Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!
#
$
!"
%
!
&
Digitally signed
by VARSHA N
RASALKAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!"
$
#
!"
%
% #
%
'$(
#
"
!"
#
$
!"
$
"
#
#
%
!"
#
%
!"
$
%%
#
!"
%
$
"
%
!"
#
#
#
%
$
"
#
$
#
"
!"
$
"
#
"
#
$
%
"
#
&
!"
$
!"
$
%
#
"
$
"
$
$
"
#
#
&
!"
$
#
"
#
"
#
"
$
%%
!"
%
%
#
!"
%
$
"
% #
"
$
#
"
!"
%
"
#
#
!"
$
"
#
%
"
"
$
"
$
!"
%%
%
!"
%
#
"
%
#
"
"
%
$
"
$
"
$
##
$
!"
!"
$
"
%
$$
"
$
$%
#
"
$
$
!"
$
"
$
#
#
%
!"
$ $
%
"
$
%
!"
#
%
"
$
%
"
#
%$
!"
%%
%
!"
##
!"
%
%
"
#
$
%
!"
$
#
!"
#
%
$
"
#
'
#
($ %
"
%
!"
#
!"
"
$
"
$
$
%
!"
"
%
#
%$
"
#
$
%
"
%
%
"
$
!
!"
#
"
$
$%
"
%$
# !"
$
%
$
%
"
&
!"
"
!
"
#
"
#
!"
"
$
"
%$
"
%
#
"
%
$
!"
%
%
!"
#
#
"
!"
!"
$
"
"
!"
$
"
%
$
!"
%
$
"
%
!"
#
$
"
$
#
"
$
!"
#
!"
"
$
"
#
$
$
"
$
"
%
$
"
% $
%
"
"
%
"
#
"
%
"
"
$
!"
%
!"
$
"
$
"
%
%
"
$ $
##
!"
%
#
"
%
"
%
% $
##
!"
%
#
!"
%%
%
!"
#
"
$
##
!"
$$
%
!"
%
!"
!"
%
"
#
$
"
%
"
#
"
"
"
$
%
$
"
%
%
"
"
"
$
"
$
$
$
!"
%
$
!"
%
%
$
"
%$
$
"
%
$
"
$$
"
$%
"
%
$%
#
"
'
$
!"
#
($ %
$
"
$
$
$
"
%
%
"
%
!"
%
"
%
##
#
"
$
%
$
%$
"
#
$
%%
#
"
$
%
"
$$
%
"
#
%
%
"
$
%
"
"
#
"
$
#
"
$
$
#
"
$$
$
&
!"
%
"
"
#
"
"
$
!"
"
# !"
$
"
$
!"
$
$
&
!"
$$
%
"
$
"
%
$
"
$
"
% %
#
!"
%
"
!"
"
"
$
$
$
"
%
"
$
#
"
%
"
$
"
"
"
%
"
$
"
"
%
$
"
$
%
"
$
$%
#
"
%
"
"
"
"
!"
$
$
"
%
"
$
$
%
"
#
)
"
#
#
##
#
#
!"
!"
"
"
!"
$
%
#
&
!"
"
$
"
#
$
%
#
"
#
$
!"
#
%
# !"
$
&
!"
%
"
$
% %
!"
%
!"
%
"
$
!"
$
$
"
%
"
"
%
"
"
!"
"
#
"
$
"
#
"
$
%
#
"
"
"
#
$
"
"
$
#
#
"
'
$
#
($ %
"
)
$
"
#
$
) $
$
!"
) $
$
!"
#
) %
$
"
)
$$
"
$%
$
)
$
"
)
$
#
"
)
$
%
!"
)$
%
"
)$ $
%
"
%
)$
%
!"
*
%
% $
%
!"
%
"
#
$
)%
*
)% %
%$
!"
)
%%
"
#
)
%
"
)
$
%
"
%
) %
%
!"
#
)
"
)
%
"
#
$
)
%
"
)
#
"
)
%
"
)
$
#
"
#
)
%
"
$
)
"
)
!
"
)
#
"
%
&
#
)
$
"
)
#
)
"
#
!
)
"
$
)
#
$
"
#
) $ $
$
"
) %
%
"
%
)
#
%
"
%
"
#
$
) %
!"
) %
"
#
) %
"
$
) % %
!"
) $%
&
"
#
$
"
#
) %
$
"
%
#
) %
%
"
#
#
) %
"
#
$
) % %
"
#
%$
"
#
) %$$
"
#
) %$
"
)
$
"
$
)
"
)
"
)
$
"
)
%
"
)
"
) %$
!"
#
)
!"
)
%
"
)
!"
) $
"
) % %
"
#
)
#
$
%
"
$
)
$%
)
$$
"
"
)
!"
#
) $
#
)
%
"
#
)
#
!"
%
)
$
!"
) $$
#
"
)
# !"
!
$
)
"
$
$
"
)
%
"
)
"
)
!
!"
)
$
"
)
"
#
) %
"
%
)
"
)
!"
)
$
"
#
'
#
$ %
+
,
#
*
*
(
($%
(
#
($%
$
-
*
(
#
#
# ($
#
#
(
#
*
. /
($%
$
"
**
(
#
#
#
%
($ %
**
"
*
(
#
#
'
#
($ %
*
(
(
#
#
'
#
($ %
(
#
(
#
**
#
'
(
**
#
* &
(
(
($ %
#
**
#
'
#
($ %
+
,
!
"!
#
*
$
#
-
!
*
*
%
*
!
*
#
'
*
&
(
$
# 1
*
-
!
!
!
*
*
(
-
#
!
*
$
*
#
&
(
*
2 3
!
5678 9567:58 ;<=:>59 ?<7 @A5 B5@C@C<:57>
88C@C<:69
8D<;6@5
5:5769
69<:E
FC@A
9567:58
<D57:G5:@
8D<;6@5 ?<7 75>B<:85:@( @6@5 6:8 9567:58 ;<=:>59 ?<7
B7CD6@5 75>B<:85:@>
AC> B5@C@C<: C> ?C958 >55HC:E @A5 ?<99<FC:E
759C5?>
!
!
"
#
$
!
!
!
%
(
)
$
"
&
'
$
*
$
+
,
$ !
$
-
!.
5@C@C<:57>
75>B<:85:@
<
(
=769
E7C;=9@=769
C:86EC
69=H
7<DC>C<:> <?
,?<7 >A<7@
;96CG
<(<B576@CD5
67:6@6H6
;@3-
@A5G @A5 B5@C@C<:57
@A5
G5GI57>
=9@CB=7B<>5
<;C5@J
C>@7C;@
CGC@58
<;C5@C5>
@ C> ;<:@5:858 @A6@
<>
6:6EC:E
@<
<?
7CG67J
686I69
75EC>@5758 =:857 @A5
<(<B576@CD5
<;C5@J @<@699J ;<:>C>@> <? %
><;C5@J A6> 6
I5
<;C5@J :6G59J
#CK6J6B=7
2@A5
@<
;@
$
<(<B576@CD5
I<77<F57 G5GI57> 6G<:E
675 G5GI57>
<GGC@@55 <?
A5 >6C8
>56@> C:;9=8C:E
@A5
75>C85:@
#C;5
75>C85:@
6:8
8C75;@<7>
A5
B5@C@C<:57> 675 >A675A<9857> 6:8 G5GI57> <? @A5 >6C8
><;C5@J
=:857
5>B<:85:@
9C>@
6:8
@A5
<
;6@5E<7J
<?
I<77<F57
G5GI57>
B75B6758 59CECI95 6:8 C:59CECI95 D<@57>3
>5:@
C@
?<7
6BB7<D69
@<
75>B<:85:@
<%
A5756?@57 75>B<:85:@( <;C5@J B=I9C>A58 @A5 59CECI95 6:8
C:59CECI95 D<@57> 9C>@ FA575C:
D<@57> 6:8
%$
G5GI57>
A5756?@57
G5GI57> F575 59CECI95
F575 C:59CECI95 D<@57> <=@ <?
@A5
5@=7:C:E
??C;57
;695:867 <? 5D5:@> @< A<98 595;@C<:> @< @A5
<;C5@J
%
C>>=58
<(<B576@CD5
> B57 @A5 ;695:867 <? 5D5:@> 86@58
@A5 96>@ 86@5 ?<7 ?C9C:E <? :<GC:6@C<: F6> <:
$0
96>@ 86@5 ?<7 FC@A876F69 <? :<GC:6@C<: F6> <:
6:8
95;@C<:>
F575
>;A58=958
@<
I5
%
$
;<:8=;@58
<:
$
A5 B5@C@C<:57> I5C:E 6EE7C5D58 IJ @A5 C:59CECI95
D<@57> 9C>@ B=I9C>A58 6:8 C: DC5F <? DC<96@C<: <?
@A5
67:6@6H6
6BB7<6;A58
@AC>
<(<B576@CD5
<=7@
#C85
=95
<?
<;C5@C5>
=95>
%
C:@57CG
<7857
86@58
$ @AC>
<=7@ B57GC@@58 @A5 B5@C@C<:57> @< ;6>@
@A5C7 D<@5> C: @A5 5:>=C:E 595;@C<:> FAC;A F6> >;A58=958
<:
$
<F5D57 C@ F6> <785758 @A6@ @A5 D<@5>
;6>@ IJ @A5 B5@C@C<:57> I5 H5B@ C: 6 >5B676@5 I699<@ I<L 6:8
>A699 :<@ I5 ;<=:@58
A5
5@=7:C:E
??C;57 F6> B57GC@@58
@< B7<;558 FC@A @A5 85;9676@C<: <? @A5 75>=9@>
<F5D57
@A5 >6G5 F6> >=IK5;@ @< <=@;<G5 <? @AC> B5@C@C<:
: DC5F
<? >6C8 C:@57CG <7857 @A5 D<@5> ;6>@ IJ @A5 B5@C@C<:57> 675
J5@ @< I5 ;<=:@58 6> @A5 >6G5 675 H5B@ C: 6 >5B676@5
I699<@ I<L
$
: DC5F <? @A5 ?6;@ @A6@ @A5 595;@C<:> 675 <D57
6:8 @A5 75>=9@> 675 6::<=:;58 @A5 D<@5> <? @A5 B5@C@C<:57>
FAC;A 6@ @A5 C:>@6:;5 <? 6: C:@57CG <7857 675 H5B@ C: 6
>5B676@5 I699<@ I<L 675 :<@ @6H5: C:@< ;<:>C8576@C<: ?<7
;<=:@C:E
567:58 ;<=:>59 ?<7 @A5 B5@C@C<:57> ;<:@5:8> @A6@
@A5 C:59CECI95 D<@57> FA< A6D5 6BB7<6;A58 @AC>
<=7@ 6:8
FA<>5 D<@5> A6D5 I55: H5B@ C: 6 >5B676@5 I699<@ I<L5> @<
I5 @6H5: C:@< 6;;<=:@ 6:8 @A5 75>=9@> I5 85;96758
6;;<78C:E9J
%
567:58
75B75>5:@C:E @A5
88C@C<:69
<D57:G5:@
8D<;6@5
@6@5 ;<:@5:8> @A6@ @A5 B75>5:@ B5@C@C<:
C@>59? C> :<@ G6C:@6C:6I95 6> @A575 C> 6: 69@57:6@CD5 6:8
5??C;6;C<=> 75G58J 6D6C96I95 =:857
5;@C<:
<? @A5
;@
?<7 @A5 B5@C@C<:57> C: ;6>5 <? 6:J 8C>B=@5 67C>5> FC@A 75E678
@< @A5 595;@C<: B7<;5>>
AC>
<=7@ C: >5D5769 K=8EG5:@>
A6D5 B7<:<=:;58 @A6@ 6:J ;A6995:E5 G685 @< @A5
B7<;5>> <7
6:6E5G5:@ <? @A5
<(<B576@CD5
95;@C<:
<;C5@J @A5
B5@C@C<:57> F<=98 I5 5:@C@958 @< 76C>5 6 8C>B=@5 =:857
5;@C<:
<? @A5
;@
6DC:E :<@ 8<:5 >< C@ G6J :<@ I5
6BB7<B7C6@5 ?<7 @AC>
<=7@ @< C:@57D5:5 C: @A5 595;@C<:
B7<;5>> <:;5 C@ A6> 697568J I5E=:
B5@C@C<:57> @< 6BB7<6;A @A5
@A5
;@
A5
@ C> <B5: @< @A5
5EC>@767 =:857
5;@C<:
<?
5EC>@767 >A699 85;C85 @A5 D69C8C@J <? @A5 D<@5>
;6>@ IJ @A5 B5@C@C<:57> FAC;A A6D5 I55: H5B@ C: >5B676@5
I699<@ I<L5> C: 6;;<786:;5 FC@A 96F FC@AC: >CL G<:@A>
?7<G @A5 86@5 <? 75;5CB@ <? 6 ;<BJ <? @AC> <7857
@ C> G685 ;9567 @A6@ @A5
5EC>@767
FAC95
8569C:E FC@A >=;A B5@C@C<:> C? 6:J ?C958 >A699 B6>> <7857>
5LB58C@C<=>9J 6?@57 6??<78C:E 6: <BB<7@=:C@J <? A567C:E @<
@A5 B67@C5> ;<:;57:58
;;<78C:E9J
F7C@ B5@C@C<: >@6:8>
785758 6;;<78C:E9J
)'*
&
!
%
#
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review