Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 132 of 2015
Date of Decision: 14.12.2023
Shri. Imam Md. Abu Alam Abdulla
Vs. State of Meghalaya & 11 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. R. Debnath, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl. Sr. GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA (For R 1-5)
Mr. R. Choudhury, Adv. (For R 9-11)
Mr. S.D. Upadhaya, Adv.
Ms. A. Synrem, Adv. (For R 12)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner has approached this Court with this instant writ
petition seeking clarification of the judgment and order dated 14.02.2014
passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 137 of 2010 and also for compliance
of order dated 24.04.2015 passed in CONT. CAS(C) NO. 3 of 2015
arising out of WP(C) No. 137 of 2010.
2.
The prayer made in this petition is for this Court to direct the
respondent to release the salary of the petitioner along with DA from
01.03.2009 onwards as per Government sanction together with interest @
12% p.a. and also to quash the letter No. HHSS/Sc-3/2015/3 dated
30.03.2015 issued by the Secretary of Hallidayganj Govt. Aided
Secondary School.
3.
Heard Mr. R. Debnath, learned counsel who has submitted that
the petitioner was initially appointed as science teacher of Hallidayganj
Govt. Aided High (now Secondary) School. The appointment order being
issued by the Secretary of the said School vide order No.
HHS/Apptt/Sc.Tr./94 dated 21.09.1994.
4.
Reference was also made to the filing of a writ petition before
this Court by the petitioner in connection with the illegal action of the
respondent/Managing Committee, which petition was registered as
W.P.(C) No. 168 (SH) of 2002. In that petition, the respondent
11/Headmaster herein filed a miscellaneous application before this Court
being Misc. Case No. 134(SH) of 2002 and order dated 26.06.2002 was
passed in their favour. However, this order was assailed before a Division
Bench of this Court which after hearing the parties had passed the order
dated 12.07.2002 in W.A. No 17(SH) of 2002 whereby the order dated
26.06.2002 was stayed and finally vide order dated 27.03.2003, the writ
appeal was disposed of with a direction to the respondents to allow the
petitioner to work as science teacher.
5.
As far as the writ petition No. 168(SH) of 2002 is concerned, the
same was finally disposed of on 28.03.2006 wherein by virtue of the said
order the position of the petitioner was restored. This order was also
challenged by the respondents before the Division Bench of this Court in
W.A. No.15(SH) of 2006 but this Court vide a common judgment dated
01.05.2008 upheld the order of the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No
168(SH) of 2002.
6.
The learned counsel has further submitted that in the light of the
relevant order of this Court and the Government sanction of the science
grant meant for the science teacher, it can be confirmed that he is the
regular science teacher of the said school.
7.
However, in spite of the fact that the petitioner is the science
teacher recognized by the Government, the respondent/Managing
Committee has failed to pay the salary meant for him prompting the
petitioner to file a contempt case before this Court, that is, the Shillong
Bench of the Gauhati High Court (as this Court then was) being C.O.P.(C)
No. 9 (SH) of 2009 and this Court vide Order dated 26.06.2009 had
disposed of the same on the assurance of the respondents/Contemnor that
one post from Deri Linda Persara Secondary School has been transferred
to the Hallidayganj Secondary School to accommodate the respondent No.
12 herein. The respondent/Managing Committee has then disbursed the
salary to the respondent No. 12 from the government grant but has
however, withheld the salary of the petitioner.
8.
Since the respondent/Managing Committee did not release the
salary of the petitioner, he was therefore compelled to file another writ
petition before this Court being W.P.(C) No. 137 of 2010. This Court vide
order dated 14.02.2014 has allowed the said petition and has directed the
State respondent to clear the dues of both the petitioners as far as their
entitlement is concerned, in accordance with rules.
9.
The learned counsel has again submitted that the petitioner has
filed a review petition for review of the said order dated 14.02.2014 but
the same was dismissed. Thereafter, a contempt petition was filed being
CONT CAS(C) No. 3 of 2015 and this Court vide order dated 24.04.2015
while disposing of the contempt petition has observed that the petitioner is
at liberty to seek clarification from the Court which has passed the order.
10.
It is also submitted that the respondent/Managing Committee
purportedly in compliance with this Court’s Order dated 14.02.2014 in
W.P.(C) No. 137 of 2010 has deposited a Bank Draft for ₹ 37,500/(rupees thirty-seven thousand five hundred) only with the Registry of this
Court as payment of the salary of the petitioner, however the amount
stated therein is not the actual amount due and payable to the petitioner as
arrear salary, the same being conveyed to the petitioner vide letter dated
30.03.2015.
11.
The learned counsel has laid stress upon the fact that there are
various sanction orders issued by the Government in the name of the
petitioner indicating therein the amount sanctioned which when tallied
comes to ₹ 4,77,125/- (rupees four lakh seventy-seven thousand one
hundred twenty-five) only. The detailed list being cited at paragraph 12 of
this petition.
12.
The learned counsel has reiterated that the petitioner has since
received his salary, however this petition is filed only with a prayer for
release of the arrear salary.
13.
On the part of the respondents No. 1 to 4 respectively, that is, the
Officials of the Education Department in the Government of Meghalaya
said to be involved with the employment status of the petitioner as a
science teacher of the said Hallidayganj Secondary School, Mr. S.
Sengupta, learned Addl. Sr. GA has submitted that at the outset, the claim
of the petitioner that he is a regular science teacher of the school is not
founded on factual situation inasmuch as though the petitioner was
appointed as the science teacher of the school on 21.09.1994, his services
as such teacher was terminated since 15.03.1995.
14.
It is further submitted that upon the petitioner being terminated,
one Shri. S. Reza was appointed as the regular science teacher on
01.03.1995 till 28.02.1997. In the meantime, the petitioner was offered by
the school to be appointed as an Additional Science Teacher which he had
accepted till he was again terminated on 31.03.1998. The petitioner
however continued to remain in service and claimed that he is the regular
science teacher of the school.
15.
It is also on record that the petitioner has then preferred a writ
petition before the Shillong Bench of the Gauhati High Court (as this
Court then was) being W.P.(C) No. 168(SH) of 2002 seeking to assert his
claim that he is the regular science teacher of the school.
16.
What is also noticed is that the respondent No. 12 herein, Smti.
Ishmatara Rahman has also filed a similar writ petition before the court
being W.P.(C) No 185 (SH) of 2002 also claiming that she is the science
teacher of the same school, her appointment as such being confirmed vide
appointment order dated 17.11.1997.
17.
This Court on being aware of the unusual situation, had vide a
common order dated 28.03.2006, in effect accepted the contention of the
petitioners in both the writ petitions and eventually had directed the State
respondents to create another post of science teacher in the said school.
The learned Addl. Sr. GA has, however, maintained that the status of the
petitioner as an additional science teacher still remains as he had accepted
the salary attached to such post as evident from the acquittance roll of the
school.
18.
The learned Addl. Sr. GA has submitted that as far as the
Government is concerned, all along, the adhoc grant against the single
existing post of science teacher has always been sanctioned and
transferred to the school through the DSEO, West Garo Hills, Tura. As for
the second post so created by way of transfer on the strength of this
Court’s order dated 28.03.2006, the salary for the said post has also been
channelized through the Inspector of School, West Garo Hills District to
be paid to the respondent/Managing Committee for necessary action on its
part. It is, therefore, the responsibility of the respondent/Managing
Committee to determine as to who is entitled to receive the said salary,
further submits the learned Addl. Sr. GA.
19.
Mr. R. Choudhury, learned counsel for the respondents No. 9, 10,
and 11 respectively, being the School Managing Committee and the
Headmaster of the said school, in his reply to the submission and
contention of the petitioner has admitted that the petitioner was initially
appointed as science teacher of the school since 21.09.1994. However, he
was terminated from service w.e.f. 15.03.1995 pursuant to a resolution of
the School Managing Committee. This action of the Managing Committee
was approved by the then Inspector of Schools vide related
communication dated 26.06.1995. It is also mentioned by the learned
counsel that on the petitioner being terminated from his post as science
teacher, the school authorities have appointed one Shri. S. Reza as the
regular science teacher w.e.f. 01.03.1995. This teacher has however
resigned in the year 1997.
20.
On his services being terminated, the petitioner was then offered
to continue teaching in the said school in the capacity of an additional
science teacher for which he is to be paid a lump sum amount of ₹ 1000/(rupees one thousand) only per month, which he had agreed to and had
functioned in that capacity till 29.02.1996 and from 01.03.1996 till
28.02.1997 he was given a lump sum pay of ₹ 1500/- (rupees fifteen
thousand) only per month. His service was continued from 01.03.1997 till
31.03.1998 when he was again terminated on 31.03.1998.
21.
On calculation of the payment due to him, which amounts to ₹
19,500/- (rupees nineteen thousand five hundred) only and for the period
from 01.03.2009 till 31.05.2009 being ₹ 18,000/- (rupees eighteen
thousand) only calculated @ ₹ 6000/- (rupees six thousand) only per
month, the total of which comes to ₹ 37,500/- (rupees thirty-seven five
hundred) only, the petitioner refuses to accept the same and accordingly,
the respondent/Managing Committee had deposited the said amount with
this Registry as per order of this Court dated 10.04.2015.
22.
The learned counsel has further submitted that records would
show that in the meantime, the respondent No. 12 herein was appointed as
a regular science teacher of the school w.e.f. 17.11.1999. This has then
prompted the petitioner to file a writ petition before this Court (the
Shillong Bench of the Gauhati High Court as this Court then was) being
W.P.(C) No 168(SH) of 2002, with a prayer that he be acknowledged as
the regular science teacher of the said school. Simultaneously, the
respondent No. 12 has also filed a similar writ petition being W.P.(C) No.
185 (SH) of 2002 also claiming that she is the regular science teacher of
the school.
23.
This Court taking up both the aforesaid writ petitions together,
had passed a common order dated 28.03.2006, disposing of the same by
directing the authorities concerned to create another post of science
teacher in the said school so that both the writ petitioners can be suitably
accommodated with salaries etc. due to them to be paid accordingly.
24.
The petitioner has also filed a contempt petition before this Court
being C.O.P. No. 9 (SH) of 2009 alleging that the order of this Court
dated 26.08.2009 has not been complied with, for which the State
respondent has responded by causing transfer of one post of science
teacher from another school, that is, Deri Linda Persara Secondary School
to the Hallidayganj Secondary School, West Garo Hills to accommodate
the petitioner herein.
25.
Again, the petitioner had filed yet another writ petition before
this Court being W.P.(C) No. 137 (SH) of 2010 wherein he has made a
claim that by virtue of the order dated 28.03.2006, he is to be reckoned as
the regular science teacher of the school and all the salary due to him be
released together with interest @ 12% p.a.
26.
Yet again, the respondent No.12 not having been impleaded as
party respondent in the case filed by the petitioner, has filed a separate
petition being W.P.(C) No. 247(SH) of 2010 also claiming that she is the
regular science teacher of the school in question since her appointment on
17.11.1999, duly approved by the Inspector of Schools, she has been
receiving salary as per sanction meant for the science teacher of the
school from the year 1999 till February 2002 with a proposal for sanction
of the same in her favour for the year 2002-2003.
27.
The learned counsel has submitted that this Court had disposed
of W.P.(C) No 137 (SH) of 2010 and W.P.(C) No. 247(SH) of 2010 vide a
common order dated 14.02.2014 with a direction to the State respondent
and the school respondent to clear all the dues of both the petitioners as
per their entitlement in accordance with rules.
28.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the petitioner has
filed this instant petition on identical grounds as found in his petition
being W.P.(C) No. 137(SH) of 2010 and as such, he could not have
approached this Court on the same grounds.
29.
In response to the claim of the petitioner that he is entitled to the
salary pending litigation, the learned counsel has submitted that the same
is factually not correct as respondent No. 12 was serving as a regular
science teacher since the day of her appointment on 17.11.1999 and the
government grant was sanctioned in her name w.e.f. December 1999 to
February 2000 and from March 2001 to February 2002 and as submitted,
a proposal for sanction for the year 2002-2003 in her name has also been
made, submits the learned counsel.
30.
On behalf of the respondent No. 12, Mr. S.D. Upadhaya, learned
counsel has made his submission by referring to the sequence of events or
dates relevant to the case of the parties herein which according to him will
clarify the stand of the respondent No. 12 as far as her status as science
teacher in the school is concerned.
31.
There is no dispute that the petitioner was serving as a science
teacher in the school on his being appointed as such in the year 1994.
However, records would also show that he was since terminated from his
post w.e.f. 01.03.1995 and in his place Shri. S. Reza was appointed as
science teacher.
32.
The learned counsel has further submitted that Shri. S. Reza had
resigned since 28.02.1998 and the petitioner was allowed by the
Managing Committee to again teach in the school, this time as an
additional science teacher which was accepted by him.
33.
The respondent No. 12 was then appointed as a regular science
teacher in the school on 17.11.1999 and her appointment was also
approved by the Inspector of Schools on 12.01.2000. The science grant
sanctioned by the Government was then allotted to this respondent since
the year 2002, again, submits the learned counsel.
34.
The confusion arose as to how two science teachers are
functioning in the same school, upon which the respondent No. 12 had
filed a writ petition before this Court being W.P.(C) No. 185(SH) of 2002
and this Court vide a common judgment dated 28.03.2006 has in effect
confirmed the status of the respondent No. 12 as the science teacher of the
said school when a direction was given to the authorities concerned to
sanction another post of science teacher, purportedly to accommodate the
petitioner herein in such post. In due course, one additional post of
science teacher was transferred to the school from Deri Linda Persara
Secondary School w.e.f. 01.03.2009. It may also be mentioned that the
said post has been transferred to accommodate the petitioner herein which
post will then be coterminus with the service of the petitioner, inasmuch
as in the event he is no longer in service as science teacher in the said
school, that is, Hallidayganj Secondary School, the said post will be
reverted, further submits the learned counsel.
35.
This Court having heard the argument advanced by the respective
counsels for the parties and also on going through the pleadings as is
available on record, including the writ petition and the affidavit-inopposition, is made to understand that this is not the first time that the
matter, as far as payment of salary and arrear salary to the petitioner is
concerned has been agitated by the parties before this Court, either before
the Single Bench or the Division Bench.
36.
As has been submitted, the fact that the petitioner has been
appointment as a science teacher of the Hallidayganj Secondary School on
21.09.1994 is not disputed. Also, the fact that his service was terminated
on 15.03.1995 has also been acknowledged on record and noticed by this
Court in its order dated 28.03.2006 in W.P.(C) No. 168(SH) of 2002.
Thereafter, after the service of the petitioner was terminated, Shri. S. Reza
was appointed as the science teacher of the said school which appointment
was approved by the Inspector of School, West Garo Hills District on
26.06.1995.
37.
According to the respondent/Managing Committee the service of
the petitioner was not done away with altogether, but he was offered to
stay on and teach in the said school however, in the capacity of an
additional science teacher with a monthly remuneration of ₹ 1000/(rupees one thousand) only per month and from 01.03.1996-28.02.1997
for a monthly remuneration of ₹ 1500/- (rupees fifteen thousand) only per
month. However, on 31.03.1998 his service as additional science teacher
was again terminated. There is nothing on record to show that the
petitioner was once again terminated from service w.e.f. 31.03.1998.
38.
In the meantime, it is also on record that the respondent No. 12
was appointed as science teacher of the said school on 17.11.1999. This
appointment has not been opposed by the petitioner herein who had
independently approached this Court vide WP(C) No. 168(SH) of 2002 to
seek confirmation of his service as science teacher of the said school and
for payment of salary thereof. The respondent No. 12 had also filed
separate writ petition being WP(C) No. 185(SH) of 2002 being aggrieved
by the action of the respondent/Managing Committee who has sought to
terminate her services in the school.
39.
It is reiterated that this Court vide order dated 28.03.2006 had
decided the case of the petitioner and the respondent No. 12 respectively
vide a common judgment, inter alia confirming both of them to be the
science teacher of the said school, but for the fact that there is only one
post of science teacher in the school, a direction was given for a sanction
of additional post of science teacher. The judgment of this Court was
complied with by the transfer of one post of science teacher to the said
Hallidayganj Secondary School from Deri Linda Persara Secondary
School, which in effect would mean that the petitioner is allowed to
function as a science teacher of the said school. Nothing is also said
specifically that the petitioner will work in the capacity of additional
science teacher.
40.
Be that as it may, the learned counsel for the petitioner has
candidly admitted that the petitioner has since received his monthly salary
regularly on the additional post of science teacher being made available as
far as the said Hallidayganj Secondary School is concerned. What is
agitated here is with regard to the fact that the petitioner has not received
the arrear salary due and payable to him, which salary was sanctioned by
the Government, the period and amount of which has been specifically
detailed at para 12 of this petition. The said para 12 is reproduced herein
below as:“12.That your petitioner states that your petitioner is entitled for
the salary dues which are furnished as follows:
Sl
No.
Particulars
Amount
As per sanction order Memo No- Rs.13,125
Science/MSGT/34 (W.G.) 99/167, dated 93-2000, wherein your petitioner’s name is
listed in the serial No-36 for the period
from 01-12-1999 to 29-02-2000 –
(Annexure-XX)
As
per
sanction
order
No- Rs.54,000
DHTE/SC/MSGT/4(WG)/2001/99, dated 312-2001 (Annexure-XXI), wherein your
petitioner’s name is listed in the serial No43 for the period from 01-09-2001 to31-122001@ Rs.4500 (Rupees four thousand five
hundred only) P.M. & as per sanction order
Memo
NoDHTE/SC/MSGT/4(WG)/2001/106
dated
5th February, 2002 (Annexure-XXII),
wherein your petitioner’s name is listed in
the serial No-43 for the period from 01-012002 to 28-02-2002 @ Rs.4500/(Four
thousand five hundred only) P.M. i.e. with
effect from 01-03-2001 to 28-02-2002 the
salary of your petitioner sanctioned @
RS4500/(Four thousand five hundred only)
P.M.
Two-third with effect from 01-03-2002 to Rs.37,000
28-02-2003 as per sanction order Memo
No-DHTE/Sc/MISC/22/2003/Pt.II/100,
dated 13-08-2003 and subsequently
released as per order, Memo NoDHTE/Sc/MISC/22/2003/Pt.II/316, dated
2nd June, 2009 (Annexure-XXIII)
With effect from 01-03-2003 to 31-05-2009 Rs.3,73,000
as
per
order
Memo
NoDHTE/SC/MISC/22/2003/Pt./23/233, dated
03-06-2009
(Annexure-XXIV)
and
subsequently it was released by Inspector of
Schools,
Tura,
vide
Memo
NoSWG/MC/AH-67/2009/8937, dated 11th
August, 2009 (Annexure-XXV).
Total amount Rs. 4,77,125/(Rupees Four lakh seventy seven
thousand one hundred twenty five) only.
Further your petitioner states that your petitioner only the
Science Teacher who served since 3rd day of October, 1994 and
your petitioner did not received the payment for the period from
01-03-1997 to 28-02-1998, which has not been included in the
list of the payment made, however, your petitioner reiterated the
claim of salary for the said period.”
41.
At para 7 of this petition the petitioner has referred to an order
dated 14.02.2014 passed in WP(C) No. 137(SH) of 2010 wherein this
Court in the third para of the same has referred to the contention of the
petitioner therein who is also the same petitioner herein and also
represented by the same counsel, that is, Shri. R. Debnath, which on
perusal of the said para it can be seen that it is exactly the same contention
made by the petitioner in this instant petition.
42.
Again, it may be mentioned that the petitioner herein had also
filed a contempt petition before this Court being Cont. Cas (C) No. 3 of
2015 alleging that the order dated 14.02.2014 passed in WP(C) No.
137(SH) of 2010 has not been complied with and this Court while
disposing of the said contempt petition vide order dated 24.04.2015 had
given the liberty to the petitioner to seek clarification from the Court
which had passed the order. Hence this petition.
43.
Accordingly, the whole case of the petitioner in a nutshell is for
clarification of the order dated 14.02.2014 passed in WP(C) No. 137(SH)
of 2010. This Court has perused the order dated 14.02.2014 and is made
to understand that the claim of the petitioner as regard his arrear salary for
the period mentioned at 3rd and 4th para of the said judgment, the State
respondent and the school respondent are directed to clear the dues of
both the petitioners, meaning the petitioner herein and also the respondent
No. 12 herein.
44.
In
response
to
the
said
order
dated
14.02.2014,
the
respondent/Managing Committee had made its calculation and has come
to the figure of ₹ 37,500/- which is considered to be due and payable to
the petitioner and for which on refusal of the petitioner to accept the bank
draft, this Court vide order dated 24.04.2015 in the said Cont. Cas (C) No.
3 of 2015 had allowed the bank draft to be deposited with the Registrar
General of this Court.
45.
At this juncture, this Court is of the considered opinion that it
would be proper for the petitioner to file a representation before the
School authorities as well as the Government authorities connected with
the affairs of the school to seek clarification as regard the computation
brought out by the school authority and also the reference to the various
sanction orders issued by the Government, particularly the Inspector of
Schools, West Garo Hills, Tura as far as the petitioner herein is concerned
since apparently there appears to be available, two sets of figures or
amounts which could not be determined by this Court in this petition
without verification of relevant documents and records.
46.
As far as the prayer of the petitioner is concerned, the order dated
14.02.2014 passed in WP(C) No. 137(SH) of 2010 has been duly clarified
herein and as far as the controversy as regard the amount of ₹ 37,500/(rupees thirty seven thousand five hundred) only, the petitioner is at
liberty to pursue the matter with the authorities concerned as observed
herein above.
47.
In view of the above, this petition is hereby disposed of
accordingly.
Judge
Meghalaya
14.12.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review