Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
$
%
&
'& (
"
"
!#
"
%
)*
&
)
+
!"!
#
$
%
&
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
'
(
'
'
!"!
)
#
$
&
'
$
&
"
!
'
$
$
*
'
+&
"
!
(
-2-
&
*
/
"$ &
*"!
'
+
'
'
$,& $--&$.&
'
''
)$ & "
!
'
'
+
324-4-5627 8..9:2;
<-=2;
41-:
:22>-6? -6427-@ ,8-= 56 @2;-.8= ?7596;: -6
!
"
$87-:-6?
!
6-56 5< 6;-8
32.-8=
5<
8:2
7-@2
(
-:47-.4
-;87 72?-:4272; ,A 412
87.54-.
56475=
97289
6-4& 326;-6? 56 412 <-=2 5< 7-6.-38=
9;?2
324-4-56
86?8=572 (568=
-:47-.4 86;
2::-56:
-;87 <57 412 5<<26.2: 396-:18,=2 96;27
2.4-56:
"$.& 728; B-41
.4
2.4-56
$,&$--&$ &
!
)
" 86;
* 5<
*"!
4 -: .56426;2; ,A 412 =28762; .596:2= <57 412
324-4-5627 4184 412 324-4-5627 -: .187?2 :12242; <57 412
8<572@264-562; 5<<26.2: 8=56? B-41 54127 <597 8..9:2;
-3-
324-4-5627
15=2=-41-8:-:
-:
$ &
<8.-6?
-8,24-.
29753841A $ 78;2 & $ &
24-653841A
:27-59:
$ &
-;62A
8-=@264:
-:28:2 B-41
A327426:-56 B-41
'5==-.9=-4-:
5<
$!&
$ &
-8,24-.
A327426:-C2
=;
9=@5687A
9,27.9=5:-: 86; 12 18: ,226 96;27 72?9=87 @2;-.84-56 -6
26478=
7-:56 :5 8=:5 84
: :9.1 41-:
5974 C-;2 57;27 ;842;
5:3-48=
8=8,978?-
"
! .8==2;
<57 412 @2;-.8= 72.57;: 32748-6-6? 45 412 324-4-5627 <75@
2;-.8=
2;-.8=
9327-6426;264
.-26.2:
28.1-6?
5<
9=,87?8
6:4-4942
5:3-48= 84
5<
8=8,978?- 45
8:.2748-6 B124127 412 .1756-. 8-=@264: :9<<272; ,A 412
324-4-5627
@2;-.8=
47284@264
62.2::-484-6? 15:3-48=-E84-56 8: 86 -6384-264
..57;-6?=A
72D9-72:
9327-6426;264 5<
8;C86.2;
26478=
7-:56 18: <57B87;2; 412
@2;-.8= 723574 8=56? B-41 @2;-.8= 372:.7-34-56: 5< 412
324-4-5627 <57@ 412
2;-.8=
<<-.27 5<
26478=
7-:56
8=8,978?- B1-.1 728;: 8: 96;27
"
#$ %
!
# &
-4-
!
'() *
%+#,+ # - !
.
* / 0 1) 0
2&
!
'()
*
"
%+#,+ # % +# + # (
/ & # -%% -%&
0 !
%2
)
!
/
2 4
*
,2
/
./ 162
!
)
. )72
2 8
&
% #
# - .9
!
2&
"
!
'()
"
%:+# + # !
&
!
%:+# + # %+# + # (
/ & # -%-,:$&
0 !
)
!
"
!
*
!
/ 16
!
*
&
%+# + # -&
& 4
!
,#
)
8 1& 4
!
'() *
"
$+# + # 8 1
;*(1 / < # -#%%#= # 1
< $+# + # -&
&
!
'()
*
"
%+#-+ # !
8 1
;*(1 / < # -#%,%%= ,
< %+#-+ # -&
.)
0 8
8 1 2
&
!
'()
*
"
# +#=+ # !
-5-
!
8 1
<# +#=+ # -&
;*(1 / < # -#%
,-%
&
*
!
%#+#=+ # -
"
&
'()
!
'()
>
.)
5 ; 2
*
?
(
/ < # - ,#, &
!
*
!
)
!
"
!
?
!
%#+#=+ # %,+#=+ # -&
*
*
*
8 1
*
!
# +#9+ # -
"
8 1
<# +#9+ # -&
&
'()
;*(1 / < # -#%9,9 =
!
%:+#9+ # -
"
8 1
< %:+#9+ # -&
&
;*(1 / < # -#%$%=#
!
"
#+#:+ # ;*(1 / < # -# =#, 1
&
"
8 1
'()
'()
!
< #+#:+ # -&
!
%+#:+ # ;*(1 / < # -#
'()
!
=$-:
-6-
< %+#:+ # -&
0/
*
/
*
&
!
'()
#,+#$+ # !
8 1
;*(1 / < # -# #=#,
<#,+#$+ # -&
&
"
!
#+#$+ # 8 1
< #+#$+ # -&
&
"
!
/ < # -# =#%:$ 1
*
"
8 1
# -&
!
$+% + # ;*(1 / < # -#,-$,:
'()
!
;*(1
<
'()
!
$+% +
&
*
!
'()
% +#%+ # =
!
.
0 )
8 1
;*(1 / < # =##%%9 %
<% +#%+ # = 0
; ' 4
&
!
*
!
& (
/
&@
"
&
5B2C27 -6 412 :8-; 723574 -4 B8: :4842; 4184
F 56 412 .5@3=8-64 5< 8,;5@-68= 38-6 12 B8:
-7-
8;C-:2;
<57
,;5@26
86;
;248-=2;
-6C2:4-?84-56 86; 47284@264 B-== ,2 -6<57@2; 45 41-:
: :9.1 41-:
5974 56.2 8?8-6 .8==2; <57 412 :8-; 723574 56
*
F
9327-6426;264 5<
2;-.8=
.5@3=-86.2
5<
:8-;
57;27
26478= 7-:56 18: 56.2 8?8-6 <57B87;2;
23574 86; :4842; 412 372:264 128=41 .56;-4-56
5< 412 324-4-5627 C-;2 723574 ;842;
)
F
B1-.1
728;: 8: 96;27
"
#$ %
'() *
!
# &
!
%+#,+ # - !
.
* / 0 1) 0
2&
!
'()
*
"
%+#,+ # % +# + # (
/ & # -%% -%&
0 !
%2
)
!
/
2 4
*
,2
/
./ 162 !
)
. )72
2 8
&
% #
# - .9
!
2&
"
!
'()
%:+# + # !
&
!
%:+# + # %+# + # (
/
# -%-,:$&
0 !
"
-8-
)
!
!
!
!
*
*
"
/ 16
&
%+# + # -
& 4
!
,#
)
8 1 4
!
'() *
"
$+# + # 8 1
;*(1 /
# -#%%#= # 1
$+# + # -&
&
!
'()
*
"
%+#-+ # !
8 1
;*(1 / & # -#%,%%= ,
%+#-+ # -&
.)
0 8
8 1 2
&
!
'()
*
"
# +#=+ # !
!
8 1
;*(1 / < # -#% ,-%
<# +#=+ # -&
&
*
"
!
%#+#=+ # -
&
!
.)
5 ; 2
'() *
?
(
/ < # - ,#, &
!
*
!
)
!
"
!
?
!
%#+#=+ # %,+#=+ # -&
*
"
8 1
<# +#9+ # -&
!
# +#9+ # -
'()
>
'()
;*(1 / < # -#%9,9 =
-9-
&
*
!
%:+#9+ # -
"
8 1
< %:+#9+ # -&
&
*
8 1
"
;*(1 / &
'()
;*(1 /
# -#%$%=#
!
#+#:+ # # -# =#, 1
'()
!
#+#:+ # -&
&
*
"
8 1
%+#:+ # -&
!
%+#:+ # ;*(1 / < # -#
'()
!
=$-:
0/
*
/
&
!
'()
#,+#$+ # !
8 1
;*(1 / < # -# #=#,
<#,+#$+ # -&
&
"
!
/ < # -# =#%:$ 1
!
#+#$+ # 8 1
#+#$+ # -&
'()
!
;*(1
*
!
$+% + # -
'()
!
*
"
"
- 10 -
8 1
# -&
;*(1 / < # -#,-$,:
$+% +
&
!
*
"
%
'()
#%
# =
&
!
)
(
!
# #% # =
!
4;
% #% # =
/ < # =%-:#&
%2
"
!
/
(2
,2 *
!
*
2 A
-2 8
&
!
# #% # =&
&
&@
.'
6 3279:8= 5< 412:2 @2;-.8= 723574:
2C-;264
15=2=-41-8:-:
&
324-4-5627
-8,24-.
29753841A $ 78;2 &
24-653841A
&
-:
-;62A
:9<<27-6?
& '5==-.9=-4-: !&
=;
<75@
-:28:2 B-41
A327426:-56 B-41
9=@5687A
-4 -:
&
-8,24-.
A327426:-C2
9,27.9=5:-:
86; 412 -6@842 B8: 472842; .56:27C84-C2=A 86; 12 -:
72D9-72; 72?9=87 @2;-.84-56
4 -: :9,@-442; ,A 412 =28762;
.596:2= <57 412 324-4-5627 4184 -< 412 324-4-5627 -: 26=87?2;
56 ,8-= <57 8 =-@-42; 327-5;
412 324-4-5627 -6426; 45
- 11 -
96;27?5 :97?27A <57 >-;62A ;-:28:2 -6 8
26?8=979
5:3-48= 84
..57;-6?=A 12 378A: 45 26=87?2 412 324-4-5627
56 ,8-= 56 @2;-.8= ?7596; <57 8 =-@-42; 327-5;
!
=28762;
2394A
5=-.-457
26278= 5<
6;-8 833287-6? <57 412 72:356;264 :9,@-442; 4184 412
324-4-5627 -: -6C5=C2; -6 8 12-659: 5<<26.2: 96;27 412
375C-:-56: 5<
5:3-48= 84
47284@264
.4 86; 12 18; @2;-.84-56 -6 412
26478=
7-:56
8=8,978?- 86; 8=:5 96;27
5:3-48=
8=8,978?-
:9.1
.-7.9@:486.2 12 378A: 45 72G2.4 412 378A27
F
18C2 ?-C26 @A 86H-59: .56:-;2784-56 ,541 56
412 :9,@-::-56 @8;2 ,A 412 =28762; .596:2= <57 412
72:32.4-C2 3874-2: 86; 3279:2; 412 ;5.9@264: @8;2
8C8-=8,=2 56 72.57;
)
: :4842;
8 3279:8= 5< 412 @2;-.8=
723574 412 324-4-5627 -: :9<<27-6? <75@ :27-59: 8-=@264:
86; -< 41-: 327:-:4: 41272 -: 8 417284 45 1-: =-<2
- 12 -
"
56I,=2
9372@2
5974 -6 412 .8:2 5<
7235742; -6
-6 3878?7831
5 ) 18: 5,:27C2; 8: <5==5B: J
9&
&
B
&
!
!
!
&
!
9372@2
5974 -6 412 .8:2
&@
*
'974127 412
56I,=2
5<
7235742; -6
! "
!
#
84 3878?7831
5:
86; !" " 18:
5,:27C2; 8: <5==5B: J
, & 4
/
)
'
!
'
!
!
B
& >
!
!
%
+
)
&
- 13 -
'
& (
'
!
&
'
& (
'
%
'
&
CCC
-:&:&
&
'
&
"
>
B
&
'
!
&@
6 3279:8= 5< 412 <-6;-6?: 5< 412
9372@2
56I,=2
5974 -6 412 8,5C2 G9;?@264: 412 8..9:2; .86
,2 ?78642; -6427-@ ,8-= 57 72?9=87 ,8-= 56 @2;-.8= ?7596;:
- 14 -
56=A 8<427 -4 -: <596; 4184 412 37535:2; @2;-.8= 47284@264
-: 8C8-=8,=2 -6 412 8-=
5:3-48=
6 412 -6:4864 .8:2 -4 -: 654
-6 ;-:3942 4184 324-4-5627 -: .564-6959:=A 48>-6? 47284@264
5:3-48=
8=8,978?- 86; :9.1 8;C86.2 47284@264
-: 654 8C8-=8,=2 -6 412
26478=
7-:56 8: 327 412 @2;-.8=
723574
18C2 ?-C26 @A 86H-59: .56:-;2784-56 ,541 56
412 @2;-.8= 723574: :9,@-442; ,A 412
8-=
94157-4A
3279:8= 5< 412 :8@2 -4 .59=; ,2 ?841272; 4184 41272 -: =-<2
417284 45 412 324-4-5627 -< 412 372:264 @2;-.8= .56;-4-56 5<
412 324-4-5627 .564-692: <57 8 D9-42 =56? 4-@2
'974127 -4
-: 2C-;264 4184 -< 8 :97?27A 96;27?562 ,A 412 324-4-5627
41272
-:
78A
5<
.-7.9@:486.2 8: 12=; ,A 412
8,5C2 G9;?@264
5<
1-:
:97C-C8=
56I,=2
32H
:9.1
5974 -6 412
8@ 5< 412 .56:-;272; C-2B 4184 412
324-4-5627I: 72D92:4 <57 -6427-@ ,8-= -6 57;27 45 96;27?5
:97?27A -6 8 37-C842 15:3-48= 5< 1-: .15-.2 622;: 45 ,2
?78642;
- 15 -
..57;-6?=A 412 324-4-56 -: $$ %
12 324-4-5627 8..9:2;
-: ;-72.42; 45 ,2
72=28:2; 56 -6427-@ ,8-= 56=A <57 8 =-@-42; 327-5; 5<
<75@ 412 ;842 5< 1-: 72=28:2 -6
"
!
7-@2
(
-:47-.4
-;87 72?-:4272; ,A 412
87.54-.
56475=
97289
86?8=572 (568=
6-4 <57 412 5<<26.2: 396-:18,=2 96;27
2.4-56: "$.& 728;
6-56 5< 6;-8
B-41
2.4-56
$,&$--&$ &
*"! 326;-6? -6
7-6.-38=
!
)
" 86;
8:2
!
56 412 <-=2 5<
2::-56: 9;?2
-;87 :9,G2.4 45 412
32.-8=
-:47-.4 86;
* 5<
.4
<5==5B-6? .56;-4-56:
8&
24-4-5627 :18== 2H2.942 8 327:568= ,56;
<57 8 :9@ 5<
:
J $ 9322:
B5
8>1: 56=A& B-41 4B5 :9724-2: <57 412 =->2:9@
45 412 :84-:<8.4-56 5< 412 G97-:;-.4-568=
,&
24-4-5627 -: 84 =-,274A 45 ?24 1-@:2=<
5327842; 86; 472842; -6 8
.15-.2 84
5:3-48= 5< 1-:
26?8=979 86; 12 :18== 723574 412
:8@2 45 412 72:356;264
8-=
5974K
94157-4-2:
5=-.2 86; 8=:5 412
- 16 -
.&
324-4-5627
:18==
;-72.4=A
-6;-72.4=A
41728426
48@327
B-41
375:2.94-56 B-462::2:K
;&
24-4-5627 :18== 375;9.2 8== 412 72=2C864
47284@264 38327: ,2<572 412 7-8=
2&
24-4-5627 :18== :97726;27 1-: 38::3574 -<
86A ,2<572 412 7-8=
<&
24-4-5627 :18== :97726;27 ,2<572 412
-@@2;-842=A
8<427
2H3-7A
5<
7-8=
41722
@5641:
?&
24-4-5627 :18== 654 =28C2 412
4842 5<
876848>8
,*
&
"
)
"
+
-:4
J
=
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review