Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:13573
NAFR
Digitally signed
INDRAJEET
INDRAJEET by
SAHU
SAHU
Date: 2026.04.04
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
13:16:50 +0530
WP227 No. 932 of 2025
1 - Shiekh Nasruddin S/o Late Shri Shiekh Badruddin Aged About 58 Years
R/o Q. No. 14-A, Street No. 21, Sector 02, Bhilai Nagar, Tahsil Distt. Durg,
Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Sarveshwar Dayal Mishra S/o Late Shri B.B. Mishra Aged About 62 Years
R/o M.I.G. 01/841, Hudco, Bhilai Nagar, Tahsil Distt. Durg, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Smt. Ratna Devi Mishra W/o Sarveshwar Dayal Mishra R/o M.I.G. 01/841,
Hudco, Bhilai Nagar, Tahsil And Distt. Durg, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
For Respondents
:
:
Shri Jitendra Pali, Advocate.
Shri Akash Kundu, Advocate.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Order on Board
20.03.2026
1.
The present writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
has been filed by the petitioner against the impugned order dated
26.06.2025 passed by IInd Civil Judge (Senior Division) Durg in Civil
Suit No.A/8/2019 whereby the application filed by the petitioner under
Order 26 Rule 9 CPC has been rejected.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that, the petitioner is the plaintiff before the
trial court and prosecuting a Civil Suit for declaration of title,
possession and permanent injunction with respect to suit land Khasra
No.76/44 area 0.03 Hect. (3120 sq.ft.) situated at village Kohka, Purani
Basti, Ward No.7, PH No.14/19, Tehsil and District Durg. In the said
civil suit the fourcorners of the suit land was claimed as, 25 ft. road in
northern side, plot No.34 in southern side, 25 ft. road in eastern side
and 20 ft. road in western side. The plaintiff had purchased the suit
land from its owner Milap Verma on 01.10.2009 through registered sale
deed and the land is recorded in his name by Khasra No.76/44. In the
month of June, 2018 when he visited his land, he found the defendants
started construction over his land. After approaching the authorities
when no action was taken to stop construction, he filed WPC No.3072
of 2018 before this court seeking a direction to the authorities for
demarcation of his land Khasra No.76/44. Vide order dated 21.10.2018
the Coordinate Bench of this court in the said writ petition directed the
petitioner/plaintiff to move an application before the concerned
Tehsildar for demarcation of the land. In compliance thereof, the
petitioner/plaintiff submitted his application on 10.11.2018 and then
after its demarcation the Revenue Inspector submitted a demarcation
report dated 16.01.2019 in which construction by defendant over the
land of petitioner/plaintiff was found.
The defendant raised objection with respect to change of its
Khasra Number and then the Revenue Inspector sought a direction
from the Tehsildar with respect to old and new Khasra Number. In the
meantime, the plaintiff filed the civil suit. In the civil suit the
plaintiff/petitioner filed his application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC and
prayed for appointment of a Commissioner to conduct a local
investigation and to carry out proper demarcation of the suit land. The
application filed by the petitioner/plaintiff was rejected by the trial court
on 24.01.2023 on the ground that application for demarcation cannot
be allowed for collection of evidence.
Against the rejection of
application of the petitioner dated 24.01.2023, the petitioner preferred
WP227 No.686 of 2023 before this court. The Coordinate Bench of this
court vide its order dated 28.08.2023 in WP227 No.686 of 2023
granted liberty to the petitioner to file his application at the subsequent
event, if so advised.
3.
In compliance of the order dated 21.10.2018 passed by coordinate
Bench of this court in WPC No.3072 of 2018, the Additional Tehsildar
along with Assistant Superintendent Land Records demarcated the
land on 04.06.2019 and the Superintendent Land Record Durg
submitted the demarcation report dated 22.08.2019 before the
Additional Tehsildar and after rejecting the objection raised by the
Objector/respondent No.1-Sarveshwar Dayal Mishra, issued the copy
of demarcation report dated 22.08.2019. The petitioner challenged the
said demarcation report dated 22.08.2019 by filing his Revision
No.20014/42/2018-19 before the Collector, Durg, which was allowed
on 23.02.2021 on the ground that the respondent No.1 in his another
cases disclosed the location of his land Khasra No.4726, Plot
No.27&28 in the southern side of Bhelva Talab and the SDO has
shown the location of his land in the eastern side of Bhelva Talab
whereas the land of the respondent No.1 is actually situated at western
side of Bhelva Talab. The order dated 23.02.2021 was challenged by
the respondent No.1 before the Commissioner Durg by filing his
revision which was partly allowed on 23.02.2023 and ordered that
there was a mistake committed during Bandobast and only after
correction of revenue records demarcation should be carried out by the
authorities and liberty was reserved in favour of the parties to get their
land again demarcated after correction of the revenue records. The
said order dated 23.02.2023 passed by by the Commissioner Durg was
challenged by the petitioner before the Chhattisgarh Board of Revenue
Circuit Court at Raipur. The Board of Revenue, by its detailed order
dated 14.03.2024 quashed the order dated 23.02.2023 passed the
Commissioner, Durg, order dated 26.08.2019 passed by Additional
Tehsildar, Durg and the demarcation report dated 22.08.2019 and has
affirmed by the order dated 23.02.2021 passed by the Additional
Collector, Durg and further directed to demarcate the land of the
petitioner in accordance with law as per the direction issued by the
High Court vide its order dated 31.10.2018 in WPC No. 3072 of 2018.
4.
Pursuant to the said direction of Board of Revenue dated 14.03.2024
the land was demarcated in presence of parties by a team of Revenue
Inspectors and Halka Patwari and submitted a report on 30.05.2024
and amended report dated 11.07.2024 before the Additional Tehsildar,
Bhilai. The said report dated 30.05.2024 and amended report dated
11.07.2024 has not been challenged by any of the parties.
5.
In the civil suit which was filed by the petitioner, he moved an
application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC for demarcation of his land in
compliance of the order dated 28.08.2023 passed by the Coordinate
Bench of this court in WP227 No.686 of 2023 which was dismissed by
the trial court vide its order dated 26.06.2025 holding that the land of
the petitioner has repeatedly been demarcated by the revenue
authorities and to collect evidence the order for demarcation cannot be
passed which is under challenge in the present writ petition.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the issue involved
in the present case is the identity of land of the petitioner as well as
defendant which can only be decided after a proper demarcation report
conducted by the revenue authorities in accordance with law. There are
variance in the report of the revenue authorities every time and in
every demarcation report. The parties have raised objection with
respect to conducting proper demarcation by the authorities, but their
objection were not properly dealt with. He would further submit that
repeatedly the demarcation or the order of demarcation was quashed
by the superior revenue authority, yet no proper demarcation was
conducted with respect to the petitioners land. Therefore, indulgence of
civil court is required to monitor the proper demarcation report for
which he made application before the trial court. It is not collecting or
creating the evidence, but it is calling of report to clarify the true and
correct fact of the spot so that the dispute between the parties can be
finally adjudicated. It is only the revenue authorities who are competent
to demarcate the land and dispute of encroachment or identity of land
is to be decided on the basis of demarcation report. He would further
submit that even after constitution of a team for demarcation of the
land of the petitioner, the first report dated 30.05.2024 was found to be
vague which was subsequently amended on 11.07.2024 which again
remain inconclusive. With the liberty granted by the coordinate Bench
of this court in WP227 No.686 of 2023 vide order dated 28.08.2023,
the petitioner moved his application for demarcation of his land which
has not been considered properly and has been dismissed on
mechanical ground. The proper demarcation in accordance with law is
required to be conducted in the case to find out the exact location and
boundary of Khasra No.76/44 which can only be done after a proper
and conclusive demarcation report. No prejudice would be caused to
any of the parties if proper demarcation is to be conducted to finally
adjudicate the dispute between the parties. Therefore, the petition may
be allowed and the impugned order may be set aside and the
application for demarcation of the suit land from the competent
revenue authorities may be allowed.
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent No.1 opposes
the submissions made by the counsel for the petitioner and have
submitted that time and again the land of the petitioner was
demarcated, however, in every time the report came against him and
he re-agitated the issue by filing various proceedings either in writ
petition or in appeal/revision before the revenue authorities and
challenged the demarcation report. It is the plaintiff’s burden to prove
the fourcorners of the suit land. Under the direction of the Board of
Revenue, the land of the petitioner was again demarcated and report
was submitted on 30.05.2024 and amended report was submitted on
11.07.2024 by the committee constituted for demarcation of the suit
land. The said order for conducting fresh demarcation was passed on
petitioner’s application for demarcation. The said demarcation report
dated 30.05.2024 and amended report dated 11.07.2024 has not been
challenged by the petitioner and it attains its finality. In paragraph 6 of
amended demarcation report dated 11.07.2024, the location of the land
of the petitioner and its fourcorners have been disclosed and in
paragraph 7 and 11 of the said report the location of the land of
respondent No.1 has been mentioned. The said demarcation report
remain un-challenged and therefore there is no need to again
demarcate the land of the petitioner under the supervision of the civil
court. Had the petitioner been disagreed with the demarcation report,
he ought to have challenged it, but he didn’t do so. Therefore, the trial
court has rightly rejected the application of the petitioner which needs
no interference.
8.
I have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the material
annexed with the writ petition.
9.
Order 26 Rule 9 CPC provides for appointment of Commissioner for
local inspection with respect to any dispute regarding boundary of the
subject property and to elucidate any matter in dispute. When there is
a dispute regarding identification of the land or encroachment of the
land, the trial court is competent enough to call the demarcation report
by appointing a local Commissioner invoking its power under Order 26
Rule 9 CPC. In Durga Prasad Vs. Parveen Foujdar And Ors., 1975
SCC Online MP 14, the Madhya Pradesh High Court has held that the
dispute of encroachment can only be decided after proper demarcation
by the revenue authorities. It has been held in the said judgment that :
“Point No. 2: In cases where there is a disputed as to encroachment,
the fact whether there is such an encroachment or not cannot be
determined in the absence of an agreed map, except by the
appointment of a Commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9 of the Code of
Civil Procedure…….”
10.
In Haryana Waqf Board Vs. Shanti Swarup and Others,
2008(8)SCC 671, the Supreme Court has held in paragraph 3 to 7 as
under:
“3.The dispute that was raised by the parties before the court was
whether the respondent had encroached upon any land belonging to
the appellant-Board. Therefore, it cannot be in dispute that the dispute
was in respect of the encroachment of the suit land.
4. Admittedly, in this case, an application was filed under Order 26
Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure which was rejected by the trial
court but in view of the fact that it was a case of demarcation of the
disputed land, it was appropriate for the court to direct the investigation
by appointing a Local Commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9 of the
CPC.
5. The appellate court found that the trial court did not take into
consideration the pleadings of the parties when there was no specific
denial on the part of the respondents regarding the allegations of
unauthorized possession in respect of the suit land by them as per
paragraph 3 of the plaint. But the only controversy between the parties
was regarding demarcation of the suit land because land of the
respondents was adjacent to the suit land and the application for
demarcation filed before the trial court was wrongly rejected.
6. It is also not in dispute that even before the appellate court, the
appellant-Board had filed an application for appointment of a Local
Commissioner for demarcation of the suit land. In our view, this aspect
of the matter was not at all gone into by the High Court while
dismissing the second appeal summarily. The High Court ought to
have considered whether in view of the nature of dispute and in the
facts of the present case, whether the Local Commissioner should be
appointed for the purpose of demarcation in respect of the suit land.
7. For the reasons aforesaid, we are of the view that the High Court
ought to have considered this aspect of the matter and then to decide
the second appeal on merits. Accordingly, we set aside the judgment
and decree passed in the second appeal and the second appeal is
restored to its original file.”
11.
From perusal of record it transpires that on the application made by the
petitioner, the land of the petitioner was demarcated and report was
submitted on 16.01.2019 before the Tehsildar and then the Tehsilar
closed the proceeding on 26.08.2019. The petitioner had challenged
the said demarcation report in revision filed before the Additional
Collector, Durg which was allowed on 23.02.2021 and the Additional
Collector, Durg, has observed in its order dated 23.02.2021 as under:
“(i) करण के लं त अव था म तीन सीमांकन
वेदन कमशः
नांक
26.08.2019, 30.09.2019 व 11.05.2020 हुए है सके अनुसार करण म
अनावेदक की भू नये एवं पुराने न%शे म अलग-अलग थान पर द त होने के
कारण ंदो त के दौरान *ु
ताया गया है। द
ं ो त के दौरान अ लेख/ म *ु
होने के कारण व मान म वाद की
त हुई है।
(ii) सं ता की धारा 129 (सीमांकन), सं ता की धारा 89 ( दो त *ु सुधार
तथा धारा 250 (क5 ा लाने) के अंत त इस 7यायालय का 8े*ा कार नह9 है।
7तु आवेदक के आवेदन प* के आधार पर वाद भू का अधी8क भू -अ लेख
ला का लय द ु से सीमांकन भी करवाया गया है , सम भी ंदो त के दौरान
अ लेख/ म *ु
ताया गया है।
उपरो< वेचना के अनुसार करण म संल> द तावे / के आधार पर म
यह पाता हूं
पू म इस 7यायालय म उ?रवादी @ी स Bर दयाल @ा Cारा
अ
< तहसीलदार लाई नगर के रा व करण कमांक 973-74 व 201718 म पा त आदेश नांक 18.06.2018 से 8ु5ध होकर पुनरी8ण तुत या
गया था सम नांक 25.11.2018 को कले% र द ु Cारा आदेश पा त या
गया सके अनुसार उ?रवादी Cारा आवेदन वापस चाहा गया सके फल वGप
चूं आवेदक अपने आवेदन प*/ म आने का वाही नह9 चाहता है। अतः आवेदक
Cारा तुत दोन/ पुनरी8ण आवेदन/ को र त या ाता है। करण न ती H
कर दा ल दफ?र हो, का आदेश पा त या गया है।
माननीय उJ 7यायालय लासपुर fjV
ीशन कमांक 3072/2018 के
आदेश नांक के अनुसार तहसीलदार को सीमांकन हेतु
त
या गया।
नांक 26.06.2019 को तहसीलदार के Cारा सीमांकन कर सम एस.एल.आर.
के Cारा या गया
वेदन को सीमांकन का अंग मानते हुए आदेश पा त या
गया है। नांक 26.08.2019, 30.09.19 एवं 11.05.2019 के सीमांकन
वेदन म ंदो त *ु
?ाया गया है।
उ?रवादी Kमांक 2 Cारा रा व करण कमांक (1) 7/3(5)/2011-12
(2) 186/3(12)/2010-11 (3) 21/अ (70)/2012-13 उ< सभी करण/ म
अपनी भू खसरा 4726 Lला नं 27 व 28 की
भेलवा ताला के द ण म
कJा ले आउ के अनुसार ताया गया है। अनावेदक के भू के द तावे / म
अनु भागीय अ कारी (रा.) के Cारा इनकी भू को भेलवा ताला के पू
शा म
लाल याही से अं त द या गया है,
पुनरी8णक की मीन प म शा
म है।
दि
ति
र्शि
टि
ब
भि
टि
ब
धि
भि
ब
ब
जि
मि
र्ग
ब
ब
टि
ब
र्मि
नि
ति
ब
हि
स्थि
वि
दि
र्ग
र्या
मि
र्ष
कि
रि
र्ग
ब
ज
कि
ट
शि
र्दे
कि
कि
रि
जि
नि
पि
कि
रि
ति
क्षि
ब
ति
स्थि
मि
ज
दि
र्व
ब
श्चि
ज
र्ता
मि
कि
ब
कि
मि
र्ष
ज
रि
ति
रि
कि
ज
रि
दि
कि
ज
लि
जि
दि
खि
रि
ज
नि
भि
ब
ष
ज
टि
कि
ब
ब
भि
ज
दि
ट
ब
धि
र्शा
कि
त्ति
टि
मि
र्वे
रि
वि
ट
मि
ज
ब
टि
ब
ब
ति
दि
दि
दि
दि
बि
खि
नि
र्य
जि
ट
कि
ज
र्वे
ज
ब
टि
र्व
भि
रि
दि
दि
कि
जि
जि
रि
ति
कि
वि
भि
जि
कि
ज
हि
र्त
ब
मि
जि
बि
7यायालय अ
< तहसीलदार लाई नगर म उ?रवादी कमांक 2 @ी
स Bर दयाल @ा Cारा *ु सुधार ा त आवेदन प*
तुत
या गया है।
आवेदन का अवलोकन करने पर यह पाया गया है
करण कमांक
07/अ(5)/2011-12 म *ु सुधार की आवNयकता नह9 है। आवेदक अपने भू पर
क5 ा चाहता है। अतः क5 ा के
ए ाO कर सकता है। अतः तुत आवेदन
पो नीय नह9 होने से इसी तर पर खा
या ाता है। अतः 07/अ (5) / व
2011-12 म न ती H कर दा ल दफतर हो, का आदेश 7यायालय अ
<
तहसीलदार लाई नगर के Cार नांक 04.05.13 को पा त या गया है, उ<
आदेश की उ?रवादी कमांक 2 Cारा कभी भी अपील या चुनौती नह9 दी गई है और
नह9 यह आदेश र त हुआ है सके कारण उ< पा त आदेश आ
नांक
भावशील है।”
12.
The said order dated 23.02.201 was challenged by the respondent
No.1 before the Commissioner, Durg, which was allowed vide order
dated 23.02.2023 and the order passed by the Additional Collector
Durg was set aside, however, the order passed by the Commissioner
Durg dated 23.02.2023 was again challenged by the petitioner before
the Board of Revenue which was again allowed vide its order dated
14.03.2024 and the order passed by the Commissioner Durg dated
23.02.2023 and order dated 26.08.2019 passed by Additional Tehsildar
Durg and demarcation report dated 22.08.2019 was quashed and the
order passed by the Additional Collector, Durg dated 23.02.2021 was
affirmed and again directed the revenue authorities to demarcate the
land of the petitioner in compliance of the order dated 31.10.2018
passed by coordinate Bench of this court in WPC No.3072 of 2018.
Thereafter, the subject land was again demarcated and report was
submitted on 30.05.2024 and amended report was submitted on
11.07.2024. On instruction, learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the demarcation report dated 30.05.2024 and amended report
dated 11.07.2024 has not been challenged by the petitioner. Since the
demarcation of the land of the petitioner was carried out and report
was submitted which has not been challenged by the petitioner, the
said report was submitted on the application made by the petitioner
before the Additional Tehsildar which traveled up to coordinate Bench
of this court in WPC No.3072 of 2018 decided on 21.10.2018 and
subsequently WP227 No.686 of 2023 which was decided on
28.08.2023 and then the demarcation of the land of the petitioner was
conducted. Since the petitioner was already having demarcation report
which has not been challenged till date, the land of the petitioner
cannot be again put under the subject of demarcation.
13.
Therefore, I do not find any perversity or illegality in the order dated
26.06.2025 passed by the trial court rejecting the application of the
petitioner under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC. However, the petitioner is at
liberty revive his prayer for demarcation of his land in the event if the
said demarcation report is challenged or he would be able to show any
discripency in its genuineness or any procedural lapses to conduct the
demarcation which makes it incorrect demarcation report by leading
their evidence and in such eventuality the trial court shall decide the
application of the petitioner in view of the evidence produced by him
and in accordance with law.
14.
With the aforesaid observations, the writ petition stands disposed of.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review