Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA NO.34 OF 2019
1. Shri Biplab Bikash Ghosh,
S/O Lt. Bilash Ch. Ghosh
2. Shri Bidit Chandra Ghosh
S/O Lt. Bilash Ch. Ghosh,
3. Smti. Bijali Ghosh
D/O Lt. Bilash Ch. Ghosh,
4. Smti. Sipra Ghosh
D/O Lt. Bilash Ch. Ghosh,
5. Smti. Banani Ghosh
D/O Lt. Bilash Ch. Ghosh,
6. Smti. Bijita Ghosh
D/O Lt. Bilash Ch. Ghosh.
All residents of Hari Mandir Road, P.O. & P.S. Dharmanagar, District - North Tripura.
……….. Defendant-Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Shri Brajagopal Saha Banik @ Brajagopal Banik,
S/O Lt. Sadhan Lal Saha Banik of Rajbari(near Golden
Valley School), P.S.-Dharmanagar, District - North
Tripura.
2. Shri Madangopal Saha Banik,
S/O Lt. Sadhan Lal Saha Banik,
3. Shri Kanailal Saha Banik,
S/O Lt. Sadhan Lal Saha Banik.
4. (a) Smti. Jaya Rani Saha Banik,
W/O Lt. Balaichand Saha Banik.
Respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4(a) are residents of Central
Road, P.O. & P.S.-Dharmanagar, District-North Tripura.
4. (b) Shri Biswajit Saha Banik,
S/O Lt. Balaichand Saha Banik, resident of Central
Road, P.S.-Dharmanagar, District-North Tripura.
4. (c) Smti Priyanka Saha Banik,
D/o Lt. Balaichand Saha Banik, resident of Central
Road, P.S.-Dharmanagar, District-North Tripura.
5. Smti Kalpana Banik,
W/o Late Priyonath Banik, resident of Rajbari(near
6.
7.
Golden Valley School), P.S.-Dharmanagar, DistrictNorth Tripura.
Smti. Kalyani Banik,
W/o Shri Manoranjan Banik, resident of Durlabcherra,
P.O.-Durlabcherra, P.S.-Ratabari, District-Karimganj.
Smti. Dipali Kairi,
W/o Shri Chakra Sudharshan Kairi, resident of
Aashram Chowmuhuni, Dhaleswar, P.S.-Agartala,
District - West Tripura.
……….. Plaintiff-respondent(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
For appellant(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
None
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment & order
:
18.01.2022
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for
the appellants. None appears for the respondents despite
repeated calls.
2.
This second appeal has been preferred by the
original defendants against the judgment and decree dated
04.02.2019 passed by learned District Judge, North Tripura
Judicial District, Dharmanagar in connection with Title Appeal
No.10 of 2013, wherein the learned first Appellate Court had
confirmed and upheld the judgment dated 24.04.2013 and
decree
dated
06.05.2013
passed
by
the
learned
Civil
Judge(Junior Division), Dharmanagar, North Tripura District in
Title Suit No.21 of 2001.
3.
By way of instituting the present suit, the plaintiffs,
i.e. the present respondents, had prayed for granting declaration
of right, title and interest of the plaintiff in the suit land
scheduled below and directing that the plaintiffs doth recover
possession thereof by evicting the defendants therefrom and by
demolition and removal of all obstructions created therein
including any feature wall, etc. and directing further that the
plaintiffs doth recover from the defendants, the cost of such
removal and demolition of obstructions.
4.
The facts of the case as projected by the learned
first Appellate Court may be reproduced here-in-below:
“4. The brief fact of the case of the Respondent
/Plaintiff before the Ld. Court below in TS-21/2001was
that the lands of registered Kabala (sale deeds) dated
10-05-1961, 10-05-1961, 12-05-1961 and 06-06-1961
was owned and possessed by the plaintiff by way of
purchase and the same was recorded in the khatiyan in
her name. That the plaintiff has / had pucca building
within aforesaid purchased land having its windows on
the east walls. That, on and from 28-08-1984 the
defendant illegally dispossessed the plaintiff from some
portion of the aforesaid purchased land and prepared
to raise pucca wall therein. Then, the plaintiff sued the
defendant by filling suit bearing No. TS. 20/1984
praying
recovery
obstruction
and
of
possession
declaration
of
on
removable
title
to
the
of
land
dispossessed. The suit was decreed in favor of the
plaintiff with a direction to break down and remove the
wall portion. The defendant then preferred an appeal
bearing No. TA-8/1989 against the decree of TS20/1984 and it was dismissed with some modification
in favor of the plaintiff /respondent and then the
defendant again preferred second appeal before the
Honorable High Court vide SA-11/1990 wherein the
decision of the 1st Appellate court was confirmed.
Thereafter, vide Execution case bearing No. Ext.(T)7/
1990, the plaintiff secured recovery of possession of
the decrial land of TS-20/1984 on 15-07-2001 through
survey knowing man.
5. That, during pendency of the aforesaid suit bearing
no. TS-20/1984 of the plaintiff, the defendant extended
his wall from 36 feet to 43 feet in length running
south-north and thereby encroached to the land i. e.,
suit land of the plaintiff illegally. The suit land of the
plaintiff situates at contiguous south of the decreed
land of suit bearing No.TS-20/1984 and the suit land
and the decreed land of TS-20/1984 are collinear with
small curvature running north-south, and on the
contiguous east of the suit land and the decreed land
of TS-20/1984 situates the land of defendant as of the
homestead having its separate plot number.
6. On the other hand, the case of the defendant
(present appellant) before the Ld. Court below was that
the plaintiff has no right, title and interest and
possession
over
the
present
suit
land.
Rather,
defendant owns and has been possessed the suit land
since January, 1930 within the knowledge of the
plaintiff and world at large. Further is has been
contended that the plaintiff had filed his suit bearing
No. TS-20/1984 for declaration of title and recovery of
possession and it was decreed and the decreed was
modified in the appeal and then the same was
confirmed in the second appeal by the Honorable High
Court where in the disputed wall over the disputed land
was measuring 43 feet in length and 9/10 „‟ in length,
accordingly, it was vide Execution case bearing No.
Ext.(T) 7/ 1990 was handed over but actually the
defendant was evicted from the land measuring 82 feet
in length, thus, execution was done beyond the decree
for which defendant filed separate case for restitution
of the land. The plaintiff has no right, title and interest
and possession over the suit land.”
5.
On the basis of the aforesaid facts, the following
issues were framed:
(i) Is the suit maintainable in its present form?
(ii) Is there any cause of action for filing of the suit?
(iii) Whether the suit barred by the law of limitation?
(iv) Whether the plaintiff has the right, title and
interest in the suit land?
(v) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get the decree of
recovery of possession of the suit land by evicting the
defendants there from and by demolishing and removal
of the constructions raised by the defendants therein
with their costs?
(vi) Whether the parties are entitled to get any relief /
relieve?
6.
The plaintiff-respondents had examined as many as
three witnesses and proved total thirteen documents. On the
other
hand,
the
defendant-appellants
had
produced
two
witnesses and proved three documents.
7.
The learned trial Court after hearing the parties and
considering the evidence, both ocular and documentary, decreed
the suit declaring the right, title and interest of the plaintiffrespondents(here-in-after referred to as plaintiffs) over the suit
land and also for recovery of possession of the same evicting the
defendant-appellants
constructions
thereon
and
at
removing/demolishing
the
cost
of
the
all
the
defendant-
appellants(here-in-after referred to as the defendants).
8.
Being
aggrieved,
the
defendant-appellants
have
preferred the instant appeal before this Court.
9.
The
defendants
have
raised
the
question
of
maintainability of the suit on the ground of limitation. While
dealing with the said issue, the learned first Appellate Court had
observed thus:
“15. Be that what it may, coming to the question of
limitation of the suit, it is as per Art. 65 of the
Limitation Act, in a suit based on title even if
dispossession is alleged, the defendant can succeed
only if he can prove that his possession has become
adverse to the plaintiff beyond 12 years of the suit. In
such case, the plaintiff needs to prove only his title and
he need not show that he was in possession within 12
years of the suit. Now, let us consider as to whether
the plaintiff/respondent in the case could prove her
title over the suit property or not. Sale deeds Ext. 1, 2,
and
4,
Judgment
in
TS-20/1984
Ext.
10,
Commissioner Reports dated 12-08-1995 and 2001-1989 Ext. 11 and 12 proves that plaintiff has his
rights, title and interest over the suit land. Finally
published Khatiyan 261 Ext. 5 even proves that plaintiff
had possessed the suit land at the time of settlement
and continued thereof both forward and backward.
Defendant / appellant claims that he has been owning
and possessing the suit land since January, 1930 within
the knowledge of the plaintiff and the world at large. I
notice that defendant though claims that the suit land
has been possessed by him since the year 1930 but in
that event he shows the description of the land
differently inasmuch as he claims land of C. S. Plot no.
6770 and C.S. Plot no. 6086 under khatiyan no. 3048.
But, the suit land of the plaintiff / respondent falls
within C. S. Plot No. 6088 and old C. S. Plot no. 6089,
new C. S. Plot no. 6957 under earlier Khatiyan No.
2746 present Khatiyan No. 261. It indicates that the
suit land of the plaintiff is not claimed by the defendant
at all. Be that what it may, it is settled law that a
person
who
claims
title
to
property
by
adverse
possession must definitely allege and prove as to how
and when the adverse possession commenced and
what the nature of his possession was and whether the
fact of the adverse possession was known to the real
owner. What the law requires in the case of claiming
adverse title is that the possession should be hostile
under a claim or color of title. It should be actual,
open, uninterrupted, notorious, exclusive, continuous,
and for a statutory period of 12 years and presence of
these all elements converts the adverse possession into
title. But, in the case the defendant has pleaded
nothing as to who was the real owner of the land and
how he commenced possession and what was his
nature of possession etc. He even could prove nothing
documentary evidence as to his possession and its
nature
etc.
In
the
event
he
could
prove
all
elements of adverse possession yet while coming to
the question of description of suit land it finds that the
land claimed by the defendant is not the suit land
claimed by the plaintiff. Plaintiff case is that defendant
dispossessed her from the suit land gradually from
the period beginning the last part of the year 1985
extending up to January 1991 which indicates that the
dispossession was done by January, 1991. The suit of
the plaintiff was filed on 28-11-2001 which was well
within 12 years of her so called dispossession. Thus,
even if the suit land and the land claimed by the
defendant be same yet it is found that the plaintiff
brought
her
suit
well
within
years
of
her
dispossession. Thus, it can be said that the suit of the
plaintiff was not barred by the law of limitation.
16. What has been discussed above it concludes that
the suit of the plaintiff was not barred by the law of
limitation and the plaintiff could prove her right, title
and interest in the suit land. I find in the facts and
circumstances of the case the Ld. Court below has
decided the issue nos. (iii), (iv) and (v) of the suit
legally and properly.”
10.
At the time of admission of the appeal, the following
substantial question of law has been formulated:
“(1)
Whether
the
present
appeal
is
barred
by
constructive res judicata in absence of any fresh cause
of action?”
Thereafter, on the basis of an application filed by the
appellants, the Court again had formulated the below noted
substantial questions of law:
“(i) Whether the civil court as well as the appellate
court have omitted the issue of res-judicata in absence
of a fresh cause of action related to the suit and
whether
such
omission
renders
the
impugned
judgment unsustainable?
(ii) Whether the observation of the first appellate court
that the suit was within the limitation is perverse for
not being founded on material fact?”
11.
In support of the above substantial questions of law,
Mr. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the appellants has tried
to persuade this Court that from the plaint itself it reveals that
the suit instituted by the plaintiffs is barred by the principle of
res judicata. Mr. Datta, learned counsel has invited my attention
to the statement made by the plaintiff in his plaint that the
construction of wall over the suit land, i.e. the land under C.S.
Plot No.6088 was started in the year 1985 and this fact was
noticed by the plaintiff in the year 1990 from the judgment
dated 20.01.1990 passed by the learned first Appellate Court in
Title Appeal No.8 of 1989. Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the
appellants has further submitted that against the judgment
passed by the first Appellate Court in TA No.8 of 1989, the
defendants of the present case had preferred second appeal and
that second appeal was also dismissed under the judgment
dated 01.08.1997(SA No.11/90). Learned counsel has further
submitted that this fact of construction of wall was noticed by
the plaintiff during the pendency of the second appeal of the
previously instituted suit, but, the plaintiff did not think it
necessary to bring the aforesaid facts into record by way of
amendment, and in the year 2001, the plaintiffs filed the instant
suit for further direction for declaration of right, title and interest
over the suit land under CS Plot No.6088.
12.
In view of the above submissions, I have gone
through the written statement filed by the defendants, i.e. the
appellants of the present appeal. After perusal, I do not find any
such averment made by the defendants as to how the present
suit is barred by constructive res judicata or res judicata. He
could not place any material before this Court to substantiate
that the dispute raised in the present suit was also subject
matter of the previous suit. As such, I do not find any merit in
the submission of learned counsel, Mr. Datta. As such, in
absence of any material, in my opinion, it will not be proper to
hold that the present suit is barred by the doctrine of res
judicata or constructive res judicata.
Furthermore, it comes to light that the right, title
and interest of the plaintiff over the CS Plot No.6088 have been
confirmed by both the learned Courts below. During the
pendency of the first appeal, on an application, the first
Appellate Court directed to measure the suit land by appointing
a Survey Commissioner. The Survey Commissioner after making
a survey over the suit land submitted his report stating inter alia
that the wall has been constructed by the defendants over the
land comprising CS Plot No.6088 over which the plaintiff has
acquired title. Both the learned Courts below held that the
plaintiff is the owner of the land comprising CS Plot No.6088.
During the pendency of the first appeal, the defendants did not
raise the issue of res judicata or constructive res judicata.
13.
For the reasons stated above, I am unable to hold
that the present suit is barred by res judicata. Accordingly, the
substantial questions of law as framed, whether the suit is
barred by res judicata or constructive res judicata is accordingly
answered.
14.
Now, coming to the question whether the suit is
barred by law of limitation, I find that the cause of action lastly
arose in the year 1997 and the suit was filed in the year 2001. A
suit of this nature has to be filed within twelve years in terms of
Article 65 of the Limitation Act, which is also admitted by Mr.
Datta, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the defendants. I
do not find any error of law in the findings of the learned first
Appellate Court regarding the issue of limitation. Even if, it is
seen that the plaintiff had got knowledge of the construction of
wall in the year 1990, then also, the period of limitation for
institution of the present suit is covered within the prescribed
period of limitation. Accordingly, the substantial question of law
formulated as to whether the suit is barred by limitation merits
no consideration.
15.
In the light of the above discussions, the present
appeal is devoid of merit and thus, dismissed. However, there
shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review