The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
32. Consequently, the LA Collector could not have sought for return of the reference through his letter dt.24.08.2022, and the said request could not have been accepted by the LA Judge, South Tripura, Belonia on 28.03.2023 stating that the reference had been sought by the petitioners beyond the period of limitation prescribed under proviso to Section 18(2) of the Act.
33. Therefore, the order dt.28.03.2023 in CM (LA) 03 of 2022 of the learned LA Judge, South Tripura, Belonia, is set aside, and the LA Collector, South Tripura, Belonia is directed to re-submit the reference to the said Court, and the said Court shall proceed to decide the same in accordance with law.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No.12 of 2026
1. Sri Durga Sankar Majumder, Son of Late Dwijendra Lal Majumder, of
Amla Para, PO and PS - Belonia, South Tripura, PIN-799155
2. Sri Shib Sankar Majumder, Son of Late Dwijendra Lal Majumder, of Amla
Para, PO and PS - Belonia, South Tripura, PIN-799155
3. Smt Uma Majumder @ Uma Majumder Saha, D/o Lt. Dwijendra Lal
Majumder, W/o Sri Suku Saha, Resident of Shaltila, Belonia, PO and PS Belonia, District - South Tripura, PIN-799155
4. Smt Gouri Majumder, D/o Lt. Dwijendra Lal Majumder, W/o Sri Biplab
Majumder, Resident of 1 No. Tilla, Belonia, PO and PS - Belonia, District South Tripura, PIN-799155
.........Petitioner(s);
Versus
1. Land Acquisition Collector, South Tripura, D.M's Office, PO and PS Belonia, Dist - South Tripura, PIN-799155
2. The Director, Department of Industries & Commerce, Khejur Bagan, PO
and PS - N.C.C, Agartala, Dist - West Tripura, PIN-799010
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Suman Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Gautam, Sr. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
Order
27/03/2026
In this Revision, petitioners question order dt.28.03.2023 of the
learned LA Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in CM (LA) 03 of 2022.
2.
The mother of the petitioners, by name Smt. Manju Saha, was the
owner in possession of land measuring 2.09 acres situated in South Tripura
District, Sub-Division- Belonia, Mouja- Sarasima, pertaining to R.S. Khatian
No.1282, Hal Plot No.1554.
3.
She had purchased the same through a registered sale deed
dt.25.09.1978, and her name was also mutated in the Record of Rights.
4.
This land came to be acquired under the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short „the Act‟) by the State Government for setting up of Industrial
Infrastructure Development Centre at Mouja- Sarasima under Belonia subdivision.
5.
Notice in Form No.9 of the Act was issued to Smt. Manju Saha
by name Sri Hari Bhushan Saha and another Sri Nani Gopal Mallik, but no
notice was issued to the mother of the petitioners, or to the petitioners.
6.
The said notice was handed over by Sri Hari Bhushan Saha to
Smt. Manju Saha asking her to take steps to receive the awarded money before
the LA Collector.
7.
Smt. Manju Saha filed an application on 29.07.2009 with the LA
Collector, South Tripura, Udaipur mentioning that the said land was purchased
by her, but the Record of Rights was in the name of her vendor and that one
Nani Gopal Mallik, who was an employee of the Revenue Department had
illegally got entered his name in the Record of Rights, and she requested the
LA Collector, South Tripura, Udaipur to award the entire awarded money for
the acquired land to her.
8.
Thereafter the headquarters of the South Tripura District shifted
to Belonia, as erstwhile South Tripura District was divided into two districts,
namely South Tripura District and Gomati District, and Udaipur was declared
as the District town of Gomati District.
9.
Then Smt. Manju Saha again made an application on 04.03.2014
for release of the awarded amount to her.
10.
But by then on 24.08.2009 itself, award of Rs.8,26,116/- was
passed by the LA Collector, South Tripura in favour of Hari Bhushan Saha,
the vendor of Smt. Manju Saha, and the forcible occupier Sri Nani Gopal
Mallik, but no notice under Section 12(2) of the Act had been issued by the
LA Collector, South Tripura to Smt. Manju Saha in spite of her representing
on 29.07.2009 and making a claim for compensation to herself exclusively.
11.
Thereafter a reference under Section 30 of the Act was made by
the LA Collector as to whether Hari Bhushan Saha or Nani Gopal Mallik is to
be paid compensation. This was disposed of on 03.10.2018 in LA (Ref.)
40/2015 by the LA Judge, South Tripura, Belonia, and the entire amount of
compensation was awarded to the forcible occupier Sri Nani Gopal Mallik.
12.
Thereafter the petitioners preferred an appeal before this Court
being LA App. No.35/2019 contending that as successors of their late mother
Smt. Manju Saha, they should get the compensation and not either Hari
Bhushan Saha or Nani Gopal Mallik.
13.
This appeal was decided on 16.04.2021 by this Court stating that
the awarded compensation should be apportioned among Sri Hari Bhushan
Saha, the petitioners and Sri Nani Gopal Mallik in equal shares.
14.
Thereafter Sri Nani Gopal Mallik filed a review petition being
Review Petition No.34/2021 to review the judgment in LA App. No.35/2019,
which was disposed of on 06.01.2022, directing that the apportionment should
be made only between the petitioners and other respondent excluding Sri Hari
Bhushan Saha.
15.
Only thereafter notice was issued to the petitioners by the LA
Collector for payment of the said amount, and payment of Rs.4,13,058/- was
made to them on 17.02.2022.
16.
Just prior thereto, on 28.01.2022, the petitioners had filed a
petition under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 for enhancement
of compensation to the LA Collector, South Tripura.
17.
The said reference proposal was referred to the LA Judge, South
Tripura, Belonia on 28.04.2022 under Section 18 of the Act. This was
numbered as CM (LA) 03 of 2022.
18.
The other claimant Nani Gopal Mallik also filed a petition under
Section 18 of the Act on 16.07.2022 for enhancement of compensation.
19.
It appears that when the case was called before the LA Judge,
South Tripura, Belonia on 28.03.2023, the Government Pleader appearing for
the LA Collector, informed the Court that the LA Collector had addressed a
letter dt.24.08.2022 asking the Court to return the reference, as the reference
was made at the instance of the petitioners by oversight; and that according to
the State Government, the petition submitted before the LA Collector for
reference under Section 18 by the petitioners was beyond the limitation
period.
20.
Though the counsel for the petitioners objected to the same, the
Court below, by the impugned order dt.28.03.2023 in CM (LA) 03 of 2022,
accepted the request of the LA Collector, and returned the reference stating
that in its opinion, the request of the LA Collector was proper.
21.
Assailing the same, this Revision is filed.
22.
Counsel for the petitioners contends that the petitioners herein
had never been given notice under Section 12(2) of the Act by the LA
Collector, and only Sri Hari Bhushan Saha and Sri Nani Gopal Mallik, had
been given notice at the time of passing of the award.
23.
He therefore contends that the limitation for seeking a Section 18
reference provided for in the proviso to Section 18(2) of the Act does not
commence as against the petitioners till the Section 30 reference was decided,
and the LA Collector was therefore not correct in stating that the application
seeking reference under Section 18 made by the petitioners, was time barred
and beyond limitation.
24.
Reliance was also placed on a judgment of the Supreme Court in
Madan and Another v. State of Maharashtra1.
25.
The learned Senior Government Advocate for the respondents
does not dispute that no notice under Section 12(2) of the Act had been served
on the mother of the petitioners, or on the petitioners at any point of time.
26.
So the petitioners had no knowledge of the award dt.24.08.2009
passed by the LA Collector, South Tripura.
27.
The reference under Section 30 i.e. LA (Ref.) 40/2015 came to be
decided on 03.10.2018, but there was a challenge to it in LA App.
No.35/2019, which came to be decided only on 16.04.2021.
28.
Even thereafter there was an application to review it, being
Review Petition No.34/2021, which was finalized on 06.01.2022.
29.
The request for reference under Section 18 was sought by the
petitioners on 28.01.2022.
30.
In Madan and Another ( 1 supra ), like in the instant case, there
was no apportionment of compensation made by the Collector and he made
reference under Section 30 of the Act to the Civil Court and it was decided on
04.09.1991. Later the appellants sought reference under Section 18 of the Act
(2014) 2 SCC 720
which was decided by the Second Additional District Judge, Beed on
dt.29.10.1993. In the order dt.29.10.1993 passed by the said Court, it was
recorded that the appellants before the Supreme Court had no knowledge of
the award of the Collector till the order dt.04.09.1991 came to be passed in the
reference under Section 30 of the Act. But the High Court held that the
reference under Section 18 was time barred, and it set aside the order of the
Second Additional District Judge, Beed.
The Supreme Court disagreed with the High Court and held that
the words “from the date of the Collector’s award” used in the proviso to
Section 18, cannot be interpreted in a literal or mechanical way.
It held that for the first time on 04.09.1991 (the date of the order
under Section 30 of the Act), the appellants in that case had come to know that
they were entitled to compensation and the quantum thereof, and since the
reference under Section 18 was sought within six weeks from the said date, it
is not barred by limitation. It therefore set aside the judgment of the High
Court.
31.
Since Review Petition No.34/2021 was finalized on 06.01.2022
and the request for reference under Section 18 was sought by the petitioners
on 28.01.2022, it cannot be said to be barred by limitation. This is because it
was within the period of six weeks from the final decision in the Section 30
application, which had been rendered on 06.01.2022 and was well within the
six weeks time in proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 18 of the Act.
32.
Consequently, the LA Collector could not have sought for return
of the reference through his letter dt.24.08.2022, and the said request could not
have been accepted by the LA Judge, South Tripura, Belonia on 28.03.2023
stating that the reference had been sought by the petitioners beyond the period
of limitation prescribed under proviso to Section 18(2) of the Act.
33.
Therefore, the order dt.28.03.2023 in CM (LA) 03 of 2022 of the
learned LA Judge, South Tripura, Belonia, is set aside, and the LA Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia is directed to re-submit the reference to the said Court,
and the said Court shall proceed to decide the same in accordance with law.
34.
Since the case is an old case, the entire exercise shall be
completed by the Court below within six months from the date of receipt of
copy of this Order. No costs.
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
Pijush/
signed by PIJUSH KANTI NAG
PIJUSH KANTI NAG Digitally
Date: 2026.03.30 15:18:01 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review