Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
134481
IN THE HIGH C9URT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
T1A/O THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITI ON NO: 2358 OF 2023
petition under Article 227 of the constitut'ron of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 1O.OT.2023 Passed in lA. No. 448 of 2023 in OS No. 211 of 2006 on the
file of the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, at Chevella RR District.
Between:
Shanthilal Bharath Bhandari, S/o. Late Ghewarchand Jain, aged about 73 years,
O;4. Business, R/o. H. No. 6-1-296128, Old CIB Quarters, Khairtabad,
Hyderabad
...Petitioner/Petitioner/Proposed
AND
1. Venkataiah (died for LRs),
2. Kandawada @ Damaragidda BlT3rq$alnl?,w9:L1" K.Venkataiah, aged
about 63 yeaE, Occ. House hold, R/o. H. No.2-27, Tholkatta Village,
Minabad and Vikarabad Dist.
3. Kandawada @ Damaragidda Laxmi, , W.lo. O-ar11! Raju, aged abou.t.42 years'
Occ. House h-old, R/o. ftT. fto. 2-27,Tholkatta Village, Minabad and Vikarabad
Dist.
ageg about
4 Kandawada@Damaragidda Vijay Kumar, S/o. Lat9.!f Venkataiah,
Minabad and
38 years, Oci. Agricutt-ure, H. No. 2-27,Tholkatta Village,
Vikarabad Oist
Smt. Yerra Sujatha, , wo. Yerra Raghupathi, aggq. about 34-years., o"9^. .
*orse hold, R7o. H. No. 162, Siddul-uru'Village, Vikarabad Mandal and Dist'
...RespondenURespondenUPla intiff
6. P. Adivaiah, S/o. Yellaiah, aged about 7O years, Occ. Agriculture' All R/o
Parnena Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy Dist
P. Ramachandraiah, S/o. Yellaiah, aged about 65 years, Occ. Agriculture'
R/o. Pamena Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy Dist
/
8. P. Rarnulu, , S/o. Yellaiah, aged about 58 years, Occ. Agriculture, R/o.
Pamerra Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy Dist.
9. P. Yellaiah, , S/o. Ramaiah, aged about 65 years, Occ. Agriculture, R/o.
PamenaVillage,ChevellaMandal,RangaReddyDist.
1.0. D. Rarnachandra Reddy, S/o. l.axma Reddy, aged about 75 years, Occ.
Agriculture, R/o. Pamena Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy Dist.
1 1.
Smt. t\tanjula Rao, Wo. Venugopal Rao, aged about 70 years, Occ. House
wife, Fl/o. Pamena Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy District
12.M. Kris;hna Reddy, S/o. Malla Reddy, aged about 65 years, Occ. Agriculture,
R/o. Pamena Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy Dist
I
13. M. Ma,rjula, Wo. M. Krishna Reddy, aged about 58 years, Occ. House hold,
R/o. Pamena Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy Dist.
14.D. Satlri Reddy, , S/o. Papi Reddy, aged about 68 years, Occ. Agriculture,
R/o. P;amena Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy Dist;
15.Anjamma, , Wo. Veera Raghavulu, aged about 70 years, Occ. Agricutture,
R/o. P;amena Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy Dfst.
Respondent Nos. 6 to 15 are not necessary parties.
... RespondenURespohdenUDefendants
lA NO: 1OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidar,'it filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay of all further proceedings in OS No 211 of 2006 on the file of Senior Civil
Judge, at Chevella RR Dist.
Counsel for the Petitioner : Sri. G Tirupathi Reddy
Counsel for t:he Respondents: The Court m;rde the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FIOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT ITYDERABAD
\
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAIT RAO
DATED: 22na JANUARY. 2O26
EI5IIITq-TTI
Shanthilal Bharath Bhandari, S/o. Late Ghewarchand Jain,
Aged about 73 years, Occ: Business, R/o. H.No.6-l-296/28,
Old CIB Quarters, Khairtabad, Hyderabad.
... Petitioner-PetitionerProposed defendant No. I 2
nr[Ilr
Venkataiah (died for LRs)
Kandawa da @ Damaragidda Bharatharnma,
W/o.Late K.Venkataiah, aged about 63 years,
Occ : House hold, R/ o. H. No .2-27, Tholkatta Village,
Minabad and Vikarabad District and Others.
...
Respondents-Respondents- Plaintiffs
oIIIrfrB
1.
This Civil Revision Petition is filed under Article 227 of t}:'e
Constitution of India assailing the o.rder passed by the learned
Senior Civil Judge at Chevella, Ranga Reddy District in IA No.448
of 2023 in OS.No.2LL of 2006, dated IO.O7.2023.
2.
Petitioner is the proposed defendant No.l2 and. respondent
Nos.1 to 5 are the respondents-plaintiffs and the respondent Nos.6
I
2lLo
,
BRMR,J
cRP_2358_2023
to 15 are other respondents in IA.No.44g of 2023 in oS.No .2ll
of
3.
tt is mentioned in the cause title of the revision that
resporldent Nos.6 to 15 are not necessary parties.
4.
lvotices got issued to respondent Nos.2 to
s-respondents_
plainti:tfs in the cRp are served on 2r.0g.2a2g,none
appeared for
them.
5.1. f'etitioner has fired IA.No.44g of 2023 under order 1 Rure 1o
of civil Procedure code, lgog (for short cpcJ to impread
him as
proposed defendant No.12 in the suit.
5.2- It. is stated in the affidavit that petitioner,s vendors by
Mujahirl Hussain and lrfan Hussain have purchased
admeasuring Acs.o4-o9 guntas in survey No. r35
the property
of pamena Vilage
from respondent Nos.6 to g-defendant Nos. r to
purchasers have sold the land in favour
3 and the said
of the petitioner under
registered sale deed, dated 20.og.2016 bearing
No.10796 0f 2016, ever since he is in physicar
er{o5rment of the above said property without
the suit when he attended Junior civil
document
possession and
any intemrption and
he obtai.ned E-pass book and the Government
Rythu Bhandu, recentry he came to know
name
has also sanctioned
about the pendenry of
Judge, chevelra in
BRMRJ
3/10
cRP_2358_2023
matter. Respondent Nos.2 to S-plaintiff Noq.2 to 5 taking
ad.vantage of the suit filed by them continuously interfering in the
petitioner's possession and that he is a proper aErd necessarJr party
to the suit and prayed to allow the same.
6.
Respondent Nos.2 to S-plaintiff Nos.2 to 5 Iiled counter and
contended that respondent Nos.6 to 8-defendant Nos.1 to 3 are not
the owners and possessors, they do not have any ngflt title over
the properties covered in survey No.135 and they have no right to
,:
execute registered sale deeds in favour of Mujahid Hussain and
Irfan Hussain and the sale deeds dated 31.03.2003, 27.OL.2OLL,
05.06.2012 and 20.09.2016 are illegal, void docr.trnents artd not
binding on them. The proposed defendant in collusion with
respondent Nos.6 to 8-defendant Nos.1 to 3 have filed tlre implead
petition to settle the scores, if the proposgd partlf is really
interested to get himself impleaded into the suit tlren he ought to
have got impleaded all the parties or his vendors in the suit. The
purchase made by the petitioner is subsequent to the filing of ttre
suit as such, the transaction is hit by Section 52 of Transfer of
Property Act, 1882 and prayed to dismiss the same.
-
The learned trial Court after going thror-rgh the material on
r:-I{
record dismissed the petition filed by the petitioner holding that
"the petitioner is not a necessary party to be iT,plg{:q and
i
i
4lL0
il
BRMR,J
cRP_2358 2023
I
it
ii
ii
t,
li
tl
withorrt his presence the suit can be completely adjudicated" which
i
I
i
is impugned in the CRp.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner-proposed defendant No.12
subrnits that the order of the learned trial court is contrar5r to law
arrd probabilities of the case which suffers serious infirmities of law
and fact and the learned trial court carried away by presumptions
and asisumptions and erroneously dismissed the application. The
firdrrrgl of the learned trial court that petitioner did not implead his
vendors as parties to the suit as defendants is erroneous, the
learne<l Judge failed to see that the petitioner is not a plaintiff
to
implea,l his vendors as parties to the suit, it is for the respondent
Nos.2 to S-plaintiffs to implead all proper and necessary parties in
the suit. The learned trial court observation that doctrine of
lis pen'denoe is applicable and the person related to the suit is
bound by the decision of the court is erroneous and the leanred
trial court ought to have allowed the petition fited by the petitioner.
counsel to substantiate his contention has relied on the decision
in the case of Yogesh Goyanka Vs. Govind and othersr.
9.
Heard learned counser for the petitioner, perysed___the
material
I
lzoz+y 7 scc s24
b11
slLo
BRMR,J
cRP_2358_2023
10. Now the point for consideration is : whether the order
passed by the learned trial court suffers from any peryersit5r or
illegality? If so, does it require interference of this Court?
11. Respondent Nos.2 to 5 are the plaintiffs and respondent
Nos.6 to 15 herein are defendant Nos.l to lo in the suit urde
OS.No.211 of 2006.
12. It is stated in the plaint that respondent Nos.2 to s-plaintilfs
are the absolute owners and possessors'of land admeasuring
Acs.16-2lguntas in survey No.135 and Acs.Oz-2z guntas in survey
No.138 situated at Pamana Village, chevella Mand.al, Ranga Reddy
District which are shown as item Nos. r and 2 of the plaint
schedule propert5r and they acquired the suit schedule property
being the only grandson of late K.Ramaiah to whom their father
late K.Yellaiah is the only son. In the first week of November,
2oo3, they have obtained certified copies of pahanies to avail loan
facility from the Bank and to their surprise they noticed that ttre
defendant's names are appearing in the pahanies against suit
schedule properties from the year lg7 l-72 to 2oo3 in pattedar and
possessor columns. They filed revision before the collector, Ranga
Reddy uid.e LR No.D5/39ol2oo4 and the same was disposed of on
06.05.2006 directing the respondent Nos.2 to s-plaintiffs to
approach the civil court under section s(2) of A.p. B.o.R Act,
6lLO
BRMR,J
cRP_2358_2023
Lg7L. 'fhe relief prayed in the suit is to declare respondent Nos'2
to S-plaintiffs as absolute owners and possessors in respect of item
Nos.l e$d, 2 of suit schedule properties and also to declare the
entries made in the name of the defendants (respondent Nos'6 to
15 herein) as null and void without authority and not binding on
the plaintiffs (respondent Nos.2 to 5 herein) and also restraining
tJle defi:ndants (respondent Nos.6 to 15 herein) from alienating or
transferring the suit schedule property in favour of third parties'
13. Rlespondent No.6-defendant No.1 has filed his written
statement and contended that his father by name P.Yetlaiah was
the Ka,uldar and absolute owner, possessor and pattedar of
agricul'Eural land bearing survey No.135 admeasuring Acs.l6-2L
guntas from Lg44 onwards, thereafter he has purchased the
property from its original owner. Since then his father is in
peaceful possession and enjoyment of the above said property as
absolur:e owner and possessor thereof. Defendant No-S
(respondent No.lO herein) in collusion with the village assistant by
narne M.Pratap Reddy, created documents and incorporated his
name in respect of land admeasuring Acs.OS- i I guntas out of
Acs.16-21 guntas in suruey No.135 and thereafter defendant No.s
(respondent No.lO herein) alienated the land to various persons.
Defendant No.S in collusion with the plaintiffs (respondent Nos.2 to
7lt0
BRMR,J
cRP_2358_?O23
5 herein) hatched a plan and filed a suit. Defendant No.lrespond.ent No.6 herein is in peacefur possessibn of land
admeasuring Acs.08-10 guntas in survey No.l35.
L4. Defendant Nos.2 and 3 (respondent Nos.7 and g herein) have
adopted the written statement liled by defendant No.l (respondent
No.6 herein).
15. Defendant Nos.7 to 9 (respondent Nos.12 to 14 herein) have
filed their separate written statement contending t.l-at defendant,
No.S (respondent No.10 herein) has sold an extent of Ac.l-oo
guntas to defendant No.6 and also sold Acs.o7-oO guntas to
defendant No.lo under registered sale deed, dated 2o.os.19gs
bearing document No.994 of 1985. Defendant No.lo in turn sold
Acs.07-00 guntas of land to defendant Nos.7 and g under
registered sale deed bearing document No.338 of lgg4, dated
25.o2.L994, the sale deed was implemented in the revenue records
and their names are also recorded as pattedars and possessors.
16. Doctrine of lis pendence as provided under sectbn s2 TpA
does not render all transfers pendente lite to be uoid. ab initio, it
merely renders rights arising from such transfers as subservient to
the rights of the parties to the pending litigation and subjecJ.t_o_-any
\
\
BRMRJ
cnp_us53:o13
direction that the Court
maJf pass thereunder:
Goyankar).
tZ. Suit is filed tV the sole
the year 2O06, after
plaintiff (respondent
his death his LRs were
plaintiff Nos.2 to S (respondent
filed ty the petitioner
Mujah.id Hussain and
of 2OO3 much prior
Nos.6 to 9 herein)
to the fiIing of the
complete adjudication
No. 135 ac.measuring
trearing document
document No. t9O
Acs.04_09 guntas
no effect to
relief can
petitioner is in survey
!
I
I
I
and item I of the
Ac
, is __-s.16_21
guntas which
observation of the
of
No.2489 of 2012.
be made and no
purchased by the
schedule propert5r
No. 135. The
Nos. I to 4 (respondent
is qrithout whose presence
of the dispute can
further
purchased some portions
on 2Z.Ol.2Ol1 bearing
be grantecl. The property
sale deed on
the suit. The affidavit
No.l3S from defendant
18. A rrecessary party
*xT
suit and thereafter pedtioner
same through registered
2Ol I and on O5.06.2012
the land
guntas in surve,
his vendors have also
of the land in survey
his vendors by name
Irfan Hussain have purchased
during pendency of
goes to show that
as
The affidavit
**;;.;;;r;: ;;;.:::::.
has ptrrchased the
2O.O9.2D16 i.e.,
I herein) in
brought on record
Nos.2 to S herein).
goes to show that
admeasuring Acs.o4_09
registered sare deed,
No.
(See yogesh
suit
is also in survey
Iearned trial Court
that t5s
/
9lL0
BRMR,J
cRP_2358_2023
petitioner cdnnot be considered as necessarJr party to the suit and
without his presence tlre suit can be completely adjudicated is
perverse in view of the decision of the Supreme Court stated supra
at Para No.16.
19. Though the issues are settled and the evidence of the
plaintiffs (respondent Nos.2 to 5 herein) is completed and the suit
is coming up for defendant evidence, which is not a bar to file the
application to implead a party in the suit.
20. On reading of Order I Rule 1O of the CPC, which states that
the Court rnay at arry stage of the proceedings add parties whose
presence befone the Court may be necessary in order to enable tlre
Court effechrally and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all
questions involved in the suit be added. As rightly contended by
the petitioner's counsel that the learned trial Court was in error in
\
observing that the petitioner failed to implead his vendors in the
present petition as defendants. The vendors of the petitioner have
purchased the property much prior to liling of the suit. It is averred
in the petition that respondent Nos.2 to S-plaintiffs are interfering
in his physical possession and that it is just and necessary to
implead him as a proposed defendant No.12 in the suit.
i
!
\
\
tolt0
,
BRMRJ
cRPJsSS-2023
21. This court is of the view that the petitioner is a proper
nece:|sary party to the lis which enables
and
the court to effectively dnd
completely adjudicate and setfle all the questions
In view of the reasons above, the order passed
involved therein.
by the leamed trial
court suffers from perversity and requires interference
of this
Court.
/
l
22. CRP is allowed arrd the order passed by the Iearned
I
civil Judge at chevena, Ranga Reddy District
l
l
in IA.No.448 of 2023
in ol; No'2rr of 20o6, dated ro.o7.2o2s is
Conserluently, the petition frled by the petitioner
defendant No. 12 in the suit is allowed without
Senior
set aside.
to implead him as
costs.
Interim Orders if any shall stands vacated.
Miscellaneous
apptication/ s stands closed.
SD/- A. JAYASRE
ASSISTANT R
R
/,TRUE COPY"
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Senior Civil Judge, at Chevella RR District.
1.
2. One CC to Sri. G Tirupathi Reddy, Advocate [OPUC]
3 Two CD Copies
) /I'S
L
Bv
t
{
HIGH C'OURT
DATED :22101/2026
THE S
o
ORDER
CRP.No.2358 of 2 23
ALLOWING THE CRP
JKS
sf.l".
2 0 r[8 2026
*
*
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review