Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1148
Serial No.34
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 304 of 2024
Date of Decision : 11.12.2024
Dr. Shireen L.Dkhar.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
The State of Meghalaya,
Represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya.
2.
The Commissioner and Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya,
Health and Family Welfare Department.
3.
The Joint Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya,
Health and Family Welfare Department.
4.
The Directorate of Health Services
(Medical Institutions), Shillong,
Represented by the Director of Health Services
(Medical Institutions), Shillong,
Meghalaya.
5.
Dr. Albandouglas Kharmawlong,
Lumsohkhlur , P.O. Mairang,
West Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya – 793120.
…Respondents
2024:MLHC:1148
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) :
Mr. S.Sen, Adv.
Mr. M.U.Ahmed, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. A.Kumar, AG with
Mr. A.Thungwa, GA and
Mr. J.N.Rynjah, GA for R 1-4.
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv. with
Mr. B.Iawim, Adv. for R 5.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The brief facts surrounding the case are that the petitioner had
applied for Master of Dental Surgery (MDS) (PG) Course against a seat
allotted for the State of Meghalaya at the Regional Dental College,
Guwahati for the academic year 2024-2025 along with six other
candidates. As per the said list, the petitioner having obtained the highest
NEET score was nominated to the said vacancy and after complying with
all the necessary formalities, was admitted to the said Post Graduate
Course for the academic year 2024-25 on 22-07-2024 and the classes had
then commenced, immediately thereafter.
2024:MLHC:1148
2.
The grievance of the writ petitioner is that the State respondents,
vide an order dated 19-08-2024, unilaterally withdrew her nomination for
the MDS PG Course against the seat allotted to the State of Meghalaya on
the ground that there existed another candidate (respondent No. 5) with a
higher NEET score as per the second list, which had been submitted to the
State respondents on 29-07-2024, and that by another order the private
respondent was nominated against the seat already occupied by the writ
petitioner in the same College.
3.
Mr. S.Sen, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the
petitioner having been allocated the seat validly on her application and
being the most meritorious,
as per the list released by the State
respondents on 22-05-2024, had acquired a vested right to the seat and the
unilateral cancellation, without affording any hearing to the petitioner was
arbitrary and illegal. It is further submitted that once the seat had been
allotted to the writ petitioner, notwithstanding the fact that other
meritorious candidates are present, however, once the order had been
issued, the State respondents were estopped from retracting the same. As
such, he prays that the allotment of the MDS PG Course seat to the private
respondent made at her expense, be set aside.
2024:MLHC:1148
4.
Mr. A.Kumar, learned AG assisted by Ms. A.Thungwa, learned GA
appearing on behalf of the State respondents Nos. 1 – 4, submits that the
reason for the issuance of the order recalling the allotment of the seat to the
petitioner, was due to the fact that after the earlier applications had been
processed, fresh applications had been received from the private
respondent and others, and as the private respondent was having a higher
NEET score, the State respondents had resorted to the action which is now
impugned in the present writ petition. It is further submitted that the
recalling of the writ petitioner’s candidature, was only not to deprive a
more meritorious candidate who was available for consideration.
5.
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
private respondent No. 5, has submitted that the request for admission for
MDS PG Course was made much prior to the allocation of the seat on 0207-2024 and has referred to Annexure-R/1 of the State respondent’s
affidavit to substantiate this fact. Learned counsel has also referred to
Annexure-R/2, to show that copies of the petition/representation from the
private respondent had been received by the concerned authority on 29-072024. He therefore, submits that the private respondent being more
meritorious and due to no fault of his, having been deprived of a seat,
deserves some consideration.
2024:MLHC:1148
6.
This Court in the course of hearing, as it appeared that there was
some serious anomaly in the matter of the allotment of the seat to the writ
petitioner, had directed for the production of the original records dealing
with the entire matter. A perusal thereof, however, has reflected that there
was no malafide intent in the entire exercise that had been conducted for
admission of the States MDS PG Course, but the same was occasioned by
the lack of procedure or policy for admission to MDS PG seats allocated to
the State. As per the notesheet, it is clearly reflected that there is no set
process followed, nor any deadline prescribed for receiving of applications
and no systematic counseling process practiced. The allocation of seats, it
is seen is based on the applications received from the candidates, as very
few applicants apply.
7.
It is also seen from the records that the applications were received in
two lists on separate dates for the same seat, and the writ petitioner, it
appears was approved from the first list, which had been then
communicated to the said College. It is further reflected from the record,
that the second list was forwarded by the DHS at a later stage which had
candidates with higher NEET scores who on not being selected, had then
submitted representations. It is further seen from the records itself, that the
State respondents in this situation, had realized that it was essential to keep
a process for the selection of candidates for the PG seats on Dentistry like
2024:MLHC:1148
the department does in MBBS Course, but however, proceeded to recall
the nomination of the writ petitioner. As observed earlier, though there has
been an anomaly in the manner of allocation of the seats, there is no
malafide intent on the part of the respondents and the entire exercise was
done bonafide, for which in the absence of a stated policy, no one can be
held responsible or accountable.
8.
In this view of the matter, notwithstanding the contesting claims of
the writ petitioner and the private respondent, in order to balance the
equities, more so, in view of the fact that the writ petitioner is already
pursuing the course for a considerable period of time now, it is provided
that henceforth, for selection and allocation of seats from the State quota
for MDS PG Course, or for that matter in other specialized streams, the
State respondents are to put in place and notify the methodology for
selection of candidates. The learned AG at this stage has also produced an
order passed by this Court in WP(C). No. 457 of 2022, wherein this Court
on the production of a Notification dated 4th February/13th May, 2022,
which contains the methodology had recorded the same in the order at para
2 thereof, which is reproduced herein below:
“ 2. Today, Mr. A. Kumar, learned AG has produced
a notification dated 04.02.2022/13.05.2022, which are
the orders of the Governor in the matter of selection of
2024:MLHC:1148
candidates for MBBS seats allotted to the State of
Meghalaya. For easy convenience the same is
reproduced hereinbelow:“GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT
Notification
Dated Shillong, the 4th February/13th May, 2022
No. Health. 306/2021/21: The Governor of Meghalaya is
pleased to notify the Methodology for selection of
candidates for MBBS seats allotted to the State of
Meghalaya as under:
1. Once notified by the Central Government, the list of
medical colleges allotted to the State of Meghalaya will
be shared with all eligible candidates for indicating
their preference descending order. The candidates are
required to provide preference for each college in an
online system.
2. The candidates will be ranked as per their NEET score
but in their respective categories. In the event that two or
more candidates obtained the same NEET score, then the
marks obtained in PCB (Physic, Chemistry, Biology) will
be the deciding factor for ranking.
3. Counselling will be done based on the preferences
provided by the candidates and seats will allocated while
adhering to the following rules;
a) For the Open Category, the seats will be allotted
solely on merit.
b) For all other categories, including Khasi & Jaintia,
Garo, SC and OST, the seats will be equitably
allocated to each category as per category rank. In the
first round, all the first rankers in each category will
be allocated a seat. In the second round, all the second
rankers will be allocated seats and this process will be
repeated until all seats are exhausted.
2024:MLHC:1148
4. The State Reservation Policy will be strictly adhered
to while allocating the seats to the eligible candidates.
This Notification will take effect from the date of issue.
Sd/Principal Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya
Health & Family Welfare Department”
9.
In the instant case, the private respondent due to no fault of his, has
been deprived of pursuing the MDS PG Course in the current academic
year and the writ petitioner who had also been granted a seat in a bonafide
exercise of power in the absence of a policy, has also acquired a vested
right; facts, which cannot be ignored by this Court.
10.
At this juncture, it would be useful to refer to the case of Krishna
Sradha vs. State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. reported in (2020) 17 SCC 465,
wherein in a similar case, the Supreme Court had at paras 13.2 and 13.3
held as follows:
“13.2. Under exceptional circumstances, if the court
finds that there is no fault attributable to the candidate
and the candidate has pursued his/her legal right
expeditiously without any delay and there is fault only
on the part of the authorities and/or there is apparent
breach of rules and regulations as well as related
principles in the process of grant of admission which
would violate the right of equality and equal treatment
to the competing candidates and if the time schedule
prescribed – 30th September, is over, to do the complete
justice, the Court under exceptional circumstances and
in rarest of rare cases direct the admission in the same
year by directing to increase the seats, however, it
2024:MLHC:1148
should not be more than one or two seats and such
admissions can be ordered within reasonable time, i.e.,
within one month from 30th September, i.e., cut-off date
and under no circumstances, the Court shall order any
Admission in the same year beyond 30th October.
However, it is observed that such relief can be granted
only in exceptional circumstances and in the rarest of
rare cases. In case of such an eventuality, the Court
may also pass an order cancelling the admission given
to a candidate who is at the bottom of the merit list of
the category who, if the admission would have been
given to a more meritorious candidate who has been
denied admission illegally, would not have got the
admission, if the Court deems it fit and proper,
however, after giving an opportunity of hearing to a
student whose admission is sought to be cancelled.
13.3. In case the Court is of the opinion that no relief of
admission can be granted to such a candidate in the
very academic year and wherever it finds that the
action of the authorities has been arbitrary and in
breach of the rules and regulations or the prospectus
affecting the rights of the students and that a candidate
is found to be meritorious and such candidate/student
has approached the court at the earliest and without
any delay, the court can mould the relief and direct the
admission to be granted to such a candidate in the next
academic year by issuing appropriate directions by
directing to increase in the number of seats as may be
considered appropriate in the case and in case of such
an eventuality and if it is found that the management
was at fault and wrongly denied the admission to the
meritorious candidate, in that case, the Court may
direct to reduce the number of seats in the management
quota of that year, meaning thereby the student/students
who was/were denied admission illegally to be
accommodated in the next academic year out of the
seats allotted in the management quota.”
2024:MLHC:1148
11.
In the present case, the private respondent being more meritorious,
in the considered view of this Court deserves the same concession, that is
to the moulding of the relief and to direct for admission to be granted in
the next academic year into the MDS PG Course with the same NEET
score. It is further noted that though the judgment refers to the admission
in the MBBS Course only, the same principle would apply to the instant
case which involves admission to Post Graduate Medical Course.
12.
It is thus ordered accordingly, that the State respondents shall make
provision for accommodating and allocating a seat in MDS PG Course
from the State quota to the private respondent in the next academic year
2025-26 with the same NEET score. This order is being passed considering
the peculiar nature of the case and to balance the equities and not to serve
as a precedent.
13.
Before parting with this case, this Court notes with appreciation the
stand of the private respondent who has agreed to accept a seat in the next
academic year for the pursuit of his MDS Degree.
14.
The writ petition on the above terms, stands allowed and is disposed
of.
2024:MLHC:1148
15.
Records are returned to the State respondents.
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2024.12.11 19:45:22 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review