The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. Rule 6 of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964 deals with Assignment for house site and for beneficial enjoyment. Note to Rule 6(2) mandates that the authority competent to assign land for beneficial enjoyment shall be the Revenue Divisional Officer. Though Rule 6(2) mandates that it is the 3 rd respondent, who is the proper authority to assign land for beneficial enjoyment, the application submitted by the petitioner was considered by the 4 th respondent Tahsildar based on a direction issued by this Court in a writ petition filed by the petitioner himself. A perusal of Ext.P3 would reveal that the petitioner has encroached upon the land and proceedings have been initiated as per the provisions of the Land Conservancy Act to evict the encroachment. After considering the records and the contentions of all parties, the 4th respondent has entered a finding that the property which is sought to be assigned for beneficial enjoyment is a Government road puramboke land and the same cannot be assigned. It was 2025:KER:23465 W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020 : 10 : also found by the 4th respondent that as per the Rules, assignment could be granted only by the Revenue Divisional Officer, after entering a finding that the land is absolutely necessary for the beneficial enjoyment of the applicant. In the appeal the 3 rd respondent RDO considered the said issue again and reiterated the stand in Ext…
8. Next aspect to be considered is the contention raised by the petitioner that going by Section 6(2) of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964 the authority competent to assign land for beneficial enjoyment is the Revenue Divisional Officer and since Ext.P3 order has been issued by the 4 th respondent Tahsildar, who is incompetent to issue the same, Ext.P3 is liable to be interfered with and Exts.P4 and P5 orders in appeal and revision confirming Ext.P3 order issued by the Tahsildar are also illegal and arbitrary. A pertinent aspect to be noted is that the 4 th respondent Tahsildar has considered the application based on a direction issued by this Court in a writ petition filed by the petitioner himself seeking an expeditious disposal of the application by the 4 th respondent. While rejecting the application by Ext.P3 order, the 4 th respondent Tahsildar has also entered a finding that it is the 3 rd respondent RDO who is competent to take a decision on the application submitted by the petitioner and as the petitioner has not substantiated that the property is indispensably required for the 2025:KER:23465 : 13 : W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020 beneficial enjoyment of the adjoining registered holding, the same cannot be recommended to the Revenue Divisional Officer. The RDO considered the appeal and rejected the request of the petitioner by Ext.P4 order assigning valid reasons in accorda…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:23465
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
:1:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
THURSDAY, THE 6TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 15TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 2007 OF 2020
PETITIONER:
SHANMUGHAN M.P.
AGED 59 YEARS
S/O. PAPPUKUTTAN, MUKKIL HOUSE, MATTOOR,
VATTAPARAMBU, KALADY P.O. ERNAKULAM DISTRICT,
683 574.
BY ADVS. DINESH MATHEW J.MURICKEN
SRI.N.R.SANGEETHARAJ
SRI.VINOD.S.PILLAI
KUM.GAYATHRI MURALEEDHARAN
SMT.SREELAKSHMI R.
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY (REVENUE DEPARTMENT),
SECRETARIAT, PALAYAM P.O. THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
DISTRICT 695 001.
THE LAND REVENUE COMMISSIONER,
OFFICE OF THE LAND REVENUE COMMISSIONER, PUBLIC
OFFICE BUILDING, MUSEUM, PLAYAM P.O.
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, DISTRICT 695 033.
THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER,
REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICE, FORT KOCHI , KOCHI P.O.
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, 682 001.
2025:KER:23465
:2:
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
THE TAHSILDAR,
ALUVA TALUK OFFICE, FIRST FLOOR, MINIS CIVIL
STATION, CIVIL STATION ROAD, PERIYAR NAG, ALUVA,
ERNAKULAM 683 101.
ADDL.R5.M.S. SOMAN
S/O. LATE SANKARAN, RESIDING AT MALIYEKKAL HOUSE,
MATTOOR, KALADY, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT.
(ADDL.R5 IMPLEADED VIDE ORDER DATED 29-05-2024 IN
IA1/24 IN W.P.(C)2007/2020)
GP – ADV.NIMA JACOB
BY ADVS.
GOVERNMENT PLEADER
V.RAJENDRAN (SR.)
SOHAIL MOHAMMED ANSARY
AMEENA.R
JOHN K.K.
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
06.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
2025:KER:23465
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
:3:
“CR”
---
VIJU ABRAHAM, J.
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -W.P.(C) No.2007 of 2020
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -Dated this the 6th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The
petitioner has approached this Court challenging
Exts.P3, P4, P5 and P7 orders and seeking for a consequential
direction to the 4th respondent to issue patta to the petitioner in
respect of 4½ cents of property in
Sy.No.138/1/7 of Mattoor
Village, Aluva Taluk.
2. The brief facts necessary for the disposal of the writ
petition are as follows:
The petitioner is in possession of 22½ cents of property in
Sy.No.138/1/7 of Mattoor Village, Aluva Taluk, which was in the
possession of the petitioner and his predecessor in interest from
1950 onwards. Out of the 22½ cents of property, the petitioner's
father obtained patta for 18 cents of property and the remaining
4½ cents of property is in the possession of the father of the
2025:KER:23465
:4:
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
petitioner from 1950 onwards. Several trees were planted in the
remaining 4½ cents of the property and after the death of the
petitioner's father in 2001, he is in possession of the above said
property. By Ext.P1, Patta was issued by the 4 th respondent with
respect
to
cents
of
properties
in
Sy.No.138/1/7
of
Manickamangalam Village on 18.11.1961. Later the property
covered by Ext.P1 patta was gifted to the petitioner by his father
as per Ext.P2 Gift deed executed on 19.04.1988. The petitioner is
also in possession of the 4½ cents of property which is lying
contagious to the property covered by Ext.P1 Patta. Though a suit
was filed for declaration of title with respect to the above-said 4½
cents of property claiming adverse possession, the same was
dismissed. It is contended that the petitioner requires the abovesaid 4 ½
cents of property for the beneficial enjoyment of the
property. Thereupon the petitioner made an application under the
Kerala Land Assignment Act 1960, to assign 4½ cents of property
belonging
to
the
Government
to
the
petitioner.
The
said
application was dismissed as per Ext.P3 order dated 03.04.2018,
holding that the petitioner is not entitled for the land as the 4½
2025:KER:23465
:5:
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
cents appurtenant is not necessary for the protection or beneficial
enjoyment of registered holding. Aggrieved by Ext.P3 order the
petitioner has preferred an appeal before the 3rd respondent which
was rejected as per Ext.P4. Further, a revision was preferred
before the 2nd respondent which also ended up in dismissal as per
Ext.P5 order. Though the petitioner preferred further revision
before the 1st respondent, finding that the said revision is not
maintainable, the writ petition filed as W.P.(C)No.75/2020 seeking
early disposal of the said revision petition was withdrawn as per
Ext.P6. While so, Ext.P7 notice was issued as per the provisions of
the Land Conservancy Act, 1957 to evict the petitioner from the
above-mentioned
property.
It
is
in
the
above-mentioned
circumstance that the petitioner has approached this Court.
3. The main contention raised by the petitioner is that the
4½
cents of land lying contiguous to the property covered by
Exts. P1 and P2 belonging to the petitioner is absolutely necessary
for the beneficial enjoyment of the property. It is further
contended that going by Section 6(2) of the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules, 1964 the authority competent to assign land for
2025:KER:23465
:6:
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
beneficial enjoyment is the Revenue Divisional Officer. But Ext.P3
order was issued by the 4th respondent Tahsildar, who is an
incompetent authority to issue the same and therefore, Ext.P3 is
liable to be interfered with. It is further submitted that the
appellate as well as the revisional order confirming Ext.P3 order
issued by the Tahsildar - an incompetent authority, is illegal and
arbitrary and therefore, liable to be interfered by this Court.
4. A detailed statement has been filed by the 4th respondent
wherein it is contended that an extent of 3.85 ares of land in
Re.Sy.No.70/16, Block No.26 in Mattoor Village in Aluva Taluk has
been recorded as “Sarkar Puramboke Vazhi” in the Basic Tax
Register and marked with road symbols in Field Measurement
Book. The additional 5th respondent and others submitted a
complaint before the District Collector, Ernakulam to evict the
encroachment
by
the
petitioner
in
1.26
ares
of
land
in
Re.Sy.No.70/16, Block No.26 in Mattoor Village in Aluva Taluk
which is recorded as “Sarkar Puramboke Vazhi” in Basic Tax
Register. After completing the legal procedures as provided in the
Kerala Land Conservancy Act, 1957 and based on the report from
2025:KER:23465
:7:
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
Village Officer, steps were taken to evict the encroachment in
“Sarkar Puramboke”. Though the petitioner filed a suit as
O.S.No.74/2005 before the Munsiff Court Aluva with a prayer to
prevent the additional 5th respondent and others from entering the
said land, the same was dismissed on 11.08.2008 rejecting the
claims of the petitioner. Later another suit, O.S.No.486/2010 was
filed by the petitioner before the Sub Court, North Paravur
claiming that the land in question was in possession and
enjoyment of his ancestors. The said suit was also dismissed.
Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner preferred an appeal as
A.S.No. 37/2015 before the District Court, North Paravur. The
said appeal was also dismissed on 28.06.2018. It is also stated that
the petitioner himself has filed WP(C)No.533/2018 before this
Court
seeking
early
consideration
of
the
application
for
assignment of land submitted before the 4th respondent, this Court
disposed of the same on 24.01.2018 with a direction to the 4 th
respondent Tahsildar, Aluva to consider application, in accordance
with law, after issuing notice of hearing to the petitioner and other
interested persons and to pass final orders within 2 months. It is
2025:KER:23465
:8:
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
on the basis of the said direction issued by this Court in a writ
petition filed by the petitioner himself that Ext.P3 order was
issued. Though an appeal was preferred before the Revenue
Divisional Officer, Fort Kochi, which is the authority to consider
the assignment of land for beneficial enjoyment, has also rejected
the appeal finding that the said land is not required for the
beneficial enjoyment of the petitioner and that the said land is
used as pathway by the neighbouring owners. Relying on Rule
11(2) (1) of Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964, it is contended
by the 4th respondent that the land that comes under the definition
of
Puramboke
as
per
the
provisions
of
the
Kerala
Land
Conservancy Act, 1957 should be kept for Government/Public
purpose only and therefore, sought for dismissal of the writ
petition.
5. The additional 5th respondent who got impleaded in this
writ petition would contend that the land which is sought to be
assigned for the beneficial enjoyment of the petitioner is a public
way leading to the adjacent properties including the property of
the additional 5th respondent and the writ petitioner has no legal
2025:KER:23465
:9:
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
right over the said property and therefore, sought for dismissal of
the writ petition.
6. I have considered the rival contentions on both sides.
7. Rule 6 of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964 deals
with Assignment for house site and for beneficial enjoyment. Note
to Rule 6(2) mandates that the authority competent to assign land
for beneficial enjoyment shall be the Revenue Divisional Officer.
Though Rule 6(2) mandates that it is the 3 rd respondent, who is the
proper authority to assign land for beneficial enjoyment, the
application submitted by the petitioner was considered by the 4 th
respondent Tahsildar based on a direction issued by this Court in
a writ petition filed by the petitioner himself. A perusal of Ext.P3
would reveal that the petitioner has encroached upon the land and
proceedings have been initiated as per the provisions of the Land
Conservancy
Act
to
evict
the
encroachment.
After
considering the records and the contentions of all parties, the 4th
respondent has entered a finding that the property which is
sought to be assigned for beneficial enjoyment is a Government
road puramboke land and the same cannot be assigned. It was
2025:KER:23465
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
: 10 :
also found by the 4th respondent that as per the Rules, assignment
could be granted only by the Revenue Divisional Officer, after
entering a finding that the land is absolutely necessary for the
beneficial enjoyment of the applicant. In the appeal the 3 rd
respondent RDO considered the said issue again and reiterated
the stand in Ext.P3 that the subject property is a Government road
puramboke and as per law, road puramboke cannot be assigned.
The 3rd respondent also found that since the petitioner is in
possession of 7.85 Ares of property, further land cannot be
assigned in the name of the petitioner. It is also found that the
subject property is used by the neighbouring property owners
including the additional 5th respondent as road and therefore, the
said property cannot be assigned to the petitioner. It is further
held by the Revenue Divisional Officer that he is not satisfied that
the land is absolutely necessary for the petitioner for his beneficial
enjoyment. A similar stand was taken by the Land Revenue
Commissioner in the Revision Petition, which culminated in Ext.P5
order. It is also to be noted that in respect of the subject property,
two suits were filed by the petitioner, which were also dismissed
2025:KER:23465
: 11 :
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
by the Court and the appeal filed as A.S.No.37/2015 was also
dismissed. Going by Rule 6 of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules,
1964 the land could be assigned to an applicant for beneficial
enjoyment only on a finding to the effect that the land is
indispensably required for the beneficial enjoyment of the
adjoining registered holding.
Rule 11 of the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules, 1964 mandates that a list of assignable land is
to be prepared by the Government and Rule 11(2)(i) mandates
that a “puramboke” as defined in the Kerala Land Conservancy
Act 1957 could be included in the said list only if it is not
detrimental to Government or the public interest. A perusal of the
statement filed by the 4th respondent and the orders impugned
herein
reveal
that
the
property
being
Government
road
puramboke, which is used by the neighbouring property owners
including the additional 5th respondent and on finding that the
same is not indispensably required for the beneficial enjoyment of
the adjoining registered holding of the petitioner, the application
has been rejected. Taking into consideration the above facts and
circumstances, I find that the reasons stated by the authorities for
2025:KER:23465
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
: 12 :
rejecting the claim of the petitioner for assignment of land for
beneficial enjoyment is in accordance with law.
8. Next aspect to be considered is the contention raised by
the petitioner that going by Section 6(2) of the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules, 1964 the authority competent to assign land for
beneficial enjoyment is the Revenue Divisional Officer and since
Ext.P3 order has been issued by the 4 th respondent Tahsildar, who
is incompetent to issue the same, Ext.P3 is liable to be interfered
with and Exts.P4 and P5 orders in appeal and revision confirming
Ext.P3 order issued by the Tahsildar are also illegal and arbitrary.
A pertinent aspect to be noted is that the 4 th respondent Tahsildar
has considered the application based on a direction issued by this
Court in a writ petition filed by the petitioner himself seeking an
expeditious disposal of the application by the 4 th respondent.
While rejecting the application by Ext.P3 order, the 4 th respondent
Tahsildar has also entered a finding that it is the 3 rd respondent
RDO who is competent to take a decision on the application
submitted by the petitioner and as the petitioner has not
substantiated that the property is indispensably required for the
2025:KER:23465
: 13 :
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
beneficial enjoyment of the adjoining registered holding, the same
cannot be recommended to the Revenue Divisional Officer. The
RDO considered the appeal and rejected the request of the
petitioner by Ext.P4 order assigning valid reasons in accordance
with the Act and the Rules and the same was confirmed by the
Revisional Authority as per Ext.P5 order. It is true that going by
Rule 6 of the Kerala Land Assignment Rules 1964, the competent
authority to assign land for beneficial enjoyment is the Revenue
Divisional Officer, but the application has been considered and
rejected by the Tahsildar. The question to be considered is
whether the orders are liable to be interfered with only for lack of
jurisdiction on the part of the 4 th respondent to consider the
application
submitted
by
the
petitioner.
Madhavikutty v. State of Kerala
This
Court
in
[2008(1) KLT 692] has
considered a similar issue wherein the petitioner therein was
dismissed from service and challenging the order of dismissal, a
petition was filed before the Registrar and the Registrar directed
reinstatement of the petitioner therein against which an appeal
was preferred before the Government and the same was allowed
2025:KER:23465
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
: 14 :
by the Government. It is challenging the said order that the said
writ petition was filed wherein it is contended that only the Cooperative Arbitration Court has jurisdiction to deal with the matter
and therefore, orders of Registrar and Government are without
any jurisdiction and sought for remittance of the case for
reconsideration
by the
Co-operative
Arbitration
Court. The
relevant portion of the judgment reads as follows:
“3. The petitioner has chosen, not to point out the lack of
jurisdiction of the Registrar or the Government before those
authorities, when the matter was heard. The petitioner who
took the chance before both the forums, cannot be
permitted to turn round and cry about the lack of
jurisdiction when the decision goes against her. This is a
well settled principle in writ jurisdiction. See the decision of
the Division Bench in Trivandrum Co-operative District
Wholesale Society v. Deputy Registrar of Co-operative
Societies, Trivandrum (1975 KLT 589).
4. Further, the Registrar considered the matter pursuant to
the direction of the Division Bench of this Court, which is a
superior court of unlimited jurisdiction. Its order cannot be
treated as a void order and it cannot be ignored. If it is
irregular, it has to be corrected by filing a review.
Otherwise, the order can be corrected only in appeal.”
In Madhavikutty's case cited supra, the Court did not interfere
2025:KER:23465
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
: 15 :
with the orders impugned therein holding that the petitioner had
not pointed out the lack of jurisdiction of the Registrar or the
Government before those authorities when the matter was heard
and the petitioner who took the chance before both the forums,
cannot be permitted to turn round and complain about the lack of
jurisdiction when the decision goes against her. The Court has
also entered a finding that the Registrar considered the matter
pursuant to the direction of the Division Bench of this Court,
which is a superior Court of unlimited jurisdiction and its order
cannot be treated as a void order and it cannot be ignored and if
the said order is irregular, it has to be corrected by filing a review
or by an appeal. Similar is the case of the petitioner herein also.
The petitioner has also not pointed out any lack of jurisdiction of
the Tahsildar or the other authorities when the matter was taken
up for hearing and the petitioner lost before all the authorities and
that the petitioner is complaining about lack of jurisdiction of the
4th respondent to consider the application only in the present writ
petition. Further, it is to be seen that Tahsildar has considered the
application based on a direction issued by this Court in a writ
2025:KER:23465
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
: 16 :
petition filed by the petitioner himself.
In Ext.P3 order, the
Tahsildar has entered a finding that as per the Kerala Land
Assignment Rules 1964, the authority to consider the application
is the RDO and as the petitioner did not satisfy the conditions for
assignment of land, the same is not recommended to the RDO. In
spite of all these, the petitioner did not choose to file an
application before the proper authority nor sought for review of
the judgment of this court or challenge the same in appeal. In
Madhavikutty's case cited supra, the Court also relied on the
Apex Court judgment in Mohammad Swalleh and Others v.
Third Addl. District Judge, Meerut and Another [(1988) 1
SCC 40] which held that even assuming that an order is passed
by an authority having no jurisdiction, still the Court need not
interfere with the same if justice has been done and held that even
if the Government has acted without jurisdiction, it is unnecessary
for the Court to interfere with the same.
In view of the above facts and circumstances and taking into
consideration the decisions of the Courts in Madhavikutty &
Mohammed Swalleh's cases cited supra, and the reasons stated
2025:KER:23465
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
: 17 :
above, even though Ext.P3 order has been issued by an authority
not competent to issue the same, I am not inclined to interfere
with the orders impugned herein and the writ petition is
accordingly dismissed.
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sm/
2025:KER:23465
: 18 :
W.P.(C). No.2007 of 2020
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 2007/2020
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE PATTA NO. 491 ISSUED BY
THE 4TH RESPONDENT WIT RESPECT TO 18
CENTS OF PROPERTIES IN SY NO. 138/17 OF
MANICKAMANGALAM VILLAGE DATED 18.11.1961.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE GIFT DEED NO. 689/1988
OF SUB REGISTRAR OFFICE, SREEMOOLANAGARAM
DATED 19.04.1988.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. C, 4-421/18
PASSED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT DATED
03.04.2018.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. J-3054/18
PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT DATED
09.05.2019.
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. LRJ320538/2019 PASSED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT
DATED 26.11.2019.
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN WPC NO.
75/2020 PASSED BY THIS HONORABLE COURT
DATED 09.01.2020.
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT DATED 19.12.2019.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review