Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 19.02.2026
Pronounced on: 31.03.2026
HCP No. 92/2025
Showkat Ahmad Dar
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. Wajid Haseeb, Advocate.
Vs.
Union Territory of J&K and Ors.
.….Respondents
Through:
Coram :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well as
for the respondents.
2.
Perused the writ pleadings and the documents
therewith from both ends. Also perused the detention
record produced for inspection of this Court.
3.
The petitioner Showkat Ahmad Dar, a 29 years’ aged
young man acting through is wife Mst. Sabreena Jan age
27 years came forward with the present petition filed on
13.05.2025, thereby seeking issuance of a writ of habeas
corpus
for
restoration
of
his
personal
liberty
with
quashment of a preventive detention order passed against
him by the respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar,
under Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978.
4.
By virtue of order No.DMS/PSA/06-2025 dated
26.04.2025, the respondent No.2-District Magistrate,
Srinagar, held the petitioner liable for suffering preventive
detention in order to prevent him from acting in manner
prejudicial to maintenance of Security of the State.
5.
was
The respondent No.2- District Magistrate, Srinagar
approached
by
the
respondent
No.3-
Senior
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Srinagar, with a dossier
submitted through vide letter No.Lgl/Det/2025/1212932 dated 09.04.2025, wherein materially is said to have
been submitted with respect to the petitioner thereby
reporting the alleged objectionable state of activities on the
part of the petitioner reckoned by District Police to be
prejudicial to the maintenance of Security of the State.
6.
The respondent No.3- Senior Superintendent of Police
(SSP), Srinagar, in his dossier referred the petitioner
working as salesmen at a Dry Fruit Shop of one Riyaz
Ahmad Rather at Nishat Srinagar, and thereafter working
as courier boy with Ecom express at 90 feet road Soura
Srinagar. The petitioner was impliedly linked with radical
social media handle on Facebook glamorizing terrorism
and luring young minds towards anti-national activities
with suspicion led to an action on the part of Police
Station
JIC
CIK,
Humhama
on
17.03.2025,
with
apprehension of the suspect along with his device which
revealed a Facebook account, “Shaddy Kashmir Dry
Fruits” along with incriminating material on the basis
whereof the petitioner was detained apprehending that he
would indulge in unlawful activities by uploading further
material having direct threats to Security of UT of Jammu
and Kashmir. This development is said to have resulted in
initiation of proceedings under section 126/170 of
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita BNSS, as is written
in the dossier without full form of BNSS being mentioned
therein as to what its stands for.
7.
The petitioner’s criminal bent of indulgence was
referred to by his alleged involvement in FIR No. 39/2019
registered
by
Police
Station
Harwan
and
FIR
No.
126/2023
registered
by
the
Police
Station
Nishat,
Srinagar but by reference to both of which, the petitioner
is said to have been granted bail.
8.
In the dossier, the petitioner’s state of personal liberty
was reckoned to be risky for public peace and order but
detention was sought to prevent him from acting in any
manner prejudicial to the security of State.
9.
By making a verbatim reproduction of the dossier the
respondent
No.2-
District
Magistrate,
Srinagar
rechristened the reproduction of dossier as grounds of
detention for deriving purported subjective satisfaction
therefrom that curtailment of the petitioner’s personal
liberty is imperative as the normal law has not been found
sufficient to stop the petitioner from indulging in activities
highly prejudicial to security of State so as to prevent the
society from violence, strikes, economic adversity and
social indiscipline.
10. Pursuant
to
the
said
detention
order
No.DMS/PSA/6/25 dated 26.04.2025, the petitioner was
arrested and taken into custody by S.I Farooq Ahmad of
Police Station Nishat, on 29.04.2025 and handed over the
person of the petitioner to the Superintendent of District
Jail, Udhampur.
11. At the time of effecting the arrest and detention of the
petitioner, he is said to have been delivered compilation of
documents in the form of warrant of arrest, notice of
detention, grounds of detention, copy of dossier, copy of
FIRs/statements
of
witnesses
and
other
relevant
document relating to detention with total compilation
being of 46 leaves.
12. The petitioner is said to have been read over in
English the contents of grounds of detention and also
explained
in
the
language
of
the
petitioner
being
Urdu/Kashmiri. The petitioner is said to have been
apprised of his right to make a representation to the
Government against the detention order.
13. The arrest and
detention
of
the petitioner on
29.04.2025 was followed by passing of Government Order
No.Home/PB-V/711/2025 dated 29.04.2025, thereby
approving the detention order No.DMS/PSA/06/2025
dated 26.04.2025, and the case forwarded for the opinion
of the Advisory Board, which came to tender its opinion on
19.05.2025, holding the preventive detention of the
petitioner resting on sufficiency of material with sufficient
cause to justify the detention of the petitioner.
14. By virtue of Government Order No. Home/PBV/992/2025 dated 22.05.2025, the petitioners’ detention
was confirmed with first installment of detention period
being prescribed for six months w.e.f 29.04.2025 to
28.10.2025 with place of detention being the District Jail,
Udhampur.
15. It is during first six month’s detention period that the
petitioner had come forward with the institution of present
writ petition on 13.05.2025 by challenging the detention
on the grounds as set out para 3(I) to (XV).
16. The petitioner has pleaded that grounds of detention
have no nexus with the petitioner and same have been
fabricated by the Police to implicate the petitioner. The
petitioner has come to the extent of saying that passing of
detention order against him seems to be a case of
mistaken identity because the petitioner is remotely
related or relatable to and with any of alleged state of
activities referred in the dossier as well as in the grounds
of detention.
17. The petitioners submits that during his questioning
in the Police Station CIK he had given explanation on the
basis whereof he was let off only to be proceeded by
reference
to
section
of the
Bharatiya
Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023. The petitioner assails the
grounds of detention as being vague and non-existent on
which no prudent man could make a representation
against such nature and type of allegations. The petitioner
asserts that
there is no specificity in the entire dossier
as well as in the grounds of detention.
18. The petitioner submits that he has no knowledge of
his involvement in FIR No.126/2023 of the Police Station
Nishat, but nevertheless the petitioners submits that he
has been granted bail by the court of law and therefore
said FIR could not have been cited as basis for detention
order.
19. The petitioner submits that his right to make an
effective representation has been seriously prejudiced by
the non supply of full material on the basis whereof the
respondent
No.2-
District
Magistrate
Srinagar,
had
exercised his application of mind.
20. The petitioner has in very bold tone asserted that he
was not at all apprised about his right to make a
representation to the detention order making authority
and also not informed as to which Government he was to
make the representation.
21. The petitioner submits that he is not an English
language knowing person and, therefore, the entire
compilation of detention record being in English left him
handicapped to make a representation so whatever the
material was available to him on that basis he has made a
representation which has remained unconsidered and unresponded till date of filing of the writ petition.
22. Counter affidavit to the writ petition came to be filed
on
17.09.2025
by
the
respondent
No.2-
District
Magistrate Srinagar, who prima facie seems to be not
the author of the detention order because same is by
his predecessor-in-office.
23. In the counter affidavit, the respondent No.2District Magistrate Srinagar, has come forward denying
the assertions and averments made in the writ petition
from the end of the petitioner. It is submitted in the
counter affidavit that petitioner was a chronic stone pelter
and trouble monger besides being a radical social media
user in district Srinagar related to a radical social media
handle on Facebook “Shady Kashmir” Dry Fruits which
was uploading and sharing extremist content to glamorize
terrorism and lure young minds towards anti national
activities. It is in said state of alleged activities that the
petitioner
is
said
to
have
been
apprehended
on
17.03.2025 by the Police Station CIK JIC Humhama and
his mobile device was recovered from him along with
incriminating material on the basis whereof the petitioner
was subjected to proceedings under section 126/170 of
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023.
24. The counter affidavit further refers to involvement of
the petitioner in case FIR No.39/2019 of the Police
Station Harwan Srinagar, and FIR No.126/2023 under
section 188 IPC and section 9 of COBA Act of the Police
Station Nishat Srinagar. In the counter affidavit, the
respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar, has not
explained the full form and name of COBA Act. The
counter affidavit further submits that all procedure
compliances were carried out.
25. Now, coming to examination of legality of the
detention of the petitioner both by reference to the
procedural side as well as to the purpose side, this Court
at the very first instance negates the plea of the petitioner
that by not disclosing to him the fact that he had a right of
making representation against his detention to the
detaining authority he has suffered a prejudice.
26. In this regard, the petitioner himself has annexed
representation dated 08.05.2025 made on his behalf by
his wife against preventive detention to none else than to
the
respondent
No.2-
District
Magistrate
Srinagar,
received on 09.05.2025.
27. Even if the petitioner was not apprised of his
entitlement to make a representation against his detention
to detention order making authority still the petitioner
having
made
said
representation
lost
no
right
of
representation.
28. Now, coming to the references with respect to the
alleged activities in involvement of the petitioner under
FIR No.39/2019 and FIR No.126/2023, the petitioner
came to be bailed out for the simple reason that he was
booked for the offences which were bail-able ones. The
petitioner is then being referred to have been subjected to
proceeding under section 126/170 of Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023 on two occasions i.e. on
17.03.2025 and 27.03.2025.
29. It is this reference which is so contradictory and self
defeating that it punctures the very dossier served against
the petitioner on the basis whereof the respondent No.2District Magistrate Srinagar, actually acted upon. If it is to
be assumed that the proceeding under section 126/170 of
Bharatiya
Nagarik
Suraksha
Sanhita
(BNSS)
initiated on 17.03.2025, led to its logical end with final
order passed by an Executive Magistrate concerned and
competent in that regard, then why without forfeiture of
said bond, personal as well as surety, the proceedings on
second occasion on 27.03.2025 came to be taken up by
the same very Police Station JIC CIK Humahma. It thus,
clearly that means that on both occasions proceedings
were initiated under section
126/170 of Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023 but both were not
taken to logical conclusion so as to constitute a valid basis
and point of reference that the petitioner is least bothered
to honour ordinary mandate of law of keeping peace in the
context for which he was proceeded against.
30. Thus, when the proceedings under section 126/170
of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) 2023 were
not able to earn a final order against the petitioner for
whatsoever reason that may be, then a switch overly the
District Police and District Magistracy to a preventive
detention mode of curtailing personal liberty of petitioner
is quite a quantum leap of judgment creating an apparent
mismatch which can be symbolized with killing of ant,
with sledge-hammer.
31. Thus, the District Police Srinagar was not to be
rewarded for its failure to take the very essential nature of
126 and 170 Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS)
2023 proceedings to the logical end before the executive
Magistrate concerned to prevent and check the petitioner
from his alleged state of activities.
32. This Court is purposely avoiding reference to the
alleged states of proceedings undertaken before and by the
Executive Magistrate 1st Class Humhama by reference to
section 126 and 170 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita
(BNSS)
as
on
both
occasions
the
proceedings are nothing but in sheer embarrassment to
the letter and spirit of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita (BNSS) 2023, and the provisions in reference.
33. The most serious flaw that this Court is finding with
respect to default of procedural compliance attending the
detention
of
communication
the
petitioner
is
that
while
in
No.DMS/PSA/Jud/30-35/2025
his
dated
26.04.2025 by the respondent No.2- District Magistrate
Srinagar in addressing to the petitioner and meaning to
apprise him therein that he may make a representation
against order of detention to the under-signed that is the
respondent No.2- District Magistrate Srinagar and to the
Government as he may desire, but when it came to the
matter of reading the grounds of detention order notice,
the Executive Officer S.I Faroq Ahmad No.896/AP, 9th,
PID No.ARP-972762 of the Police Station Nishat was
apprising
the
petitioner
that
he
could
make
a
representation to the Government against detention order
and that is what the petitioner in his receipt of grounds of
detention has also acknowledged that he has been
informed of his right to make representation to the
Government.
34. Thus, the execution report of PSA warrant and receipt
of grounds of detention document of the same date
29.04.2025 were there to be read as it when the
Government had send the detention file of the petitioner to
the Advisory Board on 29.04.2025 for its consideration
and opinion.
35. At this stage this Court is lost to figure out as to
whether the document of execution of the detention
warrant dated 29.04.2025 and receipt of grounds of
detention executed by the petitioner were ever forwarded
by the Advisory Board or not.
36. This Court has reason that the same were not put
forward to the Advisory Board otherwise Advisory Board
would not have taken it for granted and making a mention
in its opinion report that the petitioner was apprised his
right of making representation against his detention to the
detaining authority as also to the Government. Thus, even
the Advisory Board was not fully kept in a loop by the
Home Department of Jammu and Kashmir and thus
covered up a serious defect in the execution of the
detention warrant upon the petitioner.
37. In the light of the aforesaid, this Court cannot lend its
constitutional nod to continuing detention of the petitioner
which is afflicted with serious procedural deficiency and
defect at the end of the Government for the reasons best
known to it.
38. Therefore, detention order No.DMS/PSA/06/2025
dated
26.04.2025
read
with
approval/confirmation/extension order passed at the end
of government of UT of Jammu and Kashmir through its
Home Department are hereby quashed. The petitioner is
directed to be restored his personal liberty by his release
from the concerned jail wherever he is being kept confined
and to this effect Superintendent concerned to abide by
the writ hereby issued.
39. Disposed of.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
Srinagar
31.03.2026
Opinder
Whether the judgment is speaking : Yes / No
Whether the judgment is reportable : Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review