Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI
CRIMINAL PETITION No.10448 OF 2026
DATE: 23.07.2026
Between :
Shri Amir Mohammed Haq
… Petitioner/Accused
AND
The State of Telangana
Through Special Public Prosecutor P.S. GST
Commissionarate, Hyderabad
… Respondent.
ORDER
This Criminal Petition is filed under Section 482 of Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short, “BNSS”), seeking the relief
of pre-arrest bail.
2.
The petitioner is arrayed as Accused in connection with
summons issued under Section 13 of the Health Security & National
Security Cess Act, 2025 (for short “HSNS Act”).
3.
Heard Ms. Barkha Bhalla, learned Counsel for the petitioner and
Mr. D.S. Raghavender Rao, learned senior standing Counsel for CBIC
representing the respondent.
4.1.
The petitioner claims that he is engaged in the business of real
estate under the name and style of Cyber Towers and through Sanali
Housing Projects Private Limited, a duly incorporated company. It is
the petitioner's case that the summons issued by the Goods and
Services Tax (GST) authorities do not disclose the nature of the
allegations, the subject matter of the enquiry, or the specific documents
required to be produced. According to the petitioner, he has not been
shown as an accused in any disclosed offence, yet he has been
subjected to an enquiry, giving rise to a reasonable apprehension that
he may be arrested during the course of the investigation.
4.2.
The petitioner further submits that he is a permanent resident of
Hyderabad with well-established business interests. He contends that,
despite the absence of any disclosed incriminating material against
him, he apprehends arrest and other coercive action by the
investigating authorities. Consequently, the present petition has been
filed seeking the relief of anticipatory bail. The petitioner undertakes to
cooperate with the investigation and to abide by any conditions that
may be imposed by this Court.
4.3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the summons
issued by the GST authorities fail to disclose even the subject matter of
the enquiry or the alleged role of the petitioner, rendering the
proceedings vague and arbitrary. It is submitted that the petitioner is
innocent and has been unnecessarily implicated without there being
any disclosed incriminating material against him. It is further contended
that the summons do not specify the documents or information required
to be produced, thereby depriving the petitioner of an effective
opportunity to respond.
4.4.
According to the petitioner, although no offence has been
disclosed against him, the manner in which the summons have been
issued gives rise to a genuine apprehension that he may be arrested
during the course of the enquiry. Learned counsel further submits that
there is no likelihood of the petitioner absconding or evading the
process of law and that he is ready and willing to cooperate with the
investigating authorities. Emphasizing the petitioner's right to personal
liberty, learned counsel argues that custodial interrogation is wholly
unwarranted in the facts and circumstances of the case. It is, therefore,
submitted that the petitioner is entitled to the discretionary relief of
anticipatory bail, subject to such conditions as this Court may deem fit
to impose.
5.1.
Learned Standing Counsel for the Central Board of Indirect
Taxes and Customs (CBIC), appearing for the respondent, vehemently
opposed the grant of anticipatory bail, contending that the present
petition is devoid of merit and has been filed solely with a view to
obstruct the ongoing investigation into a case involving large-scale tax
evasion under the provisions of the HSNS Act.
5.2.
It is submitted that, acting upon specific intelligence, the Anti-
Evasion Wing unearthed an organized syndicate clandestinely
engaged in the manufacture of Kalakaar Pan Masala by using
unregistered packing machines without obtaining registration under the
HSNS Act and by evading payment of the statutory cess. It is further
submitted that coordinated searches conducted at the premises in
Hyderabad resulted in the seizure of four unregistered packing
machines, a huge quantity of pan masala, and substantial quantities of
raw materials and packing materials.
5.3.
According to the respondent, the investigation has, thus far,
disclosed evasion of HSNS cess amounting to approximately Rs.12
crores, constituting offences punishable under Section 19(1)(a) of the
HSNS Act, which are cognizable and non-bailable. It is further
submitted that a co-accused, in his statement, disclosed that the
petitioner was the mastermind, principal financier, and overall
supervisor of the clandestine manufacturing operations.
5.4.
The respondent further contends that the petitioner had
allegedly invested Rs.5 crores in the illegal business and that the
financial
records
and
bank
transactions
collected
during
the
investigation prima facie establish his financial involvement with the
syndicate. It is also pleaded that, despite the issuance of summons on
three occasions, the petitioner failed to appear before the investigating
authority, produced misleading medical certificates, and travelled to
Dubai during the relevant period with a view to evading the
investigation.
5.5.
It is, therefore, contended that custodial interrogation is required
for tracing the financial trail, identifying the beneficiaries of the illegal
transactions, examining the electronic and other tangible evidence,
ascertaining the petitioner's precise role in the conspiracy, and
unearthing the larger network involved in the commission of the
offences.
Learned
Standing Counsel further submits that
the
investigation is at a crucial stage and that, if protected by an order of
anticipatory bail, the petitioner is likely to influence witnesses and
hamper the investigation. Having regard to the nature of the alleged
economic offences, which involve a deep-rooted conspiracy, it is
prayed that the petition be dismissed.
6.
I have carefully considered the submissions and perused the
material available on record.
7.1.
Section 13 of the HSNS Act empowers the proper officer to
summon any person whose attendance is considered necessary during
the course of an enquiry for the purpose of giving evidence or
producing books of account, electronic records, or any other
documents relevant to the enquiry. The provision further stipulates that
every such enquiry shall be deemed to be a judicial proceeding within
the meaning of Sections 193 and 228 of the BNSS. Consequently, a
person summoned under the said provision is under a legal obligation
to appear before the authority and cooperate with the enquiry, and
failure to comply with a lawful summons may entail the consequences
prescribed under law.
7.2.
Section 19(1)(a) of the HSNS Act provides that where the
amount of cess allegedly evaded exceeds the prescribed statutory
threshold of Rs.5 crores, the offence becomes cognizable and nonbailable and is punishable with imprisonment which may extend to five
years, or with fine, or with both. In the present case, the respondent
asserts that the alleged evasion of HSNS Cess is approximately Rs.12
crores, thereby attracting the rigour of the aforesaid provision.
7.3.
Further, Section 26(1) of the HSNS Act empowers the Principal
Commissioner or any officer duly authorized by him to authorize the
arrest of a person where there are reasonable grounds to believe that
such person has committed a cognizable and non-bailable offence
under the Act.
8.
It is in the backdrop of the said statutory provision that the
petitioner
seeks
the
extraordinary
relief
of
anticipatory
bail,
apprehending arrest pursuant to the summons issued under Section 13
of the Act.
9.
The respondent, on the other hand, contends that the petitioner
deliberately failed to comply with the summons issued on three
occasions, sought to evade the investigation, and has been identified
as the mastermind behind the syndicate engaged in large-scale
evasion of HSNS Cess. Reliance has been placed upon the statement
of a co-accused, bank transactions, financial records, and other
materials collected during the course of investigation to prima facie
establish the petitioner's involvement in the alleged conspiracy.
10.
At this stage, however, this Court is not required to undertake a
meticulous appreciation of the evidentiary value of the material
collected during the investigation or record any finding regarding the
guilt or innocence of the petitioner. Whether the statements recorded,
financial transactions, and other documentary evidence ultimately
establish the prosecution case are matters that must necessarily be
examined during the course of investigation and, if warranted, at the
stage of trial.
11.
The Supreme Court has consistently held that while considering
an application for anticipatory bail, the Court is not expected to conduct
a mini-trial or evaluate the evidence as if adjudicating the case on
merits. In Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra,
(2011) 1 SCC 694, the Supreme Court observed that the power under
Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,1973 (for short, “CrPC”)
(now Section 482 of the BNSS) is intended to safeguard individual
liberty and must be exercised in an appropriate case depending upon
the facts and circumstances of each case. In Arnesh Kumar v. State of
Bihar, (2014) 8 SCC 273, the Hon'ble Supreme Court emphatically held
that the power to arrest cannot be exercised merely because it is lawful
to do so. Arrest must be justified by necessity, and the investigating
agency must demonstrate that custodial arrest is indispensable for the
purposes of investigation. The Court cautioned that deprivation of
personal liberty should not become a routine or mechanical
consequence of the registration of an offence.
12.
In the present case, the summons issued to the petitioner
merely state that an enquiry is being conducted under the provisions of
the HSNS Act and require his attendance for the purpose of giving
evidence and producing documents or other articles in his possession
or control. Beyond the said recital, the summons do not disclose the
subject matter of the enquiry, the nature of the allegations, the
petitioner's alleged role, or the specific documents sought to be
produced. The reasons for withholding such particulars have also not
been explained.
13.
Interestingly, the detailed response filed by the respondent
indicates that the petitioner is alleged to be the principal accused and
mastermind of the alleged syndicate. If that be so, the summons issued
merely requiring the petitioner to appear and make a statement,
without disclosing the nature of the allegations, create an apparent
ambiguity regarding the status in which his attendance has been
sought.
14.
Another significant circumstance which cannot be ignored is that
even if the allegations are ultimately established, the maximum
punishment prescribed under Section 19(1)(a) of the HSNS Act is
imprisonment extending up to five years. The Supreme Court in Arnesh
Kumar (supra) has laid considerable emphasis on the principle that
where the maximum punishment does not exceed seven years, arrest
should ordinarily not be resorted to unless the statutory conditions
justifying such arrest are satisfied. The said principle, though evolved in
the context of the Code of Criminal Procedure, embodies the broader
constitutional mandate against unnecessary arrest and indiscriminate
curtailment of personal liberty.
15.
Further, the very issuance of summons requiring the petitioner
to appear and cooperate with the enquiry prima facie indicates that the
investigating authority initially intended to secure his cooperation
through the process contemplated under Section 13 of the Act rather
than by immediate custodial detention. Had custodial interrogation
been
considered
indispensable
from
the
very
inception,
the
investigating agency could have proceeded in accordance with law by
invoking the power of arrest available under Section 26 of the Act upon
satisfaction of the statutory requirements.
16.
The object of arrest during investigation is to facilitate a fair,
effective, and lawful investigation wherever custodial interrogation is
genuinely necessary. Arrest cannot be employed as a punitive
measure before the guilt of the accused is established. Equally, the
investigating agency cannot secure statements from an accused under
the constant threat of arrest and subsequently characterize such
statements as voluntary disclosures. Such an approach would be
inconsistent with the constitutional guarantee of fairness embedded in
Article 20(3) and 21.
17.
Needless to observe, if during the course of investigation any
subsequent
circumstances
arise
demonstrating
that
custodial
interrogation has become indispensable, or if the petitioner fails to
cooperate with the investigation or attempts to influence witnesses or
tamper with evidence, it shall always be open to the investigating
agency to invoke the powers available under Section 26 of the HSNS
Act or under BNSS to seek appropriate orders from the jurisdictional
Court in accordance with law.
18.
Having regard to the totality of the facts and circumstances, this
Court notices that, according to the respondent itself, the investigating
authorities have already seized the alleged packing machinery,
manufactured goods, raw materials, and other incriminating articles.
The investigation concerning financial transactions, electronic records,
bank accounts, and digital evidence is largely documentary in nature
and can continue effectively even while extending the protection of
anticipatory bail to the petitioner, subject to his full cooperation with the
investigating agency.
19.
Further, the object of anticipatory bail is neither to shield an
accused from investigation nor to obstruct the administration of criminal
justice. Rather, it is intended to ensure that a person is not subjected to
unnecessary humiliation or deprivation of liberty while simultaneously
securing the interests of a fair and effective investigation. Appropriate
conditions can adequately safeguard the investigation by ensuring the
petitioner's
continuous
cooperation,
availability
for
interrogation
whenever required, and non-interference with witnesses or evidence.
20.
Therefore, balancing the competing interests of an effective
investigation on the one hand and the petitioner's fundamental right to
personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution on the other, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the ends of justice would be
adequately served by extending the protection of anticipatory bail to the
petitioner,
subject
to
appropriate
conditions
safeguarding
the
investigation.
21.
Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is allowed, subject to the
following conditions:
a) The petitioner/Accused shall surrender before the Superintendent, (Antievasion) Central Tax, Hyderabad GST Commissionarate, on or before
06.08.2026. Upon such surrender, or in the event of his arrest, the
Superintendent shall release him on bail upon executing a personal bond
for a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five lakhs only), with two sureties for a
like sum each, to the satisfaction of the said officer.
b)
The petitioner shall appear before the Superintendent every
Tuesday and Thursday between 10:00 a.m. and 3:00 p.m. for a period
of ten (10) weeks from the date of his release on bail and shall
cooperate with the investigation in all respects.
c)
The petitioner shall furnish their complete residential addresses and
contact details to the Investigating Officer and shall keep the same
updated throughout the proceedings before the trial court.
d) Additionally, the petitioner shall remain available as and when
required by the investigating officer during the course of investigation.
e)
The petitioner shall not leave India without prior intimation to the
investigating authority and permission of the Court concerned.
e) The petitioner shall neither directly nor indirectly induce, threaten,
influence, nor contact any prosecution witness, nor shall they tamper with
the prosecution evidence in any manner whatsoever.
f) Any willful breach or violation of any of the aforesaid conditions shall
render the petitioner liable to appropriate proceedings before the
jurisdictional Court, including cancellation of bail, in accordance with the
provisions of the BNSS and other applicable laws.
22.
It is made clear that any observations made herein are confined
solely to the adjudication of the present application for anticipatory bail
and shall not be construed as an expression on the merits of the case.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
______________
N.TUKARAMJI, J
Date: 23.07.2026
MRKR
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI
CRIMINAL PETITION No.10448 OF 2026
DATE: 23.07.2026
MRKR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review