Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A No.126 of 2023
Shibu Limbu
JC/E- 380007N, Ex-Subedar (B and R) of
Headquarters, 10 Sector, Assam Rifles,
attached to Headquarters, 21 Sector, Assam
Rifles, Agartala, C/O 99 APO.
Permanent residence- Ambootia Tea Estate
Vill- Basseri, P.O- Kurseong, DistDarjeeling, West Bengal, Pin-7342032
…… Appellant (s)
–Versus–
1. The Union of India and Ors
Represented by the Secretary to the
Government of India, Ministry of Home
Affairs, North Block, New Delhi-110011
2. The Director General of Assam Rifles
Directorate General of Assam Rifles, Laitkor,
Shillong-10, Meghalaya.
3. The Inspector General Assam Rifles, (North)
Headquarters IGAR (N), C/O 99 APO, PIN932554.
4. The Inspector General Assam Rifles, (East)
Headquarters IGAR (East), C/O 99 APO, PIN932553
5. Colonel (Administration)
Headquarters IGAR (North), C/O 99 APO,
PIN-932554
6. Ex-Officio Commandant
Headquarters, Nagaland Range,
C/O 99 APO, PIN-934827
(North),
7. IC 65988M-Maj. Deepak Bayala
Recording Officer of SOE
Headquarters Nagaland Range, (North),
C/O 99 APO, PIN-934827
8. The Sector Commander
Headquarters 21 Sector,
C/O 99 APO
Assam
Rifles
…… Respondent(s)
For the Appellant (s)
:
Mr. A. Puri, Adv.
Ms. A. Saha Hirawat, Adv.
For the Respondent (s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI
Date of hearing & delivery of
Judgment & order
:
01.04.2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. A. Puri, learned counsel assisted by Ms. A. Saha Hirawat,
learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioner-appellant and Mr. B. Majumder, learned
Deputy SGI appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The learned Writ Court has dismissed the writ petition vide impugned
judgment dated 24th August, 2023. The petitioner had sought quashing of the impugned
order dated 18th October, 2021 whereby his services were terminated by way of
dismissal. The petitioner had also sought quashing of the order dated 9th March, 2022 by
which the appeal was rejected. The petitioner had sought reinstatement with all pay and
allowances with permission to allow the petitioner to retire at his normal date of
retirement and get all the pensionary and post retirement benefits. The impugned
judgment dated 24.08.2023 reads as under:
“This present application has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
seeking the following reliefs:“i. Certiorari shall not be issued setting aside and quashing the impugned Order
dated 18.10.2021 whereby the service of the petitioner is terminated by way of
dismissal, and,
ii. Certiorari shall not be issued setting aside and quashing the impugned Order
dated 09.03.2022 of the Appellate Authority rejecting the appeal of the
petitioner, and,
iii. Mandamus shall not be issued directing the respondents to reinstate the
petitioner in service with all pay and allowances as it existed at the time of
passing of the impugned order and thereafter, to allow the petitioner to retire
from service with all pension and retirement benefits as the age of the
petitioner is now completed 60 years which is the retirement age in Assam
Rifle and
iv. Mandamus directing the respondents to keep the impugned orders in
abeyance till disposal of the present petition and upon such causes shown be
pleased to make the Rule absolute and/or pass such further order and and/or
direction as Your Lordships may deem fit and proper in the interest of Justice.
AND
Pending disposal of the writ petition. Your Lordship may pleased to pass an
order in the interim staying/suspending the operation of the impugned Order
dated 18.10.2021 and 09.03.2022.”
2. Heard Mr. K.D. Singha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as well as Mr. B.
Majumder, learned CGC appearing for the respondents-Union of India.
3. Mr. K.D. Singha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that respondents
committed arbitrary, unreasonable, high-handed, and malafide action against the petitioner
herein by dismissing him from service vide order dated 18.10.2021 on the ground of
misconduct without proper inquiry/trial and urged this Court to allow this appeal and quash
the impugned order.
4. Heard both sides and perused the evidence on record.
5. In a petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, procedural irregularities
and violation of legal provision are to be highlighted, but on the point of factual aspects and
other issues, the same cannot be appreciated. For that aspect, disciplinary authority and
appellate authority are there but the petitioner has crossed all those limits. Further, the
petitioner herein has been given an opportunity by way of cross-examination by the
respondents in the form of question head, but the petitioner did not choose to take the
opportunity. As such, this Court is of the opinion that the petitioner side has failed to make
out the case, and accordingly, this present writ petition stands dismissed.
6. As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stands closed.”
[3]
Learned counsel for the appellant inter-alia has taken a number of
grounds to assail the impugned order of dismissal from his service and rejection of the
appeal. The chronology of facts and events culled out from the pleadings on record
placed on behalf of the appellant are as under:
S.
No.
Date
05.07.1985
19.01.1987
01.05.1993
04.08.201412.08.2014
24.09.201425.09.2014
29.09.2014
@ Pg. No.129
01.10.2014
@Pg. no. 130
07.10.2014
Particulars
Petitioner was enrolled in Assam Rifles on Recruit/General Duty.
Appointed as Naib Subedar (B&R) in Assam Rifles.
Promoted as Subedar (B&R) in Assam Rifles.
An alleged sting operation was carried out by blacklisted contractor,
Assam Rifles, Mr. CC Mathew in connivance with Mr. Shyju
Maruthumpilly of Tehelka.Com at Imphal, Ukrul, Shillong and
Guwahati to expose the corruption in Assam Rifles.
A purported broadcast was aired in Malayaiam Channel
Mathrubhumi News and Tehelka.com alleging corruption in Assam
Rifles based on the aforesaid alleged sting operation.
A Court of Inquiry was convened by the HQ, DGAR.
Amendment to the convening order in respect of composition of COI
was passed by the HQ, DGAR.
A Corrigendum was issued to the convening order dated 29.09.2014
@Pg. no. 131
03.12.2014
@Pg. 132- 135
09.10.201420.12.2014
@ Pg. no. 220-229
23.12.2014
@ Pg. no. 275-277
25.02.2015
@Pg. no. 136
28.02.2015
@Pg. no. 344-346
02.03.2015
@Pg. no. 137
04.03.201523.05.2015
16.05.2015
@Pg. no. 138
29.05.2017
@Pg. no. 278-279
01.06.2017
04/16.06.2017
@Pg. no.140
08.06.2017
09.06.2017
20.07.2017
@ Pg. No.280-281
13.03.2018
@Pg. No.282-321
27.06.2018
01.07.2019
@Pg. no.322-339
26.02.2020
@Pg. no.340
wherein it was stated that while recording of summary of evidence
Assam rifle Rule 49 (1-4) and Rule 183 will be strictly complied
with.
Mr. C. C. Mathew had approached the Hon'ble Delhi High Court by
filing a writ, petition being WP (Crl.) No.2420/2014 for issuance of a
writ of Mandamus to the Respondents to change the venue of the
Court of Inquiry or in the alternative record the evidence of the
Petitioner at Delhi under the protection of the Respondents as there is
danger and threat to the life of the Petitioner in case of conducting the
inquiry at Silchar, Assam. Hon'ble Delhi High Court disposed off the
Writ Petition vide order dated 03.12.2014 directing the Respondent to
escort Mr. C.C. Mathew to the Court of Inquiry from the airport and
escort back Mr. C.C. Mathew to airport.
A court Inquiry was carried out in the intervening period wherein
Contractor Mr. Suresh Kumar Gupta and Mr. Swapan Sha of Assam
Rifles denied the allegation.
Order of finalization of court inquiry was passed.
Tentative Chargesheet was issued to the Petitioner wherein charges
purported under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act and
Section 49 of Assam Rifle Act were proposed to be framed.
Hearing on charge took place.
Order issued for recording of Summary of Evidence.
Summary of Evidence was recorded at HQ 7 Sector Assam Rifles at
Tuensang (Nagaland)
Recording officer dispensed with the personal appearance of
Complainant Mr. CC Mathew by endorsing certificate on a Letter
sent by him as Written statement and accepted it as evidence.
Order of convening of the General Assam Rifles Court was passed.
Intimation was given that trial will be conducted by General Assam
Rifles Court at HQ 21 Sector, Assam Rifles at Agartala.
Another Chargesheet issued to the Appellant under the Section 55
and Section 49 of the Assam Rifles Act.
General Assam Rifles Court assembled at HQ, 21 Sector, Assam
Rifles, Agartala.
GARC was adjourned till 09.07.2017.
Petitioner filed a Writ petition bearing no. WP(C) No.710/2017
before the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura with a prayer to quash the
Charge Sheet on the ground that the General Assam Rifles Court
cannot carry out trial of offence under the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988 and in violation of the procedure set forth in Assam Rifles
Act, 2006 and Assam Rifles Rules, 2010. The Appellant has also
challenged the findings of the Court of Inquiry and Summary of
Evidence proceedings.
High Court of Tripura passed an order in WPC) No.710/2017 filed by
the petitioner and stayed the GARC proceedings.
Judgment and order passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura in
WP(C) No. 710/2017 whereby it held that the GARC has the
jurisdiction to try offences under PC. Act, 1988 and also directed to
take out the statement (Manuscript @ Pg. No. 210-219) of Mr. CC
Mathew from the SOB and to procure attendance to record his
statement and to allow the petitioner to cross examine him.
Respondent filed Review Petition bearing No.45/2018 filed by the
respondent against the Judgment and Order dated 13.03.2018 passed
in WP(C) No.710/2017.
Hon'ble High Court of Tripura dismissed the Review Petition being
No.45/2018 filed by the respondent against the aforesaid Judgment
and Order dated 13.03.2018 passed in WP(C) No.710/2017
Judgment passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.5136
of 2019 whereby it held that GARC has the jurisdiction to try the
offences under Prevention of Corruption Act.
Order passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Review Petition (Civil)
No. 673 of 2020 in Civil Appeal No.5136 of 2019 whereby it
01.12.2020
@Pg. no.141-149
26.06.2020
@Pg. no.342
15.06.2021
@ Pg. no.150-153
34.
35.
37.
39.
[4]
18.07.2021
@Pg. no.154-172
18.10.2021
@Pg. no.173-177
28.12.2021
@ Pg. No.178-198
09.03.2022
@ Pg. No.196-200
27-05-2022
27.09.2022
@Pg. No.231-346
31.07.2023
@Pg. No.202-230
24.08.2023
@Pg. No.348-349
dismissed the Review Petition.
Respondent filed an Appeal being No. WA/52/2018 before Hon'ble
Division Bench of High Court of Tripura against the Judgment and
Order dated 13.03.2018
Hon'ble Division Bench of High Court of Tripura allowed the Appeal
being No. WA/52/2018 filed by the respondent against the aforesaid
Judgment and Order dated 13.03.2018 passed in WP(C) No.710/2017
whereby it was held that it would be open for GARC to proceed with
the trial and the issue of cross examination of Mr. CC Mathew is kept
open being not necessary to interfere in the interim stage of trial.
Convening order dated 29.05.2017 was cancelled vide order passed
by IGAR (North).
Show Cause Notice for termination of service was issued to the
Appellant under Section 11(1) of Assam rifles Act r/w Rule 20 of the
Assam rifles rules, 2010.
Petitioner submitted its reply to the aforesaid Show cause notice
dated 15.06.2021.
Impugned order passed by the IGAR (North) whereby it terminated
the Petitioner from service by way of dismissal on the ground of
misconduct.
Petitioner preferred an Appeal under Rule 28 of Assam Rifle Rules
before the DGAR against the aforesaid order dated 18.10.21.
Appeal preferred by the petitioner was rejected by the DGAR.
The Petitioner filed Writ Petition vide WP(C) 462 of 2022 before the
Hon'ble High Court praying for issuance of Writ of Certiorari and
Mandamus and/or necessary Order/direction upon the Respondents to
set aside and quashed impugned termination order dated 18.10.2021
whereby the service of the Petitioner was terminated by way of
dismissal and re-instate the Petitioner in service with all pay and
allowances as it existed at the time of passing the impugned order
and thereafter to allow the Petitioner to retire from service with all
pension and retirement benefits.
Counter Affidavit was filed on behalf of the respondents in W.P (C)
462/2022
The Appellant herein filed its Affidavit to bring additional documents
on record.
The Hon'ble Single Judge of the High Court vide Judgment and
Order (Oral) dated 24.08.2023, dismissed the writ petition.
Learned counsel for the appellant, Mr. Puri has inter-alia taken a number
of grounds to question the findings of the disciplinary authority as upheld in appeal.
Apart from that the learned counsel for the appellant has also assailed the impugned
judgment on the ground that it is a non-speaking order. Learned counsel for the appellant
while assailing the impugned order made specific reference to the provisions of Section
11(2) of the Assam Rifles Act, 2006 read with Rule 20 of the Assam Rifles Rules, 2010
and submitted that the plea taken by the respondents in conducting a Force Court as
inexpedient or impracticable, is wholly untenable in law and on facts in the present case.
Learned counsel for the appellant in support of his proposition has placed reliance on the
case of Tarsem Singh vs. State of Punjab and others, reported in (2006) 13 SCC 581,
Prithpal Singh vs. State of Punjab, reported in (2006) 13 SCC 314, wherein the
Constitution Bench judgment in the case of Union of India vs. Tulsiram Patel, reported
in (1985) 3 SCC 398 has also been referred. These are in relation to dispensing of a
regular enquiry under Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India. He also referred to
another judgment of the Apex Court in Union of India and others vs. Ram Bahadur
Yadav, reported in (2022) 1 SCC 389 in context of the similar provisions in the Railway
Protection Force Rules, 1987. He submitted that Rule 20(2) is couched in similar
language. Therefore, the interpretation of Rule 20(2) will follow the principles as have
been held applicable to interpretation of Article 311(2) of the Constitution. In the present
case, there was no such basis to dispense with an enquiry which had already been
commenced by GARC dated 29th May, 2017. However, the Inspector General, Assam
Rifles has cancelled it by an order dated 26th June, 2020 (Page-342 of the memo of
appeal) by a cryptic single line order.
[5]
The learned Writ Court has failed to deal with any of the contentions
raised by the writ petitioner while dismissing the writ petition by a non-speaking order.
Learned counsel for the appellant, therefore, submits that this Court may either remand
the matter for fresh consideration or decide it afresh.
[6]
Learned Deputy SGI appearing for the respondents-Union of India and
Assam Rifles has submitted that a detailed counter affidavit was filed before the Writ
Court contesting the grounds urged by the writ petitioner on all counts. However, he is
not in a position to dispute that the learned Writ Court has not dealt with any of the
grounds of law and facts both urged by the writ petitioner-appellant as contested by the
respondents.
[7]
On consideration of the rival submissions of the parties, we are inclined to
remand the matter to the learned Writ Court for fresh consideration since we are of the
opinion that none of the grounds of law and facts urged by the writ petitioner have been
dealt with by the learned First Court to enable the appellate court to test the correctness
and legality of the impugned judgment. However, since the writ petition has been filed
in the year 2022 and the petitioner is out of service since 2021 and by now, he has also
reached the age of superannuation, the learned Writ Court is requested to decide the writ
petition, if possible, within a period of 3[three] months. However, it is indicated that this
court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the grounds of law or facts urged by
the parties.
The writ appeal is accordingly allowed to the extent as indicated above.
Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA, J)
SUJAY GHOSH
Sujay
GHOSH
Date: 2025.04.03 12:56:54
+05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review