Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:1243
Serial No.19
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.648/2025
Date of order: 16.12.2025
Shillong Cricket Association, Polo Ground, Shillong 793001, through
its President Shri Peter Macdonald K. Sawian
Vs.
1. Meghalaya Cricket Association, through its Honorary Secretary, J.N.
Stadium, Polo Ground, Shillong-793001.
2. Mr. Hemant Nazary, IAS (Retd.), Returning Officer, Meghalaya
Cricket Association, J.N. Stadium, Polo Ground, Shillong-793001.
3. The Board of Control for Cricket in India, 4 th Floor, Cricket Centre,
Wankhede Stadium ‘D’ Road, Churchgate, Mumbai-40020.
4. Mr. Rayonald Kharkamni, Honorary Secretary, Meghalaya Cricket
Association, J.N. Stadium, Polo Ground, Shillong.
5. The Deputy Commissioner, East Khasi Hills District, Shillong.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv
For the Respondents : Mr. S. Dutta, Sr.Adv with
Mr. I. Lahiri, Adv
Mr. P. Sengupta, Adv
Mr. K.V. Kharlyngdoh, Adv for R/1-4
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA
i)
Whether approved for
Yes/No
reporting in Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
2025:MLHC:1243
JUDGMENT: (Oral)
The present writ petition has been filed by the Shillong Cricket
Association (SCA) an affiliated to the Meghalaya Cricket Association
(MCA) which is in turn affiliated to the Board of Control for Cricket in
India (BCCI). The grievance as set forth is with the electoral process
adopted for the MCA General Elections 2025, on the ground that the
process adopted is irregular, arbitrary, opaque and not in consonance
with the BCCI Memorandum of Association, and the Rules and
Regulations thereof, and also of the MCA Memorandum of Association,
and the Rules and Regulations as amended.
2.
The core questions that have been raised by the petitioner is
firstly with the appointment of the respondent No.2 a former Chief
Electoral of Assam, as the Electoral Officer to conduct the elections on
the ground that it violates Rule 36 of the MCA Constitution which
stipulates that the Electoral Officer should be a former Central or State
Election Commissioner. The other question that has been raised is with
the schedule for the elections wherein, it is alleged that the same suffers
from critical procedural flaws, notably with regard to the preparation of
the draft electoral roll published on 26.11.2025 and the final electoral
2025:MLHC:1243
roll published on 27.11.2025 where the names of the authorised voting
representatives of the affiliated units of the MCA were not disclosed.
Further, it has been contended that the window for objections provided
in the schedule, were illusory and deprived members of any meaningful
opportunity to scrutinize voter eligibility, inasmuch as, the names of the
representatives was disclosed only on 03.12.2025, after the objection
period had closed and the nomination and scrutiny stages over.
3.
The President of the Petitioner Association who was also an
aspiring candidate for the post of Vice President of the MCA, withdrew
his candidature on 02.12.2025 being dissatisfied with the alleged
compromise nature of the electoral process and representations to
Electoral Officer in-charge of the election and also to the Deputy
Commissioner of East Khasi Hills had been preferred on 04.12.2025
which, however, before the same could bear any fruit, in view of the
impending elections scheduled for 09.12.2025, the instant writ petition
had been filed on 08.12.2025.
4.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned senior counsel with Ms. M. Myrchiang
on behalf of the petitioner has raised key contentions which are (i)
illegal appointment of Electoral Officer (ii) defective electoral roll
2025:MLHC:1243
process (iii) violation of mandatory timelines (iv) truncated and unfair
process being adopted and (v) invocation of writ jurisdiction being
appropriate as the irregularities were grave and affected public interest.
On the first contention, it has been submitted that the Constitution of the
MCA at clause 36(1) mandates that the Apex Council of the MCA, shall
appoint an Electoral Officer who should be a former Central or State
Election Commissioner, and that the directions issued by the
‘Committee Of Administrators on Appointment of Electoral Officers,
pursuant to order dated 02.01.2017 passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, at para 1(c) thereof, also allows for the appointment of a former
Chief Electoral Officer of the State and in case such person is not
available, then a former Chief Electoral Officer of a neighbouring State
may be appointed. In the instant case, he submits though there is an
availability of former Chief Electoral Officers in the State itself, a
former Chief Electoral Officer from Assam has been appointed.
5.
On the second contention, it has been submitted that the
schedule as published especially the publication of the electoral roll
made the period for objection a farce, inasmuch as the final electoral
roll with the names was published on 03.12.2025, after the window for
2025:MLHC:1243
objections was already closed, which rendered the process opaque and
prevented any check on voter eligibility. To buttress this argument, the
learned senior counsel has drawn the attention of this Court to clause
32(3) of the Rules which he submits, provides for the voting of any
members association to be through the President and in his absence by
the Honorary Secretary whereas, the final electoral roll reveals that a
Treasurer of the West Jaintia Hills District Cricket Association has been
named as a voting representative. Further, it is submitted that the
campaigning period from 02.12.2025 to 08.12.2025, commenced before
the final voters list was published on 03.12.2025 which apart from
making the period ineffective, also contravened the Rule requiring the
communication of the said list not later than one week before the
election date, which should have been 02.12.2025. In support of his
contention that invocation of writ jurisdiction is appropriate, the learned
senior counsel has placed reliance in the case of Ameen Pathan v. State
of Rajasthan: 2025 SCC OnLine Raj 2607, wherein he submits it has
been held that courts can interfere in an election process in special
circumstances when executive actions subvert the principles of fairness
and equal opportunity.
2025:MLHC:1243
6.
Mr. S. Dutta, learned senior counsel with Mr. I. Lahari
appearing on behalf of the respondent No.1 in reply, has first questioned
the locus of the petitioner and submits that the petitioner is merely a
voter and not a candidate and as such cannot challenge the election
process, and that the writ petition is a motivated afterthought filed only
after their candidate withdrew apprehending defeat. It is then submitted
that the appointment of the Electoral Officer, is justified and that the
BCCI directions referred to by the counsel for the petitioner allows the
appointment of a former Chief Electoral Officer of neighbouring State.
The categories mentioned therein he submits, are not a prescription to
maintain strict hierarchy, but are alternative options. The adopted
election procedure he submits, is an established practice and it is
identical to the elections held in 2022 wherein, the petitioner
participated without objection. The voters list he contends, are the
District Associations as reflected in the draft electoral roll, which was
up for objection as per the schedule and that the names of the
representatives of the respective Associations, was disclosed later for
logistical reasons and no prejudice can be said to have been caused to
the petitioner.
2025:MLHC:1243
7.
It is further submitted that the Rules provide for alternate
remedy as contained at Rules 40 and 4,1 where an Ombudsman is
available and the grievance redressal mechanism spelt out. The writ
petition he argues, is premature and an abuse of the process, inasmuch
as, there is no material illegality, or the existence of any ground for
invalidating, or cancelling the election when the process is already
underway. The objections if any he contends, are purely technical and
will have no impact on the outcome of the final election.
8.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, this Court first
has to be mindful of the fact that courts are slow to interfere in matters
of election, once the process has commenced, be it of any nature,
especially on the availability of alternate remedy. However, on
examination of the facts as presented, it appears that some consideration
and observations are necessary on the issues that have been raised. In
this context therefore, it is first noted that Rule 36 of the MCA
Memorandum of Association and the Rules and Regulations as
amended governs the conduct of elections and Rule 36(3) and provides
as follows:
2025:MLHC:1243
“36. The Electoral Officer
(1) .....
(2) .....
(3) In case of any dispute or objection as to candidacy,
disqualification, eligibility to vote, or the admission or rejection
of a vote in the elections to the Apex Council, the Electoral
Officer shall decide the same and such decision shall be final
and conclusive.”
This provision as can be seen, vests the Electoral Officer with
authority to adjudicate disputes relating to consideration of candidacy
and voter eligibility. As such, the MCA Rules itself provides for the
redressal of grievances such as the ones raised by the petitioner.
However, coming to Rule 36(1) it provides that at least four weeks prior
to the annual general meeting at which the election is to be held, the
Apex Council is to appoint an Electoral Officer who shall be a former
Central or State Election Commissioner. This requirement when read
together with the directions issued by the Committee of Administrators
appointed by the Supreme Court for supervision of the administration of
the BCCI dated 25.07.2019, allows for the appointment of a former
Chief Electoral Officer of the State at clause 1(c) thereof, however, also
providing that in such case if a person is not available a former Chief
Electoral Officer of the neighbouring State may be appointed. In the
instant case, the Apex Council has perhaps overlooked this prescription
2025:MLHC:1243
inasmuch as a former Chief Electoral Officer from Assam (respondent
No.2) has been appointed.
9.
On the other issue that is the schedule of elections that has been
published by the Electoral Officer that is respondent No.2 for the sake
of convenience the same is reproduced hereinbelow:
OFFICE OF THE ELECTORAL OFFICER,
MEGHALAYA CRICKET ASSOCIATION (MCA)
SUB: NOTICE OF ELEVTION SCHEDULE AND CALL FOR
FULL MEMBERS TO FILE APPLICATIONS TO NOMINATE
THEIR RESPECTIVE REPRESENTATIVES
1.
The Electrical Officer, Meghalaya Cricket Association
(“MCA”) hereby invites Full Members of the MCA to submit
applications
to
have
their
respective
representatives
(“Representatives”) included in the electoral roll for the election to be
held at the General Meeting of the MCA, on 9th December, 2025
(“MCA Election”), for the posts of six (6) members of the Apex
Council (as members elected by the General Body under Rule 25 (b)(iv)
of the MCA Constitution).
2.
The MCA Election process shall be conducted in accordance
with the Schedule provided in Table 1 below (“Election Schedule”).
Table 1 – Election Schedule
Event
Date/Timeline
1. Call for Affiliated Districts to File 19th November 2025
Application
to
Nominate
One
Representative as voter for MCA Election
2. Deadline for Members to File Application to 25th November 2025
Nominate their Representative via email
06.00 pm
3. Release of Draft Electoral Roll
26th November 2025
05.00 pm
4. Submission of Objections to Names in the 27th November 2025
Draft Electoral Roll
11.00 am to 03.00
2025:MLHC:1243
pm
5. (i) Examination of Objections and Decisions 27th November 2025
Thereon
06.00 pm onwards
(ii) Release of Final Electoral Roll
6. Windows to File Nomination Application 1st December 2025
(To be filled in person)
11.00 am to 04.00
pm
7. Scrutiny of Nomination Applications
1st December 2025
04.00 pm to 05.00
pm
8. Announcement of List of Validity 1st December 2025
Nominated Candidates (Code of conduct)
06.00 pm
9. Withdrawal of Nomination (in person)
2nd December 2025
11.00 am to 05.00
pm
10. Announcement of List of Contesting 2nd December 2025
Candidates
06.00 pm
11. MCA Elections (Casting of Votes)
9th December 2025
01.00 pm to 03.00
pm
12. Declaration of Results
9th December 2025
(Counting of Votes)
03.00 pm to 04.00
pm
10.
A perusal of the schedule would show that the objection window
was limited to 27.11.2025 between 11 am and 3 pm, with the release of
the final electoral roll scheduled at 6 pm of the same day. However, as
can be seen from the records, the draft and final electoral rolls, only
named the respective member associations and not the identities of the
authorised voting representatives, which was disclosed only on
03.12.2025, after the objection period was closed and after the
2025:MLHC:1243
nomination and withdrawal stage was over. The ground taken that the
petitioner was effectively prevented from filing a meaningful objection
therefore, has some basis, as raising of objections in electoral processes
as to voter eligibility etc. is integral to any electoral process which
ensures fairness and transparency. These issues, in the light of clause
36(3) though available to the petitioner to raise before the respondent
No.2, however, due to the schedule, the same precluded such action.
11.
On the question of availability of alternate remedy as observed
earlier, Rule 40 has provided for an Ombudsman and at Rule 41 speaks
of circumstances and the grievance redressal stipulations. In the course
of hearing, it has been submitted that such an Ombudsman exists and
that the present dispute, being one between affiliated members under the
BCCI structure would squarely fall within the ambit of Rules 40 and 41.
No doubt, recourse can be resorted to under the aforesaid provisions,
but in the instant case, perhaps for the purpose of the instant election,
considering the fact that the same has been postponed on Court orders
to 19.12.2025, the matter has to be settled at the earliest to avoid any
further delay.
2025:MLHC:1243
12.
At this juncture, it would not be out of place to mention herein
that the President of the petitioner Association was a nominated
member of the Apex Council which had ratified the appointment of the
respondent No.2 as the Chief Electoral Officer for the MCA 2025
General Elections and had also participated in the meeting where the
election schedule was discussed and ratified. This aspect, cannot be
ignored by this Court, which while noticing that the election schedule
and appointment of the Electoral Officer is under a cloud due to the
discrepancies mentioned earlier, the process having gone ahead, it
would be best left to the Electoral Officer himself to exercise powers
under Rule 36(3) of the MCA Rules to address the grievances relating
to voters eligibility and candidacy, take corrective steps to enhance
transparency in the electoral rolls and to ensure the conduct of smooth
and fair elections.
13.
Though the powers of this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution are wide enough to address any grievance, considering the
facts and circumstances of the case and the legal position as discussed
above, in the considered view of this Court, especially on the
availability of alternative remedy, no further interference is called for
2025:MLHC:1243
and the matter is left to be decided by the Chief Electoral Officer in
accordance with law, for any necessary course of action to be put in
place, while maintaining probity and transparency.
14.
Accordingly, as per the discussions and observations made
hereinabove the instant petition is closed and disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
16.12.2025
“Lam DR-PS
LAMPHRANG KHARCHANDY
Date: 2025.12.17 19:53:27 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review