Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed
by
SHAYNA
KADRI
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Reserved for orders on : 05.02.2026
Order passed on : 13.02.2026
WPS No. 9471 of 2023
1 - Shrawan Kumar Singh S/o Late Shivcharan Singh Aged About 32
Years Occupation - Assistant Grade- I I I, Under The Office Of Deputy
Director Agriculture Baikunthpur District- Korea C.G. R/o VillageGopalpur Ward No. 1, Post- Ps-Tahsil Surajpur, District : Surajpur,
Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Agriculture Department,
Mantralay Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar Nawa Raipur, District : Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
2 - The Director Agriculture Block- I I, Second Floor, Indrawati Bhawan,
Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
3 - The Joint Director Agriculture Surguja Division Ambikapur, District :
Surguja (Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
4 - Deputy Director Agriculture Baikunthpur, District : Koriya
(Baikunthpur), Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Santosh Kumar Pandey, Advocate
For State
: Mr. Hariom Rai, Panel Lawyer
(Hon'ble Shri Amitendra Kishore Prasad, Judge)]
C.A.V. Order
1.
By way of the present writ petition, the petitioner calls in question
the legality and validity of the order dated 13.05.2019 (Annexure
P-3), whereby respondent No. 3, acting suo motu, has cancelled
his earlier order dated 08.09.2017 granting the petitioner the
benefit of regular pay scale from the initial date of appointment
and has further directed recovery of the alleged excess amount
paid to the petitioner. The petitioner has also assailed the arbitrary
and discriminatory action of the respondents in denying him
promotion from the post of Assistant Grade-III to Assistant GradeII. It is submitted that despite the petitioner having submitted
several representations ventilating his grievance, the respondents
have failed to take any decision thereon, thereby perpetuating
discrimination and causing continuing prejudice to the petitioner.
The petitioner has prayed for following reliefs :
“10.1 The Hon'ble court may be
pleased to call for the entire records
pertaining to the case of petitioner from
the respondents for kind perusal of this
Hon'ble Court.
10.2 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to set-aside the impugned
order dated 13.05.2019 (Annexure P-3)
issued by the office of respondent no.
3.”
2.
Facts of the case, as canvased are that, the petitioner was initially
appointed on compassionate grounds to the post of Assistant
Grade-III vide order dated 28.02.2014 issued by the competent
authority. In pursuance of the said appointment order, the
petitioner duly joined service on 13.03.2014 and has been
continuously discharging his duties thereafter. Prior to joining on
the said post, the petitioner was already possessing a valid
certificate of computer training course, which was submitted
before respondent No. 3. Taking note of the petitioner’s eligibility
and qualification, respondent No. 3 sanctioned the benefit of
regular pay scale to the petitioner with effect from the date of his
initial appointment i.e. 13.03.2014, vide order dated 08.09.2017.
The said order granting regular pay scale remained in force and
was acted upon by the respondents. However, to the utter
surprise of the petitioner, respondent No. 3, without issuing any
show-cause notice and without affording any opportunity of
hearing, suo motu cancelled his earlier order dated 08.09.2017
vide order dated 13.05.2019 and further directed recovery of the
alleged excess amount paid to the petitioner. The said action was
taken in complete violation of the principles of natural justice.
Even otherwise, the said cancellation and recovery order has not
been properly communicated to the petitioner till date. Thereafter,
respondent No. 3 issued the seniority gradation list of Assistant
Grade-III as on 01.04.2020 vide order dated 26.06.2020, wherein
the petitioner’s name was duly reflected at Serial No. 21, thereby
acknowledging his continuous service and seniority position.
Subsequent to issuance of the said gradation list, respondent No.
3, vide order dated 01.09.2020, directed respondent No. 4 to
furnish the preceding five years’ Annual Confidential Reports
(ACRs), details of immovable property and no-dues certificates of
eligible employees for the purpose of considering them for further
promotion. In the said order, the name of the petitioner was
specifically mentioned at Serial No. 26, clearly indicating that the
petitioner was within the zone of consideration for promotion.
Despite the above, when the promotion order dated 29.05.2021
was issued by the office of respondent No. 2 for promotion from
the post of Assistant Grade-III to Assistant Grade-II, the
petitioner’s name was arbitrarily omitted, whereas several juniors
to the petitioner were granted promotion. The exclusion of the
petitioner, without assigning any reason, is manifestly illegal and
discriminatory.
successfully
During
the
relevant
period,
cleared
the
departmental
the
typing
petitioner
examination
conducted by the competent committee. Consequent thereto,
respondent No. 4, vide order dated 23.09.2021, sanctioned typing
allowance of Rs. 500/- per month in favour of the petitioner, which
further establishes his eligibility and satisfactory service record.
Thereafter, respondent No. 3 again issued a seniority gradation
list of Assistant Grade-III as on 01.04.2021 vide order dated
08.09.2022, wherein the petitioner’s name found place at Serial
No. 28, thereby once again recognizing his service status and
seniority. However, in a wholly arbitrary manner, the seniority
gradation list as on 01.04.2022 issued on 13.06.2023 by
respondent No. 3 does not contain the name of the petitioner at
all, without assigning any reason or issuing any prior notice to
him. The unexplained deletion of the petitioner’s name from the
gradation list is ex facie illegal and unjustified. On the basis of the
said gradation list as on 01.04.2022, respondent No. 3, vide order
dated 14.08.2023, again directed respondent No. 4 to furnish the
preceding five years’ ACRs, immovable property details and nodues certificates of employees for further promotion. The
petitioner, being aggrieved by his continuous exclusion and
deletion from the gradation list and denial of promotion, submitted
several objections and representations to the respondent
authorities and made repeated correspondence requesting
consideration of his case for promotion from Assistant Grade-III to
Assistant
Grade-II.
However,
despite
receipt
of
such
representations, the respondents have failed to take any decision
or pass any reasoned order till date. In these circumstances, the
entire act and conduct of the respondents in cancelling the benefit
of regular pay scale, deleting the petitioner’s name from the
gradation list, and not considering him for promotion despite his
eligibility, seniority and clean service record, are arbitrary, illegal,
mala fide and contrary to the applicable rules and settled
principles of law, giving rise to the present writ petition.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the entire act and
conduct of the respondent authorities, particularly respondent No.
3, is manifestly arbitrary, illegal and vitiated by non-application of
mind, being in clear violation of the settled principles of
administrative law and the fundamental tenets of natural justice.
The impugned actions demonstrate an unreasonable exercise of
power, causing serious civil consequences to the petitioner
without affording him any opportunity of hearing.
It is further
submitted that the impugned actions of the respondents are in
direct contravention of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India, which guarantee equality before law and equal opportunity
in matters of public employment. The petitioner, though similarly
situated and otherwise eligible, has been subjected to hostile
discrimination, while his juniors have been conferred benefits of
promotion and service advantages. Learned counsel submits that
it is an admitted and undisputed fact that prior to joining the post
of Assistant Grade-III, the petitioner possessed the requisite
computer training certificate, which was duly placed on record.
Upon due verification of his eligibility, respondent No. 3 granted
the petitioner the benefit of regular pay scale with effect from
13.03.2014 vide order dated 08.09.2017. However, in complete
disregard of the principles of natural justice, the said benefit was
withdrawn suo motu by respondent No. 3 vide order dated
13.05.2019, without issuance of any show-cause notice, without
affording an opportunity of hearing, and without assigning any
cogent reasons, coupled with a direction for recovery of the
alleged excess payment, which itself was never properly
communicated to the petitioner.
It is further submitted that
respondent No. 3, vide order dated 01.09.2020, directed
respondent No. 4 to furnish the preceding five years’ ACRs,
immovable property details and no-dues certificates of eligible
employees for the purpose of further promotion, wherein the
name of the petitioner was specifically included, thereby
acknowledging his eligibility and consideration for promotion.
Despite the same, when the promotion order dated 29.05.2021
was issued, the petitioner’s name was arbitrarily omitted, whereas
several juniors to the petitioner were promoted from Assistant
Grade-III to Assistant Grade-II, without assigning any justification
for such exclusion.
Learned counsel further submits that the
petitioner’s name again found place in the seniority gradation list
of Assistant Grade-III as on 01.04.2021, issued vide order dated
08.09.2022, wherein he was placed at Serial No. 28. However, in
a wholly arbitrary and unexplained manner, the petitioner’s name
was deleted from the subsequent gradation list as on 01.04.2022
issued on 13.06.2023, without issuing any notice, without
affording any opportunity of hearing, and without recording any
reasons, rendering the action ex facie illegal. It is submitted that
despite being senior and fully eligible, the petitioner has been
deliberately deprived of promotion, whereas his juniors have been
granted such benefit, clearly indicating mala fide intent and
colourable exercise of power on the part of respondent No. 3. The
denial of promotion to the petitioner, without any valid reason,
amounts to arbitrary discrimination and unfair treatment. Learned
counsel lastly submits that the petitioner has consistently raised
objections
and
made
repeated
representations
and
correspondence before the respondent authorities, requesting
consideration of his case for promotion and redressal of his
grievances. However, the respondents have failed to take any
action or pass any reasoned order thereon till date, thereby
compounding the illegality and causing grave prejudice to the
petitioner. In view of the aforesaid submissions, it is contended
that the impugned actions of the respondents are unsustainable in
law.
4.
Learned State counsel, at the very outset, submits that the
answering respondents categorically, vehemently and specifically
deny all adverse allegations, insinuations and averments made by
the petitioner against the respondents/State in the instant writ
petition. It is submitted that the petition is misconceived, devoid of
merit and substance, and has been filed by suppressing material
facts, and therefore does not warrant any interference by this
Court.
Learned State counsel submits that the petitioner was
granted compassionate appointment on the post of Assistant
Grade-III vide order dated 28.02.2014 issued by the Joint Director,
Agriculture, Division Surguja, Ambikapur, and was posted in the
office of the Deputy Director, Agriculture, Balrampur, District
Balrampur. The said appointment was subject to specific
conditions, namely that the petitioner was required to pass Hindi
Typing/Computer from a recognized institution within a period of
two years from the date of appointment, and till fulfillment of the
said condition, he was entitled only to the lower pay scale
attached to the post. It was further stipulated that only after
passing the requisite Hindi Typing/Computer qualification would
the petitioner be placed on probation and his seniority be
determined in accordance with rules. Learned State counsel
further submits that respondent No. 3, on the basis of a computer
training
certificate
issued
by
UICT
Computer,
Surguja,
erroneously passed an order dated 08.09.2017 granting the
petitioner regular pay scale with effect from 13.03.2014. However,
the said order was contrary to the circular dated 14.06.2013
issued by the General Administration Department, Government of
Chhattisgarh, which governs compassionate appointments. As per
Clause 10(3) of the said circular, except for a widow of the
deceased employee, no exemption is permissible in the
prescribed educational qualifications for the post of Assistant
Grade-III, and other dependents must necessarily pass Hindi
Typing with 5000 depressions on computer from a recognized
institution. Since the petitioner did not fulfill the said mandatory
requirement and the certificate relied upon was not from a
recognized institution for the prescribed qualification, the order
dated 08.09.2017 was rightly cancelled vide order dated
13.05.2019. The said cancellation was thus legal, justified and in
strict conformity with the governing policy. It is further submitted
that since the petitioner had not passed the requisite Hindi
Typing/Computer
qualification
and
his
services
were
not
regularized at the relevant point of time, his case was rightly not
considered by the Departmental Promotion Committee for
promotion from the post of Assistant Grade-III to Assistant GradeII. Therefore, the allegation of discrimination or violation of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India is wholly misconceived,
vague and baseless. Learned State counsel also submits that the
writ petition suffers from gross delay and laches. The petitioner
has challenged the order dated 13.05.2019 only in the year 2023,
i.e. after an inordinate and unexplained delay of more than four
years. In this regard, reliance is placed on the judgments of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in U.P. Jal Nigam & Another v. Jaswant
Singh & Another, (2006) 11 SCC 464 and Gulam Rasul v. State
of Jammu & Kashmir, (2009) 15 SCC, wherein it has been
categorically held that a litigant who sleeps over his rights is not
entitled to discretionary relief under writ jurisdiction, and stale
claims cannot be revived after a long lapse of time. It is further
submitted that after the petitioner cleared the requisite skill/typing
test organized by the respondent department, he was granted
typing allowance of Rs. 500/- per month vide order dated
23.09.2021. Subsequently, upon clearing the typing skill test
conducted by the Government Industrial Training Institute,
Ambikapur on 25.08.2024, the probation of the petitioner was
ended vide order dated 16.01.2026 with effect from 25.08.2024.
Thereafter, his name has been duly included in the gradation list
as on 01.04.2025 for the post of Assistant Grade-III. Thus, the
petitioner is now being treated strictly in accordance with law and
applicable rules.
Learned State counsel submits that the
petitioner’s claim for promotion had earlier been rejected on
12.09.2023 solely on the ground that his probation had not ended
at the relevant point of time. The said decision was legal,
reasoned and in consonance with service jurisprudence. There is
no arbitrariness, mala fide or illegality in the action of the
respondents.
Lastly, learned State counsel submits that the
grounds raised by the petitioner are untenable and not available
to him in law, in view of the factual and legal position explained
hereinabove. The petitioner is not entitled to any of the reliefs
sought for, and the writ petition, being devoid of merit and
substance, deserves to be dismissed with costs. In view of the
aforesaid submissions, the answering respondents pray that the
instant writ petition be dismissed.
5.
The present writ petition calls in question the legality and validity
of the order dated 13.05.2019 (Annexure P-3), whereby
respondent No. 3, acting suo motu, cancelled the earlier order
dated 08.09.2017 granting the petitioner regular pay scale from
the date of his initial appointment and further directed recovery of
the alleged excess payment. The petitioner has also assailed the
consequential denial of promotion from the post of Assistant
Grade-III
to
Assistant
Grade-II,
alleging
arbitrariness,
discrimination and violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India.
6.
From perusal of the record, it is not in dispute that the petitioner
was appointed on compassionate grounds to the post of Assistant
Grade-III vide order dated 28.02.2014 and joined service on
13.03.2014. The appointment order clearly stipulated that the
appointee was required to acquire Hindi Typing / Computer
knowledge / examination / diploma within a period of two years or
earlier, and till fulfillment of the said condition, regular pay scale
was not to be granted. The language employed in the
appointment order makes it manifest that the condition was
framed in the alternative, namely, Hindi Typing or Computer
qualification. The relevant condition, as stipulated in the
appointment order, is reproduced hereunder for ready reference:
"नि यनिु
के शቔኔ :-
1) छ्ቈीसगढ़ शास , सामान्य ्ቚशास
मं्ቔालय,
रायपुर
4/2002/1-3/नि
के
परिरप्ቔ
नि भाग,
्ቅमांक/एफ-7-
ांक 17.02.2004 की कंडि#का-
3 के अ ुसार सहायक ्ቇे#-3 के प पर काय' भार
्ቇहण कर े के नि
ांक से मान्यቔኔा ्ቚा् संस्था से
निहन् ी मु्ቖलेख / कम्प्यट
ू र का ्ሺा
/ परी्ቌा /
डि#प्लोमा संबंधी अह' ቔኔा ्ቚमाण प्ቔ 02
्ቧ' की
काला डिध में या इसके पू ' जो भी पहले हो उ्ቈीण'
कर ा होगा। जब ቔኔक
े निहन् ी मु्ቖलेख
ए ं
कम्प्यट
ू र का ्ሺा / परी्ቌा / डि#प्लोमा संबंधी अह' ቔኔा
परी्ቌा उ्ቈीण'
हीं करेंगे ቔኔब ቔኔक उन्हें सहायक
्ቇे#-3 के ेቔኔ मा
का नि म् ቔኔम ेቔኔ
ቔኔथा भ्ቈे
निहन् ी मु्ቖलेख
परी्ቌा ए ं
्ቚा् होगें।
2) यनि
े उपयु
कम्प्यट
ू र का ्ሺा / परी्ቌा / डि#प्लोमा संबंधी परी्ቌा
नि धा'रिरቔኔ अ धी में उ्ቈीण' कर ले े के स
ू रे नि
से
सहायक ्ቇे#-3 के प पर ो ्ቧ' की परिर ी्ቌा पर
नि यु
निकया जा ेगा साथ ही इ की
नि यनिमቔኔ ेቔኔ मा में नि यनिु
के नि
रिर्ቔኔा
ांक से नि धा'रिरቔኔ
की जा ेगी।"
7.
It is further evident from the record that prior to his appointment,
the petitioner had already obtained a computer diploma/certificate
from a recognized university on 30.06.2013, which was duly
placed
before
the
respondent
authorities.
Taking
into
consideration the said qualification and after due verification,
respondent No. 3 passed a conscious and reasoned order dated
08.09.2017 granting the petitioner regular pay scale with effect
from the date of his initial appointment i.e. 13.03.2014. The said
order was acted upon and remained operative for a considerable
period.
Once the competent authority, after examining the
eligibility and qualification of the petitioner, found him suitable and
granted the benefit of regular pay scale, the subsequent
cancellation of the said benefit vide order dated 13.05.2019 is ex
facie
arbitrary
and
unsustainable
in
law. The
impugned
cancellation proceeds on the premise that the petitioner had not
cleared the Hindi typing examination, ignoring the admitted
position that the appointment condition itself permitted compliance
either through Hindi typing or computer qualification. The
respondents, having accepted the computer certificate as
sufficient compliance in the year 2017, are estopped from
reopening the issue on a hyper-technical ground at a later stage.
8.
This Court is of the considered opinion that once the petitioner
was found eligible on the basis of the computer certificate and
regular pay scale was granted after due application of mind, the
same could not have been withdrawn subsequently on the ground
that the petitioner had not passed Hindi typing examination. Such
an action amounts to review of a concluded issue without any
statutory authority and is hit by the principles of fairness and
certainty in administrative decision-making. Additionally, the
impugned order dated 13.05.2019 has been passed without
issuance of any show-cause notice and without affording an
opportunity of hearing to the petitioner, despite the fact that the
order entails serious civil consequences, including recovery of
alleged excess payment. The action is thus in clear violation of
the principles of natural justice and cannot be sustained on this
ground alone.
9.
Insofar as the denial of promotion is concerned, the record reveals
that
the
petitioner’s
name
consistently
appeared
in
the
seniority/gradation lists issued from time to time and he was even
placed within the zone of consideration for promotion, as evident
from the communication dated 01.09.2020 seeking ACRs and
other details. The subsequent omission of the petitioner’s name
and denial of promotion, while granting promotion to juniors, is a
direct consequence of the illegal cancellation of regular pay scale
and alleged non-regularization, which itself has been found to be
unsustainable. Once the cancellation order dated 13.05.2019 is
held to be illegal, the consequential actions flowing therefrom,
including denial of consideration for promotion and deletion of the
petitioner’s name from gradation lists, cannot survive. The
respondents are duty-bound to consider the petitioner’s case for
promotion in accordance with law, on the basis of his seniority and
eligibility, without being influenced by the quashed order.
10.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court holds that the order
dated 13.05.2019 (Annexure P-3), cancelling the earlier order
dated 08.09.2017 and directing recovery, is per se illegal, arbitrary
and unsustainable, and is hereby quashed. Consequently, the
order dated 08.09.2017 granting regular pay scale to the
petitioner from the date of initial appointment stands restored. The
respondents are further directed to restore all consequential
service benefits to the petitioner and to consider his case for
promotion from the post of Assistant Grade-III to Assistant GradeII strictly in accordance with law, within a reasonable period,
preferably within three months from the date of receipt of a copy
of this order.
11.
The writ petition is accordingly allowed to the extent indicated
above.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
JUDGE
Shayna
The date when The date when The date when the judgment is
the judgment is the judgment is uploaded on the website
reserved
pronounced
05.02.2026
13.02.2026
Operative
Full
13.02.2026
13.02.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review