Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:563
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 45 of 2015 with
WP(C) No. 46 of 2015
Date of Decision: 24.06.2024
Shri. Panna Lal Shome
Son of (L) P.S. Shome,
Resident of Polo Hills,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
……. Petitioner
Vs.
1. North Eastern Hill University (NEHU)
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793002
Meghalaya, represented by the Registrar
2. The Registrar,
North-Eastern Hill University
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022
Meghalaya
3. The Deputy Registrar (Establishment-I),
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022
Meghalaya
4. Local Cadre Review Committee, NEHU
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022,
Meghalaya, represented by its Chairman
AND
Shri. Ajoy Krishna Bhattacharjee,
Son of (L) A.C. Bhattacharjee,
Resident of Laban,
……Respondents
2024:MLHC:563
Shillong, East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
……. Petitioner
Vs.
1. North Eastern Hill University (NEHU)
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793002
Meghalaya, represented by the Registrar
2. The Registrar,
North-Eastern Hill University
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022
Meghalaya
3. The Deputy Registrar (Establishment-I),
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022
Meghalaya
4. Local Cadre Review Committee, NEHU
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022,
Meghalaya, represented by its Chairman
……Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Ms. A. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. R. Dutta, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Sen, SC, NEHU with
Ms. S. Shallam, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:563
COMMON JUDGMENT
1.
It is the petitioners’ case that there has been an incorrect interpretation
of para 5 of the Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP) Scheme by
the respondent/NEHU resulting in denial of grant of the appropriate grade
pay under the 6th Central Pay Commission which has prompted the
petitioners to approach this Court with respective application under Article
226 of the Constitution of India with the prayer made therein.
2.
Heard Ms. A. Paul, learned Sr. counsel for the petitioners who has
submitted that the background facts of the case of the petitioners is that the
petitioner in WP(C) 45 of 2015, was appointed as Junior Stenographer in the
North Eastern Hill University (NEHU) on 06.03.1986 in the pay scale of ₹
330-10-380-EB-15-560.
3.
In course of his service, on completion of 8 years of service, he was
granted the 1st financial upgradation under the One Time Upward Movement
(OTUM) Scheme and his pay was then revised to ₹ 5500-175-9000 w.e.f.
06.03.1994. This was on account of the recommendations made under the 5th
Central Pay Commission which was also adopted by the University Grants
Commission (UGC), whereby the One Time Upward Movement Scheme was
also made applicable to the staff of NEHU.
4.
Again, on the introduction of the Assured Career Progression (ACP)
Scheme effective from the month of August, 1999, the scheme which
provides for financial upgradation on completion of 12 years’ service, the
petitioner on completion of 12 years’ service was granted the 2 nd financial
upgradation vide Office Order No F.2-25/CRC/2004-942 dated 24.04.2006
w.e.f. 06.03.2006 in the pay scale of ₹ 6500-200-10500.
2024:MLHC:563
5.
It is the contention of the learned Sr. counsel that pursuant to the 6th
CPC recommendations, the pay scales were restructured with the pay scales
of ₹ 5000-8000/-, ₹ 5500-9000/- and ₹ 6500-10500/- merged in the pay band
of ₹ 9300-34800/- with the corresponding grade pay of ₹ 4200/-. However,
vide Office Memorandum dated 13.11.2009, the Ministry of Finance,
Department of Expenditure, Government of India has granted revised pay
structure of grade pay of ₹ 4600/- in PB-2 to the posts that existed in the prerevised scale of ₹ 6500-10500/-. The petitioner who was in the pay scale of
₹ 6500-10500/- was granted grade pay of ₹ 4600/- w.e.f. 01.01.2006.
6.
In this regard, when the petitioner, under the 6th Pay Commission
recommendations was entitled to the said pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/- with
grade pay of ₹ 4600/- w.e.f. 01.01.2006, on 03.06.2006, he was given the 2nd
ACP, therefore, the financial upgradation which was to be given to him
should be the next higher grade pay than the one he was receiving as revised
pay scale under the 6th CPC recommendations, such grade pay being ₹ 4800/.
But instead, he was given the relevant pay scale with grade pay of ₹ 4600/only. Hence this petition.
7.
The learned Sr. counsel has further submitted that pursuant to the
recommendations of the 6th Central Pay Commission at para 6.1.15 of its
report, the Modified Career Progression Scheme (MACPS) was formulated
on the strength of Office Memorandum No. 35034/3/2008-Estt. (D) dated
19.05.2009 which provides for financial upgradation at intervals of 10, 20
and 30 years of continuous regular service of an employee of the Central
Government. Vide letter No.F.4-5/2009(JCRC) dated 09.07.2010, the UGC
has informed all concerned that the MACP scheme would also apply to all
non-teaching employees of all Central Universities, including NEHU.
2024:MLHC:563
8.
The learned Sr. counsel has reiterated that the provision of paragraph
5 of the MACP Scheme is relevant for consideration of the petitioners’ case
as the same has been misinterpreted by the respondent/authorities,
particularly as regard the issue of merger of pay scales/upgradation of posts
recommended by the 6th Pay Commission, wherein the petitioner was granted
the 1st financial upgradation w.e.f. 06.03.1994 was placed in the pay scale of
₹ 5500-9000/- and on being granted the 2nd financial upgradation, he was
placed in the pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/-. Again, under the 6th Pay
Commission, the two pay scales mentioned herein being merged into one
scale of ₹ 9300-34800/- with grade pay of ₹ 4200/-, therefore the petitioner
is entitled to be placed in PB-2 of ₹ 9300-34800/- in the 1st upgradation with
grade pay of ₹ 4600/- and on the 2nd financial upgradation he is to be placed
in pay band PB-2 with grade pay of ₹ 4800/-.
9.
Under the MACP Scheme, after a period of 10 years from
06.03.2006, the petitioner is due to receive the 3 rd MACP w.e.f. 06.03.2016
which was given to him. However, the pay scale that was given to him was
in the grade pay of ₹ 4800/-, when he ought to have got ₹ 6600/- which is
also evident when other similarly situated employees of NEHU were given
the grade pay of ₹ 6600/- for the relevant period.
10.
The learned Sr. counsel has also referred to Memo No. F.75-1/Estt-
I/Per/MACP/2009 (Part File)-3638 dated 19.12.2014 (Annexure-10 of the
petition), issued by the respondent No. 3 herein, by which communication,
also issued upon the petitioner Shri P. L. Shome, the respondent/NEHU has
clarified that the merger of the pay scales etc. in terms of para 5 of the MACP
Scheme will cover only those in the pay scale of ₹ 5000-8000/- and ₹ 55009000/-. This, was based on an erroneous interpretation of para 5 of the
2024:MLHC:563
MACP Scheme, wherein nowhere has it been stipulated that the upgradation
should be from a particular pay scale to those grades which now carry the
same grade pay due to the merger of pay scales/upgradation of posts, submits
the learned Sr. counsel.
11.
Per contra, Mr. S. Sen, learned Standing Counsel, NEHU while
contradicting the stand of the petitioner has submitted that the fact that the
petitioner is entitled to the financial upgradation on completion of 8 years of
service when he was granted the 1st financial upgradation on 06.03.1994
w.e.f. 06.03.1992 is admitted. On completion of 12 years of service from the
date when he received the 1st financial upgradation, that he was granted the
2nd financial upgradation under the ACP Scheme vide order dated
24.04.2006, the same being effective from 06.03.2006 is also admitted.
12.
In course of these proceedings, the petitioner was granted the 3rd
financial upgradation under MACP Scheme vide order dated 15.11.2016
w.e.f. 17.07.2016. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner
that the MACP Scheme became operational w.e.f. 01.01.2006 is factually
incorrect, submits the learned counsel for the respondent/NEHU since on
perusal of the office memorandum dated 19.05.2009 issued by the
Government of India, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions
(Department of Personnel and Training) notifying the operation of the MACP
Scheme, the same also being extended to central universities, including
NEHU by relevant notifications of the University Grants Commission
(UGC), at para 9 of the same, it is clearly mentioned that the Scheme would
be operational w.e.f. 01.09.2008.
13.
The learned counsel has further submitted that in the case of the
2024:MLHC:563
petitioner, his first financial upgradation was under the OTUM Scheme, his
second was under the ACP Scheme and his third was under the MACP
Scheme.
14.
It is also submitted that the petitioner at the relevant period when he
was granted the first financial upgradation, the relevant pay scale was as per
the 5th Central Pay Commission (CPC) recommendation and his scale at that
point of time was ₹ 5500-9000/-. When he was granted the second financial
upgradation under the ACP, his pay scale was ₹ 6500-10500/- in pay band
PB-2 with grade pay of ₹ 4600/-. This scale was made applicable under the
6th CPC recommendation.
15.
The learned counsel has pointed out that under the 6 th CPC, revised
pay bands and grade pay have been fixed. At page 32, Annexure-A7 of the
counter affidavit of the respondents is found the First Schedule of Part-A
wherein at serial No. 10, 11, 12 and 13 the scale of ₹ 5000-8000/-, ₹ 55009000/-, ₹ 6500-6900/- and ₹ 6500-10500/- were all merged together at pay
band PB-2 for a revised pay scale of ₹ 9300-34800/- with grade pay of ₹
4200.
16.
This being the situation, even if the petitioner has been granted the
second ACP with pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/-, he would not have been
financially benefitted since his earlier pay scale was ₹ 5500-9000/- which
was merged with the same pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/- the revised pay scale
being ₹ 9300-34800/- and grade pay of ₹ 4200/-.
17.
To correct this anomaly, the Ministry of Finance has issued office
memorandum dated 13.11.2009 and has inter alia taken out the pre-revised
scale of ₹ 6500-10500/- as on 01.01.2006 and has replaced the same with the
2024:MLHC:563
revised grade pay of ₹ 4600/-. This being the case, since the pay scale of ₹
6500-10500/- has been taken out of the merger, there is no requirement of
granting fresh financial upgradation to the petitioner, para 5 of the MACP
Scheme will thus not be applicable to the case of the petitioner as far as the
relevant financial upgradation is concerned, submits the learned counsel.
18.
This contention is to counter the reliance of the petitioner with regard
to the provision of para 5 of the MACP Scheme which states as follows:“5. Promotions earned/upgradations granted under the ACP Scheme
in the past to those grades which now carry the same grade pay due
to merger of pay scales/upgradations of posts recommended by the
Sixth Pay Commission shall be ignored for the purpose of granting
upgradations under Modified ACPS.”
19.
Following the pattern of grant of financial upgradations to the
petitioner, the 3rd MACP which was due and entitled to by the petitioner as
on 03.06.2016, his pay scale was fixed at ₹ 9300-34800/- with grade pay of
₹ 4800/- which is next in the hierarchy.
20.
As to the contention of the petitioner that there are similarly situated
employees of NEHU who have been granted the 3 rd financial upgradation
under MACP Scheme with grade pay of ₹ 6600/- following which the
petitioner is also entitled to the same but was given only in the grade pay of
₹ 4800/-, the learned counsel has submitted that looking into the date of
appointment and other related details as far as financial upgradation to such
employees are concerned, there is a difference between their case and the
case of the petitioner and as such, no comparison can be made between the
two to entertain the demand of the petitioner on this score.
2024:MLHC:563
21.
The dispute between the parties appear to be based on different
interpretation and understanding of the manner the financial upgradation has
been fixed vis-à-vis the entitlement of the petitioner to the relevant pay scale
and corresponding grade pay, particularly as regard the grant of benefit under
the ACP Scheme under the payment regime of the 6th CPC.
22.
There is no disagreement between the parties as far as the grant of the
1st financial upgradation under the OTUM Scheme given to the petitioner.
However, even though the respondent authorities would concede that the
petitioner has been subsequently granted the 2nd financial upgradation under
the ACP Scheme on 06.03.2006, the calculation of the pay scale and grade
pay that the petitioner ought to have been placed has become the bone of
contention.
23.
The respondent NEHU would maintain that since the petitioner was
granted the 2nd financial upgradation under the ACP Scheme, his pay scale
was fixed at ₹ 6500-10500/- as per the 5th CPC. Under the 6th CPC, the pay
scale of ₹ 5000-8000/- and ₹ 5500-9000/- as well as the pay scale of ₹ 650010500/- were merged together in pay band PB-2 with grade pay of ₹ 4200/,
the petitioner would not have been financially benefited. Therefore, when
the pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/- was taken out of the merger of the pay scale
of ₹ 5000-8000/- and ₹ 5500-9000/- with grade pay of ₹ 4200/- and was now
placed in pay band PB-2 with grade pay of ₹ 4600/- his financial upgradation
under the 2nd ACP with grade pay of ₹ 4600/- was deemed to be the proper
placement as far as the petitioner is concerned.
24.
Again, since the said pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/- which was earlier
merged together with that of ₹ 5000-8000/- and ₹ 5500-9000/- with grade
2024:MLHC:563
pay of ₹ 4200/- was taken out of the merger and placed in the grade pay of ₹
4600/-, therefore the benefit of para 5 of the MACP Scheme cannot be availed
by the petitioner and accordingly, when he was due to receive the 3rd financial
upgradation under the MACP Scheme, he was given the same with grade pay
of ₹ 4800/- which is next in the hierarchy.
25.
This, according to this Court is not the correct interpretation of the
actual position as it ought to be. The mistake of the respondent authorities
was the confusion created at the time when the 2nd financial upgradation
under the ACP Scheme was given to the petitioner. It must be reminded that
the petitioner was due to receive the 2nd financial upgradation on 06.03.2006
when in receiving the same, he was placed in the pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/.
But in view of the revised pay scale under the 6th CPC, he is now entitled to
be placed in the pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/- with grade pay of ₹ 4600/- as
on 01.01.2006. Therefore, as on 03.06.2006, taking into consideration that he
was then receiving his salary in the pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/- with grade
pay of ₹ 4600/-, his next financial upgradation ought to be in the grade pay
of ₹ 4800/-.
26.
Even if the provision of para 5 of the MACP Scheme is not applicable
to the petitioner, his next financial upgradation under the 3rd MACP which is
due to him on 03.06.2016 should be given to him in the next higher grade
pay of ₹ 5400/-. Being placed in the grade pay of ₹ 4800/- under the 3rd
MACP which was given to him as on 03.06.2016 is also erroneous.
27.
The above, is the correct calculation of the entitlement of the
petitioner to the pay scale under the 6th CPC and his corresponding
entitlement under the 2nd and 3rd financial upgradation respectively, in the
2024:MLHC:563
considered opinion of this Court.
28.
As to the demand of the petitioner that he ought to be placed in the
relevant pay scale with grade pay of ₹ 6600/- when the 3rd financial
upgradation under the MACP Scheme was given to him as other similarly
situated employees of the NEHU were also given their 3rd financial
upgradation with grade pay of ₹ 6600/-, this Court on perusal of the additional
affidavit dated 06.04.2022 filed by the petitioner to bring certain documents
on record, one of such documents being the information received by way of
RTI filed by the petitioner wherein is shown the details of some of the
employees of NEHU who have been granted the financial upgradation at
various stages, for example, one Shri Dhiraj Chakraborty, Rtd. Senior Private
Secretary got his 3rd MACP with pay scale of ₹ 9300-34800/- with grade pay
of ₹ 5400/-, while Smti. Virginia Diengdoh, Rtd. Senior Private Secretary,
got her 3rd MACP with grade pay of ₹ 6600/-, the same is the case with Smti.
Miracle Shabong, Rtd. Private Secretary, who at the relevant period got her
3rd MACP with grade pay of ₹ 6600/-.
29.
On trying to convince this Court that the above cited employees have
received their financial upgradation under the MACP Scheme with a higher
grade pay than was received by the petitioner, what is noticed is that the date
of joining of all the said employees are different to that of the petitioner and
that they have joined service before the petitioner was ever appointed.
Therefore, even on this ground, no comparison can be made in this respect.
The claim of the petitioner cannot be accepted in this regard.
30.
In the case of Shri. Ajoy Krishna Bhattacharjee, the petitioner in
WP(C) No. 46 of 2015, the circumstances are almost identical to the case of
2024:MLHC:563
the petitioner in WP(C) No. 45 of 2015 as has been discussed hereinabove,
except for the fact that there is a difference as far as the date of appointment
is concerned correspondingly affecting the dates on which he was also
granted financial upgradation under the OTUM Scheme, the ACP Scheme
and the MACP Scheme.
31.
According to this petitioner, he was given the 1 st financial
upgradation under the OTUM Scheme w.e.f. 04.09.1997. He was thereafter
granted the 2nd financial upgradation vide order dated 24.04.2014 w.e.f.
04.09.2009 when he ought to be upgraded in the pay scale of ₹ 9300- 34800/with grade pay of ₹ 4800/- as per the provision of para 5 of the MACP
Scheme, which the petitioner assert is applicable to his case. Vide order dated
22.04.2019, he was granted the 3rd financial upgradation under the MACP
Scheme and his pay scale was fixed at Level-8 (47600-151100) under the pay
matrix of 7th CPC, which according to the petitioner is incorrect.
32.
The petitioner has also submitted that some of the employees of
NEHU who are similarly situated to him are getting the 3rd financial
upgradation under the MACP Scheme with grade pay of ₹ 6600/- and as such,
he ought to be given the same, which was not done so.
33.
The case of this petitioner is similar to that of the petitioner in WP(C)
No. 45 of 2015 except for the fact that the date of joining does not fall on the
same day. The petitioner has, however, admitted that he has been granted the
financial upgradation from the first one, that is under the OTUM Scheme and
the next two was granted to him under the MACP Scheme, since on the date
he is due to receive his 2nd Financial Upgradation on 04.09.2009, the ACP
Scheme is no longer applicable since it was replaced by the MACP Scheme.
2024:MLHC:563
Be that as it may, after the grant of the 2 nd financial upgradation, the 3rd
MACP was granted to him on 22.04.2019 w.e.f. 01.09.2018.
34.
As has been observed herein above, at the time when the petitioner
was granted the 1st financial upgradation, his pay scale was revised to ₹ 55009000/- under the 5th CPC. The 6th CPC became applicable with effect from
01.01.2006. In view of the pay revision affected across the board, the pay
scale of the petitioner ought to have been revised to enable him to draw a new
pay scale of ₹ 6500-10500/- with grade pay of ₹ 4600/-. When he was due to
be granted the 2nd financial upgradation on 04.09.2009, at that point he was
drawing his pay scale with grade pay of ₹ 4600/-. It is therefore, but logical
for the authorities concerned to grant him his 2nd financial upgradation on the
next higher pay scale which ought to be in the grade pay of ₹ 4800/- but
which was not given to him, instead he was confirmed in the grade pay of ₹
4600/-. As in the case of the petitioner, P.L. Shome, this petitioner was also
entitled to the grade pay of ₹ 4800/- w.e.f. 04.09.2009. His 3rd financial
upgradation under the MACP Scheme was also given to him w.e.f.
01.09.2018 in the grade pay of ₹ 4800/-. This too, ought to be revised to the
grade pay of ₹ 5400/- under the circumstances.
35.
In the opinion of this Court, the petitioner Ajoy Krishna
Bhattacharjee is entitled to the grade pay of ₹ 4800/- at the time of grant of
the 2nd financial upgradation and the grade pay of ₹ 5400/- when the 3rd
financial upgradation was given.
36.
As in the case of the petitioner in WP(C) No. 45 of 2015, the claim
of parity with those employees who have been granted their 3 rd MACP with
grade pay of ₹ 6600/- at the relevant point of time, since there is an evident
2024:MLHC:563
difference in the date and year of joining, the former having joined
employment earlier than the petitioner herein, he is therefore not entitled to
the said grade pay of ₹ 6600/-.
37.
The case of Union of India v. Dineshan K.K. reported in (2008) 1
SCC 586 at para 12 and also the case of State of Punjab and Ors. v. Jagjit
Singh & Ors., (2017) 1 SCC 148, para 42.14, 44.2, 58 and 60 cited by the
learned Sr. counsel for the petitioners are not applicable in this case as the
said judgment speaks about the principle of equal pay for equal work, which
principle cannot be applied in the case of the petitioners herein.
38.
In the final analysis, this Court hereby find that the petitioners have
made out a case in their favour to the extent indicated herein above and the
prayer made in this regard is allowed.
39.
The respondent authorities in the NEHU are hereby directed to take
necessary steps by passing relevant orders to correct the anomaly made out
by granting the said 2nd and 3rd financial upgradation to the petitioners as
determined herein above and to make necessary arrangement for payment of
arrears etc. in this connection. The steps taken should be done so within
3(three) months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
40.
With the above, these petitions are hereby disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
24.06.2024
TIPRILYNTI
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
2024.06.24 18:54:58
KHARKONGOR Date:
-07'00'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review