Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CRIMINAL APPEAL (SJ) No.5170 of 2025
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-704 Year-2017 Thana- BIHTA District- Patna
======================================================
Shankar Kumar @ Sankar Kumar Chaudhary @ Shankar Chaudhary, S/o Late
Ganesh Prasad @ Late Ganesh Chaudhary, Resident of Dr. N.C. Gosh Lane,
New Yarpur, P.S.- Gardanibagh, Dist.- Patna.
... ... Appellant
Versus
The State of Bihar
... ... Respondent
======================================================
with
CRIMINAL APPEAL (SJ) No. 2579 of 2026
In
CRIMINAL REVISION No.1094 of 2025
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-704 Year-2017 Thana- BIHTA District- Patna
======================================================
Shankar Kumar @ Shankar Choudhary @ Shankar Kumar Choudhary, son of
Late Ganesh Prasad Choudhary, Resident of Village - Yarpur Devi Sthan,
Nimtar, PS- Gardanibagh, Dist- Patna.
... ... Appellant
Versus
1.
The State of Bihar
2.
Ajay Kumar, Son of Uday Kumar Singh, Resident of village and PS- Bihta,
Dist- Patna.
... ... Respondent
======================================================
Appearance :
(In CRIMINAL APPEAL (SJ) No. 5170 of 2025)
For the Appellant
:
Mr. Abhishek Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Niraj Kumar, Advocate
For the State
:
Mr. Mukeshwar Dayal, APP
(In CRIMINAL APPEAL (SJ) No. 2579 of 2026)
For the Appellant
:
Mr. Abhimanyu Deo, Advocate
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
2/14
For the State
:
Mr. Ram Priya Sharan Singh, Spl. PP
Amicus Curiae
:
Mr. Anil Singh, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE JITENDRA KUMAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 20-07-2026
Both these appeals are being taken up together and
decided by a common judgment because they have been filed by
the same Appellant in connection with Bihta P.S. Case No.704
of 2017. Appeal No.2579 of 2026 has been filed by the
Appellant for release on bail, whereas the appeal no.5170 of
2025 has been filed by the Appellant challenging the
Preliminary Assessment conducted by learned Children Court
under Section 19 of the J.J. Act and trial of the Appellant as an
adult.
CRIMINAL APPEAL (SJ) No. 5170 of 2026
2. The present appeal has been preferred by the Appellant
against the impugned order dated 19.09.2025 passed by learned
Children Court in Special Child P.S. Case No. 21 of 2025 under
Section 19 of the J. J. Act, whereby learned Children Court after
doing Preliminary Assessment held that the Appellant is juvenile
and physically and mentally competent to understand the
consequences of the crime and the circumstances under which
the offence has been committed. Hence, in view of learned
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
3/14
Children Court, the trial of the Appellant is required to be
conducted as an adult as per the procedure of the Criminal
Procedure Code.
3. As per the FIR, one Nirbhay Singh was standing along
with his brother/informant before a cinema hall when three
young persons with mask on their face, came on motorcycle and
fired at Nirbhay Singh, injuring him seriously, who, in the
course of treatment died. During investigation, one Akshay
Kumar was arrested, who confessed to the crime implicating
eleven other co-accused, including the Petitioner. As per his
confession, the brother of one Pappu Singh hired the coaccused, Akshay Singh for killing Nirbhay Singh and this coaccused, Akshay Kumar called the Appellant and other coaccused for the killing of Nirbhay Singh. As per the planning,
all of them being armed with fire arms visited the village, where
Nirbhay Singh was living and the co-accused, Amit fired at him.
Subsequently, on 26.09.2017 the present Appellant was arrested
and charge-sheet was submitted on 12.12.2017 against him and
ten other co-accused persons. During Sessions Trial, the
Appellant was released on bail by the order of this Court dated
01.05.2019. However, his bail bond was later on cancelled on
28.03.2022 by the Sessions Court on account of failure of the
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
4/14
Appellant to appear before it at the stage of statement of the
accused under Section 313 Cr.PC. Meanwhile, one Jakkanpur
P.S. Case No. 300 of 2021 was lodged for the offences
punishable under Section 307 and other Sections of IPC against
named accused persons. But the name of the Appellant was not
there in the array of the accused in the FIR. However, his name
transpired in the confessional statement of the co-accused in
Jakkanpur P.S. Case 300 of 2021 and he was arrested in that
case on 12.09.2022 and he was also remanded in the present
Bihta P.S. Case No.704 of 2017, and since then, he has been in
custody.
4. The facts giving rise to the present appeal is that Bihta
P.S. Case No. 704 of 2017 was registered on 15.09.2017 for the
offence punishable under Section 326, 302/34 of the Indian
Penal Code and Section 27 of the Arms Act against unknown
persons for the murder of one Nirbhay Singh.
5. In Bihta P.S. Case No. 704 of 2017, plea of juvenility
was taken before the Sessions Court by the Appellant twice in
the year 2024 and 2025. However, the same were rejected by the
Sessions Court, and subsequently, when again the plea of
juvenility was taken by the Appellant before the Sessions Court
on the basis of School Leaving Certificate, his case was referred
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
5/14
to the Juvenile Justice Board, Patna, vide order dated.
16.05.2025 and thereafter, the J.J.B vide order dated 08.07.2025
found the Appellant as juvenile being 16 year 5 months and 7
days old. Thereafter, vide order dated 06.08.2025, Preliminary
Assessment of the Appellant was conducted under Section 15 of
the J.J. Act and he was found to be mature enough to be tried as
an adult by the Children Court. Thereafter, the matter was sent
to the Children Court. Thereafter, by the impugned order dated
19.09.2025, learned Children Court passed the order under
Section 19 of the J.J. Act finding the Appellant adult and
holding
that the trial of the Appellant is required to be
conducted as an adult. Hence, the present appeal has been filed
by the Appellant being aggrieved by the order dated 19.09.2025
of learned Children Court.
6. I heard learned counsel for the Appellant, learned
Special Public Prosecutor for the State as well as learned
Amicus Curiae, Mr. Anil Singh, Advocate.
7. Learned counsel for the Appellant submits that
undisputedly, the offence has been allegedly committed on
15.09.2017 and the Preliminary Assessment under Section 15 of
the Appellant has been conducted by learned J.J. Board on
06.08.2025 i.e after about 7 years and 11 months of the alleged
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
6/14
occurrence. Hence, the Preliminary Assessment of the Appellant
has been conducted at the age of above 24 years as the
Appellant was found to be 16 years 5 months and 7 days on the
date of commission of the alleged offence. Hence, at the age of
above 24 years, there is no meaning of conducting the
Assessment regarding maturity of the Appellant. Any test at this
age of above 24 years is bound to be positive regarding maturity
of the Appellant.
8. He also submits that the Preliminary Assessment of the
Appellant is erroneous. He points out that as per the report of
the psychologist, Rani Kumari, the mental age of the Appellant
was 16 years, whereas the date of psychological test conducted
by the psychologist is 16.07.2025 i.e after about 7 years and 11
months of the date of the occurrence. Even as per the J.J. Board,
the mental age of the Appellant is found to be 16 years at the
present age of 24 years 3 months and 8 days. As such, the
maturity of the Appellant about 8 years back must be much
lower than the mental age of 16 years. As such, the Appellant
was not matured enough to understand the nature of the alleged
offence and its consequences at the time of the occurrence.
9. He further submits that in the impugned order dated
19.09.2025, passed under Section 19 of the J.J. Act, learned
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
7/14
Children Court has also committed error making Preliminary
Assessment of the Appellant only on the basis of answers to
some questions put up by him to the Appellant. He has also not
taken into consideration the report of the psychologist and as per
law, the Preliminary Assessment by the Children Court under
Section 19 of the J.J. Act is not an empty formality. It has to be
conducted independently by the Children Court with all care
and sincerity, but the same is missing in the impugned order.
Hence, the same is not sustainable and the Appellant is entitled
to get tried as a juvenile and not as an adult.
10. He further submits that the Appellant is already in
custody since 12.09.2022, and even prior to that he was in
custody for one year and about eight months. As such, the total
incarceration of the Appellant is more than five years and four
months, whereas the maximum detention of Appellant by the
J.J. Board may be up to three years. Hence, the Appellant is
entitled to get set free and the whole proceeding is liable to be
set aside.
11. He also submits that the preliminary assessment of the
appellant has been conducted at his age of 24 years 3 months
and 18 days and hence, the whole exercise of preliminary
assessment was futile at that age of the appellant and therefore,
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
8/14
he could not be tried as an adult as per this preliminary
assessment. The benefit of doubt must be given to the appellant
in regard to his maturity.
12. However, learned Special Public Prosecutor for the
State defends the impugned order passed by learned Children
Court and the trial of the Appellant as an adult because he was
matured enough at the time of commission of the alleged
offence to understand the crime and its consequences. He also
submits that the plea of the Appellant that the Preliminary
Assessment has been conducted at belated stage at the age of
about 24 years, has no substance because it is the Appellant who
has taken plea only in the year 2024-25, and hence, after inquiry
he was found to be juvenile and after the Preliminary
Assessment, he was found to be matured enough to understand
the crime and its consequences. Hence, he cannot take benefit of
his own wrong.
13. Learned Amicus Curiae Mr. Anil Singh, Advocate
submits that the Appellant has been already declared juvenile on
08.07.2025 by the J.J. Board and that is still unchallenged.
Hence, the juvenility of the Appellant has become absolute. He
also submits that the Preliminary Assessment is required to be
conducted by learned J.J. Board as well as learned Children
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
9/14
Court as a serious affair. It is contemplated to be conducted with
all care and sincerity because the consequences of the order is
very serious for any juvenile because in case he is found to be
matured enough to understand the crime and its consequences,
his trial is bound to be conducted as an adult by learned
Children Court and in that situation, the punishment is very
severe, whereas, if his trial/inquiry is conducted as a juvenile by
the J.J. Board, the maximum detention is up to three years.
14. He also submits that the Preliminary Assessment by
the Children Court is not proper at all. The Children Court was
required to make the Preliminary Assessment of the Appellant
taking all comprehensive measures with all care and sincerity,
but learned Children Court has made the Preliminary
Assessment only on the basis of answers to the questions put up
by him. He has not taken into consideration the psychologist’s
report, as per which, mental age of the Appellant at the age of
about 24 years was 16 years.
15. He also submits that now, at this stage this is also
futile to remand the matter for fresh Preliminary Assessment of
the Appellant because now he is much above 25 years of age
and at this stage, the whole exercise to make the Preliminary
Assessment would be futile. As such, the benefit of doubt may
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
10/14
be given to the Appellant regarding his maturity
and his
trial/inquiry should be conducted as a juvenile and the
maximum detention contemplated in such trial/inquiry is only
up to three years, whereas the Appellant has already suffered
incarceration for 5 years and 4 months. Hence, the Appellant
may be set free.
16. I considered the submissions advanced by both the
parties as well as the submissions of learned Amicus Curiae and
perused the material on record.
17. It clearly transpires that the alleged offence was
committed on 15.09.2017 and vide order dated 8.7.2025,
learned J.J. Board found the Appellant juvenile being 16 years 5
months and 7 days old on the date of alleged occurrence on
15.09.2017. The Preliminary Assessment of the Appellant was
conducted on 06.08.2025 by learned J.J. Board, i.e at the age of
24 years 3 months 18 days and as per the psychologist’s report,
the intellectual capacity of the Appellant was found to be below
average and at the time of inquiry report submitted by the
psychologist vide the report dated 23.07.2025, he was found to
be of mental age of 16 years. Hence, his mental capacity at the
time of alleged offence i.e about eight years ago must be much
below 16 years. As such, he cannot be held mentally matured
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
11/14
enough to understand the alleged offence and its consequences
at the time of commission of the alleged offence.
18. Hence, the Preliminary Assessment conducted by
learned J.J. Board is not sustainable. Moreover, learned Children
Court has not taken into consideration the report of the
psychologist and the Preliminary Assessment is based only on
some answers to the questions put up by him to the Appellant.
Hence, the Preliminary Assessment conducted by learned
Children Court, vide order dated 19.09.2025 is also not
sustainable.
19. In such situation, the Appellant is held not to be
mentally and physically capable enough at the time of the
alleged occurrence to commit the alleged offence and
understand
the
consequences
of
the
offence
and
the
circumstances in which the offence was committed. Hence,
there was no need to conduct the trial of the Appellant as an
adult by learned Children Court. Under such circumstances, the
Children Court under Section 19(1)(ii) of the J.J. Act has to
conduct inquiry as J.J. Board and pass appropriate order under
Section 18 of the J.J. Act.
20. I further find that the maximum punishment under
Section 18 of the J.J. Act by the J.J. Board is detention up to
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
12/14
three years, whereas, the Appellant has already suffered
incarceration in jail for more than five years and four months.
21. There is also another aspect to the issue involved in
this case. The preliminary assessment of the appellant was
conducted on 06.08.2025 at his age of 24 years 3 months and 18
days. Hence, at that age, the preliminary assessment was also a
futile exercise as Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in
Thirumoorthy v. State of T.N., as reported in (2024) 12 SCC
307.
22. In Thirumoorthy case (supra), the trial was
conducted by the Sessions Court and the matter was never put
up before the J.J. Board or Children Court under the J.J. Act,
whereas the appellant was found to be juvenile at the time of the
alleged occurrence. During appeal, Hon’ble Apex Court found
this illegality and held the whole criminal trial vitiated. Hon’ble
Apex Court further held that at that stage when the appellant
was 23 years of age, there was no realistic possibility of finding
out the mental and physical capacity of the appellant to commit
the offence or to assess his ability to understand the
consequences of the offence and circumstances in which he
committed the offence in the year 2016. Hence, the matter was
not remanded for preliminary assessment of the appellant before
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
13/14
the J.J. Board or the Children Court and the judgment was
quashed and set aside and the appellant was directed to be
released forthwith, if not required in any other case. The
relevant part of the judgment reads as follows :
“47. The appellant-accused being a CICL was never
subjected to preliminary assessment by the Board so as to
find out whether he should be tried as an adult. Directing
such an exercise at this stage would be sheer futility
because now the appellant is nearly 23 years of age.
48. At this stage, there remains no realistic possibility of
finding out the mental and physical capacity of the
appellant-accused to commit the offence or to assess his
ability to understand the consequences of the offence and
circumstances in which he committed the offence in the
year 2016.
49. Since we have held that the entire proceedings taken
against the appellant right from the stage of investigation
and the completion of trial stand vitiated as having been
undertaken in gross violation of the mandatory
requirements of the JJ Act, we need not dwell into the
merits of the matter or to reappreciate the evidence
available on record for finding out whether the
prosecution has been able to prove the guilt of the
appellant by reliable circumstantial evidence.
50. Thus, we are left with no option but to quash and set
aside the impugned judgment [Thirumoorthy v. State of
T.N., 2021 SCC OnLine Mad 1520] and direct that the
appellant who is presently lodged in jail shall be released
forthwith, if not required in any other case.”
(Emphasis supplied)
23. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed setting aside the
impugned order and the Appellant is directed to be released
forthwith, if not required in any other case.
24. The assistance provided by learned Amicus Curiae is
highly appreciated and the Secretary, Patna High Court Legal
Patna High Court CR. APP (SJ) No.5170 of 2025 dt.20-07-2026
14/14
Services Committee is directed to pay Honorarium of Rs.
15,000/- to Learned Amicus Curiae within a month of receipt of
this order.
CRIMINAL APPEAL (SJ) No. 2579 of 2026
25. This appeal has become infructuous, in view of the
judgment passed in Cr. Appeal (SJ) No. 5170 of 2025.
26. Hence, it is dismissed as infructuous.
(Jitendra Kumar, J.)
Chandan/Shoaib
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
A.F.R
N.A.
10.08.2026
10.08.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review