Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A. 101 of 2022
Sri Goutam Sarkar, son of late Anil Sarkar, resident of
Totabari, P.O. Totabari, P.S. Kalyanpur, District- Khowai, Tripura
… APPELLANT
(Petitioner in the writ petition)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary, Government of Tripura,
Department of PWD, Civil Secretariat P.O. + P.S. New Capital
Complex, Distict- West Tripura, PIN-799010
2. The Superintending Engineer (PWD)
2nd Circle, West Tripura, Pin-799006
3. The Executive Engineer (PWD)
Teliamura Division, Teliamura, District- Khowai, Tripura
… RESPONDENTS
(Respondents in the writ petition)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. SK Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. PK Pal, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
Date of hearing & delivery of judgment :
29.03.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes / No
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
29/03/2023
(T. Amarnath Goud, ACJ)
Heard Mr. SK Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. PK
Pal, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr. D. Sarma,
learned Additional GA appearing for the respondent-State.
2.
This appeal has been filed by the appellant assailing the
judgment and order passed by a learned Single Judge dated
04.05.2022 in WP(C) no. 642 of 2021 dismissing the writ petition
filed by the petitioner, the appellant herein.
Page 2
3.
Briefly stated, the father of the petitioner, namely, Anil
Sarkar was serving as Helper under the respondent no. 3. On
09.03.2012, the father of the petitioner had died in harness
leaving behind his survivors. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted
an application seeking appointment under the die-in-harness
scheme, and in pursuant thereof the respondent no. 3 directed
the petitioner to submit certain documents. In pursuant to that
the petitioner submitted the relevant documents. Thereafter on
22.05.2014 the respondents have forwarded the list of names of
similarly situated candidates for considering their appointment
under die-in-harness scheme. In the said recommendation, the
name of the petitioner was figured at serial no. 15. Thereafter,
on further inquiry, by a communication dated 28.09.2021, the
respondents asked the petitioner to submit his ration card for
considering
his
name
in
the
light
of
the
memorandum.
Thereafter, the petitioner vide his letter dated 13.12.2021
intimated the respondents that the ration card is not traceable
for which he could not submit the same. Accordingly, the
respondents after inquiry into the matter vide communication
dated 14.12.2021 opined that the petitioner had been residing
separately by maintaining separate ration card prior to death of
his father, and subsequently, rejected his prayer for providing
him job under die-in-harness scheme. Feeling aggrieved, the
Page 3
appellant herein had preferred a writ petition before this court
vide WP(C) 642 of 2021. The learned single Judge while
appreciating the case of the petitioner has formulated two issues
(i) on the point of delay and laches in approaching the court for
compassionate appointment, and ii) on the point of dependency,
whether the petitioner constitutes within the definition of ‘family’.
Since the writ petition was filed, without giving any impugned
order, the writ petition could have disposed of directing the
respondents to decide the matter in the light of the scheme or
any other legal provisions and also the memorandums and in
accordance with law. However, learned single judge gone into the
grass root level of the matter and after hearing both sides by its
order dated 04.05.2022 had dismissed the writ petition. Being
aggrieved, the petitioner had preferred this writ appeal.
4.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant
has submitted that similarly situated persons have been granted
with job under die-in-harness scheme by this learned court. Mr.
Deb, learned senior counsel has also submitted that though the
appellant is having separate ration card, but he is living in the
joint family. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has further
submitted that since there is no physical separation of the
appellant from his family so he cannot be excluded from
consideration of appointment under the die-in-harness scheme.
Page 4
Learned senior counsel also has submitted that the petitioner has
approached the authority since after death of his father and also
after rejection he had immediately approached this court, hence,
there is no delay and laches on the part of the appellant.
5.
Learned Additional GA has fairly submitted that findings of
the learned single Judge in its order dated 04.05.2022 is valid
and no interference is called for since the petitioner had
separated his family from the family of the deceased employee
much before the death of his father by obtaining separate ration
card so on the ground of dependency, the instant writ appeal
requires to be dismissed. Further, learned Additional GA has
submitted that the petitioner after elapse of a long period had
approached this court seeking reliefs. Lastly, Mr. Sarma, has
submitted that in the light of the judgment rendered in The
State of West Bengal vs. Debabrata Tiwari and others
reported in 2023 LiveLaw(SC) 175, the instant writ appeal
deserves to be dismissed on the ground of laches.
6.
We have perused the record and also the judgment of the
learned single Judge.
7.
Keeping in mind the rival submissions, it would be useful to
extract the relevant portion of the notification under No. F.1(2)GA(P&T)/15, dated 19.05.2017
Tripura,
General
issued by the Government of
Administration
(Personnel
&
Training)
Page 5
Department
on
the
subject
‘Die-in-harness
Scheme-
Government of Tripura’, which is as under“Provided that a married son or daughter-in-law or widowed daughter if he/she
lives/used to live separately from other members of the family on or before the
death of the Government employee shall not be considered as family member of
the family of the government employee for the purpose of providing benefits
under the Scheme only. Married daughter(s) under any circumstances shall not
come under the purview of Die-in-harness Scheme.”
8.
For being entitlement of the benefits under the die-in-
harness
and
extremists/ethnic
violence
schemes,
the
Government of Tripura, General Administration (Personnel &
Training) Department vide its Memo dated 24.09.2011 has been
expanded the term ‘family’ in the following manner:
“(i) his wife or her husband, as the case may be;
(ii) legitimate children excluding a married son or married daughter or daughter-in-law, if he/she
lives separately from other members of the family;
(iii) step Children,
(iv) adopted Children.
(v) dependent daughter-in-law;
(vi) dependent parents;
(vii) dependent unmarried brother(s) and unmarried sister(s) and
(viii) dependent widow daughter(s).”
9.
From the record, it is evident that the deceased, Anil
chandra Sarkar, father of the appellant herein, had died in
harness on 09.03.2012, but the appellant had obtained separate
ration card on 16.06.2010 i.e. much prior to the death of his
deceased father and had been residing separately at Totabari
maintaining separate family. In the rejoinder submitted by the
appellant, the appellant has also averred that ‘it is a fact that the
petitioner obtained a separate ration card for him during the
lifetime of his father and it was obtained to have the government
Page 6
employment for him because at that point of time it was the
policy of the state government there should have no other
member in the family having government employment. The
petitioner though
obtained separate ration card
he
never
separated himself including his spouse and baby from joint living
with his parents and other. The petitioner accommodate the
same house premises sharing the same mess because it was not
possible for him to maintain separate establishment with his
meager earning of Rs. 2,000/- per month without the help of his
parents’.
10. Die-in-harness scheme does not confer a right on a person
for compassionate appointment. This is purely a discretion to be
exercised by the authority concerned and this discretion is
required to be exercised reasonably by the authority after taking
into consideration all the materials and factual aspects. Here in
the instant writ appeal, the appellant though claimed to be living
in joint mess, but from the record it is abundantly clear that the
appellant had obtained separate ration card prior to the death of
the deceased employee and is living separately maintaining
separate mess. It is further evident that inspite the petitioner
was figured at serial no. 15 and was considered for being
appointed under the scheme but on several persuasions and
correspondences made by the respondents, the appellant failed
Page 7
to submit his ration card, which implies the laches on the part of
the appellant. It is not disputed that the appellant had been
maintaining separate messing prior to the death of the deceased
employee by obtaining separate ration card. Thus, the appellant
cannot come under the purview of the term ‘family’.
11. This court is of the prima facie view that the compassionate
appointment
is
only
a
support
that
is
extended
by
the
government under the scheme of the policy to see that the policy
does not suffer any hardship and since there is an inordinate
delay, in the light of the findings rendered in The State of West
Bengal (supra), the petitioner is not entitled to claim any relief.
In view of the delay, whether it happens on the point of the
petitioner or the respondent, this court further point out that
when the death has taken place in the year 2012 and the
petitioner makes his application in the year 2013, till 2021, the
petitioner has not moved this court seeking mandamus. Delay or
laches is a relevant factor for a court of law to determine the
question as to whether the claim made by an petitioner deserves
consideration because delay or laches on the part of a petitioner
may deprive him of the benefit which had been given to others
Further, on the point of dependency, the definition which is
explained in memo dated 19.05.2017, that married son if living
Page 8
separately is exempted from claiming dependency, the petitioner
is further barred from claiming the compassionate appointment.
12. In our ultimate analysis and for the above reasons, we do
not find any infirmity or irrationality
in the order dated
04.05.2022 passed by a learned single Judge of this court in
W.P(C) 642 of 2021, and thus, we refrain from interfering with
the order passed by the learned Single Judge. Hence, there is no
substance in this Appeal, the same is, therefore, dismissed.
Interim application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Saikat
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review