work was 20.08.2020.
(ii) Respondents also have made statements at para 9, 10 and 11 as to the
payments made in favour of the petitioner. The work for construction of
District Administration Complex, Sepahijala District, Tripura was estimated at
Rs.14,59,75,730. Payments have been made from time to time as per submitted
running account bills and as per availability of funds. Out of balance amount of
Rs.15,88,411/- (Provisional) of the final bill, Rs.8,00,000/- has already been
paid vide voucher No.113 dated 18.03.2023. The outstanding amount of
Rs.7,88,411/- which has to be paid to the contractor (the petitioner) is subject
to approval of the Final deviation/ Extra item/ Substitute item statements by the
Competent Authority and the same is under process. 90% of the price
escalation bills up to 6th running account amounting to Rs.47,34,366/- has
already been paid to the petitioner. Rest 10% amount i.e. approximately
Rs.5,26,000/- will be paid after approval of Final deviation/ Extra item/
Substitute item statements and availability of fund with the D.D.O. The price
escalation bills with respect to 7th, 8th and 9th running account bills amounting
to Rs.30,90,759/- approx. (provisional) for the periods beyond the stipulated
period of completion have been resubmitted to the Superintending Engineer,
4th Circle, PWD (R&B), Agartala and further forwarded to the Chief Engineer,
PWD(Buildings) along with copies of time extension approval, Hindrance
Register, Site Order Book etc. for approval as per Clause-44 of the Agreement.
(iii) In reply to para 8 of the petition, the Respondents in para 13 have partially
agreed to the claim of the petitioner but they have also stated that the schedule
of claim amounting to Rs.1,41,75,454/- plus interest and cost of arbitral
proceedings is abnormally on higher side.
(iv) Respondents further said that the Executive Engineer has communicated
his reply on 12.01.2023 to the letter dated 27.12.2022 (Annexure-5) which is
for payment of the outstanding dues within a period of thirty days failing which
he would be compelled to claim other compensation. In respect of the letter
dated 19th April, 2023 (Anenxure-7) addressed to the Chief Engineer, PWD
(Building), Sectt. Complex, Kunjaban, Tripura, the comments of the Executive
Engineer, PWD(R&B), Bishramganj Division, Bishramganj, Sepahijala,
Tripura was communicated vide letter dated 04.05.2023 with copy to the Chief
Engineer, PWD(R&B), Tripura, Agartala also. A status report was also
communicated by the Executive Engineer, PWD(R&B), Bishramganj Division,
Bishramganj, Sepahijala, Tripura in response to the letter dated 6th May, 2023
of the Nodal Officer, PWD(R&B). The subject matter of all the letters of the
Executive Engineer, PWD(R&B), Bishramganj Division, Bishramganj,
Sepahijala, Tripura as mentioned in this para does not refer to the subject
matter of the statement of counter claim also. According to the respondents
except Rs.8,00,000/- other payments have already been made and full security
deposit has been refunded. Balance price escalation bill will be paid after
observing required formalities. Payments against overhead expense, interest
etc. are not permissible as per clause of agreement. They have also taken a plea
that the execution of the work was delayed with time over run of 438 days for
various reasons and such time over run was granted by the competent authority
without levy.
[3] In the aforesaid factual background, learned counsel for the respondentState submits that the contractor had primarily failed to discharge his
contractual liability due to his own fault and lapse and therefore, no dispute is
required to be referred to any arbitrator.
[4] Learned counsel for the petitioner in reply submits that the stand of the
respondents shows that the claim is not stale as the work was completed during
COVID period and time extension was also granted. It also shows that part
payments have been made to the petitioner and certain running account bill are
yet to be paid. Petitioner has followed the procedure by approaching the
Engineer-in-charge and the Superintending Engineer as well as the Chief
Engineer of the PWD department before approaching this Court for
appointment of an independent arbitrator under Clause-22 of the agreement. He
has followed the procedure described for invocation of the arbitration clause.
Since the respondents have accepted that the claims are pending though they
said that it is abnormally high, there exists a dispute which is referable for
arbitration in terms of the agreement entered into between the parties. As such,
this court may appoint an independent arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute
between the parties.
[5] I have considered the submission of the parties and taken note of the
pleadings placed from the records. Clause 22 of the agreement at Annexure- 2
contains the arbitration clause, which is extracted hereunder:
“22. Settlement of disputes:
22.1 If any dispute or difference of any kind whatsoever arises between the
department and the Contractor in connection with, or arising out of the
Contract at stage, whether during the progress of the works or after their
completion and whether before or after the termination, abandonment or breach
of the Contract, it shall in the first place, be referred to and settled by the
Engineer-in-charge who shall, within a period of twenty days after being
requested by the Contractor to do so, give written notice of his decision to the
Contractor. Upon receipt of the written notice of the decision of the Engineerin-Charge the Contractor shall promptly proceed without delay to comply with
such notice of decision.
22.2 If the Engineer-in-Charge fails to give notice of his decision in writing
within a period of twenty days after being requested or if the Contractor is
dissatisfied with the notice of the decision of the Engineer-in-Charge, the
Contractor may within fifteen days after receiving the notice of decision appeal
to the concerned Superintending Engineer of Department who shall after
affording opportunity of being heard shall give notice of his decision within a
period of thirty days. After Superintending Engineer has given written notice of
his decision to the Contractor and no claim to arbitration, has been
communicated to him by the Contractor within a period of fifteen days from
receipt of such notice the said decision shall remain final and binding on both
side. If the Superintending Engineer fails to give notice of his decision, as
aforesaid within a period of thirty days after being requested as aforesaid, or if
the Contractor be dissatisfied with any such decision, then and in any such case
the contractor within thirty days after the expiration of the first named period
of thirty days as the case may be, require that the matter or matters in dispute
be referred to arbitration as detailed below:SETTLEMENT OF CLAIMS:
All disputes or difference arising of or relating to the Contract shall be referred
for the adjudication as follows:
a) Claims up to a value of Rupees 50,000/- Superintending Engineer of another circle in the same department.
b) Claims above Rs.50,000/- Another Chief Engineer or Arbitrator appointed by the Chief Engineer of the
same department.
The arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with the provisions of Indian
Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 or any statutory modification thereof.
The arbitrator shall state his reasons in passing the award.
A reference for adjudication under this clauses shall be made by the contractor
within six months from the date of intimating the contractor of the preparation
of final bill or his having accepted payment whichever is earlier. Only
contracts executed in Tripura shall have jurisdiction for any suit arising out of
this contract. More particularly no suit shall be instituted or entertained in any
court outside the State arising out of contract.”
[6] Upon hearing the learned counsel for the parties and the pleadings on
record including the stand of the respondents, it appears that the petitioner’s
claim for outstanding dues on certain heads are pending with the respondent
authorities. He has also approached the concerned Executive Engineerrespondent No.3, the Superintending Engineer and the Chief Engineerrespondent No.2 before approaching this court for appointment of an
independent arbitrator. As such, this court is of the view that petitioner has
made out a case for appointment of an independent arbitrator. Learned counsel
for the petitioners and the respondent-State on being asked agreed to the
appointment of Sri Subash Sikdar, Retired Grade-I Judicial Officer of Tripura
Judicial Service, Sankar Chowmuhani, P.O-Agartala, West Tripura, for
adjudication of the dispute between the parties. The Registry is directed to
communicate the instant order to the proposed arbitrator for his consent and
declaration in terms of schedule-VII read with Section 12 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended within a period of 3(three) weeks from
the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
Accordingly, list the matter on 14.12.2023.
The proposed Arbitrator has submitted his consent and declaration
in terms of 6th Schedule read with Section 12(1)(b) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996.
Learned counsel for the parties submit that Mr. Subhash Sikdar
may now be appointed as an Arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the
parties.
Having regard to the reasons recorded in the order dated
23.11.2023 as extracted above and on submission of the requisite consent and
declaration by the proposed Arbitrator, I hereby appoint Sri Subash Sikdar,
Retired Grade-I Judicial Officer of Tripura Judicial Service, Sankar
Chowmuhani, West Tripura, Agartala as an Arbitrator to decide the dispute
between the parties. While prescribing the fees for the Arbitration proceedings,
the learned Arbitrator would take into regard the ceiling laid under IVth
Schedule of the Act of 1996. The learned Arbitrator is also requested to keep
into mind the timeline prescribed for declaration of an award in terms of
Section 29-A of the Act of 1996.
Let the order along with the copy of the entire pleadings of this
arbitration petition be communicated to the learned Arbitrator Mr. Subash
Sikdar by the Registry.
Arbitration petition is disposed of accordingly.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
DIPESH DEB
DEB
Date: 2023.12.18 14:44:36
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review