The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. 03.1971. Page No.# 9/13 11) The learned Tribunal, upon appreciating the exhibited documents, had referred to the names of voters contained in Ext.1 and Ext.2, and held that the names recorded as electors, ex facie does not prove its relevancy. In respect of Ext.3, the voter’s list of 1985, as it contained in the name of the petitioner, the said exhibit was stated to be a relevant document with regard to Sher Ali, the petitioner. In connection with Ext.4, Ext.5 and Ext.6, the learned Tribunal referred to the names of petitioner, his wife Kosiron Nessa and their sons and daughters, not connected with Kaser Ali and Basatan Nessa of Ext.1 and Basatan Nessa, Idrish Ali and his wife Lalbhanu of Ext.2. Accordingly, Ext.1 and Ext.2 were rejected as their relevancy with regard to Sher Ali is not proved. It was held that as a logical corollary of the finding of Ext.3, Ext.4, Ext.5 and Ext.6, the petitioner’s claim to relationship with his projected father, Kaser Ali, his wife Basatan Nessa and their son Idrish Ali was rejected as not proved. It was held that the petitioner’s claimed place of birth with no pleading on his date of birth was also held to be not proved. It was held that earliest presence of the petitioner in Assam was in 1985 at 35 years of age vide Ext.3, which is post 25.03.1971 period document, with no connection with Ext.1 and Ext.2. Moreover, in the absence of documenta…
05. 04.2019. Therefore, it cannot be said that the said Ext.7 has been proved in accordance with law because the said exhibit is not supported by any certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act, 1872. Moreover, neither the petitioner nor the DW-2 had made any effort to exhibit the contents of the said Ext.7. It is too well settled that exhibiting of a document and proof of its contents are two separate things. In this case, the petitioner has failed to show from the said Ext.7 that the name of the petitioner or any other person through whom he is claiming title had his or her name in the record of rights prior to 25.03.1971, which is the cut-off date. Therefore, the discarding of the said exhibit also cannot be faulted with. Page No.# 13/13 19) Therefore, on all counts, the challenge to the impugned opinion fails. Resultantly, the writ petition fails and the same is dismissed. The consequences of the opinion dated 16.07.2019, passed by the learned Member, Foreigners’ Tribunal, Barpeta 11th, at Sarbhog, in (Bpt/11th) F.T. 940/2016 would follow. 20) Interim bail granted to the petitioner vide order dated
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010273382019
2026:GAU-AS:10038
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/8302/2019
SHER ALI
S/O- KASER ALI @ KASER, VILL- KHARBALLI, MOUZA- RUPSHI, P.S.
KALGACHIA, DIST- BARPETA ASSAM, PIN- 781301
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 6 ORS.
REP. BY THE SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF HOME
AFFAIRS, NEW DELHI-1
2:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
NEW DELHI-1
3:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP. BY THE COMM. AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
HOME DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY-6
4:THE ASSAM CO-ORDINATOR OF NRC
BHANGAGARH
ASSAM
GHY-5
5:THE DY. COMMISSIONER
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN- 781301
6:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM
Page No.# 2/13
PIN- 781301
7:THE OFFICER-IN-CHARGE
KALGACHIA P.S.
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN- 78130
Advocate for the Petitioner
AHMED,MS F N ZAMAN
: MR. M U MAHMUD, MR S H MAHMUD,MS K GOGOI,MS. R
Advocate for the Respondent : ASSTT.S.G.I., SC, NRC,SC, ELECTION COMMISSION.,SC, F.T
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
Advocate for the petitioner
Advocate for the respondents
: Mr. M.U. Mahmud.
: Mr. A.K. Dutta, CGC,
: Mr. A. I. Ali, SC, ECI,
: Mrs. R.B. Bora, Jr. G.A.,
: Mr. G. Sarma, SC, FT,
Border matters and NRC.
Date on which judgment was reserved : 20.04.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 22.07.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(Kalyan Rai Surana, J.)
Heard Mr. M.U. Mahmud, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. A.K. Dutta, learned CGC for respondent no.1; Mr. A.I. Ali, learned
advocate, standing counsel for respondent no.2; Mr. G. Sarma, learned
advocate, standing counsel for FT matter, Border and NRC, for respondent nos.
Page No.# 3/13
3, 4, 6 and 7; and Ms. R.B. Bora, learned Junior Govt. Advocate for respondent
no.5.
2)
The opinion dated 16.07.2019, passed by the learned Member,
Foreigners Tribunal, Barpeta 11th, at Sarbhog, in (Bpt/11th) F.T. 940/2016, by
which the petitioner was declared to be a foreigner of post 25.03.1971 stream,
is assailed by filing this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
3)
The learned counsel for the petitioner had submitted as
follows:a.
It was submitted that the petitioner was the son of Kaser Ali @
Kaser and Basaton Nessa. His grandfather is Khosh Mamud. He was
born at Village- Kharballi, under P.S. Sorbhog, in the district of Kamrup
(presently, under P.S. Kalgachia, in the district of Barpeta), where he is
permanently residing. Late Idrish Ali was his brother and Late Kasiran
and Late Rofiya Khatun were his sisters. Kosiran Nessa is his wife and
he has three sons and two daughters, namely, Kasimuddin,
Jahimuddin, Mohidul Islam, Rajida Khatun, wife of Shajahan Ali and
Samiran Nessa, wife of Mohibul Sikdar.
b.
It was submitted that the petitioner had exhibited all the relevant
documents, which proves that the petitioner had discharged his burden
to show that he is an Indian and not a foreigner.
c.
The voter’s list of 1966 (Ext.1) was in respect of Kaser Ali, son of
Khosh Mamud, father of the petitioner, and Basatan Nessa, his mother,
who were the voters of village- Kharballi; voter list of 1970 (Ext.2),
was in respect of Basatan Nessa, mother of the petitioner, who was a
Page No.# 4/13
voter at Kharballi; voter list of 1985 (Ext.3) is in respect of Sher Ali,
petitioner, son of Kaser, a voter at village- Kharballi; voter’s lists of
1989 (Ext.4), 2010 (Ext.5), and 2017 (Ext.6), are in respect of the
petitioner, his wife Mofida Khatun and his son Kasimuddin.
d.
He had submitted that the petitioner had also exhibited
jamabandi in respect of his land measuring 1 bigha- 0 katha- 6 lessa,
covered by Dag No. 159, K.P. Patta No. 219 of village- Kharballi, under
Kalgachia Revenue Circle, in the names of 10 (ten) pattadars, including
the petitioner.
e.
Accordingly, it was submitted that the petitioner is all throughout
in the same village, having landed property and has proved his link
with his projected parents. Moreover, it was submitted that entries in a
jamabandi cannot be disbelieved.
f.
It was submitted that without any discussion, the learned
Tribunal had discarded all exhibited documents with a comment “not
proved”, which is impermissible.
g.
It was also submitted that certified copies must be accepted by
the Foreigners Tribunals, and could not have been discarded as
inadmissible and not proved.
h.
It was submitted that the evidence of Amzad Ali, the nephew of
the petitioner was disbelieved and discarded without any discussion,
though he had stated that he is the grandson of Koser Ali and Basatan
Nessa.
i.
It was submitted that the State did not cross-examine the
witnesses examined by the petitioner and thus, none of his statements
were controverted. Moreover, no evidence was tendered by the State.
Page No.# 5/13
j.
Accordingly, it was submitted that the impugned opinion is not
sustainable on facts and in law and the same is liable to be set aside
by declaring the petitioner to be an Indian citizen.
k.
No other submission was made and no case law was cited at the
Bar. However, a copy of the judgment of the Supreme Court of India in
the case of Sirajul Hoque v. Union of India, Crl. Appeal No. 267/2019,
decided on 14.02.2019, is found annexed in the writ petition as
Annexure-9.
4)
Per contra, the learned standing counsel for the FT, Border
matter and NRC has submitted that the name of the petitioner appears for the
first time in the voter list of 1985, where his age is recorded as 35 years. Thus,
the presence of the petitioner in Indian soil is not there before the cut of date of
25.03.1971. It was submitted that the continuous presence of the parents of the
petitioner for 15 years between the years 1970 and 1985 is also not proved.
Moreover, there is absence of pleadings as to where the father of the petitioner
was born; date when his parents died; and moreover, disclosure of all family
members has also not been made. It was also submitted that Amzad Ali (DW-2)
did not prove his relationship with his projected grandparents and parents and
could not show that his father was the brother of the petitioner. Thus, it was
submitted that the petitioner has manufactured a family by taking advantage of
name appearing in the voter list of 1966 and then projecting him to be his
father.
5)
Perused the Tribunal’s records, also considered the submissions
and cases cited at the Bar.
6)
The petitioner, in his written statement, has stated that at no
Page No.# 6/13
point of time he was asked to submit any document to the police or to the L.V.O
(i.e. Local Verification Officer for short) in support of his citizenship. He had
stated that he was a citizen of India and born at village- Kharballi under
Sarbhog P.S. (now Kalgachia P.S.), in the District of Barpeta (then, Kamrup). The
name of his father is Kaser Ali, name of his mother is Basatan Nessa, name of
his grandfather is Khish Momud. His elder brother was Idrish Ali (deceased), He
had two sisters, Kasiran (expired) and Rofiya Khatun (expired). He had one
uncle- Naser Sheikh (expired). Kosiran Nessa is his wife. Kasimuddin,
Jashimudin and Mohidul Islam are his three sons and Rafika Khatun, married to
Shajahan Ali and Samiran Nessa, married to Mohibul Sikdar are his two
daughters. His age is 68 years and is permanently residing at village- Kharballi.
No F.T. Case is pending against any other family member. He had stated that the
name of his parents has been recorded in the voter list of 1966. In the voter list
of 1970, the name of his mother, elder brother (Idrish Ali), elder brother’s wife
(Lal Bhanu), has been recorded. His own name (Sher Ali) has been recorded in
the voter list of 1985. His name (Sher Ali) and his wife (Kosiran Nessa) has been
recorded in the voter list of 1989. His name, name of his wife (Kosiran Nessa),
son (Karimuddin) and son’s wife (Mofida Khatun) has been recorded in the voter
list of 2010. His name (Sher Ali), wife (Kosiran Nessa), son (Karimuddin), son’s
wife (Mofida Khatun), son (Jahiruddin), and son’s wife (Basatan Nessa), has
been recorded in the voter list of 2017. He had stated that his name has been
recorded in the jamabandi of land, as Sher Ali, son of Kaser Ali. He has been
issued with an Elector Photo Identity Card (EPIC for short). The Gaonburah of
villages Amguri, Kharballi and Sutirpathar, Charge No. 17, had issued a
certificate in his name showing his identity and present residential status.
Accordingly, it was stated that he is a citizen of India and to dismiss the
Page No.# 7/13
reference.
7)
It may be mentioned that in paragraph 5 of his written
statement, the name of his eldest son is written as Kasimuddin, but in
paragraph 12, and 13, the name of his eldest son is written as Karimuddin.
8)
In support of his defence, the petitioner had examined himself
as DW-1. He had also examined Amzad Ali, son of petitioner’s projected elder
brother.
9)
In his examination in chief, the petitioner has stated that his
parents were born at village Kharballi, under Kalgachia PS and the names are
recorded in the voter list of 1966. The name of his mother is recorded in the
voter list of 1970 along with the name of his elder brother, namely, Idrish Ali
and Lalbhanu, wife of Idrish Ali, i.e. his sister-in-law. He had cast his first vote
in the year 1985, but he does not know his age in that year. He had stated that
he has been casting his vote regularly since then till date. His name has been
reflected in the land document of jamabandi record of village Kharballi in
respect of land measuring 0B-2K-10L, vide dag No. 159 and patta no. 219
situated in village Kharballi. He has been issued EPIC. He has three sons and
two daughters. His three sons are- (i) Kasimuddin, (ii) Jahimuddin, (iii) Mahidul,
and his two daughters are- (i) Samiran Nessa, wife of (not remembered), (ii)
Rezida, wife of Shajahan, Sontali PS, Boko. They are two brothers. The other
one is Idrish Ali, who is no more. He had two sisters, namely, Kasiron Nessa and
Rufiya Khatun, who are both dead. His grandfather was Kosh Mahmud, whom
he had not seen during his lifetime. His father had one brother, Late Noser Sk,
who died long ago. In his cross-examination, he had stated he does not
remember when his father died. His mother died after 1970. He had denied that
Page No.# 8/13
Kaser Ali whose name is recorded in the voter list of 1966 is not his father. He
was at village Kharballi before he had casted his vote in 1985. He does not
know why the name of his wife or other close relatives were not included in the
voter list of 1985 or thereafter along with his name. He had denied that the land
which is recorded in his name and in the name of his brother Idrish Ali does not
prove their nationality. He had also denied that he came to Assam from
Bangladesh after 25.03.1971.
10)
The petitioner had examined Md. Amzad Ali, son of Late Idrish
Alias DW-2. In his examination-in-chief, he had stated that his is the grandson
of Koser Ali. Basatan Nessa was his grandmother. Their names were enrolled in
the voter list of 1965 as resident of Kharballi under Jania LAC. He does not
know the house number and serial number. His grandmother’s name is recorded
in the voter list of 1970 along with the name of his parents. He had stated that
Sher Ali is his parental uncle and younger brother of his father. He had stated
that Sher Ali is a voter after 1970 and is a regular voter till date. Sher Ali has
five children. His father died three years ago. His house is half km from the
house of Sher Ali in village Kharballi. Sher Ali possesses land property at
Kharballi jointly with his brother Idrish Ali. He does now know his dag number
and patta number. He had stated that Sher Ali is a citizen of India by birth. In
his cross examination, DW-2 had stated that he has not furnished the common
voters list with his father to prove his identity. He had submitted the EPIC to
prove his relation with his father Idrish Ali. He had denied that he is not the son
of Idrish Ali. He has denied that his identity is not proved. He has denied that
his testimony is not supported with his documentary evidence and they are not
reliable. He had denied that Sher Ali came to Assam from Bangladesh after
25.03.1971.
Page No.# 9/13
11)
The
learned
Tribunal,
upon
appreciating
the
exhibited
documents, had referred to the names of voters contained in Ext.1 and Ext.2,
and held that the names recorded as electors, ex facie does not prove its
relevancy. In respect of Ext.3, the voter’s list of 1985, as it contained in the
name of the petitioner, the said exhibit was stated to be a relevant document
with regard to Sher Ali, the petitioner. In connection with Ext.4, Ext.5 and Ext.6,
the learned Tribunal referred to the names of petitioner, his wife Kosiron Nessa
and their sons and daughters, not connected with Kaser Ali and Basatan Nessa
of Ext.1 and Basatan Nessa, Idrish Ali and his wife Lalbhanu of Ext.2.
Accordingly, Ext.1 and Ext.2 were rejected as their relevancy with regard to Sher
Ali is not proved. It was held that as a logical corollary of the finding of Ext.3,
Ext.4, Ext.5 and Ext.6, the petitioner’s claim to relationship with his projected
father, Kaser Ali, his wife Basatan Nessa and their son Idrish Ali was rejected as
not proved. It was held that the petitioner’s claimed place of birth with no
pleading on his date of birth was also held to be not proved. It was held that
earliest presence of the petitioner in Assam was in 1985 at 35 years of age vide
Ext.3, which is post 25.03.1971 period document, with no connection with Ext.1
and Ext.2. Moreover, in the absence of documentary evidence, the oral evidence
of the petitioner (DW-1) and of Amzad Ali (DW-2), recorded on oath was also
rejected. Resultantly, the learned Tribunal declared the petitioner to be a
foreigner of post 1971 stream and liable to appropriate follow up action.
12)
On a careful perusal of records, it is noticed that while recording
their respective examination-in-chief, the DW-1 and DW-2, had not exhibited
any documents. However, 7 (seven) documents were marked as Ext.1 to Ext.7
by the learned Tribunal on 01.07.2019. As per the order-sheet, DW-1 was
examined on 01.07.2019. The DW-2 was examined on 04.07.2019, but no
Page No.# 10/13
documents were marked as exhibits by the learned Tribunal on 04.07.2019.
13)
Out of the seven exhibited documents, Ext.1 to Ext.6 are voters
lists. The voters, whose name appear in the said exhibits are as follows:Name of voter and voter Relation
list year
VL- 1966
Relation:
Kaser Ali
Khosh Mamud
Basatan Nessa
Kaser Ali
VL- 1970
Relation:
Basatan Nessa
Kaser
Idrish Ali
Kaser Ali
Lalbhanu
Idrish
Village
Ext. No.
Age
Khar Balli
Ext.1
Khar Balli
Ext.2
Age
Age
VL- 1985
Sher Ali
VL- 1989
Sher Ali
Kosiran Nessa
VL- 2010
Sher Ali
Kosiran Nessa
Kasimuddin
Mofida Khatun
VL- 2017
Sher Ali
Kosiran Nessa
Kasimuddin
Mofida Khatun
Jahimuddin
Basatan Nessa
Khar Balli
Ext.3
Khar Balli
Ext.4
Khar Balli
Ext.5
Khar Balli
Ext.6
14)
Relation:
Kaser
Relation:
Kaser
Sher
Relation:
Kaser
Sher Ali
Sher Ali
Kasimuddin
Relation:
Kaser
Sher Ali
Sher Ali
Kasimuddin
Sher Ali
Mohidul Islam
Age
Age
Age
Age
In the case ofMd. Fakharuddin v. Union of India, W.P. (C)
4512/2016, decided on 28.02.2018, this Court has held that just because name
of a person is enlisted in the voter list, it would not mean that he is a citizen of
India. Enlistment of name in voter list or long stay in the Country per se are no
proof of citizenship. In the case of Aziz Miya @ Md. Aziz Mia v. Union of India,
Page No.# 11/13
2024 (4) GLT 246, this Court has held that a mere claim by a suspected person
by referring to voters list, claiming that person to be his father, is not a
conclusive proof and by doing so he has discharged his burden that he is not a
foreigner and hence, there is further requirement to prove that the person who
is reflected in the voters list is actually the father who makes the claim will have
to be further substantiated with further material record. Therefore, the exhibited
voter’s lists, being Ext.1 to Ext.6 does not help the petitioner to establish that he
is an Indian or that he draws his lineage from his projected father, whose
existence in India is proved to be prior to the cut-off date of 25.03.1971.
15)
In this case, the petitioner is not a voter along with his father in
any exhibited voter list. The names of his projected father and mother appeared
in the voter list of 1966. The name of his projected mother, Basanta Nessa,
appears with the name of Idrish Ali and Lalbhanu and the petitioner claims that
Idrish Ali and Lalbhanu are his elder brother and the wife of his elder brother
respectively. In the written statement, the petitioner has neither pleaded
regarding the year of death of his parents not about his projected elder brother
and elder brother’s wife. The existence of his projected father vanishes after
1966. The name of his projected mother and projected brother vanishes after
1970. The name of the petitioner appears in the voter list of 1985 at the age of
35 years, with no explanation why his name not appeared immediately after his
attained the age of 21 years. There is no existence of any family members of
the petitioner for a long period of 15 (fifteen) years between 1970 and 1985.
The petitioner has not exhibited any other voter list containing the name of his
projected mother and projected brother together after 1970. Moreover, the
name of the petitioner does not appear in any electoral roll with his brother
Idrish Ali. Thus, the petitioner has not been able to show that he or his
Page No.# 12/13
projected parents had continuously stayed in India from prior to 25.03.1971 till
the year 1985, when his name appears in the voter’s list of 1985.
16)
Thus, the petitioner has not been able to show that he or his
parents had continuous stay in the Country as per requirement of Section 6A(3)
(b) of the Citizenship Act, 1955.
17)
Therefore, on the basis of entries in the exhibited voter’s lists
alone, it cannot be held that the opinion of the learned Tribunal that the
petitioner could prove his citizenship. Therefore, on that count, the opinion of
the learned Tribunal cannot be faulted with.
18)
The petitioner had exhibited the jamabandi (land revenue
record) as Ext.7, but the said Ext.7 is not a certified copy but a system
generated printout. Though the signature of the Circle Officer, Kalgachia
Revenue Circle is affixed in the said document, but above his signature is a note
to the following effect- “please note this is a system generated certificate and
does not need any signature” and the date of generation of the said print-out is
05.04.2019. Therefore, it cannot be said that the said Ext.7 has been proved in
accordance with law because the said exhibit is not supported by any certificate
under Section 65B of the Evidence Act, 1872. Moreover, neither the petitioner
nor the DW-2 had made any effort to exhibit the contents of the said Ext.7. It is
too well settled that exhibiting of a document and proof of its contents are two
separate things. In this case, the petitioner has failed to show from the said
Ext.7 that the name of the petitioner or any other person through whom he is
claiming title had his or her name in the record of rights prior to 25.03.1971,
which is the cut-off date. Therefore, the discarding of the said exhibit also
cannot be faulted with.
Page No.# 13/13
19)
Therefore, on all counts, the challenge to the impugned opinion
fails. Resultantly, the writ petition fails and the same is dismissed. The
consequences of the opinion dated 16.07.2019, passed by the learned Member,
Foreigners’ Tribunal, Barpeta 11th, at Sarbhog, in (Bpt/11th) F.T. 940/2016 would
follow.
20)
Interim bail granted to the petitioner vide order dated
28.08.2020, stands vacated.
21)
The Registry shall return back the Tribunal records along with a
copy of this order, to be made a part of records by the said learned Tribunal.
JUDGE
JUDGE.
Rajbongshi
Date: 2026.07.22 14:43:03 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
Private Secretary
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review