Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC040004322025
2026:GAU-AP:924
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/118/2025
Shri Biri Taha and 3 Ors
Son of Late Biri Tai, permanent resident of Village Rakso, PO and PS Palin, Kra
Daadi District, Arunachal Pradesh and place of posting Sangram, Po and PS Sangram,
Kurung Kumey District, Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Khamjat Ajang
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Jaho Ajang
permanent resident of Wasathong Village
PO and PS Deomali
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh and presently post as Circle Officer
Longding
PO and PS Longding
Longding District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Smti Jyoti Borang
Age:
Occupation :
Daughter of Late Apel Borang
permanent resident of Village Ngorlung
PO and PS Ruksin
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh and post as Circle Officer
O/o ADC Ruksin
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Nabam Tarang
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Nabam Taya
Circle Officer cum I/C SDO
Page No.# 2/15
Dollungmukh
Kamle District
Arunachal Pradesh
VERSUS
The State of AP and Anr
represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
2:The Commissioner/ Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Personnel
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
Duggong
: Nikita Danggen, Nani Kuru,Honi Tana Tara,Karmu Chotton,Oken
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP),
Advocate for the Petitioners
: Ms. N. Danggen, Adv.
Advocate for the respondents
: Mr. S. Tapin, Sr. Govt. Adv.
Date on which judgment was reserved
Date of pronouncement of judgment
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: 14.09.2026.
: 21.09.2026
: NA
: Yes
- BEFORETHE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners and Mr. S. Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate
Page No.# 3/15
representing the respondents.
2.
The instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioners being
aggrieved by non-consideration of their cases for giving retrospective
effect to the petitioners’ appointment as APCS (Entry Grade) (Circle
Officer) w.e.f. 29.06.2017 at par with other similarly situated officers.
3.
The petitioners’ case is that they were amongst 18 candidates
shortlisted for facing interview for recruitment to the post of APCS
(Entry Grade), otherwise known as Circle Officer in the Arunachal
Pradesh Civil Service in the year, 2017. The recruitment process was
initiated for Lateral Entry of Arunachal Pradesh Civil Services (Entry
Grade) in terms of Rule 5 (1) (b) of the Arunachal Pradesh Civil
Service Rule, 2006. Amongst 21 candidates, 18 candidates were
shortlisted which included the petitioners. The petitioners after being
shortlisted and after various scrutiny procedures were called for
interview/ viva-voce. The recruitment process which commenced on
13.08.2014 was going on for a long time and on 03.03.2017, a date
was fixed for interview/viva voce. When they arrived for appearing in
the interview/viva voce, they were informed about the Office
Memorandum dated 28.02.2017 (formally issued on 02.03.2017). By
the aforesaid Office Memorandum, the cut off marks of 45% was
introduced for the interview/viva voce.
4.
In terms of the Office Memorandum, the petitioners were not
selected for the post of Circle Officer in the aforesaid lateral entry
recruitment process. Being highly aggrieved by the aforesaid non-
Page No.# 4/15
selection, the petitioners filed a writ petition which was numbered
and registered as WP (C) 241 (AP) 2017 on the ground that the said
Office Memorandum was illegal and it is a settled position of law that
‘Rules of the game cannot be changed after the game has started ’’.
The Office Memorandum was also challenged on the ground that the
same was in conflict with the recruitment Rules holding the field and
the said Rules do not give any discretion to the selection committee
to prescribe any cut off marks for the interview/viva voce.
5.
After due consideration of the aforesaid writ petition, vide
judgment and order dated 05.04.2019, the Hon’ble High Court had
allowed the writ petition and a direction was issued to the respondent
authorities to consider the cases of the petitioners for appointment to
the post of APCS (Entry Grade) (Lateral Entry) without insisting on
the cut off marks in the interview/ viva voce and based upon their
performance, make the recruitment as per merit and in accordance
with law.
6.
The State of Arunachal Pradesh had challenged the aforesaid
judgment and order dated 05.04.2019 passed in WP (C) 241 (AP)
2017, vide Writ Appeal No. 204/2020 and the same was dismissed by
the Hon’ble Division Bench of the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court, vide
judgment and order dated 12.02.2021, which had affirmed the
judgment and order dated 05.04.2019 passed by the learned Single
Judge of this Court passed in WP (C) 241 (AP) 2017. Consequently, in
compliance of the aforesaid judgment and order dated 05.04.2019,
the petitioners were appointed to the post of Circle Officer, vide
Page No.# 5/15
separate
orders
12/1/2021/744,
i.e.
order
No.
PERS-12/1/2021/745,
PERS-12/1/2021/746
and
PERS-
PERS-12/1/2021/747
respectively. However, since the petitioners were not given any
notional appointment at par with the other candidates selected in the
year, 2017, on 06.12.2021, the petitioners submitted a joint
representation to the respondent authorities requesting that their
appointments should be given retrospective effect at par with
similarly situated officers who were appointed in the same
recruitment process in 2017. The same was not responded to by the
respondent authorities and therefore, another joint representation
was submitted in the year, 2022 reiterating the same request. The
respondent
authorities
did
not
respond
to
both
the
joint
representations submitted by the petitioners.
7.
The Department of Personnel, Government of Arunachal Pradesh
issued a Memorandum, i.e., Memo No.-PERS-12/1/ 1/2024 dated
Itanagar the 28th August, 2024, whereby, a provisional inter-seseniority list of APCS officers was published. In the said list, the
petitioners were placed below the Circle Officers appointed in the
year, 2017, their date of appointment was mentioned as 16.11.2021.
It is also stated that the petitioners were, however, placed above and
ranked senior to those officers appointed in 2020. The petitioners
filed another joint representation dated 24.02.2025 before the
respondent authorities praying for immediate redressal of their
grievances and the confusion that has been created in the seniority
list. However, since the same was also not responded to, the
Page No.# 6/15
petitioners have approached this Court by filing the instant writ
petition.
8.
It is sated that the next higher promotional post for APCS (Entry
Grade) is the APCS (Senior Grade) under Rule 25 of the Arunachal
Pradesh Civil Service Rules, 2006. An officer in the APCS (Entry
Grade) shall have to have a minimum of 5 years of service in the
grade to be eligible for promotion to the APCS (Senior Grade). It is
stated that some vacant posts for promotion to APCS (Senior Grade)
are existing in the Department and therefore, the Department of
Personnel, Government of Arunachal Pradesh is in the process of
giving promotions to eligible officers. It is stated that for the aforesaid
purpose, a communication No.PERS-32012/2/2021 dated Itanagar the
5th February, 2025 has been issued and the petitioners along with
other officers who are in the zone of consideration have been directed
to obtain No Objection Certificates (for short, ‘NOC’) from work place
and Home town along with details of posting of places for obtaining
vigilance clearance at the earliest. Accordingly, when the petitioners
tried to submit their NOCs, the Department of Personnel informed
them verbally that their cases for promotion would not be considered
as they have not fulfilled the eligibility criterion of 5 years of service in
the post of APCS (Entry Grade) as per the recruitment rules.
Accordingly, the petitioners were advised not to submit their NOCs.
9.
Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
submits that due to anomaly in the seniority list, it is quite possible
Page No.# 7/15
that later on those officers appointed in the year, 2020 would object
to the petitioners’ promotions (if and when granted) as their
appointments to the posts of circle officers are entered as 16.11.2021
whereas the direct recruits were appointed in the year, 2020. It is
submitted that due to fault of the respondent authorities, the
petitioners were not appointed in the year, 2017 along with other
similarly placed officers. She submits that since the petitioners had to
be appointed in the year, 2021 due to the fault of the respondent
authorities and similarly placed officers who have been recruited
under the same process had been appointed in the year, 2017, the
petitioners should be also given notional appointments on the same
date as those officers appointed in the year, 2017. She submits that
their appointments were delayed due to the filing of the writ petition
by the petitioners and thereafter, the Writ Appeal by the State, which
consumed about
4 (four) years and thereby, delayed their
appointments to the post of APCS (Entry Grade). She submits that the
petitioners should have been given notional appointments from the
date of appointment of other similarly placed officers.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioners has referred to the final
inter-se-seniority list of Arunachal Pradesh Civil Service Officers as on
08.07.2025, the same is placed before this Court and the same is
marked as ‘X’ and kept on record. The forwarding letter dated
09.07.2025, wherein, the final inter se-seniority list has been annexed
reveals that the date of appointment of the petitioners’ have been
kept as same, i.e., in the year 2021. She submits that though the
Page No.# 8/15
petitioners are not eligible for any salary for the period from 2017 to
2021, however, the petitioners are eligible to be given notional
appointments in the year, 2017 which will put them at par with the
other selected candidates who were appointed in the year, 2017. She
submits that the law permits such notional appointment in the event
a person is illegally not promoted due to the reasons not attributed to
the person and subsequently, the person is promoted in a later date.
She submits that in such cases notional appointment should be made
on the date when others were appointed from the same selection
process. In support of her case, the learned counsel has referred to
the case of C. Jayachandran-vs-State of Kerala and Others;
reported in (2020) 5 SCC 230, wherein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that a direct recruit whose appointment is held for no fault on his
part due to the latches on the part of the Department, cannot be
denied retrospective effect to his appointment when the other
candidates faced the same selection process were appointed on an
earlier date.
11. On the other hand, the learned Sr. Govt. Advocate, Mr. S. Tapin
appearing for the State submits that the petitioners were appointed in
compliance of the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court’s order in WA No.
204/2020 dated 12.02.2021, vide order No. PERS-12/1/2021 dated
16.11.2021. He further submits that for promotion of APCS (Entry
Grade) to APCS (Senior Grade) a minimum of 5 years of regular
service in the grade is required in terms of Schedule-II (5) of APCS
Rules, 2018. He submits that since the petitioners joined their duties
Page No.# 9/15
only in 2021, their services can only be counted from 2021 and
therefore, there is no question of counting their service from 2017 as
they did not perform their duties. He submits that since the
petitioners have been appointed only in 2021, they cannot be given
any retrospective appointment from 2017. He submits that since they
were not borne in the cadre in 2017 but only in 2021, their seniorities
have to be counted from 2021 only. He further submits that the
petitioners are going to complete 5 years in November, 2026 and
therefore, their cases would also be in consideration for promotion to
the next higher post of APCS (Senior Grade) when they complete 5
years in service in APCS (Entry Grade) in November, 2026. In support
of his submission, the learned Senior Government Advocate submits
that the petitioners were not borne in the year, 2017 and since they
have been appointed only in 2021, their seniorities have to be
counted
from
2021,
he
has
referred
to
the
case
of
K.
Meghachandra Singh and Others-vs-Ningam Siro and Others;
reported in (2020) 5 SCC 689, wherein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that the under the service jurisprudence, seniority cannot be
claimed from a date when the incumbent is yet to be borne in the
cadre.
12.
It is seen from the above that in terms of the aforesaid
recruitment process for Lateral Entry of Arunachal Pradesh Civil
Service (Entry Grade), 21 candidates applied for the post of APCS
(Entry Grade) (Circle Officer), however, 18 candidates were shortlisted
including the petitioners. It is seen that the recruitment process
Page No.# 10/15
commenced on 13.08.2014 and on 03.03.2017, the date was fixed for
interview/viva
voce.
However,
though
recruitment
process
commenced on 13.08.2014, wherein, no criteria of minimum 45% cut
off marks in the interview/viva voce was mentioned, the respondent
authorities, vide Office Memorandum No. PERS-44/2017 dated
Itanagar the 5th February, 2017 laid down the conditions that
candidates who failed to secure a minimum of 45% marks in the
interview/viva voce, they will not be considered by the Department.
The aforesaid Office Memorandum came to be challenged by the
petitioners as due to introduction of the minimum cut off marks in the
interview/viva voce, the petitioners were not selected. After hearing
of the aforesaid writ petition, the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court, vide its
judgment and order dated 05.04.2019 allowed the writ petition with
the following directions:“23. In viewof the aforesaid discussions and after perusal of the materials on record including the
original files produced, this Court is of the opinion that this writ petition is liable to be allowed.
Accordingly, the Office Memorandum dated 28.02.2017 (issued on 02.03.2017) is set aside. As the
learned counsel for the petitioners had taken a specific stand not to disturb the selection of the
private respondents, their selection is not interfered with. Consequently, the cases of the
petitioners for appointment to the post of APCS (EG) Lateral Entry be considered without insisting
on the cut off marks in the Viva-voce and based upon their performance, make the recruitments as
per merit and in accordance with law. The aforesaid exercise is directed to be undertaken and
complete within an outer limit of 2 (two) months fromtoday”.
13.
The aforesaid judgment of the learned Single Judge was
challenged by the State of Arunachal Pradesh by filing Writ Appeal
being WA No. 204/2020 before the Division Bench of the Hon’ble
Page No.# 11/15
Gauhati High Court. The Hon’ble Division Bench, vide its judgment
and order dated 12.02.2021 dismissed the Writ Appeal with the
following observations:“9. We are of considered view therefore that the findings recorded by the learned Single Judge in
the writ petition are liable to be affirmed. The Office Memorandum dated 28.02.2017 (issued on
02.03.2017) was liable to be quashed and set aside as it has rightly been done. The learned Single
Judge has not interfered with the selection of candidates. As it has already been stated above,
there were in total 19 vacancies, and 18 candidates, out of which 14 have already been selected.
The ones who have not been selected were before the learned Single Judge and are also before us
(as respondents in the present writ appeal), these private respondents have now to be given
appointment on the remaining vacancies as has been already directed by the learned Single Judge.
An order which we affirm”.
14.
Now, the only question which remains to be answered is
whether though the petitioners were appointed in the year, 2021,
they should have been given notional appointments in the year, 2017
as other 14 candidates who also took part in the said selection
process, have been appointed in the year, 2017, due to the fact that
the delay in appointments occurred due to reasons attributable to the
respondent authorities and not for any fault or latches on the part of
the petitioners.
15. In the case of C. Jayachandran (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court while considering a similar issue has observed as follows:“35. The earlier writ petition filed by the appellant was allowed on 13-9-2010. The Division Bench of
the High Court has directed to re-cast the seniority amongst the seven shortlisted candidates. The
appellant was one of them. The challenge to the said order by three affected candidates remained
unsuccessful when SLP was dismissed by this Court on 8-10-20107. The SLP was filed by the
Page No.# 12/15
candidates who were granted benefit of moderation of marks. Once the direction of the Division
Bench has attained finality, the appellant was entitled to seniority as per the select list to be
revised as per merit of the candidates. In terms of Rule 6(2), the seniority is to be determined the
serial order in which the name appeared in the appointment order. The argument of the learned
counsel appearing for Respondent 5 that the appellant was not appointed by the same appointment
order, therefore, the appellant cannot claimseniority is not tenable. The appellant was entitled to
be appointed along with other three candidates but because of the action of the High Court in
adopting moderation of marks, the appellant was excluded from appointment. The exclusion of
appellant fromappointment was on account of an illegal act by the High Court which has been so
found by the judgment dated 13-9-2010. Since the select list has to be revised, the appellant would
be deemed tobe the part of the appointment along with other candidates in the same select list. As
the actual date of appointment was on 24-2-2011, the appellant cannot actually be treated to be
appointed on 30-3-2009 but is entitled to notional appointment from that date and consequential
seniority”.
“36. In Sanjay Dhar, a three-Judge Bench of this Court held as under: (SCCp. 191, para 16)
"16. For the foregoing reasons the appeal is allowed. The judgment under appeal is set aside. It is
directed that the appellant shall be deemed to have been appointed along with other appointees
under the appointment order dated 6-3-1995 and assigned a place of seniority consistently with his
placement in the order of merit in the select list prepared by J&K PSC and later forwarded to the
LawDepartment".
37. In Lakshmana RaoYadavalli, this Court held as under: (SCCp. 397. para 13)
"13. For the reasons recorded in Lakshmana Rao Yadavalli v. State of A.P.18, the present appeals
are allowed and it is directed that the High Court as well as the respondent State will do the
needful for giving appointment to the appellant with retrospective effect i.e. from the date on
which she ought to have been appointed, however, she shall not be paid salary for the period
during which she has not worked as a District and Sessions Judge. We are sure that the
respondents will dothe needful for the appointment of the appellant at an early date".
“38. In viewof the above, the appellant having been participated in the same selection process and
in viewof the direction of the Division Bench of the High Court, was rightly placed by the High Court
by giving him revised select list placing him at Sl. No. 41 by pushing Badharudeen from general
category candidate to OBCcategory candidate at Sl. No. 42”.
Page No.# 13/15
“39. The appellant was wrongfully excluded from the process of f appointment on account of an
illegal and arbitrary grant of moderation of marks. The Government in its Order dated 22-12-2010
cancelled the appointment of three District and Sessions Judges who were granted benefit of
moderation. Badharudeen was earlier assigned general category seat but since the appellant was
higher in merit, Badharudeen was pushed down and adjusted against OBC category seat at Sl. No.
42. Badharudeen has not challenged his pushing down at Sl. No. 42 either before the learned Single
Bench of the High Court or before the Division Bench of the High Court or even before this Court.
Therefore, as respondent, he cannot be permitted to dispute the grant of seniority to the appellant
at Sl. No. 41. The judgment referred to by the learned counsel is not helpful tothe arguments raised
as the appellant therein sought seniority as direct recruit from the time when the vacancies
occurred. To raise such an argument, reliance was placed upon judgment of this Court reported in
Union of India v. N.R., wherein this Court held that a person is disentitled to claimseniority fromthe
date he was not borne in the service. The said finding is in the context of the claimof the appellant
to claim seniority from the date of availability of the vacancies; whereas in the present case, the
appellant is claiming seniority from the date the other candidates in the same selection process
were appointed but the appellant is excluded on account of an illegal act of the High Court of the
moderation of marks. Therefore, the said judgment is not of any help tothe arguments raised”.
16.
From the above observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
what transpires is that it is an established principle of service
jurisprudence that a person cannot be made to suffer due to fault or
causes or latches on the part of someone else. The principles of
fairness dictates that a candidate who has successfully cleared the
selection process and his appointment has been delayed or held
solely due to certain false or administrative latches of the appointing
authority, he/she cannot be made to suffer due to such fault or
administrative latches. If the candidates in the same selection process
have been appointed earlier and due to certain latches or fault non
attributable to the candidates aggrieved and he is appointed at a later
Page No.# 14/15
stage, the appointing authority cannot take advantage of its own
default and deny him the retrospective effect to his appointment from
the date on which the other candidates, who have been already
appointed/ selected, vide the same selection process. Therefore, it is
discernible from the above that in the instant case also since the
petitioners have been appointed in a delayed manner due to no fault
of theirs and similarly situated candidates who have appeared in the
same selection process, have been appointed in the year, 2017 only,
there is no bar or any hindrance for recognizing their appointments
with retrospective effect in a notional manner from the date on which
the other candidates have been appointed in 2017.
17. This Court has also considered the case of K. Meghachandra
Singh (supra). However, the ratio laid down in the case of K.
Meghachandra Singh (supra) cannot be made applicable to the
instant case as the issue before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of K. Meghachandra Singh (supra) is distinguishable from the
issued involved in the instant case, since in the present case, the
petitioners are claiming seniorities from the date, the other
candidates in the same selection process were appointed but the
petitioners were excluded on account of reasons attributable to the
appointing authorities.
18.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, this Court is of the
considered view that the instant writ petition deserves to be allowed.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands allowed and disposed of
with the following directions:
Page No.# 15/15
(i) The petitioners shall be deemed to have been appointed as APCS (Entry Grade)
(Circle Officer) w.e.f. June, 2017, in the month, wherein, the other selected
candidates were appointed;
(ii) The appointment of the petitioners’ w.e.f. the month of June, 2017 till their actual
appointments on 16.11.2021 shall be notional and they shall not be entitled to any
monetary benefits. However, the petitioners shall be entitled to all other service
benefits as well as consideration for promotion to the next higher post i.e. APCS
(Senior Grade); and
(iii) The aforesaid exercise is directed to be undertaken and completed within an
outer limit of 2 (two) months fromthe date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
19. In the aforesaid terms, the instant writ petition is disposed of, as
allowed.
20. No order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Digitally signed
by TAGE BUNYI
Date:
2026.09.21
17:50:27
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review