Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 24
REGULAR CAUSE LIST
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP(C) No. 3231/2025
c/w WP(C) No. 3228/2025
Shazia Akhter and Anr.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. S.M. Ayoub, Advocate in WP(C) No. 3231/2025
Mr. S.A. Naik, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Shazia Bashir, Advocate in WP(C) No. 3228/2025.
Vs.
Union Territory of J&K and Ors.
Through:
...Respondent(s)
Mr. T.A Lone, Dy. AG
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
ORDER (ORAL)
31.08 .2026
Chief Justice (A):
WP(C) No. 3228/2025:
01.
The petitioner, namely Asif Yaqoob, has filed the instant
petition seeking quashing of the judgment and order dated 22nd
May 2025, passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Srinagar Bench, [“the Tribunal”] in TA No. 4786/2021, titled
“Shazia Akhter and Another v. State of Jammu and Kashmir and
others”, and TA No. 141/2022, titled “Asif Yaqoob v. State of
Jammu and Kashmir and others”, whereby the Tribunal has
allowed TA No. 4786/2021 and directed the respondents to act
upon the pending recommendations and issue formal orders of
appointment in favour of the petitioners therein, namely Ms.
Shazia Akhter and Mr. Shahnawaz Ahmad Sheikh, against the two
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
02.09.26
WP(C) No. 3231/2025 c/w WP(C) No. 3228/2025
Page 1
posts of Class-IV (Watchman) which were kept reserved pursuant
to an interim order dated 21st August, 2014 passed in SWP No.
1780/2014. The writ petition was later transferred to the Tribunal
and registered as TA No. 4786/2021. However, the TA No.
141/2022, filed by the petitioner-Asif Yaqoob, was dismissed by
the Tribunal.
02.
The challenge to the judgment impugned by the
petitioner-Asif Yaqoob is primarily on the ground that the
Tribunal has failed to appreciate that the petitioner had a higher
merit than petitioners of TA No. 4786/ 2021, namely Ms. Shazia
Akhter and Mr. Shahnawaz Ahmad Sheikh, and, therefore, had a
better right to be appointed as Class-IV (Watchman).
WP(C) No. 3231/2025:
03.
The instant petition has been filed by Ms. Shazia Akhter
and Mr. Shahnawaz Ahmad Sheikh, who were the petitioners in
TA No. 4786/2021, assailing the judgment and order dated 22nd
May 2025, passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Srinagar Bench.
04.
The challenge in the present petition is confined to the
extent that, while allowing the aforesaid TA, the Tribunal has
failed to adjudicate upon and determine the real controversy
involved in the matter, viz, the challenge to the entire selection
process on the ground that the same was conducted on the basis of
an irrational, arbitrary and legally unsustainable criteria.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
02.09.26
WP(C) No. 3231/2025 c/w WP(C) No. 3228/2025
Page 2
05.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused the material available on record, it is necessary, at the
outset, to notice a few relevant facts.
06.
The respondent-Department notified Class-IV vacancies
borne on district cadre Shopian through an Advertisement
Notification dated 8th August, 2013. The posts notified included
Watchman, Kandaman, Depot Assistant and Orderlies. Twenty
out of these vacancies were of „watchman‟ earmarked for Open
Merit Category.
07.
The selection process was envisaged to be undertaken on
the basis of the marks obtained by the candidates in Matriculation
carrying 60 points, 10+2 carrying 20 points, and Viva-Voce
carrying 20 points. The candidates were to be shortlisted for the
Viva-Voce in the ratio of 1:5 against the available vacancies.
08.
The selection process was, accordingly, completed and a
provisional selection list was published in the daily newspaper,
Kashmir Uzma, on 1st August 2014, followed by publication of the
final selection list in the daily newspaper Greater Kashmir on 18th
August 2014. The selection list was also accompanied by a waiting
list.
09.
It appears that, out of the selected candidates, two
candidates failed to join despite issuance of a final notice for
joining dated 20th April 2015. In order to fill up the posts that had
fallen vacant on account of the non-joining of the selected
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
candidates, the Assistant Director, Consumer Affairs and Public
02.09.26
WP(C) No. 3231/2025 c/w WP(C) No. 3228/2025
Page 3
Distribution Department, Shopian forwarded the names of the
candidates figuring at Serial Nos. 1 and 2 of the waiting list,
namely Mr. Asif Yaqoob and Mr. Sajad Ahmad Lone vide
communication dated 7th May 2015.
10.
Before the waiting list could be implemented and the
aforementioned individuals appointed, the two candidates namely
Ms. Shazia Akhter and Mr. Shahnawaz Ahmad Sheikh filed SWP
No. 1780/2014 in this Court, in which this Court vide order dated
21st August, 2014, directed that the two Class-IV posts out of the
twenty posts shall not be filed. It is because of this interim order
the process for appointment of the candidates from waiting list
could not proceed. This petition was ultimately transferred to the
Tribunal and registered as TA No. 4786/2021.
11.
Having been denied appointment despite being the
candidate next in the order of merit, Mr. Asif Yaqoob also
approached this Court by filing SWP No. 135/2016, which, upon
transfer to the Tribunal, came to be registered as TA No. 141/2022.
Both the aforesaid TAs were ultimately taken up for consideration
together by the Tribunal and, in terms of the judgment impugned
before us, the TA filed by Ms. Shazia Akhter and Mr. Shahnawaz
Ahmad Sheikh was allowed, whereas the TA filed by Mr. Asif
Yaqoob came to be dismissed. This is how Mr. Asif Yaqoob, as
also Ms. Shazia Akhter and Mr. Shahnawaz Ahmad Sheikh, are
before us in these two writ petitions.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
02.09.26
WP(C) No. 3231/2025 c/w WP(C) No. 3228/2025
Page 4
12.
We have given our thoughtful consideration to the
matter in the light of the material available on record. We are of
the considered opinion that the Tribunal has failed to appreciate
the controversy in its proper perspective. No direction for
appointment in favour of Ms. Shazia Akhter and Mr. Shahnawaz
Ahmad Sheikh for their appointment could have been passed
merely on the ground that in their writ petition this Court had
kept two posts of Class-IV reserved, unless the Tribunal would
have determined the issues raised by the said petitioners on merits
and come to the conclusion that the selection process was vitiated.
13.
The Tribunal, however, failed to determine the real
controversy involved in the matter and proceeded to dispose of
the TA filed by Ms. Shazia Akhter and Mr. Shahnawaz Ahmad
Sheikh merely on the premise that two posts had been kept
reserved pursuant to the interim order passed in their petition
and, therefore, they could be accommodated against those posts.
14.
The Tribunal failed to appreciate that the petitioner-Asif
Yaqoob who was figuring as serial No. 1 of the wait list had a
better right than that of the petitioners Ms. Shazia Akhter and Mr.
Shahnawaz Ahmad Sheikh.
15.
Having regard to the nature of controversy involved and
the erroneous judgment passed by the Tribunal, it was a fit case
for us to remand. We could have sent both the petitions back to
the Tribunal for consideration afresh. However, having regard to
the considerable time spent by the petitioners in litigation and,
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
02.09.26
WP(C) No. 3231/2025 c/w WP(C) No. 3228/2025
Page 5
more particularly, keeping in view the fact that the selection
pertains to the year 2013, it would be too late in the day to ask the
Tribunal to adjudicate the controversy on merits afresh.
16.
With a view to put a quietus to this litigation, we had
vide our order dated 24th December, 2025, called upon the official
respondents to indicate as to whether there was any post of ClassIV in addition to the two posts kept reserved in the writ petition
filed by Ms. Shazia Akhter and Mr. Shahnawaz Ahmad Sheikh
available in the Department, so that we could accommodate all the
petitioners including Mr. Asif Yaqoob. The affidavit in terms of
the order dated 24th December, 2025, has been filed by the
Assistant Director, Consumer Affairs and Public Distribution
Department, Shopian, a perusal whereof indicates that there are
several posts of Class-IV available in the Department.
17.
In view of the aforesaid information supplied by the
official respondents and with a view to do complete justice
between the parties and bringing an end to the long-drawn
litigation, we are inclined to dispose of these petitions in the
following terms:
(i)
The judgment and order dated 22nd May 2025, passed
by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Srinagar
Bench, in TA No. 4786/2021 and TA No. 141/2022, is
set aside to the extent that it dismisses TA No.
141/2022.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
02.09.26
WP(C) No. 3231/2025 c/w WP(C) No. 3228/2025
Page 6
(ii)
The official respondents are directed to appoint all the
three petitioners, namely, Ms. Shazia Akhter, Mr.
Shahnawaz Ahmad Sheikh in TA No. 4786/2021 and
Mr. Asif Yaqoob in TA No. 141/2022, against the two
posts of Class-IV (Watchman) which had remained
vacant due to non-joining of the selected candidates
and one post of Class-IV out of the 30 posts which are
lying vacant with the respondents, subject to the
fulfillment of the requisite eligibility and other
formalities.
(iii)
The appointment of all the three petitioners shall be in
the order of merit and prospective in nature.
(iv)
Let the formal order of appointment of all the three
petitioners in these petitions be passed within a period
of eight weeks from the date a copy of this judgment is
served upon the respondents.
18.
Disposed of.
(Mohd Yousuf Wani)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Chief Justice (Acting)
SRINAGAR:
31.08 .2026
“Mir Arif”
(i)
(ii)
Whether the order is reportable? Yes/No.
Whether the order is speaking? Yes/No.
MIR ARIF MANZOOR
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
02.09.26
WP(C) No. 3231/2025 c/w WP(C) No. 3228/2025
Page 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review