Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA No.40 of 2019
Sri Hebel Abel Koloi @ Hebel Koloi,
S/O Late Angadh Koloi,
Of Senior Officer‟s Quarters,
TTAADC, Headquarters Complex, Khumulwng,
West Tripura, 799045.
---- Appellant
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
(Represented by Commissioner)
Home Department,
Government of Tripura,
Agartala, Tripura West,
PIN-799001.
2. The Director General of Police,
Office of the Director General of Police,
Agartala,Tripura West,
PIN-799001.
3. The Superintendent of Police(West),
Office of the Superintendent of Police,
Agartala, Tripura West,
PIN-799001.
4. The Superintendent of Police(Dhalai),
Office of the Superintendent of Police,
Ambassa, Dhalai Tripura,
PIN-799289.
5. The Officer-in-charge,
Radhapur Police Station,
Khumulwng,
West Tripura, 799045.
6. The Officer-in-charge,
Ambassa Police Station,
Dhalai Tripura, 799045.
7. Mr. Arindam Nath,
S/O Debendra Nath,
Superintendent of Police (Traffic),
Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799001.
----Respondents
:
Mr.N.G. Nandi, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA,
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Senior Advocate,
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Advocate,
Ms. A Pal, Advocate,
Ms. N. Chakma Saha, Advocate.
Date of hearing
& delivery of
Judgment and order
:
04.03.2022
For Appellant(s)
[
Whether fit for reporting :
No
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R (O R A L)
(Arindam Lodh, J)
This is a first appeal filed under Section 96 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908, challenging the legality and validity of the judgment
dated 17.08.2019 and decree dated 29.08.2019, passed by learned Civil
Judge(Senior Division), Dhalai Judicial District, Ambassa, Dhalai Tripura,
in case No. Money Suit 07 of 2018.
2.
A brief recapitulation of the facts of the instant case is
necessary. The plaintiff-appellant, Hebel Koloy, was serving as a
Headmaster in “Khumpui Academy” under Tripura Tribal Areas
Autonomous District Council (TTAADC),
at the office of the Chief
Executive Officer Khumulwng, West Tripura, and was also holding the
post of Chairman of a voluntary organization, namely Borok People‟s
Human Rights Organization. On 26.10.2006, some police personnel of
Radhapur police outpost went to the quarter of the plaintiff and took him to
Jirania police station and kept him there without providing food. Thereafter,
he was escorted to the Teliamura police station. Subsequently, on the
instruction of defendant-respondent(here-in-after referred to as the
defendant No.7), Arindam Nath (Superintendent of Police), the plaintiffappellant was taken into the custody of Dhalai District. As alleged by the
appellant, at the instigation of defendant No.7, a suo moto complaint was
lodged against the appellant herein at Ambassa police station by the O/C of
Manu PS, namely Buddha Debbarma, the defendant-respondent No.8. The
allegation was that in course of supervision of Manu PS case No. 37/06,
criminal activities of the plaintiff and his associates under the banner of
Borok People‟s Human Rights Organization came to the notice of the
police. Moreover, it has been alleged in the complaint that the plaintiff was
involved in extremist activities as an overground agent of the NLFT
extremist organization. Further, it was alleged that the plaintiff was arrested
on 27.10.2006 in connection with the aforesaid Manu PS case No.37/06
under Section 396/307/353 of IPC and under 27 of the Arms Act in addition
to Section 120 B of IPC for his involvement in an extremist incident. In
course of supervision of the aforesaid case of Manu PS, police seized one
photocopy of the first page of the passport regarding the present address of
the plaintiff at “Tripura Tribal Students Hostel” at Hostel Shillong,
Meghalaya and the plaintiff admitted that his two passports were issued by
PRO, Guwahati and he did not handover any of these passports to the IO. It
was further alleged that the plaintiff went to Geneva, Switzerland to attend
the 21stSession of the UN Working Group on Indigenous People
„UNWGIP‟. After completion of investigation, the IO submitted the chargesheet against the plaintiff-appellant (here-in-after referred to as “plaintiff”)
under Sections 121/121A/124/153A/153B of the IPC and under Sections
10/13 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act.
3.
The plaintiff had faced trial. On closure of prosecution
evidence and after hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties, the
learned Additional Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Kamalpur acquitted the
accused-appellant by judgment dated 28.11.2013.
3.1.
The acquittal prompted the plaintiff to institute the present suit.
It was pleaded by the plaintiff that the defendant-respondents launched a
series of false cases against the plaintiff but he has been acquitted from
such cases. According to the plaintiff, the defendants instituted those cases
only to cause mental and physical harassment, loss of reputation,
imprisonment, financial loss, deprivation of service benefits, due to which
the defendants are liable to pay compensation to the plaintiff for malicious
prosecution. The plaintiff claimed compensation of Rs.1,00,00,000/- from
the defendant-respondents, Rs.80,00,000/- for compensation against
malicious prosecution and imprisonment of 169 days and Rs.20,00,000/for compensation against loss of reputation, suspension in service, mental
and physical pain, agony, hardship to self and family members. Hence, the
cause of action of this suit arose.
4.
The defendant Nos.1 to 6 contested the suit by way of filing
a common written statement. The defendant No.7 had filed a separate
written statement. The defendant Nos.1 to 6 challenged the suit of the
plaintiff on the ground of non-disclosure of cause of action being barred by
limitation. It was contended in the written statement that one SK Mishra,
Assistant Commandant of 8th Battalion of Tripura State Rifles (TSR)
lodged an FIR dated 26.10.2006 with the fact that on the said date, at about
0750 hours, while the TSR personnel were on patrolling duty at Joyrampara
under Manu PS, at that time, some NLFT extremists attacked suddenly on
the said TSR personnel by opening fire, when one NK (GD) Phalguna
Debbarma died on the spot and his AK-47 Rifle along with 3 magazines
and 90 rounds of bullets were snatched away by the extremists. In the said
attack, another Rifleman, namely Nirmal Debbarma, received bullet injuries
and he was shifted to RGM hospital, Kailashahar and subsequently died.
The said incident was registered in Manu Police Station via Manu PS case
No. 37/06. During the course of the investigation, it was revealed that the
plaintiff was the over-ground agent of NLFT extremist organization.
Accordingly, the plaintiff was arrested on 27.10.2006 and produced before
the Court. Moreover, the defendants in their written statement denied the
allegation asserted by the plaintiff that the plaintiff was not allowed to take
food, and the defendant No.7 instigated the police to implicate the plaintiff
with the afore-stated criminal case. It was further asserted by the defendants
that during the course of investigation it was revealed that the plaintiff had
two passports issued by the Regional Passport Officer, Guwahati, Assam,
but neither the plaintiff nor his advocate handed over a copy of the passport
to the investigation officer. At the time of investigation, the plaintiff
admitted that he visited Geneva, Switzerland to attend, the 21 st Session of
the UN Working Group of Indigenous People from July 21-25, 2003, and in
that session he delivered a speech as a Chairman of Borok People‟s Human
Rights Organization, Agartala. In the said session, the plaintiff had badly
criticized the very existence of Government activities in the State of
Tripura. He also asserted that no protective measures were taken by the
State Government or the Central Government to prevent the process of
continuous affluence of illegal immigrants into the State. Further pleadings
of the defendants are that the ideology expressed by the plaintiff was
similar to the ideology of banned extremist organization like NLFT and
ATTF. So, according to defendants, the plaintiff had calculatedly hatched a
conspiracy and revolt against the State Government and Central
Government as well. On interrogation by the police the plaintiff admitted
his association with the banned extremist group and Bodo Militants. The
aforesaid facts being thus revealed, the Officer-In-Charge of Manu PS,
namely, Buddha Debbarma lodged an FIR with the O/C Ambassa PS which
was registered as Ambassa PS case No. 63/06 dated 8.11.2006, under
Section 121/121A/124/153A/153B of IPC and under Sections 10/13 of
Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. The copy of the speech given by the
plaintiff in the Geneva conference was also certified by one Executive
Magistrate being authenticated copy of the original and having satisfied
with the prima facie materials, the defendants submitted charge-sheet
against the plaintiff. It is pleaded that in the course of trial, most of the
witnesses became hostile and the plaintiff was acquitted by the learned trial
court. The defendants further stated that since 1980 the State of Tripura was
facing troubles from the extremists and since 1993 to 2008, kidnapping,
murder and heinous cases of crimes by the extremists were day-to-day
affairs. Thus, the defendants acted bonafide without any malice and prayed
for dismissal of the suit with cost. The written statement of the defendant
Nos.7 is re-iteration of the averments made in the written statement filled
by the defendant Nos.1 to 6. It is noted that defendant No.8 died during the
proceeding of the suit and his name was deleted.
5.
The plaintiff had adduced four witnesses and also exhibited
several documents in support of his plaint. The defendant No.7 adduced
four witnesses and exhibited relevant documents. The defendant nos. 1to 6
did not adduce any evidence.
6.
After exchange of pleadings, learned trial court framed the
following issues:
i.
Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and
manner?
ii.
Whether the suit is barred by limitation
iii.
Whether there is any cause of action for filing this suit?
iv.
Whether the defendants entangled the plaintiff in a false
case with mala-fide intention?
v.
Whether the plaintiff was clearly acquitted in such a false
case
vi.
Whether the plaintiff suffered in reputation and financially
due to such false filing of criminal case by the defendants?
vii.
Whether the plaintiff is entitles to compensation as prayed
for?
viii.
7.
Whether the plaintiff is entitles to any other relief?
We have gone through the judgment of the learned court below
passed in Money Suit No.07 of 2018. Learned trial court after hearing the
parties to the lis and on consideration of the evidence and materials on
record decided issue nos. (i), (ii) and (iii) in favour of the plaintiff i.e. the
appellant herein and issue nos.(iv) and (v) decided against the plaintiff with
the observation that the plaintiff failed to prove that the criminal case No.
63 of 2006 renumbered as case No. ST 22(NT/KMP) of 2012 was filed
with malice and without any reasonable and probable cause. Issue nos.(vi),
(vii) and (viii) were also decided against the plaintiff. Ultimately, the suit of
the plaintiff has been dismissed.
8.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforesaid
judgment and decree, the plaintiff has preferred the instant appeal before
this court on the ground that the learned trial Court below arrived at an
erroneous finding while passing the impugned judgment and decree.
9.
We have heard Mr. N.G. Nandi, learned counsel appearing for
the appellant as well as Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel,
assisted by Ms. A Pal, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.7
referred to as the defendant No.7 and Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA
assisted by Ms. N. Chakma Saha, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent nos.1 to 6.
10.
At the threshold, Mr. Nandi, learned counsel appearing for the
plaintiff, quite candidly contended that the cause of action of the instant suit
arose, when the plaintiff was acquitted of all the charges levelled against
him in connection to case No.ST 22(NT/KMP) of 2012. Mr. Nandi, learned
counsel for the plaintiff also argued that the cases instituted against the
plaintiff were actuated with malice by the State of Tripura to cause mental
and physical harassment, loss of reputation, imprisonment, financial loss
and for depriving the plaintiff from all sorts of service benefits due to which
the State of Tripura and its officers are liable to pay compensation for
malicious prosecution. Moreover, the detention of the plaintiff, resulting in
catastrophic effects on his service career including his destruction of honor,
self-esteem, total devastation of the peace of his entire family, are an
irreparable loss. According to learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
plaintiff, the loss of reputation, financial loss, mental and physical
harassment being established would constitute the offence of malicious
prosecution for which he was entitled to be adequately compensated.
11.
On the other hand, Mr. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel
appearing for the defendant-respondent No.7, submitted that the defendant
No.7, while discharging his duties as Superintendent of Police (Special
Branch), he received an information regarding an incident dated 26.10.2006
from SI Kamal Kar Chowdhury, and undertook special operations in the
concerned areas to nab the extremists group. Accordingly, the respondent
No.7, being a public servant, discharged his duty. He had no malafide
intention to harass the plaintiff. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing
for the State respondents contended that to prove malicious prosecution
against the State Authority, the plaintiff in the entire plaint did not make
any specific statement about malice against the respondents, which is
contrary to the provision of Order VIII Rule 10 CPC. Moreover, Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing for the State respondents contended
that the onus is with the plaintiff to prove his case.
12.
In the suit, the plaintiff has prayed for following reliefs:
“In the premises above it is most humbly prayed that your
honour would be kind enough to issue summon to defendants and after
being satisfied about the contention made by the plaintiff:(a) pass a decree declaring that the plaintiff was maliciously
prosecuted by the defendants;
(b) pass a decree that the plaintiff is entitled to get a compensation
of Rs.1,00,00,000/- only as shown in the schedule a of the plaint
from the defendants;
(c) Pass a decree declaring that the plaintiff is further entitled to
recover the entire amount under the aforesaid decree from the
defendants.
(d) Pass appropriate order as to interest, cost and any other
relief/reliefs for ends of justice.”
13.
We have perused the evidence and the judgment passed by
learned trial court. According to the learned trial court, the plaint was not
clear regarding the claim that whether the plaintiff was claiming
compensation only for the case No. ST 22(NT/KMP) of 2012 or for other
cases referred to paragraph 7 of the plaint, respectively, Manu PS Case
No.37/06, Ambassa PS Case No.61/06, Ambassa PS Case No.61/09,
National
Security
Act
detention
order
No.F.10/89-
20/DM/D/Con/2006/5904 dated 19/12/2006. Also, it was an admitted fact
that the plaintiff that was arrested in connection with Manu PS case
No.37/06, dated 27/10/2006, against which no claim has been made in the
suit. Hence, the matter of detention and not providing food to the plaintiff
will not arise. It is surfaced from the judgment that the plaintiff was not in
custody
for
days
in
connection
with
Ambassa
PS
case
No.63/06.Learned trial Judge has held at para7. The judgment which reads
thus:“So it is clear that the plaintiff was not in custody for 169 days in connection
with Ambassa PS Case no.63/06 and he was not suspended due to his detention made in
the other cases or the losses suffered in other cases is not subject matter of this suit.
Moreover during cross PW2 and PW4 Basuri Meska deposed that their examination-inchief were prepared by the plaintiff himself and they only put their signatures on those
sheets. PW4 also deposed that he was not aware about the contents of his examinationin-chief. So the evidence of PW2 and PW4 cannot be relied upon as those are not
voluntarily given and not their own versions.”
Learned trial Court also mentioned that acquittal of the plaintiff in the
criminal proceeding cannot be a sole ground for claiming compensation for
malicious prosecution. The burden lies with the plaintiff to prove that the
case was filed with a mala-fide intention and there was no reasonable and
probable cause to file the same. Moreover, it was held by the learned trial
Court that there was reasonable and probable cause for filing the criminal
cases against the plaintiff. It has been also found by the learned trial Judge
that the defendants did not implicate the plaintiff in a false case with
malafide intention. While identifying the legal injury as suffered by the
plaintiff the learned trial Judge held that actual physical loss without
infringement of a legally protected interest and such kind of damage is not
actionable.
14.
According to us, the reasoning to arrived at the findings on the
issues as formulated by the learned trial Judge had been well dealt with. We
find no error of facts and law in the aforesaid findings as arrived at by the
learned Civil Judge. The learned trial Judge has correctly interpreted the
law as regards reasonable and probable cause, legal injury and in
identifying malice in criminal prosecution.
15.
We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions
of learned counsel, Mr. Nandi appearing on behalf of the plaintiff that the
plaintiff has suffered serious mental agony, loss of reputation,
imprisonment, financial loss in service benefit.
16.
In order to succeed in an action for malicious prosecution, the
plaintiffs must in the first instance prove two things, (1) that defendant was
malicious and (2) that he acted without reasonable and probable cause, as
mentioned in the case of Raja Braja Sunder Deb v. Bamdeb Das, reported
in 1944 PC 1, the Privy Council held as under:
“ In order to succeed in an action for malicious prosecution the plaintiff
must in the first instance prove two things: (i) that defendant was malicious and
(ii) that he acted without reasonable and probable cause. Malice has been said
to mean any wrong or indirect motive, but a prosecution is not malicious merely
because it is inspired by anger. However wrongheaded a prosecutor may be, if
he honestly thinks that the accused has been guilty of a criminal offence he
cannot be the initiator of a malicious prosecution.”
Moreover, malice is not enough. There must also be shown to be
absence of reasonable and probable cause. If the defendant honestly
believed a criminal offence to have been committed and had reasonable
cause for so doing, and arrested the accused for the purpose of
investigation, then it would be wrong to say that the defendant/s or the
concerned police officer/s have communicated any actionable wrong. It is
incumbent upon the plaintiffs, if they were to succeed, to prove that no
reasonable and probable cause for the prosecution existed and if they had
not made this out their suit must fail.
17.
In the present case, the two questions are interwoven, first,
whether the cases were instituted with malice by the defendants against the
plaintiff to cause him mental and physical harassment, loss of reputation,
imprisonment, financial loss in service benefit. Secondly, whether there is
reasonable and probable cause for filing the suit.
18.
While dealing with the first ingredient, it has been revealed that
defendant No.7, being the SP Dhalai District , had exercised his power of
supervision over the investigation in which he had no personal interest and
when the charge-sheet was submitted he was not the SP of the Dhalai
District. Hence, there was no malice on the part of the defendant No.7,
against the plaintiff. After perusing the evidence in hand, in the crossexamination, the appellant stated that one Buddha Debbarma, officer-incharge of Manu PS lodged suo-moto FIR with the Ambassa Police Station,
against the appellant at the instigation of then Superintendent of Police,
Arindam Nath. Moreover, such evasive statement without any fraudulent
facts does not carry any evidence. Law is well settled that malice is to
proved and mere statement will not suffice. In absence of any evidence it
will not be prudent to say that Sri Arindam Nath was acted with malice and
the plaintiff was arrested without any reasonable and probable cause to
implicate the appellant with the cases. In the present case, the plaintiff
failed to adduce any evidence in support of his claim. Added to it, the
defendant No.7, namely, Arindam Nath, had only given consent as SP of
Dhalai District to lodge FIR dated 8/11/2006 by one OC Buddha
Debbarma.
19.
While deciding the second ingredient, it has been reflected
from the written statement as submitted by the defendant No.7 that during
investigation of Manu PS case No. 37/2006, criminal activities of the
plaintiff was revealed as overground agent of NLFT extremist organization.
Moreover, there was no allegation of non-supplying of food by the plaintiff
regarding the said mentioned case No.37/2006. During investigation, it was
revealed that the plaintiff had two passports issued by the Regional Passport
Officer, Guwahati, Assam, but neither the plaintiff nor his advocate handed
over copy of the passport to the investigation officer. It is an admitted fact
that the plaintiff that during the process of investigation, visited Geneva,
Switzerland to attend the 21st sessions of the Working Group on Indigenous
Populations from July 21st to 25th, 2003 and in that session he delivered a
speech as a Chairman of Borok People‟s Human Rights organization,
Agartala, wherein he had criticized the very existence of a functional
Government in the State of Tripura as well as Government of India. In that
speech, the ideology expressed by the plaintiff was similar to the ideology
of banned extremist organization like NLFT and ATTF. Moreover, in
custodial interrogation, the plaintiff admitted that he also associated with
the NLFT and Bodo Militants. On the basis of the above mentioned facts,
the OC of Manu PS lodged an FIR against the plaintiff, dated 8/11/2006,
under sections 121/121A/124/153A/153B of the IPC and sections 10/13 of
the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. While confronted with the crossexamination of PW1, the speech given by the plaintiff had been exhibited
as Exhibit A before the learned trial Court. The documents contains
criticism of the State and Central Government and laws made by the
Parliament in dealing with illegal immigrants of State of Tripura and
gradual conversion of Borok people in marginalized group in Tripura. From
the above mentioned facts, it has been transpired that there was reasonable
and probable cause for filing the criminal case against the plaintiff.
20.
Consequently, the judgment dated 17.06.2019, passed by the
learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dhalai Judicial District, Ambassa in
case No. MS.07 of 2018, stands upheld.
21.
In the result, this appeal stands dismissed.
Draw the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
JUDGE
PUSPITA/SNIGDHA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review