The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. On a subsequent development, due to the pendency of the litigation before this Court, an application under Section 17B of the ID Act was preferred before this Court on a finding that the petitioner in the said petition remains unemployed and is waiting for reinstatement. That petition was allowed. However, in defence to the petition, the management has produced certain photographs whereby they tried to establish 2025:KER:18808 WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015 that the petitioner in Section 17B petition is gainfully employed in DTDC. The evidence to prove such employment was the production of Exts.P17 to P20 photographs, whereby stated that two mobile numbers, provided in the Advertisement Board in DTDC are the mobile phone numbers used by the workman and two photographs, which were taken in the background of the posters of DTDC courier services and the profile picture of the facebook has been brought in to prove that she is gainfully employed in DTDC.
15. Going by those evidences, I am not convinced that the 1st respondent is gainfully employed and hence, that contentions cannot be countenanced and accordingly rejected. However, on practical side, accepting the contention that the petitioner herein stopped their operation within the jurisdiction of the State of Kerala, the implementation of the award to its fullest extent is not workable. Hence, the only interference made to that extent is the reinstatement of the workman to the petitioner - establishment is restricted to the date on which they stopped the operation within the jurisdiction of State of Kerala and the workman is liable to get back wages only upto that date. 2025:KER:18808 WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015 Only to that extent, the impugned award is modified. Writ petition No.21747 of 2015 is disposed of accordingly. The prayers sought for in WP(C) No.25739 of 2015 cannot be allowed in the aforementioned background and hence, the same is dismissed. sd/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.M.MANOJ
MONDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 12TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 21747 OF 2015
AGAINST
THE
ORDER/JUDGMENT
DATED
25.03.2015
IN
ID
NO.1 OF 2013 OF LABOUR COURT, ERNAKULAM
PETITIONER:
FEDEX EXPRESS SERVICES (INDIA)PVT.LTD
(NOW KNOWN FEDEX EXPRESS TRANSPORTATION & SUPPLY
CHAIN SERVICES,INDIA PVT LTD)39/4706A-PRAKASH
COTTAGE, SREEKANDATH ROAD, RAVIPURAM, KOCHI 16.
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER, MR JIBU K JOHN
BY ADVS. SRI.P.V.VINOD (BENGALAM)
SMT.D.REETHA
SRI.MANU SEBASTIAN
DINESH P.V. (SR.)(D/258-A/1994)
RESPONDENTS:
SMT.SHINY.P.A.
PALLIPARAMBIL HOUSE,ELAMAKKARA P O, KOCHI 26
LABOUR COURT, ERNAKULAM, KOCHI 18
BY ADVS. SRI.A.JAYASANKAR
SRI.MANU GOVIND
SRI.C.V.MANUVILSAN
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 03.03.2025, ALONG WITH WP(C).25379/2015, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.M.MANOJ
MONDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 12TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 25379 OF 2015
AGAINST
THE
ORDER/JUDGMENT
DATED
25.03.2015
IN
ID
NO.1 OF 2013 OF LABOUR COURT, ERNAKULAM
PETITIONER:
SHINY P.A., AGED 48 YEARS
PALAZHIYIL HOUSE, EDAPPALLY P O, KOCHI 682025
BY ADVS. SRI.A.JAYASANKAR
SRI.MANU GOVIND
SRI.C.V.MANUVILSAN
RESPONDENTS:
LABOUR COURT
ERNAKULAM 682031
FEDEX EXPRESS SERVICES
(INDIA)PVT LTD, 39/4706 A , PRAKASH COTTAGE,
SREEKANDATH ROAD, RAVIPURAM KOCHI 682016
BY ADVS. SRI.P.V.VINOD (BENGALAM)
SMT.D.REETHA
SRI.MANU SEBASTIAN
DINESH P.V.(D/258-A/1994)
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 03.03.2025, ALONG WITH WP(C).21747/2015, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 3rd day of March, 2025
The captioned writ petitions are preferred challenging
the award dated 25.03.2015 in Industrial Dispute No.1 of 2013
passed by the 2nd respondent.
2. For the purpose of convenience, the status of the
parties shall be referred to as described in WP(C) No.21747 of
2015.
3. The issue involved is that the 1 st respondent in WP(C)
No.21747 of 2015, who is the petitioner in WP(C) No.25379 of
2015, was the Sales Executive of the FedEx Express Services
(India) Pvt. Ltd. She was terminated from service as she failed
to achieve the target allotted to her during the month of January
to March 2012.
direction
for
consequential
The Labour Court passed the award with a
reinstatement
benefits.
with
The
50%
back
employer
wages
and
challenges
the
reinstatement whereas the employee challenges granting of
50% of back wages instead of 100%.
4. Short facts of the case are as follows:
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
Originally the 1st respondent was serving in M/s.
Prakash Air Prides Pvt. Ltd. She was designated as Sales
Executive and posted at Regional Office at Ravipuram, Kochi.
Later, M/s. Prakash Air Prides Pvt. Ltd. was takenover by FedEx.
Since the performance level of the 1 st respondent was alleged to
be not upto the mark, a performance appraisal was conducted
by assigning certain targets. However, she was unable to
achieve the target while her counterparts achieved the same in
consecutive years. According to the petitioner, all the possible
steps have been taken by them by giving her an opportunity to
improve her performance. Unfortunately, she couldn’t achieve
the target despite several opportunities being given. The period
of
assessment
was
between
January
and
March
2012.
Thereafter, she was issued with a warning memo. She submitted
her explanation and the management issued show cause notice.
That was also replied. Since the reply was not satisfactory,
charge sheet was issued.
5. An enquiry was commenced on 26.04.2012 by
appointing
a
lady
advocate,
which
was
concluded
on
27.04.2012. The enquiry officer submitted the enquiry report to
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
the management. The management called for the explanation
from the 1st respondent. Since the explanation offered by the 1st
respondent
was
not
satisfactory,
the
management
issued
termination order on 10.05.2012. The termination was under
challenge before the Labour Court as ID No.1 of 2013.
6. By award dated 25.03.2015, the Labour Court set
aside
the
enquiry
report
and
found
that
the
denial
of
employment to the workman by the management was illegal and
unjustifiable and the management was directed to reinstate the
workman with 50% of back wages and continuity of service.
Being aggrieved by that the employer – petitioner herein has
preferred WP(C) No.21747 of 2015 and the workman - 1 st
respondent has preferred WP(C) No.25379 of 2015.
7. The jurisdiction of this Court to examine the award
passed by the Labour Court is (1) whether there is any
jurisdictional error, (2) Whether there is any violation of
Principles of natural justice (3) whether there is any patent
illegality or perverse findings (4) whether there is any error of
law apparent on the face of record (5) Whether there is
contravention of constitutional provisions or public policy (6)
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
whether there is malafides or fraud (7) whether there is non
application of mind.
8. The interference envisaged by exercising jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is sparingly used
only when the award suffers from one or more of the above
mentioned defects.
9. In the case on hand, going by the pleadings in both
the writ petitions, I do not find any pleadings with respect to (1)
the jurisdictional error, (2) violation of principles of natural
justice, (3) patent illegality or perverse findings (4) error of law
apparent
on
the
face
of
record
(5)
contravention
of
constitutional provisions or public policy (6) malafides or fraud.
However, the only contention is with respect to the non
application of mind and in oral submissions, the learned counsel
for the petitioner contended that the findings in the award of the
Labour Court are perverse.
10. For the purpose of examining the non application of
mind, the decision taken by the Labour Court has to be
considered at length. Similarly, to enter into a finding that the
award is perverse, the findings of the Labour Court should be on
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
non evidences, misleading evidences or ignoring material facts.
In the case on hand, the Labour Court has meticulously
examined the documents produced before it and examined the
witnesses on the side of the management as well as the
workman.
On the side of the management, two persons were
examined. On the side of the workman, only the workman was
examined. Exts.M1, M1(a) to M1(m) were marked. The workman
has not marked any document. To a question, the learned
counsel for the respondent submitted that the workman need
not produce any fresh document, as she is relying on the
documents produced by the management.
11. The Labour Court has meticulously examined the
procedures followed in the domestic enquiry conducted by the
management.
The Labour Court also examined the allegation
with respect to the lack of performance by the 1 st respondent
and it was found that the disciplinary proceedings were initiated
merely on the basis of workman’s failure to achieve the target
fixed by the management. In that regard, they reproduced the
target given to the workman.
On finding that the workman
miserably failed to achieve the target, disciplinary proceedings
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
were initiated by appointing an enquiry officer. Enquiry officer
conducted the enquiry. The Labour Court has gone through the
process of enquiry and reassessed the documents produced
before it as well as the enquiry authority and entered into a
finding that from the evidences tendered by the management it
appears
that
they
fixed
a
target
arbitrarily
and
in
the
performance assessment and improvement review meeting they
found that the performance of the workman is not satisfactory.
12. Above all, nothing is seen produced by the
management to take the Court into confidence that the non
attainment of the target fixed by the establishment is a cause
sufficient to subject the workman to a domestic enquiry for
misconduct and to show exit on the basis of that enquiry. I do
not find any non application of mind in this finding, which
appears to be quite reasonable. On such finding, the conclusion
of the Labour Court that the denial of employment of a workman
by the management was illegal and unjustifiable. Hence, there is
no sufficient ground for interference with the award passed by
the Labour Court to the extent it directs reinstatement of the
workman and the finding that the domestic enquiry conducted
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
by the management was in gross violation of principles of
natural justice and fairness.
13. Similarly, the Labour Court entered into a finding
that the management has not brought in any evidence to show
that the workman was gainfully employed. Moreover, the
workman deposed that she has not been gainfully engaged
elsewhere. Therefore, the Labour Court concluded that the
workman is entitled to back wages as there is denial of
employment by the management without any reasonable cause.
I do not find any unjustifiable reason in awarding back wages to
the employee on the background that the Labour Court entered
into a finding that the management denied the employment
arbitrarily and illegally.
14. On a subsequent development, due to the pendency
of the litigation before this Court, an application under Section
17B of the ID Act was preferred before this Court on a finding
that the petitioner in the said petition remains unemployed and
is
waiting
for
reinstatement.
That
petition
was
allowed.
However, in defence to the petition, the management has
produced certain photographs whereby they tried to establish
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
that the petitioner in Section 17B petition is gainfully employed
in DTDC.
The evidence to prove such employment was the
production of Exts.P17 to P20 photographs, whereby stated that
two mobile numbers, provided in the Advertisement Board in
DTDC are the mobile phone numbers used by the workman and
two photographs, which were taken in the background of the
posters of DTDC courier services and the profile picture of the
facebook has been brought in to prove that she is gainfully
employed in DTDC.
15. Going by those evidences, I am not convinced that
the 1st respondent is gainfully employed and hence, that
contentions cannot be countenanced and accordingly rejected.
However, on practical side, accepting the contention that the
petitioner herein stopped their operation within the jurisdiction
of the State of Kerala, the implementation of the award to its
fullest extent is not workable. Hence, the only interference made
to that extent is the reinstatement of the workman to the
petitioner - establishment is restricted to the date on which they
stopped the operation within the jurisdiction of State of Kerala
and the workman is liable to get back wages only upto that date.
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
Only to that extent, the impugned award is modified.
Writ
petition No.21747 of 2015 is disposed of accordingly.
The prayers sought for in WP(C) No.25739 of 2015
cannot be allowed in the aforementioned background and hence,
the same is dismissed.
sd/-
P.M.MANOJ
JUDGE
das
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 25379/2015
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
P1:-COPY OF THE AWARD DTD 25/3/2015 IN ID NO
1/2013 OF THE LABOUR COURT, ERNAKULAM
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 21747/2015
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE
PERFORMANCE EXPECTATIONS FROM DULY SIGNED
BY THE IST RESPONDENT IN 2010 DTD 27/8/2010
TRUE COPY OF LETER DTD 21/7/2011 ON
PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT OF IST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF CALCULATIONS OF OVERALL
PERFORMANCE REVIEW RATING DTD 25/6/2010 OF
THE IS RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DTD 23/5/2011 ISSUED TO
IST RESPONDENT ON PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT
AND IMPROVEMENT REVIEW MEETING
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF WARNING LETTER DTD 22/7/2011
ISSUED TO THE IST RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DTD 12/10/2011 ISSUED
TO THE IST RESPONDENT ON PERFORMANCE
ASSESSMENT AND IMPROVEMENT REVIEW MEETING
EXHIBIT P6
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF WARNING LETTER DTD 15/10/2011
WAS ISSUED TO THE IST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE COPY OF THE AN EMAIL SENT TO THE IST
RESPONDENT ON 18/10/2011 DETAILING THE
DISCUSSION AND RESPONSE DURING THE COURSE
OF PERFORMANCE REVIEW MEETING ON 15/10/2011
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE COPY OF WARNING LETTER DTD 10/1/2012
WAS ISSUED TO THE IST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE COPY OF A REPLY TO THE WARNING LETTER
DTD 22/1/2012 BY THE IST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P11
TRUE COPY OF SHOW CAUSE NOTICE DTD
23/2/2012 ISSUED TO THE IST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P12
TRUE COPY OF REPLY DTD 24/2/2012 BY THE IST
2025:KER:18808
WP(C) Nos.21747 & 25379 of 2015
RESPONDENT TO THE SHOW CAUSE NOTICE
EXHIBIT P13
TRUE COPY OF CHARGE SHEET DTD 23/4/2012
ISSUED TO THE IST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P14
TRUE COPY OF PETITTION DTD 29/12/2012 FILED
BY THE IST RESPONDENT BEFORE THE 2ND
RESPONDENT ID NO 1/2013
EXHIBIT P15
TRUE COPY OF WRITTEN STATEMENT DTD
11/6/2013 FILED BY THE PETITIONER IN ID NO
12013
EXHIBIT P16
TRUE COPY OF AWARD DTD 25/3/2015 BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT IN ID NO 1/2013
EXHIBITS P17
A COPY OF THE ENQUIRY REPORT ON 23.04.2012
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review