The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. Learned trial Court, while dismissing the application filed by the petitioner under Order 7, Rule 11 CPC, has observed as under :"Admittedly, an agreement to sell can not be said to be "Instrument securing property" or it does not assure vesting right of the title in the transferee and extinction of transferor's interest. Thus, agreement to sell can not be treated at par with the sale deed. The reliance is placed by counsel for the defendant No. 1, in the judgment Suhrid Singh @ Sardool Singh v. Randhir Singh & others, is distinguishable in the facts and circumstances of the present case because relief in those cases is for declaration for cancellation of sale deed, but in this present case, it is related to the agreement to sell. Thus, the plaintiff need not to affix Ad-valorem Court fees over seeking relief of cancellation of agreement to sell. Thus, this application u/o 7 rule 11 CPC is hereby dismissed."”
16. In view of the above, present Revision Petition stands allowed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
Date of decision: 30.04.2026
Shekhar & Others
...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
Rajesh & Another
...Respondent(s)
CORAM:
HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GUPTA
Present:-
Mr. Partap Singh, Advocate
Mr. M.S. Kathuriya, Advocate
for the petitioners.
***
NIDHI GUPTA, J.
Present Revision Petition has been filed by the plaintiffs laying
challenge to the order dated 23.09.2025 (Annexure P8) passed by learned
Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Karnal, whereby application filed by
the respondents/defendants under Order 7 Rule 11(d) read with Section 151
CPC seeking rejection of plaint on ground of non-payment of requisite Court
fee, has been allowed.
2.
Brief facts of the case in chronological order are as under:-
13.05.2024: The plaintiffs had filed present Civil Suit dated 13.05.2024
(Annexure P2) seeking declaration that the Agreement to Sell dated
11.10.2023 was illegal null and void; with consequential relief of permanent
injunction against the respondents/defendants.
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
18.05.2024: Vide order dated 18.05.2024 (Annexure P3), parties to the Suit
were directed to maintain status quo qua existing state of affairs of the suit
property till next date of hearing.
18.05.2024: On 18.05.2024 itself, the respondents/defendants had filed an
application (Annexure P6) under Order 7 Rule 11 read with Section 151 CPC
seeking rejection of the plaint on the ground of non-payment of ad valorem
Court fee.
21.01.2025: The plaintiffs had filed reply dated 21.01.2025 (Annexure P7) to
the above-said application.
23.09.2025: Vide impugned order dated 23.09.2025 (Annexure P8), the
application of the respondents has been allowed.
3.
It is inter alia submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners that
the learned Civil Judge has passed the impugned order in a mechanical manner
without appreciating that by way of the instant Suit, the petitioner was not
seeking cancellation of any Deed. The petitioner was only seeking cancellation
of the alleged Agreement to Sell on the ground that signatures of the
petitioners had been taken on blank papers and therefore, the said document
is void ab initio and not merely voidable. It is contended that therefore, for a
void document, the Suit for declaration with fixed Court fee is maintainable
and ad valorem Court fee is not required.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners further submits that the
learned Civil Judge has wrongly applied the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
Court in Suhrid Singh @ Sardool Singh v. Randhir Singh (SC) : Law Finder Doc
ID # 209047. The petitioners have clearly stated that their signatures were
taken on blank papers and that the Agreements are void from the very
beginning. In such cases, the law requires only a declaration and not
cancellation with ad valorem Court fee. The learned Civil Judge ignored this
distinction, which makes its finding on Court fee unsustainable. Moreover, the
petitioners are admittedly in possession of the suit property as also recorded
in the interim order dated 18.05.2024 (Annexure P3). It is contended that
Section 7(iv)(c) of the Court Fees Act applies where declaration is coupled with
consequential relief such as possession or cancellation of a valid instrument.
In the present case, both of the aforesaid factors do not apply since petitioners
are already in possession and are only seeking to protect their possession and
declare the forged papers as void. Therefore, the fixed Court fee is sufficient.
5.
The learned trial Court ignored the fact that no registered Sale
Deed exists. The challenge is to an unregistered Agreement to Sell. The
valuation of a Suit challenging an Agreement to Sell, which does not itself
convey title, cannot be equated to the valuation of a Suit challenging a
registered Sale Seed for the purpose of Court fees. An Agreement to Sell does
not itself convey title and cancellation of such an unregistered document does
not attract the Court fee principles applicable to cancellation of a registered
Sale Deed.
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
6.
Ld. Counsel argues that the trial Court ignored the basic rule laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court on how Order VII Rule 11 must be applied.
The Supreme Court in T. Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal (1977 AIR 2421) held:
“xx
"If on a meaningful-not formal-reading of the plaint it is
manifestly vexatious and meritless, in the sense of not disclosing
a clear right to sue, he should exercise his power under Order VIl
Rule 11."
Xx”
7.
In the present case, the plaint clearly mentions denial of
execution and fraud, which gives a valid right to sue, yet the learned trial Court
applied Order VII Rule 11 mechanically without carrying out the meaningful
reading required by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. It is accordingly prayed that
the present petition be allowed and the impugned order be set aside.
8.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents/defendants
vehemently opposes the submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioners
and submits that vide the impugned Agreement, the plaintiffs had agreed to
sell the suit land measuring about 8 acres to the respondents/defendants at
the rate of Rs.1,22,00,000/- per acre. An earnest amount of Rs.1,39,00,000/has been paid to the plaintiffs. It is contended that therefore, the plaintiffs are
required to pay ad valorem Court fee on the earnest money of Rs.1,39,00,000/sought to be recovered by them. Thus, the impugned order suffers from no
error and deserves to be dismissed. In support, learned counsel for the
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
respondents has relied upon judgment of this Court in Mehnga Singh v.
Narinder Kaur, (Punjab And Haryana) : Law Finder Doc ID # 2713131.
9.
No other argument is made on behalf of the parties. I have heard
learned counsel and perused the case file in great detail. I find merit in the
submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioners/plaintiffs.
10.
Perusal of case file shows that plaintiffs had filed the instant CS-
1134-2024 dated 13.05.2024 (Annexure P2) seeking the following declaration:“It is, therefore, prayed that a decree for declaration to the effect
that the alleged agreement to sell dated 11.10.2023 and Majid
agreement dated 29.10.2023 may please be declared as illegal,
null and void, Ab- initio, ineffective, inoperative, arbitrary and not
binding upon the rights of plaintiffs as the alleged agreement to
sell / Majid agreement are the act of fraud played by the
defendants in connivance with each other. Further a decree for
permanent Injunction. thereby restraining the defendants to enter
into any agreement to sell, sell, mortgage, alienate, lease out,
transfer or create any charge over the suit property in any manner
and further restrained the defendants to dispossess / interfere into
the peaceful and continuous possession of plaintiffs over the suit
property, as fully detailed in para no.1 of the plaint above, may
kindly be passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the
defendants with costs, in the interest of justice.”
11.
as follows: -
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
As per Section 7(iv)(c) of the Court Fees Act, court fees is payable
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
“7. Computation of fees payable in certain suits: The amount of
fee payable under this Act in the suits next hereinafter mentioned
shall be computed as follows:
(iv) in suits - xxxx (c) for a declaratory decree and consequential
relief.- to obtain a declaratory decree or order, where
consequential relief is prayed, xxxxx according to the amount at
which the relief sought is valued in the plaint or memorandum of
appeal.
In all such suits the plaintiff shall state the amount at which he
values the relief sought:
Provided that minimum court-fee in each shall be thirteen rupees.
Provided further that in suits coming under sub-clause (c), in cases
where the relief sought is with reference to any property such
valuation shall not be less than the value of the property
calculated in the manner provided for by clause (v) of this section."
The second proviso to section 7(iv) of the Act will apply in this case
and the valuation shall not be less than the value of the property
calculated in the manner provided for by clause (v) of the said
section. Clause (v) provides that where the relief is in regard to
agricultural lands, court fee should be reckoned with reference to
the revenue payable under clauses (a) to (a) thereof; and where
the relief is in regard to the houses, court fee shall be on the
market value of the houses, under clause (e) thereof.”
12.
A perusal of the above provision clearly shows that Court fee is
payable in a declaratory Suit where consequential relief of possession is also
prayed for. In the present case, it is undisputed that possession is with the
petitioners. This fact is also established from the interim order dated
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
18.05.2024 (Annexure P3) whereby the parties were directed to maintain
status quo regarding the suit property. Accordingly, Court fee was not payable.
13.
Now coming to the next aspect of the matter, in the impugned
order, the learned trial Court has held that the petitioners are liable to pay
Court fee for the following reasons: “6. The legal position on this issue is no longer res integra. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Suhrid Singh @ Sardool Singh
vs Randhir Singh & Ors. (AIR 2010 SC 2807) has laid down a clear
and succinct principle, which is directly applicable to the case at
hand. The Court held:
"where the executant of a deed wants it to be annulled, he has to
seek cancellation of the deed. But if a non-executant seeks
annulment of a deed, he has to seek a declaration that the deed
is invalid, or non est, or illegal or that it is not binding on him. If
'A'; the executant of the deed, seeks cancellation of the deed, he
has to pay ad-valorem court fee on the consideration stated in the
sale deed."
XXX XXX XXX
8. The scheme of the Court Fees Act, 1870 is clear. A plaintiff
seeking to cancel an instrument of which he is an executant must
pay ad valorem court fee on the value of the subject matter of the
suit, as per Article 1 of Schedule I of the Act. The plaintiffs have
paid only a fixed court fee under Article 17(iii) of Schedule II, which
is applicable only to a declaratory suit where no consequential
relief is prayed for, or where the plaintiff is a non-executant.”
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
14.
Thus, the petitioners have been held to be liable to pay court fee
as they are seeking cancellation of Deed of which they are executants.
However, the said reasoning of the trial court is palpably wrong as in the
present case petitioners are only seeking cancellation of an ‘Agreement to Sell’
and not of a ‘Sale Deed’ or any other ‘Deed’ or registered document. The
learned trial court has failed to make this distinction. Moreover, the entire case
of the petitioners is that they are totally denying having executed the
impugned Agreement to Sell. The petitioners have categorically alleged fraud;
the correctness of which shall be established or not upon trial. However, in the
interregnum, the learned Civil Judge has failed to appreciate that a person who
denies execution cannot be treated as an executant for the purpose of Court
fee. Accordingly, the learned Civil Judge has wrongly applied the judgment in
case of Suhrid Singh (supra).
15.
In the circumstances, reliance of the respondents upon the
judgment in Mehnga (supra) is misplaced as in the said case, executant was
challenging the Sale Deed on ground of fraud; whereas in the present case, the
alleged executant is seeking cancellation of Agreement to Sell. Reliance is
placed upon judgment of this Court in Balwan Singh v. Premo Devi, (Punjab
and Haryana) : Law Finder Doc ID # 898519, wherein it is held that:“Court Fees Act, 1870 Section 7(iv)(c) Cancellation of agreement
to sell - Ad valorem court fee - Suit for cancellation of sale deed
executed by plaintiff on ground of fraud - Suit not to be convert to
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CR-9538-2025 (O&M)
suit with one for declaration with consequential relief of
possession - Ad Valorem court fees not attracted.
XXX XXX XXX
7. Learned trial Court, while dismissing the application filed by the
petitioner under Order 7, Rule 11 CPC, has observed as under :"Admittedly, an agreement to sell can not be said to be
"Instrument securing property" or it does not assure vesting
right of the title in the transferee and extinction of
transferor's interest.
Thus, agreement to sell can not be treated at par with the
sale deed. The reliance is placed by counsel for the
defendant No. 1, in the judgment Suhrid Singh @ Sardool
Singh v. Randhir Singh & others, is distinguishable in the
facts and circumstances of the present case because relief
in those cases is for declaration for cancellation of sale deed,
but in this present case, it is related to the agreement to sell.
Thus, the plaintiff need not to affix Ad-valorem Court fees
over seeking relief of cancellation of agreement to sell. Thus,
this application u/o 7 rule 11 CPC is hereby dismissed."”
16.
In view of the above, present Revision Petition stands allowed.
17.
Pending application(s) if any also stand(s) disposed of.
(Nidhi Gupta)
Judge
30.04.2026
Sunena
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Whether reportable:
SUNENA
2026.05.04 10:09
I agree to specified
portions of this document
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review