Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP (C) No. 634/2025
Reserved On: 30th of December, 2025.
Pronounced On: 27th of February, 2026.
Uploaded On: 27th of February, 2026.
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Full.
1. Sher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences
& Technology, Jammu through its Vice Chancellor,
Main Campus Chatha, Jammu, 180009.
2. The Registrar, Sher-e-Kashmir University of
Agricultural Sciences & Technology, Main Campus
Chatha, Jammu, Tehsil & District Jammu, 180009.
3. The Dean, Division of Veterinary Surgery
Radiology,
Sher-e-Kashmir
University
of
Agricultural Sciences & Technology, Jammu,
180009.
4. The Head, Division of Veterinary Surgery
Radiology,
Sher-e-Kashmir
University
of
Agricultural Sciences & Technology, Jammu,
180009.
5. The Assistant Registrar (Est), Sher-e-Kashmir
University of Agricultural Sciences & Technology,
Jammu, 180009.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Rahul Pant, Senior Advocate with
Mr Anil Khajuria, Advocate.
V/s
1. Dr. Ankur Sharma
W/O Vikas Gourishanker
R/O Channi Himmat, Jammu, 180015, J&K.
2. The Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir
… Respondent
WP (C) No. 634/2025
Through Principal Secretary to Govt. Agricultural
Production Department, Civil Secretariat, Jammu,
180001.
… Proforma Respondent
Through: Mr Abhinav Sharma, Senior Advocate with
Mr Abhirash Sharma, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MS JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
Shahzad Azeem-J:
01.
The Petitioners have challenged the Order dated February 18,
2025 passed by the learned Central Administrative Tribunal, Jammu Bench,
Jammu [the Tribunal], whereby the Tribunal, while allowing the OA filed by
the Respondent No.1 herein titled ‘Dr. Ankur Sharma v. Union Territory
of J&K and Ors.’, quashed the impugned communication dated December
18, 2024 and directed the Petitioners herein to grant post-facto sanction to
the Respondent No.1 for foreign assignment at the United Arab Emirates
University [UAEU).
FACTS:
02.
The facts in brief relevant to the controversy on hand are that
the Respondent No.1-Dr. Ankur Sharma (Applicant before the Tribunal),
while serving as an Associate Professor at Sher-e-Kashmir University of
Agricultural Sciences & Technology, Jammu (SKUAST), had vide
communication dated October 07, 2024 applied to the competent authority
seeking permission to apply online for the position of Instructor and
Associate/ Professor at the UAEU and further to attend as a follow-up the
interview through same mode. Despite the active follow up by the
Respondent No.1, she faced delays for the requisite permission. The
Respondent No.1, thereafter, received an employment offer from UAEU for
the post of Instructor commencing from January 06, 2025 till July 31, 2028,
renewable by mutual agreement between the parties.
WP (C) No. 634/2025
03.
Accordingly, the Respondent No.1, vide communication dated
December 11, 2024, apprised the Petitioner No.2-the Registrar, SKUAST,
that she had applied and appeared for an online interview for employment
opportunity at the UAEU and now she is being informed of her selection as
an Instructor and tenure whereof has been commencing from January 06,
2025 till July 31, 2028. However, while awaiting the outcome of her request
for necessary permission and protection of lien during the said foreign
assignment, the Respondent No.1 was slapped with a show cause notice dated
December 18, 2024, so as to explain as to how she had applied for the said
foreign assignment and appeared in an interview without formal permission
of the competent authority. Thereafter, the Respondent No.1, vide legal
notice dated December 23, 2024, submitted her reply to the explanation and
thereupon, she had filed OA before the Tribunal titled ‘Dr. Ankur Sharma
v. UT of J&K and Ors.’ and same has been disposed of by the Tribunal vide
impugned Order dated February 18, 2025.
GROUNDS OF CHALLENGE AND SUBMISSIONS:
04.
The contention of the Petitioners is that the Respondent No.1
had applied and was selected for the position/ employment in UAEU without
formal permission by the competent authority, however, the Respondent
No.1 only apprised the University authorities that she had appeared for an
interview for a position in a foreign University and had been selected.
Therefore, seeking employment abroad without permission amounts to
violation of the relevant Rules, accordingly, show cause notice came to be
issued, so as to explain her position.
05.
It is further contended that in essence the communication dated
December 18, 2024 amounts to rejection of the representation of Respondent
No.1, therefore, the Tribunal was not justified in holding that issuance of
communication dated December 18, 2024 was arbitrary and unreasonable. It
is further stated by the Petitioners that once the Rules operating in the field
do not authorize an employee to opt for employment at any other place,
WP (C) No. 634/2025
within or outside the country, the employee in any such event cannot either
make representation for seeking foreign employment or otherwise press a
claim for joining a foreign employment. It was in this backdrop the
Respondent No.1 neither had a right to take an employment in a foreign
country or otherwise obligate the Petitioners to necessarily grant permission
to her for either making application or attending an interview for such
employment.
06.
Further bone of contention of the Petitioners is that the Tribunal
has completely misinterpreted the provisions of the J&K Civil Service
Regulations, 1956 [CSR] and J&K Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1979
[Leave Rules] and also had failed to consider that in absence of any proper
permission or authorization from the competent authority, the Respondent
No.1 had applied for a position in a foreign University and also participated
in an interview in violation of the provisions of the CSR or Leave Rules,
therefore, the Tribunal, while passing the impugned Order, had exceeded its
jurisdiction and also overlooked the fact that the discretionary power lies with
the competent authority. Therefore, the Petitioners finally pray for setting
aside of the impugned Order dated February 18, 2025 as same being passed
in contravention to the statutory rules governing the field.
07.
Per contra, the Respondent No.1 has filed the Objections and
resisted the Petition on the ground that the case of the Respondent No.1 is
squarely covered under Schedule XIX of the CSR. It is further stated that the
Respondent No.1 had duly applied, seeking permission to submit online
application and also to appear in the consequent interview, however, despite
she having remained vigilant and having made every effort to know the status
of her application, no permission was granted in her favour. In this regard,
Respondent No.1 contends that despite she met with the Vice Chancellor,
SKUAST, who assured for grant of requisite permission, but nothing was
done, though she was selected and also received an employment offer.
According to the Respondent No.1, the Tribunal, vide the impugned Order,
WP (C) No. 634/2025
had allowed the OA which is in line with the relevant Rules and also in
conformity with the doctrine of legitimate expectation and equal treatment
under Article 14 of the Constitution.
08.
The other limb of argument is that the Petitioner-University in
similar facts and circumstances has allowed numerous employees of the
University to take up foreign employment/ assignment, therefore, in the case
of the Respondent No.1, the Petitioners are bound to give equal treatment as
has been done in similarly situated cases.
09.
Much reliance has also been placed on the instructions on
Foreign Assignment of Indian Experts issued by the Department of Personnel
and Training, that according to the learned Counsel for the Respondent No.1,
are duly followed by the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR). In
this regard, the learned Counsel canvassed at Bar that as per the guidelines,
the clearance in cases of foreign assignment is to be obtained from the
respective Cadre Controlling Authority and, in the case of the Respondent
No.1, the Cadre Controlling Authority, being the Head of the Department of
Veterinary Sciences, who had duly cleared the application of the Respondent
No.1, therefore, there was no plausible reason to delay or deny the permission
in favour of the Respondent No.1 to take up foreign employment, hence no
fault can be found with the Order of the Tribunal.
ANALYSIS:
10.
Broadly speaking, the point that needs consideration is that
whether a Government employee can apply for foreign employment without
obtaining prior permission from the competent authority and whether, in
absence of any violation of statutory rules or provisions, the interference by
the Tribunal is legally justified solely on the basis of a show cause notice
issued to the employee. Answer to the point under consideration lies on the
interplay between the relevant provisions of the CSR, Leave Rules and the
WP (C) No. 634/2025
J&K Government Employees (Conduct) Rules, 1971 [Conduct Rules],
respectively.
11.
It is an admitted fact that the Respondent No.1, in absence of the
requisite permission from the University authorities, had not only applied
online for the said post, but also participated in the interview, whereupon she
was issued a show cause notice dated December 18, 2024, that was impugned
before the Tribunal, whereby explanation was called for applying and
appearing in an interview without formal permission of the competent
authority for a foreign employment.
12.
From the factual narration as adumbrated, it is conspicuous that
the Respondent No.1 approached the Tribunal by calling in question the show
cause notice dated December 18, 2024, mainly, on the ground of delay in
considering her request by the University authorities for grant of permission
to apply online and to participate in the interview for a position in UAEU.
13.
The reasoning that appears to have prevailed with the Tribunal,
while passing the impugned Order dated February 18, 2025 proceeds on two
considerations: firstly, that the University authorities have failed to take
timely action on the request of the Applicant-Respondent No.1, and same
amounts to administrative negligence, therefore, show cause notice dated
December 18, 2024 was quashed; secondly, the Tribunal had come to the
conclusion that in terms of Schedule XIX of CSR and Rule 14 (b) of the
Leave Rules, the Applicant-Respondent No.1 is entitled to go abroad for
employment of her own and thus directed the University Authorities to grant
post-facto sanction to the Respondent No.1-Applicant for foreign assignment
at UAEU in terms of Schedule XIX of CSR and Rule 14 (b) of Leave Rules.
14.
Insofar as the period of service spent on foreign assignments is
concerned, same is regulated by Article 55-A of CSR, that, in turn, refers to
the guidelines contained in Schedule XIX of CSR and the Tribunal had also
placed reliance on the same.
WP (C) No. 634/2025
15.
Now, coming to Schedule XIX of CSR, that regulates the terms
and conditions of service during foreign assignments, same categorises
foreign assignment under three heads which, for ready reference, read thus:
“(a) When a Government servant is selected by the
Government of India for foreign assignment with a foreign
country after due sponsorship by the Central Government;
(b) When a Government servant of his own, manages an
offer for a foreign country; and
(c) When a Government servant of his own, wants to go
abroad for prosecution of higher studies and side by side takes
up employment there.”
16.
Categories (a) and (c) are admittedly not applicable to the case
on hand, in that, the Respondent No.1-Applicant was neither selected by the
Government of India for foreign assignment nor she wanted to go abroad for
prosecution of higher studies, therefore, the case of the Respondent No.1 falls
within the category (b) which deals with a situation when a Government
servant, of his own, manages an offer in a foreign country.
17.
Schedule XIX of CSR further provides that regarding category
(b) cases, the Department may take action in terms of the provisions
contained in Rule 14 (b) of the Leave Rules. It further provides that if a
person seeks employment abroad and joins foreign assignments without
seeking proper permission of the Government to take up such assignments,
same infringe the Rules and, in such cases, disciplinary action shall be taken
for the unauthorized absence. It further provides that such action includes
termination of service.
18.
Now, coming to Rule 14 (b) of the Leave Rules, same, inter alia,
provides that if a Government servant, desirous of taking up service or
employment under a non-Government employer, he may be required to
resign his appointment before taking up any other service or employment,
except where grant of permission to serve elsewhere is considered desirable
in any exceptional case.
WP (C) No. 634/2025
19.
Rule 14 (b) of the Leave Rules is in two parts. Under the first
part, the Government servant, who is desirous of taking up service or
employment under a non-Government employer, may be required to resign
his appointment before taking up any other service or employment; and the
second part of it is an exception to the first part, which provides that except
where grant of permission to serve elsewhere is considered desirable in any
exceptional case.
20.
The expression “except where grant of permission to serve
elsewhere is considered desirable in any exceptional case” (emphasis
supplied) carries important connotations, which confers discretionary power
and also implies subjective judgment by the employer which falls within its
exclusive discretion and domain, if the employer finds it appropriate or
beneficial but, in no case, it creates a right enforceable unless a specific
provision of law found to be contravened. It is simply for this reason that the
Tribunal was not supposed to substitute its own judgment for that of the
employer in matters of administrative desirability and policy.
21.
Apart from the already discussed statutory provisions so far,
there is another aspect of the matter having far reaching consequences that
perhaps, while analyzing the interplay between the provisions of CSR and
Leave Rules, somewhere Rule 10 (1) of the Conduct Rules has escaped from
the attention of the Tribunal, relevant portion whereof reads, thus:
“No Government employee, whether on leave or active
service, shall except with the previous sanction of the
Government, engage directly or indirectly in any trade or
business or undertake any other employment.
Provided ……”
22.
Therefore, in the wake of the above statutory position governing
the employment elsewhere, that too abroad without seeking previous
sanction of the Government, same not only amounts to misconduct but also
violates the statutory safeguards contained under the provisions of the CSR
and Leave Rules, respectively.
WP (C) No. 634/2025
23.
Where the discretion to grant permission to take up foreign
assignment/ job lies with the employer, the Tribunal generally cannot direct
the employer to grant such permission, as in the case of granting permission
for leave, foreign assignment or similar administrative permissions, to grant
or to refuse the necessary permission lies within the discretion of the
employer and, thus, the role of the Tribunal is very limited to adjudicate and
consider as to whether the action of the employer contravenes any statutory
provision involving right of an employee to ask for permission to go abroad
or same is mala fide and discretionary, but, in any case, the Tribunal cannot
substitute its own decision for that of the employer or mandating the grant of
permission outright as that would amount to interfering with the legitimate
administrative discretion.
24.
Nonetheless, the Tribunal, of course, can interfere if the
employer’s decision is illegal, arbitrary, mala fide or violates the statutory or
rules of natural justice. The Tribunal, however, can also direct the employer
to consider the application properly and fairly and pass a reasoned order or
reconsider the issue in accordance with law/ rules, but, in no case, can grant
permission itself and to direct the employer to issue the formal orders in tune
with its direction.
25.
Since, conditions of service during foreign assignments of a
Government servant are being regulated under Schedule XIX of CSR and the
case on hand falls within the category (b) of the cases mentioned under
Schedule XIX, that in an unequivocal terms postulates that a person who
seeks employment abroad and joins foreign assignments without seeking
proper permission of the Government to take up such assignments infringe
the Rules and, in such cases, disciplinary action has to be taken for their
unauthorized absence and such action includes termination of service,
however, this is subject to the action if any taken by the employer in terms of
Rule 14 (b) of the Leave Rules. Under Rule 14 (b) of Leave Rules either the
employer may require the employee to resign his appointment before taking
WP (C) No. 634/2025
up any other service or employment or, in exceptional cases, may grant
permission to serve elsewhere if considered desirable.
26.
Therefore, on a plain reading of the relevant provisions of
Schedule XIX of the CSR and Rule 14 (b) of the Leave Rules in conjunction
with Rule 10 of Conduct Rules there remains no iota of doubt that if a
Government servant takes up foreign assignment without seeking proper
permission, same amounts to misconduct and calls for disciplinary action,
except if, any action is taken in terms of Rule 14 (b) of the Leave Rules,
including considering the desirability to grant such permission. Therefore, it
appears that while directing for grant of post-facto sanction in favour of
Respondent No.1-Applicant for taking up a foreign assignment, the Tribunal
had arrogated to itself the discretionary power which the employer would
otherwise have exercised.
27.
Notwithstanding the above factual and legal aspects of the
matter, even otherwise, the contention of the Respondent No.1, all along, that
there is no statutory prohibition barring from taking up foreign assignment
flies in the face of Rule 10 of the Conduct Rules, which is couched in a
mandatory language and enjoins upon a Government employee to not engage
directly or indirectly in any trade or business or to undertake any other
employment, except with the previous sanction of the Government, therefore,
if without seeking previous sanction of the Government, an employee takes
up any employment, as in the case on hand, a foreign assignment, he/ she has
to run the risk of misconduct and disciplinary proceedings in terms of Rule
10 of the Conduct Rules.
28.
Needless to say, even otherwise, the Respondent No.1 may not
have a cause to approach the Tribunal against a mere show cause notice as
the competent authority has yet to take a call on the explanation tendered by
her. In this regard, we are fortified in our view by the Judgments passed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled ‘Union of India v. Kunisetty
WP (C) No. 634/2025
Satyanarayana, (2006) 12 SCC 28’ and ‘Secretary, Ministry of Defence
& Ors. v. Prabhash Chandra Mirdha, (2012) 11 SCC 565’.
29.
In view of above, we are of the considered opinion that the
Tribunal has overstepped by substituting its views in place of the competent
authority by quashing the show cause notice dated December 18, 2024,
instead of leaving it to the employer to consider the case within the ambit of
the Rules governing the subject.
RESULT:
30.
As a necessary corollary to the above discussion, the instant
Petition is allowed and the impugned Order dated February 18, 2025 passed
by the Tribunal is hereby set aside. However, in the peculiar facts and
circumstances of the case and in order to balance the equity, the Petitioners
are directed to consider the application of the Respondent No. 1 for grant of
permission strictly within the contours of law by a speaking Order, within a
period of four weeks from the date copy of this Judgment is made available.
31.
Writ Petition is, accordingly, disposed of in the above terms,
along with any pending CM(s).
(SHAHZAD AZEEM)
JUDGE
(SINDHU SHARMA)
JUDGE
JAMMU
February 27th, 2026
“TAHIR”
i.
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Whether the Judgment is approved for reporting?
YES.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review