The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. The case of the present petitioners is squarely covered by the aforesaid judgment, which has attained finality. This Court, in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction, cannot be called upon to return a finding contrary to that already rendered by the Co-ordinate Bench in respect of the same controversy arising out of the same criminal case. The facts of both cases are pari materia. In fact, the present petitioners as well as the petitioner in CRM(M) No. 406/2021 are jointly facing trial pursuant to the same FIR. Therefore, the findings returned in the aforesaid judgment apply with equal force to the present case. Consequently, this Court finds no merit in the present petition. The same is, accordingly, dismissed, leaving the Trial Court free to proceed with the trial in accordance with law, interim directions if any shall stand vacated.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 14.09.2026
Pronounced on: 28.09.2026
Uploaded on: 28.09.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Full
CRM(M) No. 281/2020
CrlM No. (1087/2020)
(1). Shree Pal Singh the then Executive
Engineer, Srinagar Central Division,
CPWD, Humhama Srinagar (now retired)
S/o Mool Chandra R/o Village Ghoshi
Post Belain District Fethepur, UP.
(2). Hardeep Singh the then Assistant
Engineer Srinagar Central Division,
CPWD, Humhama Srinagar A/O Sardar
Gurdhian Singh R/o (Nz-1) Kencrya
Sadhan Sector 09 Chandrigarh House
No.4015, Sector 68 Mohali.
(3). Rakesh Sharma the then Assistant
Engineer, Srinagar Central Division,
CPWD, Humhama Srinagar S/o Keshav
Dutt Sharma R/o House No.7/27 1st Floor
Sector-05 Rajendra Nagar Sahibabad
Gaziabad, UP.
(4). Umesh Chandra Tripathi the then
Assistant Engineer Srinagar Central
Division , CPWD Humhama Srinagar S/o
Shree Dutt R/o House No.J-36/A, Pandav
Nagar, Near Mother Diary, Delhi-92.
Through:
…Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Mr. Syed Faisal Qadri, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Shaifta Balkhi, Advocate and
Ms. Sameena Altaf, Advocate
Vs.
Central Bureau of Investigation
Anti-Corruption Branch
Srinagar
Through: Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Ms. Bisma Ali, Advocate
CRM(M) No. 281/2020
...Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioners stand charged with the commission of offences under
Section 120-B read with Section 420 of the RPC and Section 5(2) read
with Section 5(1)(d) of the J&K Prevention of Corruption Act, Svt.
2006, besides the offence under Section 4-H of the J&K Prevention of
Corruption Act, arising out of an incident which occurred on
25.07.2017. At the relevant time, petitioner No. 1 was serving as
Executive Engineer in the Central Public Works Department, Srinagar,
whereas petitioner No. 2 was serving as Assistant Executive Engineer.
Petitioner Nos. 3 and 4 were also serving as Assistant Executive
Engineers in the Central Public Works Department. The FIR came to be
registered on the basis of a preliminary inquiry conducted by the
respondent. It was alleged that the petitioners had entered into a
criminal conspiracy with the contractor, M/s Sheikh & Sons, with the
object of causing wrongful loss to the public exchequer and
corresponding wrongful gain to themselves in connection with the
contract for construction of a 9.1-km boundary wall for the Central
University of Kashmir, Ganderbal, thereby causing a loss of Rs. 3.4
crore to the public exchequer. The work had been allotted to M/s
Sheikh & Sons at a cost of Rs. 9.38 crore. The stipulated date of
commencement of the work was 19.05.2013 and the date of completion
was 11.08.2014. However, it was revealed that the contractor, in
connivance with the public servants of the Central Public Works
Department, Srinagar, did not execute the work in accordance with the
approved specifications and drawings.
CRM(M) No. 281/2020
2.
It was further alleged that defective work was found in 34 columns
extending from village Tulmulla to Barsoo along the left side of the
road and in 40 columns in the prefab area on the right side of the road.
In addition, two plinth beams, each measuring approximately 2.70
metres in length, were found tilted. About seven wall panels, out of a
total of 150 panels in the Tulmulla area on the left-hand side, were also
found tilted inwards. It was further alleged that, even after the expiry of
the stipulated period for completion of the work, only 16% of the work
had been executed by the contractor, and even that work was defective
and of poor quality. Notwithstanding the same, the petitioners had
passed bills corresponding to 36% of the work, amounting to Rs. 3.4
crore out of the total contract value of Rs. 9.38 crore, which was
claimed by the Central Public Works Department authorities and paid
to the contractor.
3.
It was alleged that the accused public servants had released payments in
respect of the defective work through various Running Account Bills
after maintaining false entries in the Measurement Books and other
official records.
4.
Upon completion of the investigation, on 21.12.2018, a charge-sheet
under Section 173 Cr.P.C. was presented before the Court of the
learned Special Judge, Anti-Corruption (CBI), Kashmir, against
petitioners and the co-accused, with a prayer that they be tried for the
offences punishable under Section 120-B read with Section 420 RPC
and Sections 4-H and 5(2) read with Section 5(1)(d) of the J&K
Prevention of Corruption Act, Svt. 2006. Thereafter, the Trial Court
CRM(M) No. 281/2020
proceeded to frame charges against the accused by passing the order
which is impugned in the present petition.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioners primarily contended that, insofar as
the offence under Section 4-H of the J&K Prevention of Corruption Act
is concerned, the charge is unsustainable in the absence of a valid
previous sanction for prosecution. It was submitted that such sanction
could neither be presumed nor enlarged by the Trial Court at the stage
of framing of charge. Learned counsel further argued that the statutory
discretion vested in the sanctioning authority cannot be exercised,
supplemented, reconstructed, or deemed to have been exercised by the
Trial Court at the stage of framing of charge. It was, therefore,
contended that a charge under Section 4-H could not be sustained
merely on the ground that the ingredients of the said offence could
otherwise be discerned from the allegations contained in the chargesheet.
6.
The principal contention of learned counsel for the petitioners is that,
while granting sanction for prosecution of the petitioners, the
competent authority did not accord sanction for their prosecution for
the offence under Section 4-H of the J&K Prevention of Corruption
Act. Thus, according to learned counsel, the charge framed to that
extent is legally unsustainable. It was accordingly prayed that the
present petition be allowed and the charge, insofar as it relates to
Section 4-H of the J&K Prevention of Corruption Act, be quashed.
7.
Per contra, the counsel for the respondent, while drawing the attention
of this Court to the judgment rendered by a Co-ordinate Bench in
CRM(M) No. 406/2021, argued that a petition filed by the co-accused,
Ram Gopal Meena, had already been dismissed. It was argued that,
CRM(M) No. 281/2020
while dismissing the said petition, the Co-ordinate Bench had
considered the legal position governing the controversy and had held
that the Trial Court's order framing a charge under Section 4-H could
not be vitiated merely because the sanction order did not specifically
mention the said provision. Such omission, it was submitted, would not
vitiate the criminal proceedings, as the same did not go to the root of
the jurisdiction of the Court. When confronted with the aforesaid
position, learned counsel for the petitioners sought to contend that the
case projected by the present petitioners was distinguishable from that
of the co-accused.
8.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and examined the record.
9.
The petitioner in CRM(M) No. 406/2021 was one Ram Gopal Meena,
who figured as accused No. 1 in case RC1232017A0001. The present
case also arises out of the same FIR registered by the CBI. The order
dated 05.09.2020 passed by the Trial Court framing charges was also
called into question in the said petition.
10.
The dismissal of the petition filed by the co-accused by this Court vide
judgment dated 02.12.2022 has not been challenged by the said
accused. The findings recorded therein would, therefore, also govern
the case of the present petitioners, as the facts and legal issues involved
are substantially identical. Petitioners along with Ram Gopal Meena,
belonged to the same Department, namely, the Central Public Works
Department, Srinagar, and all were accused of having misused their
official positions by entering into a criminal conspiracy with the
contractor with the object of causing wrongful loss to the public
exchequer and corresponding wrongful gain to themselves in
connection with the contract for construction of the boundary wall.
CRM(M) No. 281/2020
When confronted with this aspect of the matter, the counsel for the
petitioners was unable to satisfactorily distinguish the case of the
present petitioners.
11.
Framing of charge is an important stage in a criminal trial at which the
Court is required to apply its mind to the material on record and the
documents placed before it. The Co-ordinate Bench, while considering
the merits of the case, had also examined the plea raised with regard to
the applicability of Section 4-H of the J&K Prevention of Corruption
Act. The said issue was dealt with in paragraphs 22 and 23 of the
judgment, wherein it was held that the mere omission to specifically
mention a particular offence in the sanction order would not render the
sanction invalid if the allegations and material referred to in the
sanction order otherwise disclose the ingredients constituting such
offence. In arriving at the said conclusion, the Co-ordinate Bench relied
upon the judgments rendered in Prakash Singh Badal v. State of
Punjab and Others 2007 1 SCC 1 and State of Bihar and Others v.
Raj Mangal Ram 2014 11 SCC 388. The view taken by the Coordinate Bench is the view applicable to the facts of the present case
and is, accordingly, reaffirmed by this Court.
12.
The case of the present petitioners is squarely covered by the aforesaid
judgment, which has attained finality. This Court, in exercise of its
inherent jurisdiction, cannot be called upon to return a finding contrary
to that already rendered by the Co-ordinate Bench in respect of the
same controversy arising out of the same criminal case. The facts of
both cases are pari materia. In fact, the present petitioners as well as
the petitioner in CRM(M) No. 406/2021 are jointly facing trial pursuant
to the same FIR. Therefore, the findings returned in the aforesaid
CRM(M) No. 281/2020
judgment apply with equal force to the present case. Consequently, this
Court finds no merit in the present petition. The same is, accordingly,
dismissed, leaving the Trial Court free to proceed with the trial in
accordance with law, interim directions if any shall stand vacated.
(SANJAY PARIHAR)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
28.09.2026
Akhil Dev
Whether the order is speaking? Yes
Whether the order is reportable? No
CRM(M) No. 281/2020
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review