The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. The Commissioner and Secretary, Education Department Government of Meghalaya, Shri. P. Bakshi, IAS, as also his predecessor, Dr. B.D.R. Tiwari, it is noted, in the conduct of enquiry on several dates, had summoned all the stake holders, in the several cases that had been filed before this Court and they were also examined in person, apart from being allowed opportunity of being heard and also for submission of any final relevant documents. Relevant documents had been submitted including originals for the purpose of enquiry, which was relied upon, as also the submissions and statements made by all the teachers of the school, Head Teacher, members and Chairman of the School Managing Committee, officials of the Education Department and other litigant parties. School attendance registers, reports of earlier enquiries, conducted at various levels had also been examined, and as recorded on 22nd June, 2023, all litigants and concerned parties had made further statements, in addition to the earlier statements and documents apart from being subject to cross-examination on the submissions. In the considered view of this Court, the enquiry had arrived at the findings, as recorded in the report in a fair and transparent manner, wherein all the parties concerned were afforded adequate opportunity. In these circumstances therefore, the report is accepted in its totality, as also the suggesti…
15. As such, without lingering or dwelling any longer, on the facts, claims and counter claims of the parties individually, in these batch of writ petitions, the same are disposed of with the following directions: (i) As Shri. Nurul Amin, has been found not to be a teacher, occupying a sanctioned post, and terminated from service on 9th February, 2021, as per the Resolution of the same date, and further having indulged in disruptive activities such as, filing of fabricated documents, which has dislocated the functioning of the school as recorded in the report, appropriate action as per relevant rules and in accordance with law, both civil and criminal shall be initiated against him, both by the Managing Committee, as well as, by the District School Education Officer, West Garo Hills, within a period of 8(eight) weeks, from the date of this order. (ii) Smti. Ela Begum Laskar, in her capacity as Joint DMC and DMC, having acted in a manner, which is prejudicial and damaging to the school, and the office she occupied, appropriate disciplinary proceedings shall be drawn up against her by the Director of School Education & Literacy, Government of Meghalaya, Shillong. (iii) As 3 teachers namely, Shobuza Begum, Shri. Abdul Rafique and Smti. Nazila Begum, are the rightful sanctioned teachers of Khetadhowa SSA UP School, all outstanding salaries and benefits is to be released to them immedia…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 383 of 2017 with
WP(C) No. 264 of 2020
WP(C) No. 456 of 2021
WP(C) No. 460 of 2021
WP(C) No. 464 of 2021
WP(C) No. 119 of 2022
WP(C) No. 147 of 2022
Date of Decision: 24.11.2023
Smti. Nazila Begum
Vs.
Shri. Nurul Amin
Vs.
Shri. Joyan Ali
Vs.
Smti. Shobuza Begum & Anr.
Vs.
Smti. Shobuza Begum & Anr.
Vs.
The School Managing Committee,
Vs.
Khetadhowa SSA UP School, Bhaitbari
Nurul Amin
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting)
Appearance:
In WP(C) No. 383 of 2017
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Abraham, GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Ms. I. Lyngwa, GA(For R 1 & 2)
Ms. P. Agarwal, Adv. (For R 4).
In WP(C) No. 264 of 2020
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Ms. P. Agarwal, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Abraham, GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Ms. I. Lyngwa, GA(For R 1-3)
Mr. S. Deb, Adv. (For R 4)
In WP(C) No. 456 of 2021
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Abraham, GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Ms. I. Lyngwa, GA(For R 1-6)
Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv. (For R 7 & 8).
In WP(C) No. 460 of 2021
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Abraham, GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Ms. I. Lyngwa, GA(For R 1-6)
Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv. (For R 7).
In WP(C) No. 464 of 2021
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Abraham, GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Ms. I. Lyngwa, GA(For R 1-6)
Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv. (For R 7 & 8).
In WP(C) No. 119 of 2022
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Abraham, GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Ms. I. Lyngwa, GA(For R 1 & 2)
Mr. S. Deb, Adv. (For R 3).
In WP(C) No. 147 of 2022
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Abraham, GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Ms. I. Lyngwa, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
These matters where the common issue involves the service of
the teachers of Khetadhowa SSA UP School, are being taken up and
disposed of by this common order and judgment.
2.
The genesis of the controversy which has engulfed the school
which has seen multiple and protracted litigation repeatedly before this
Court, with claims and counter claims which had become difficult to
adjudicate, occasioned for an order of this Court dated 07.02.2023 to be
passed, directing for a full-fledged enquiry to be instituted by the
Commissioner and Secretary, Education Department. Pursuant to the
said order, and after grant of extension of time, for completion of the
enquiry, the report was submitted on 21st July, 2023.
3.
Before adverting to the report, which is detailed and
conclusive, it is relevant to note herein that, due to the disputes that have
arisen, coupled with unauthorized and illegal actions of some of the
players herein, both from the official side, as well as the teachers, the
salaries of the rightful recipients amongst the teachers have been
withheld. A case in point is WP(C) No. 383 of 2017, wherein the
petitioner, who is a sanctioned teacher namely Smti. Nazila Begum, has
not been paid her salary from the month of January 2021, till date.
Subsequently, as it appears from the records, the operation of the
account of the school was also suspended, as there was no valid school
Managing Committee in existence. Further, the controversy became
more pronounced and complicated due to the rival claims, as to who
were the sanctioned teachers in the said school.
4.
The enquiry report which has been furnished has however,
clarified the issues in contention, and has shed light as to the nature of
the controversy involved in the said school. In this context therefore,
this Court finds it expedient and necessary to rely upon the same in the
adjudication of these cases.
5.
As per the report, the history of disputes between the teachers
and the Managing Committee of Khetadhowa SSA UP School, involves
three significant phases:-
6.
(i)
First Phase – February 2010 - January 2017
(ii)
Second Phase – February 2017 - 27th September, 2019
(iii)
Third Phase – 28th September, 2019 - 5th February, 2021.
In the First Phase, the school was brought under SSA in
February 2010, and it was instructed by the District Mission
Coordinator (DMC), that the school Managing Committee should be
constituted, and three teachers, that is, (i) One Language teacher, (ii)
One Science and Mathematics teacher, and (iii) One Hindi teacher with
Diploma, was to be appointed. The same was done vide a Resolution
dated 03.03.2010, and four teachers, were appointed namely one
Giasuddin Ahmed, as Head Teacher, Abdul Goffur Khan and Abdul
Rafique as Assistant Teachers, and one Nurul Amin as Hindi Teacher.
However, on the resignation of Shri. Abdul Goffur Khan, the Managing
Committee appointed Smti. Nazila Begum as Language Teacher, and
thereafter, on the resignation of the Head Teacher, Shri. Giasuddin
Ahmed, Smti. Shobuza Begum, BSc was appointed as Head Teacher. It
is to be noted that, all the teachers including Nurul Amin, had endorsed
her appointment.
7.
As the fulfillment of National Council for Teachers Education
(NCTE) norms was made mandatory, the school Managing Committee
of the school, in its meeting dated 06.04.2014, decided to give three
years’ time to its teachers to acquire the said qualification. As per the
meeting dated 03.05.2015, it was reported that, three teachers of the
school, had fulfilled the required NCTE norms, and these were Smti.
Shobuza Begum, Shri. Abdul Rafiq and Smti. Nazila Begum. As
recorded in the enquiry report, Shri. Nurul Amin, failed to acquire the
required qualification, to fulfil NCTE norms, during that period of time
and was present in the meeting dated 03.05.2015, as a teacher
representative, when all the decisions were taken. Thereafter, with the
advent of the ‘Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education’
(RTE), the permissible number of teachers as per SSA UP School norms
was 3 in number, one for Language, one for Science and Mathematics,
and one for Social Studies.
8.
The Second Phase, as per the report, then witnessed the origin
of the controversy, as Shri. Nurul Amin, started claiming himself to be
the Language Teacher, the Senior Most Teacher and also Head Teacher,
from the year 2017. This it appears, was on the basis of a purported
approval order issued by one Shri. T.S. Sangma, the then In-charge Joint
DMC, who was not authorized nor empowered to issue the same. It is
noted that, in this regard, a show-cause notice was issued to the said
Thomas S. Sangma, on 29.10.2019, by the competent authority, for his
illegal action. The controversy was then compounded due to the actions
of another Joint DMC, namely Smti. Ela Begum Laskar, who then
issued orders in favour of Shri. Nurul Amin, such as, by declaring him
to be the Language Teacher, apart from the Senior most and Head
Teacher. Thereafter, the Managing Committee with Smti. Shobuza
Begum, as the ex-officio member convener, was also dissolved by Smti.
Ela Begum Laskar, and a new Managing Committee with Nurul Amin,
as ex-officio member convener, was approved. Though complaints were
made, as to the illegal constitution of the said Managing Committee,
which was formed without a general public meeting being called,
contradictory resolutions were passed by this Committee, which were
approved by Smti. Ela Begum Laskar, in her capacity as Joint DMC. As
recorded in the report, Shri. Nurul Amin, allegedly mis-appropriated
school funds and also deducted the salary of Smti. Nazila Begum, which
compelled her to file WP(C) No. 383 of 2017. In this period, another
writ petition being WP(C) No. 30 of 2018, was also filed for dissolution
of the Managing Committee, approved by Smti. Ela Begum Laskar,
wherein Shri. Nurul Amin, was made the ex-officio member convener.
9.
The Third Phase, in the sequence of events commenced with
the State Project Director SSA Shillong, directing for a detailed enquiry
about the irregularities in the school, on receipt of complaints vide order
dated 28.09.2019, to ascertain the correct position. In the said order, it
was also directed that ample opportunity be given to all the stake
holders, to file their claims and counter claims with relevant documents.
On notices being issued, all concerned respondents except Nurul Amin
replied, and who, even after 3 notices were issued, instead wrote to the
DMC, asking for revocation of the notices, which on being refused,
even wrote to the State Project Director, asking him to revoke the letter
dated 28.09.2019, by which the enquiry had been ordered. The enquiry
authority, that is, the DMC Tura, then as no replies were forthcoming,
obtained all the relevant documents from the office of the Joint DMC,
Shri. R.K. Hajong, whereafter, a detailed report was prepared and
submitted to the State Project Director SSA, vide letter dated
06.02.2020.
10.
As per the materials and the report, the DMC Tura, on the
directions of the State Project Director SSA, then vide letter dated
02.03.2020, declared that the claim of Shri. Nurul Amin, as a Language
Teacher, Senior Most Teacher and Head Teacher, was untenable, as
compared to the claim of Smti. Nazila Begum, as Language Teacher,
and Smti. Shobuza Begum as Head Teacher. However, the events took
another twist, inasmuch as, Smti. Ela Begum Laskar, on assuming
charge as In-charge DMC, once again, by an order dated 13.05.2021,
first kept in abeyance the enquiry report dated 06.02.2020, and also
order dated 02.03.2020, passed by her predecessor, and subsequently
passed an order dated 04.08.2021, nullifying the enquiry report and
order dated 03.02.2020. It is noted that as per the report, the said
enquiry report dated 06.02.2020, and order dated 02.03.2020, as per the
claim of Smti. Ela Begum Laskar, was cancelled pursuant to the
findings of a meeting allegedly conducted on 04.08.2021, which
however, was found out to be false on an enquiry conducted by the
Administrative Officer SSA(E), on directions from the State Project
Director.
11.
It is then seen that in this continuing saga, in the said school,
amidst the intense litigation, as per the report, and which is evidenced
by material documents, a forged document that is, a letter dated
13.05.2021, was annexed by Shri. Nurul Amin in WP(C) No. 119 of
2021, which was with regard to the term of the Managing Committee.
This was then compounded by the same document being annexed by the
State respondents, which however, when the same was detected was
corrected by the Government Advocate, who in his letter dated
28.07.2022, stated that the same was done so inadvertently.
12.
What can be gleaned from the report, on the facts as placed
above, is that, the entire dispute had arisen from the time that Shri.
Nurul Amin, claimed that he was the duly appointed Language Teacher
and not Smti. Nazila Begum, and further, that being the founder teacher,
was the Head Teacher and not Smti. Shobuza Begum. This Court, has
thoroughly examined the enquiry report dated 21.07.2023, and all the
supporting documents which have been annexed to the said report, on
which the findings have been rendered. The findings concisely put are
as below:(i)
The root of the problem of the Khetadhowa SSA UP
School, is because of the claim made by Shri. Nurul
Amin, that he is the Head Teacher, being a founder
Teacher, and that he is also the Language Teacher. This
controversy came about, on account of the new NCTE
norms, that they could be only one teacher each for
Language, Social Science and Mathematics.
(ii)
When Smit. Nazila Begum, was appointed as a
Language Teacher, and Smti. Shobuza Begum, as
Science and Mathematics Teacher in 2010, Shri. Nurul
Amin, never raised any grievance at that stage, and in
fact, on merits has no case, as he was never appointed
against the sanctioned posts.
(iii)
It is evident from the circumstances, that Shri. Nurul
Amin, became active after the illegal approval order was
granted by the then I/c Joint DMC, Shri. T.S. Sangma,
and when subsequently Smti. Ela Begum Laskar,
occupied the said post. He never responded to the
enquiry to seek to establish his position.
(iv)
That Shri. Nurul Amin, allegedly was found to be
embezzling SSA funds, and never took any steps to reply
to the allegations and rather than reply chose to
challenge the authority of the official, who had instituted
the enquiry, which raised sufficient suspicion, as to his
acts of commission and omission. The matter is all the
more serious, as Nurul Amin, had even submitted fake
documents to substantiate his claims.
(v)
Shri. Nurul Amin, failed to acquire the required
qualification, to fulfill NCTE norms, and at that time,
when the 3 teachers, were appointed against the
sanctioned post namely Shobuza Begum, Abdul Rafique
and Nazila Begum, he had attended the Managing
Committed meeting held on 03.05.2015, and as a
participant of the proceedings, was therefore party to all
the decisions taken.
(vi)
From the records submitted, Shri. Nurul Amin, attended
his duties in the school w.e.f. his date of joining from
05.03.2010 to June, 2017, and remained absent from his
duty from July 2017 to 8th February, 2022, whereafter,
he was terminated from service on 09.02.2021, no reply
was given by him nor the charges rebutted.
(vii) During the period, Shri. Nurul Amin, was the convener
member, the salaries of Shobuza Begum and Nazila
Begum were deducted in an unauthorized manner, which
led them to file writ petitions before the High Court,
which resulted in a situation, where salaries have not
been paid to teachers, who are regularly attending to
their duties in the school.
(viii) With regard to the role of officials in the Education
Department in complicating the matters, the role of Smti.
Ela Begum Laskar, in her capacity as Joint DMC and
DMC, is questionable, as she has passed many arbitrary
orders favouring Shri. Nurul Amin, and also her enquiry
reports, appear to be suspect and not in order. In the
enquiry, she accepted that it was difficult for her to
understand the rules. It is further remarked in the enquiry
report that, Smti. Ela Begum Laskar may be cautioned.
13.
Apart from the findings indicated above, the report has also
noted serious areas of concern that need to be addressed, such as, the
manner of functioning of the Managing Committee and also the manner
and method of selection and appointment of teachers.
14.
The Commissioner and Secretary, Education Department
Government of Meghalaya, Shri. P. Bakshi, IAS, as also his
predecessor, Dr. B.D.R. Tiwari, it is noted, in the conduct of enquiry on
several dates, had summoned all the stake holders, in the several cases
that had been filed before this Court and they were also examined in
person, apart from being allowed opportunity of being heard and also
for submission of any final relevant documents. Relevant documents
had been submitted including originals for the purpose of enquiry,
which was relied upon, as also the submissions and statements made by
all the teachers of the school, Head Teacher, members and Chairman of
the School Managing Committee, officials of the Education Department
and other litigant parties. School attendance registers, reports of earlier
enquiries, conducted at various levels had also been examined, and as
recorded on 22nd June, 2023, all litigants and concerned parties had
made further statements, in addition to the earlier statements and
documents apart from being subject to cross-examination on the
submissions. In the considered view of this Court, the enquiry had
arrived at the findings, as recorded in the report in a fair and transparent
manner, wherein all the parties concerned were afforded adequate
opportunity. In these circumstances therefore, the report is accepted in
its totality, as also the suggestions given therein to finally give a quietus
to the disputes in Khetadhowa SSA UP School, and to bring to a closure
all the pending writ petitions before this Court, concerning the present
dispute.
15.
As such, without lingering or dwelling any longer, on the facts,
claims and counter claims of the parties individually, in these batch of
writ petitions, the same are disposed of with the following directions:
(i)
As Shri. Nurul Amin, has been found not to be a teacher,
occupying a sanctioned post, and terminated from
service on 9th February, 2021, as per the Resolution of
the same date, and further having indulged in disruptive
activities such as, filing of fabricated documents, which
has dislocated the functioning of the school as recorded
in the report, appropriate action as per relevant rules and
in accordance with law, both civil and criminal shall be
initiated against him, both by the Managing Committee,
as well as, by the District School Education Officer,
West Garo Hills, within a period of 8(eight) weeks, from
the date of this order.
(ii)
Smti. Ela Begum Laskar, in her capacity as Joint DMC
and DMC, having acted in a manner, which is prejudicial
and damaging to the school, and the office she occupied,
appropriate disciplinary proceedings shall be drawn up
against her by the Director of School Education &
Literacy, Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
(iii)
As 3 teachers namely, Shobuza Begum, Shri. Abdul
Rafique and Smti. Nazila Begum, are the rightful
sanctioned teachers of Khetadhowa SSA UP School, all
outstanding salaries and benefits is to be released to
them immediately by the School Managing Committee.
(iv)
As the RTE norms are in place, the Managing
Committee shall be constituted as per the said norms to
be re-constituted every 2(two) years comprising of 75%
of the members, from amongst parents or guardians of
children studying in the school and 25% from elected
members of the local authority, teachers of the school
and local educationists.
(v)
All vacancies are to be compulsorily advertised by the
School Managing Committee and eligible candidates be
selected by way of test and interview.
16.
Accordingly, as per the discussions and as ordered herein
above, these writ petitions stand closed and disposed of.
17.
The report dated 21.07.2023, is made part of the records.
18.
A copy of this order to be furnished to Mr. H. Abraham,
learned GA for necessary action.
Chief Justice (Acting)
Meghalaya
24.11.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review