Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!
"
!
$
%&' % (
)*
'%
)
*+
$
'&
*
+
! "
Digitally signed
by
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
"
#
! "
$
$!
! "
%
$"
#
-2-
! "
"!
&
! "
&
'
(
)
*
#
#
!
"
+
#
$%
! "
'
&
,
#
(
)#
#
"!
%!"
"*
#
'
*
#
#
*
%$ " ""
#
%
%$ %
#
#
!% " ""
# '
)
#
##
%-!
#
)
#
#
$"$
-
-3-
'& *
+
"+
'
(
)
*
#
#
"
. !
+
)#
"*
#
$
'
#
"!
#
'
#
!%
%!"
,
#
'
*
" ""
#
)
%$ " ""
#
%-!
$"$
-
#
%
##
%$ %
#
#
*
-4-
)
#
#
#
/
/
3"
$" " "
=7;4;43>715 ?@@A578
3"
!%
" "
35 "
64278
;3
?>8
;3 CA?5< ;<7 =13@7784>D5 4>
3667>@7 =A>45<?927 A>871
1 B
7@;43>
13<494;43>
@;
A8D7 (
"
+,
;<7
B<717?5
?8D41
3 !%
" "" ' 14E7
3E7>
324@7 631 ;<7
7@;43>5 %-!
?>8
$"$
% ?>8
7@;43>5 $ ?>8 % 36
=7>84>D 3> ;<7 6427 36
3B1:
7>431
4F42
;<?;
98A2
?8D41
<7
175=3>87>;
?5<778 3>
175=3>87>;
%- 36
-
9:
45 64278 9: ;<7 =7;4;43>71 ?@@A578
3 %$ " ""* 17D45;7178 9:
6?@;A?2
E?;14G
;<7
@?57
3 " @3E=2?4>?>; E?11478 ?@@A578
% +"
+
; ;<7 ;4E7 36 E?114?D7
;<7
3 "H5 6?;<71 D4F7> ;B3 ;32?5 36 D328 ?>8
@?5< ?>8 ?253 3>7 E3;31@:@27 ?=?1; 613E ;<7
-5-
A;7>5425 ?>8 3;<71 <3A57<328 E?;714?25 ;3 ?@@A578
6;71 ;<7 E?114?D7
175=3>87>;
3 " 5;?1;78 ;3 175487
?23>D B4;< <71 <A59?>8 ?>8 4> 2?B5 4> ;<7 E?;14E3>4?2
<3E7
<7: 233I78 ?6;71 <71 B722 631 ? =71438 36 3>7
E3>;< ?6;71 ;<7 E?114?D7
;3
<717?6;71 ?@@A578
34E9?;317 ;3 ?;;7>8 <45 J39
B7>;
<717?6;71 ;<7 4> 2?B5
?>8 3;<71 ?@@A578 =7153>5 5;?1;78 ;3 <?1?55 175=3>87>;
3 " 93;< =<:54@?22: ?>8 E7>;?22: 9: 87E?>84>D ?884;43>?2
83B1:
<3AD<
175=3>87>;
3"
;<7
5?48
?5=7@;
;3
<71
<A59?>8 ?@@A578
5A==31;78 <45 6?E42: E7E9715 4 7
5;?1;78 ;3 <?1?55 175=3>87>;
3"
B?5
4>631E78
9:
<7
3;<71 ?@@A578 ?>8 ?253
@@3184>D ;3 <71 ;<7
?@@A578 B717 >3; D4F7> 6338 3> ;4E7 ?>8 ?253 ?55?A2;78
<71 3> 57F71?2 3@@?543>5 9: 87E?>84>D ?884;43>?2 83B1:
#4>?22:
?>@<?:?; B?5 @3>F7:78 B4;< ;<7 4>;71F7>;43> 36
;<7 728715 36 53@47;:
<717?6;71
631 53E7;4E7
;<7:
233I78 ?6;71 <71 B722 ?>8 5A957CA7>;2: 5;?1;78 ;3 <?1?55
@3>;4>A3A52:
?884;43>?2
83B1:
?
5AE
-6-
?>8
;32?5 36 D328
?;71 5<7 D?F7 941;<
;3 ? 67E?27 @<428
$
3B7F71 3> "
175=3>87>;
" "" ?@@A578
B7>; ;3
3 "H5 =?17>;?2 <3A57 ?>8 ?9A578 <71 4> 642;<:
2?>DA?D7 ?>8 ;<17?;7>78 <71 ;3 J34> ;<7 E?;14E3>4?2 <3E7
?>8 ?253 4>631E78 ;<?; <7 B3A28 =71631E 57@3>8 E?114?D7
46 5<7 87>475 ;3 J34> <4E
976317 ;<7 175=3>87>;
7>@7 5<7 238D78 ;<7 @3E=2?4>;
=324@7 3>
"
! " "" ?D?4>5;
;<7 =7;4;43>715 ?>8 ?>3;<71
%
> ;<7 5;17>D;< 36 ;<7 @3E=2?4>; 175=3>87>;
324@7 17D45;7178 ? @?57 4>
?6317E7>;43>78 3667>@75
?;71
14E7
3 %$ " "" 631 ;<7
175=3>87>;
324@7
@3>8A@;78 ;<7 4>F75;4D?;43> ?>8 2?48 @<?1D7 5<77; ?D?4>5;
;<7 =7;4;43>715 ?>8 ?>3;<71 9: ?11?:4>D ;<757 =7;4;43>715
?5 ?@@A578
35 " ;3 +
@3D>4K?>@7 36 ;<7 3667>@75
<7 27?1>78
?D45;1?;7 ;33I
74>D ?DD147F78 9: ;<7 5?E7
;<7 =7;4;43>715 4> 93;< ;<7 =7;4;43>5 ?17 976317 ;<45
;3 CA?5< ;<7 =13@7784>D5
3A1;
-7-
7?18
27?1>78
4D<
27?1>78
3A1;
@3A>572
3F71>E7>;
;<7
=7;4;43>715
27?871 631 175=3>87>;
;?;7 ?>8 27?1>78 @3A>572 631 175=3>87>;
3"
@3E=2?4>?>; 4> 93;< ;<7 =7;4;43>5
=?1; 613E A1D4>D 57F71?2 @3>;7>;43>5 27?1>78
@3A>572 631 ;<7 =7;4;43>715 4> 93;< ;<7 =7;4;43>5 @3>;7>;78
;<?; 175=3>87>;
175484>D ?;
3 " ?>8 <71 <A59?>8 ?@@A578
34E9?;317 54>@7 ?@@A578
?>8 B31I4>D 4> ? @7E7>; 6?@;31: ?;
B717
B?5 7E=23:78
34E9?;317
5 5A@<
;<717 45 >3 =35549424;: 36 ;<7 3;<71 ?@@A578 <?1?554>D
175=3>87>;
3"
7 6A1;<71 @3>;7>;78 ;<?; 7G@7=; 53E7
3E>49A5 ?227D?;43>5 E?87 4> ;<7 5;?;7E7>; 36 B4;>75575
;<717 ?17 >3 5=7@464@ ?227D?;43>5 ?D?4>5; ;<757 =7;4;43>715
;3 ?;;1?@; ;<7 3667>@75 ;<7: <?F7 977> @<?1D78
7 ?253
@3>;7>;78 ;<?; =7;4;43>71
14E4>?2
3"
$" " "
AE9?4 ?>8 >3B ?;
35 $
?@@A578
A>7
% ?>8
3 % B?5 7?12471 175484>D ?;
@@A578
?>8
;<7 <A59?>8 ?>8 B467 ;<7: ?17 175484>D ?;
=7;4;43>71
?@@A578
4>
4>
B<3 ?17
7>D?2A1A
14E4>?2
<7
7;4;43>
-8-
3"
!%
" "
45 >3>7 3;<71 ;<?> ;<7 B467 36 ?@@A578
3 % ?>8 ;<7: 93;< ?17 175484>D ?;
A>7
> 5A@<
@41@AE5;?>@75 4E=24@?;43> 36 ;<757 =7;4;43>715 45 3>2: 3A;
36 F7>D7?>@7 ?>8 ;<7: >7F71 <?1?5578 175=3>87>;
=<:54@?22: 31 E7>;?22: 631 87E?>8 36 83B1:
3"
@@3184>D2:
<7 =1?:5 ;3 CA?5< ;<7 =13@7784>D5 ?D?4>5; ;<7 =7;4;43>715
4> 93;< ;<7 =7;4;43>5
+
27?1>78 @3A>572 631 175=3>87>;
@3>;7>878 ;<?;
>3B ;<7 175=3>87>;
3"
324@7 <?F7
4>F75;4D?;78 ;<7 @?57 ?>8 2?48 @<?1D7 5<77; ?D?4>5; ;<7
=7;4;43>715 ?>8 ;<7 @<?1D7 5<77; E?;714?25 845@2357 ;<?;
;<717 45 ?> 4>F32F7E7>; 36 ?22 ;<757 =7;4;43>715 4> ;<7
@14E7
@@3184>D ;3 <4E
?@@A578
=7;4;43>71
?>8 " 4>
175484>D ?;
?84
3B>
35 " ?>8 $ 4 7
3"
<4;;?=A1
$" " "
?17
?2AI ?>8 175=3>87>;
3 " B?5 ?253 175484>D ?23>D B4;< ;<7E ?>8 ;<7: <?1?5578
175=3>87>;
3 " 93;< =<:54@?22: ?>8 E7>;?22:
7 ?253
@3>;7>878 ;<?; ;<7 3;<71 ?@@A578 <?F7 ?253 4>F32F78 4> ;<7
?227D78
3667>@75
?5
=71
;<7
5;?;7E7>;
E?;714?2
-9-
B4;>75575 7G?E4>78 9: ;<7 =1357@A;43>
7>@7 <7 =1?:5
;3 845E455 93;< ;<7 =7;4;43>5
!
7?1>78
4D<
3A1;
3F71>E7>;
27?871
3==3578 93;< ;<7 =7;4;43>5 ?>8 =1?:5 ;3 845E455 ;<7 5?E7
-
<?F7 D4F7> E: ?>G43A5 @3>54871?;43> 93;< 3>
;<7 5A9E45543>5 E?87 9: ;<7 27?1>78 @3A>572 631 ;<7
175=7@;4F7 =?1;475 ?>8 ;<7 83@AE7>;5 ?F?42?927 3> 17@318
5 @3A28 97 D?;<7178 613E 17@3185 ?5 =71 ;<7
@3E=2?4>; ?F71E7>;5
3 " B4;< ?@@A578
3B>
<4;;?=A1
?6;71 ;<7 E?114?D7 36 175=3>87>;
?2AI
5<7 5;?1;78 175484>D ?;
?23>D B4;< ?@@A578
B7>; ;3
?84
;3 $
<717?6;71 ?@@A578
34E9?;317 631 B31I
;
;<?; ;4E7 ?@@A578
35 " ?>8 $ ?23>D B4;< 3;<715 5;?1;78
;3 <?1?55 <71 93;< =<:54@?22: ?>8 E7>;?22: 631 ?884;43>?2
83B1:
<7 17@3185 845@2357 ;<?; ?@@A578
6?;<71 4> 2?B
?>8
E3;<71 4> 2?B
175=3>87>;
?84
3B> ?23>D B4;<
3 " 4> ;<7 5<?178 <3A57
; ;<?; ;4E7 ;<7:
175=7@;4F72: B717 175484>D ?;
175=3>87>;
35 " ?>8 $ 4 7
3"
- 10 -
87E?>878 ?884;43>?2 83B1:
5;?;78 9: ;<7 >74D<93A15 4 7
<7 5?48 ?5=7@; B?5 >7F71
;<7 E?;714?2 B4;>75575
<7 ?227D?;43>5 ?D?4>5; ?@@A578
@3>@71>78
35 % ;3 + 45
;<741 =?1;4@4=?;43> 4> ;<7 4>@487>; @?>>3; 97
97247F78 ?; ;<45 5;?D7 631 ;<7 17?53> ;<?; 27?1>78 @3A>572
631 ;<7 =7;4;43>715 =2?@78 ;<7 ?881755 =1336 36 ;<757
=7;4;43>715 B<4@< 5;?;7 ;<?; ?@@A578
35 % ?>8
?17
175484>D ?;
A>7 ?>8 ?@@A578
?>8 + ?17 175484>D ?;
7>D?2A1A
> =71A5?2 36 @<?1D7 5<77; ?F71E7>;5 7G@7=;
53E7 3E>49A5 ?227D?;43>5 ?D?4>5; ;<757 =7;4;43>715 ;<717
?17 >3 5A@< 5=7@464@ ?227D?;43>5 E?87 ?D?4>5; ;<757
=7;4;43>715 631 ;<7 3667>@75 ;<7: <?F7 977> @<?1D7
5<77;78
"
> 5A@< @41@AE5;?>@7 ;<7
3>0927
=7G
3A1; 4>
;<7 @?57 36
!
! ) *
" #
$
17=31;78 4>
<728 ;<?; ;<7
"% &
+
'
,-
( '
?; =?1?D1?=<
3A1; 5<3A28 97 @?176A2 4> =13@7784>D
?D?4>5; ;<7 845;?>; 172?;4F75 4> @14E75 =71;?4>4>D ;3
- 11 -
E?;14E3>4?2 845=A;75 ?>8 83B1: 87?;<5
<7 172?;4F75 36
;<7 <A59?>8 5<3A28 >3; 97 13=78 4> 3> ;<7 9?545 36
3E>49A5 ?227D?;43>5 A>2755 5=7@464@ 4>5;?>@7 36 ;<741
4>F32F7E7>; 4> ;<7 @14E7 ?17 E?87 3A;
; 45 ?253 57;;278
=354;43> 36 2?B ;<?; 46 ? =7153> 45 E?87 ;3 6?@7 ? @14E4>?2
;14?2 3> 53E7 D7>71?2 ?>8 5B77=4>D ?227D?;43>5 B4;<3A;
914>D4>D 3> 17@318 ?>: 5=7@464@ 4>5;?>@75 36 @14E4>?2
@3>8A@; 4; 45 >3;<4>D 9A; ?9A57 36 =13@755 36 ;<7
<7
3A1;
3A1;5 =357 ? 8A;: ;3 5A9J7@; ;<7 ?227D?;43> 27F72278 4>
;<7 @3E=2?4>; ;3 ? ;<313AD< 5@1A;4>: ;3 64>8 3A; B<7;<71
;<717 45 ?>: D?4> 36 ;1A;< 4> ;<7 ?227D?;43>5 31 B<7;<71
;<7: ?17 E?87 3>2: B4;< ;<7 5327 39J7@; 36 4>F32F4>D
@71;?4> 4>84F48A?25 4> ? @14E4>?2 @<?1D7 E317 =?1;4@A2?12:
B<7> ? =1357@A;43> ?1457 613E ? E?;14E3>4?2 845=A;7
$
&
#A1;<71 ;<7
. *'#
17=31;78 4>
?5 A>871/
3>H927
=7G
3A1; 4> ;<7 @?57 36
"
/
0/
<728 4> =?1?
35 "
?>8 "!
- 12 -
!
"
#
$
%
&
$ '
$ '
$ %
(
)
!
(
!
*+,
#
- 13 -
.
!
*+,
#
/ .
"
!
*+,
.
.
!
#
.
#
-
#
%
> ;<7 4>5;?>; @?57 ? 9?17 =71A5?2 36 @<?1D7
5<77; E?;714?25 @27?12: 5<3B5 ;<?; ;<7 ?227D?;43>5 E?87 9:
175=3>87>;
3 " ?17 F?DA7 ?>8 3E>49A5
@2?4E4>D ;<?; ;<7 <A59?>8 4 7
?@@A578
=?1; 613E
?>8 <45
6?E42: E7E9715 E7>;?22: <?1?5578 <71 B4;< ? 87E?>8 631
83B1:
175=3>87>;
3 " <?5 >3; =13F4878 ?>: 5=7@464@
87;?425 31 875@14978 ?>: =?1;4@A2?1 4>5;?>@7 36 <?1?55E7>;
<7 <?5 >3; E7>;43>78 ;<7 ;4E7 8?;7 =2?@7 31 ? E?>>71
4> B<4@< ;<7 ?227D78 <?1?55E7>; 3@@A1178 31 ;<7 87;?425 36
- 14 -
;<7 >?;A17 36 87E?>8 31 4;5 =?1;4@A2?15
<7176317
;<7
@<?1D7 5<77; 2?@I5 @3>@17;7 ?>8 =17@457 ?227D?;43>5
<7
;71E L@1A72;:M @?>>3; 97 75;?9245<78 B4;<3A; 5=7@464@
4>5;?>@7
<7 5?E7 B7?I7>5 ;<7 @?57 36 ;<7 =1357@A;43>
?>8 @?5;5 57143A5 83A9; 3> ;<7 =139?9424;: 36 ;<7 F71543> 36
175=3>87>;
3"
<7
E717
D7>71?2
?227D?;43>5
<?1?55E7>; B4;<3A; =34>;4>D 3A; ;<7 5=7@464@ 87;?425 B3A28
>3; 97 5A664@47>; ;3 @3>;4>A7 @14E4>?2 =13@7784>D5 ?D?4>5;
?>: =7153>
; 45 57;;278 =354;43> 36 2?B ;<?;
3A1;5 <?F7 ;3
97 @?176A2 ?>8 @?A;43A5 4> 87?24>D B4;< @3E=2?4>; ?>8 EA5;
;?I7 =1?DE?;4@ 17?24;475 4>;3 @3>54871?;43> B<427 87?24>D
B4;< E?;14E3>4?2 845=A;75 B<717 ;<7 ?227D?;43>5 <?F7 ;3
97 5@1A;4>4K78 B4;< D17?; @?17 ?>8 @41@AE5=7@;43> 4> 31871
;3 =17F7>; E45@?114?D7 36 JA5;4@7 ?>8 ?9A57 36 =13@755 36
3A1;
==2:4>D ;<7 ?93F7 =14>@4=275 ;3 ;<7 6?@;5 ?>8
@41@AE5;?>@75 36 ;<45 @?57
4> E: @3>5487178 F47B
@3>;4>A?;43> 36 @14E4>?2 =13@7784>D5 ?D?4>5; ;<7 =7;4;43>71
- 15 -
?@@A578
3A1;
35 % ;3 + 45 >3;<4>D 9A; ?9A57 36 =13@755 36
3B7F71
;<717 ?17
E?;714?25 ?17
631;<@3E4>D ?D?4>5; ;<7 =7;4;43>71
?>8 " ?@@A578
35 " ?>8 $ 631 ;<7 3667>@75 ;<7: <?F7 977> @<?1D7
5<77;78
@@3184>D2:
=13@778 ;3 =?55 ;<7 63223B4>D,
3"
$" " " 45
3"
$" " "
=7;4;43>71
1 !#
4>
175=7@;
?>8 " 4 7
?@@A578
35 "
?>8 $ 45 <7179: !# '#
!
<7 =13@7784>D5 4>
3 !%
3A; 36
14E7
3 %$ " ""
?8D41
3E7>
324@7
" "" ?1454>D
17D45;7178 9:
;<7
=A>45<?927 A>871
7@;43>5 %-!
?>8
7@;43>
1 B
7@;43>5 $ ?>8 % 36
-
35 $ ;3
$"$
%- 36
3B1:
%
?>8
13<494;43>
=7>84>D 3> ;<7 6427 36
A8D7 (
3667>@7
7>431
@;
4F42
?8D41 4> 175=7@; 36 =7;4;43>71
<7179: CA?5<78
?@@A578
35 %
?>8 + 45
- 16 -
4F
3"
!%
" " 45
F
<7 =13@7784>D5 4>
1 !
3 !%
3A; 36
14E7
3 %$ " ""
?8D41
3E7>
324@7
" "" ?1454>D
17D45;7178 9:
;<7
=A>45<?927 A>871
7@;43>5 %-!
?>8
7@;43>
1 B
7@;43>5 $ ?>8 % 36
-
3667>@7
$"$
%- 36
3B1:
?>8
13<494;43>
=7>84>D 3> ;<7 6427 36
7>431
?@@A578
45 <7179: CA?5<78
!
)
!
3/
4F42
?8D41 4> 175=7@; 36 =7;4;43>71
,*
;,1J
@;
A8D7 (
%
45;
%
3/%
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review