Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010352042026
2026:CGHC:39794
NAFR
Digitally
RAGHVENDRA signed by
JAT
RAGHVENDRA
JAT
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 4638 of 2026
1 - Shamshad Hussain S/o Irshad Hussain, Aged About 37 Years R/o
Shanti Nagar, Champa, Tahsil Champa Distt. Janjgir - Champa (C.G.)
Presently R/o Ward No. 07, Laxmi Bai Nagar, Surabahar, Katghora,
Distt. Korba (C.G.)
2 - Gulshan Bano Memon, W/o Mohd. Hanif Parekh, Aged About 32
Years R/o Near Kankalin Temple, Jamnipali, Korba Distt. Korba (C.G.)
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Department Of Transport,
Mantralaya,
Mahanadi
Bhawan,
New
Raipur
(C.G.)
2 - Regional Transport Authority, 3rd Floor, Indravati Bhawan, Nava
Raipur,
Mantralaya,
Raipur
(C.G.)
3 - Devendra Sharma, S/o B. R. Sharma, Bus Operator, R/o Village
Khadgava, Koria Distt. Koria (C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Bharat Lal Dembra, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)/State : Mr. Shreyansh Mehta, Panel Lawyer.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
11/09/2026
1.
By way of this petition, the petitioner has prayed for following
reliefs:“10.1 The Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to issue
a writ or direction, calling for the records from the
concerned authorities for its kind perusal.
10.2 The Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to issue a
writ or direction, quashing/set-aside the order dated
24.02.2025 in revision no. 06/2024 by the State
Transport Appellate Tribunal Raipur and order dated
11.08.2023 passed by the RTA be restored.
10.3. That, the Hon'ble Court may further be pleased to
stay the effect and operation of impugned order dated
24.02.2025 and petitioner no.2 may be allowed to
operate vehicle as per permit no. CG20203-SC-267A
from Pandopara to Korba till disposal of the petition.
10.4 Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court may
deems fit and proper looking to the facts and
circumstances of the case may also be awarded to the
petitioner including the cost and expenses of this
petition. An affidavit in support of this petition is filed
herewith.”
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that petitioner No. 1 is
a bus operator who has been plying his vehicle on the strength of
a permit duly granted by the competent authorities. It is submitted
that petitioner No. 1 had submitted an application dated
20.01.2023 for grant of a permanent stage carriage permit on the
route from Patna to Jamnipali via Baikunthpur, Bachrapodi,
Sirmina, Korbi, Chhotia, Katghora, Chhruri and back, with one
return trip daily. After considering the objections raised and all
other relevant aspects of the matter, the Regional Transport
Authority (RTA), vide order dated 11.08.2023, granted the
permanent stage carriage permit in favour of petitioner No. 1,
pursuant to which the permit was duly issued. Learned counsel
further submits that respondent No. 3, being aggrieved by the
aforesaid order, preferred a revision petition before the learned
State Transport Appellate Tribunal (STAT), Raipur, which, vide the
impugned order dated 24.02.2025, allowed the revision petition
and set aside the order passed by the RTA, primarily on the
ground that petitioner No. 1 had remained ex parte in the
proceedings and that the application submitted by him was
incomplete. It is submitted that the learned STAT, particularly in
paragraph 10 of the impugned order, has proceeded on the
premise that the application submitted by petitioner No. 1 was
incomplete and, on that basis, has held the order passed by the
RTA to be unsustainable in law. Learned counsel submits that the
learned STAT has committed a manifest error of law in passing
such a cryptic and non-speaking order, without properly
appreciating the material available on record and the settled
principles governing the grant of permits. It is further submitted
that merely because an application is alleged to be defective or
incomplete, the permit already granted by the competent authority
cannot, as a matter of course, be quashed, particularly when the
requisite documents had been furnished and the matter had been
duly considered by the RTA. In this regard, learned counsel places
reliance upon the judgment of this Court in M/s Rainbow Travels v.
RTA & Others, passed in W.A. No. 260/2026, wherein it has been
held that a permit cannot be denied merely on the ground of a
defective application. Learned counsel further submits that
petitioner No. 1 subsequently transferred the aforesaid permit in
favour of petitioner No. 2, and, therefore, petitioner No. 2 has been
impleaded as a party to the present petition. It is submitted that
petitioner No. 2 has been continuously plying the vehicle pursuant
to the permit transferred in her favour for the last about two years
and, despite the impugned order having been passed by the STAT,
neither petitioner received any notice regarding the said order nor
any notice directing surrender of the permit. Learned counsel
submits that petitioner No. 1 had remained ex parte before the
STAT and, therefore, had no knowledge of the passing of the
impugned order. Subsequently, petitioner No. 1 transferred the
permit in favour of petitioner No. 2, and the petitioners thereafter
submitted applications for extension of the route, which were duly
published and considered by the competent authority; however, no
information regarding the passing of the impugned order was ever
communicated to them. It is submitted that the petitioners came to
know about the impugned order only on 31.08.2026, and hence
the present petition has been filed without any deliberate or
intentional delay. Learned counsel further submits that the order
passed by the RTA was based upon proper consideration of the
relevant facts and documents, as the petitioner had submitted all
requisite documents, and only a partial stretch of approximately
10–15 kilometres of the route is common with that of respondent
No. 3. It is further submitted that there is sufficient time gap
between the services operated by the petitioners and respondent
No. 3, and the same was duly considered and approved by the
RTA while granting the permit. Learned counsel submits that,
since no frequency of operation on the concerned routes has been
formally formulated in the State of Chhattisgarh, the alleged
difference in timing or frequency cannot, by itself, be treated as
creating a conflict or clash between the services of the petitioners
and respondent No. 3, particularly when sufficient time gap has
already been approved by the competent authority. It is further
submitted that the RTA has, on two occasions, allowed the
applications submitted by the petitioners for extension of the route,
which clearly demonstrates that the permit and subsequent route
extensions were being acted upon by the competent authority;
nevertheless, the petitioners were never informed about the order
passed by the STAT. Learned counsel further submits that,
considering the fact that petitioner No. 2 has been operating the
vehicle under the transferred permit for nearly two years and that
the permit has been acted upon by the competent authorities, the
same ought not to have been set aside merely on the ground of an
alleged defect or incompleteness in the original application. It is
also submitted that respondent No. 3 has only a limited common
portion of approximately 10–15 kilometres with the route of the
petitioners and, therefore, setting aside the entire permit granted
in favour of the petitioners, on such a limited ground, is wholly
disproportionate and legally unsustainable. Learned counsel lastly
submits that the impugned order passed by the learned STAT
suffers from material illegality, non-application of mind and failure
to consider the relevant facts and settled principles of law, and that
the Tribunal has exceeded the scope of its jurisdiction by passing
a cryptic and non-speaking order. It is, therefore, submitted that
the impugned order dated 24.02.2025 deserves to be quashed
and set aside and the permit granted in favour of petitioner No. 1
and subsequently transferred in favour of petitioner No. 2
deserves to be restored, particularly keeping in view the fact that
the petitioners have been operating the vehicle pursuant thereto
and also considering the larger public interest involved in the
matter.
3.
On the other hand, learned State Counsel appearing for
respondents No.1 and 2 vehemently opposes the writ petition and
submits that the impugned order passed by the learned STAT
does not suffer from any illegality, perversity or jurisdictional error
warranting interference in exercise of writ jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India. It is submitted that the entire
process for grant of permit was undertaken strictly in accordance
with the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and the
Chhattisgarh Motor Vehicles Rules, 1994. The application
submitted by respondent No.3 was duly received by the Regional
Transport
Authority,
published
in
the
prescribed
manner,
objections were invited from all interested persons and existing
operators, and adequate opportunity of hearing was afforded to all
stakeholders before any decision was taken. Therefore, the
petitioner cannot contend that there has been any violation of the
principles of natural justice or any procedural irregularity in the
decision-making process.
4.
Learned State Counsel further submits that the Regional
Transport Authority, while considering the application for grant of
stage carriage permit, had specifically examined the proposed
route and timings in light of Rule 70-B of the Chhattisgarh Motor
Vehicles Rules, 1994. The objections raised by the petitioner and
other operators with regard to the alleged clash of timings were
also considered. Upon such consideration, the proposed timings
were suitably modified so as to ensure compliance with the
minimum interlude requirements prescribed under Rule 70-B(4). It
is contended that the statutory provisions do not prohibit grant of
permit merely because a portion of the route overlaps with that of
an
existing
operator.
impermissible
timing
What
is
conflicts
required
and
is
avoidance
safeguarding
of
public
convenience, both of which were duly taken into account by the
competent authority while granting the permit in favour of
respondent No.3.
5.
It is next submitted that the principal challenge raised by the
petitioner pertains to the power of the learned STAT to remand the
matter for fresh consideration. According to learned State
Counsel, the contention is wholly misconceived. Referring to
Section 90 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, it is argued that the
revisional authority has been conferred wide powers to pass such
orders as it may deem fit in the facts and circumstances of a given
case. Such powers necessarily include the authority to set aside
an order and remit the matter to the original authority for fresh
consideration whenever the revisional authority finds that certain
aspects require reconsideration or that adequate opportunity has
not been afforded to the parties. Therefore, the direction issued by
the learned STAT remitting the matter to the Regional Transport
Authority for a fresh decision after granting due opportunity to all
concerned parties cannot be said to be beyond jurisdiction.
6.
Learned State Counsel also submits that the learned STAT, after
examining the record, found that except for objections relating to
the proposed timings, no substantial objection had been raised
before the Regional Transport Authority. The Tribunal further found
that the issue concerning the alleged deficiencies in the
application required proper examination by the competent
authority. In such circumstances, instead of finally adjudicating the
matter on disputed factual aspects, the Tribunal adopted the
course of remand so that the Regional Transport Authority could
reconsider the matter comprehensively after hearing all concerned
parties. Such an order, it is submitted, advances the cause of
justice and ensures a fair adjudicatory process rather than causing
prejudice to any party.
7.
Lastly, learned State Counsel submits that both the Regional
Transport Authority as well as the State Transport Appellate
Tribunal
are
statutory
authorities
discharging
quasi-judicial
functions under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The findings
recorded by such authorities are based on appreciation of factual
aspects relating to route feasibility, public convenience, transport
requirements and timing regulations. In the absence of any
manifest arbitrariness, patent illegality or jurisdictional error, this
Court, while exercising supervisory jurisdiction, ought not to
substitute its own view for that of the competent statutory
authorities. It is therefore submitted that the impugned order has
been passed in accordance with the statutory scheme governing
grant of stage carriage permits and does not warrant interference.
The writ petition, being devoid of merit, deserves to be dismissed.
8.
Reliance has been placed upon the judgment rendered by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in Harikrishna Ogare v. Regional
Transport
Authority
(WPC
No.4138/2025
decided
on
27.01.2026) as well as the judgment rendered by the Division
Bench of this Court in M/s Rainbow Travels v. Regional
Transport Authority (WA No.260/2026 decided on 01.04.2026)
to buttress his submissions.
9.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents annexed with the writ petition.
10.
Before proceeding to examine the rival submissions advanced on
behalf of the parties, it would be apposite to refer to the relevant
statutory provisions governing the controversy.
11.
Section 72 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, which deals with grant
of stage carriage permits, empowers the Regional Transport
Authority to grant a stage carriage permit subject to such
conditions
as
may
be
specified
therein.
The
provision
contemplates consideration of an application made in accordance
with law and authorizes the permit granting authority to impose
conditions while granting such permit.
12.
Section 80(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 provides as under:“80. Procedure in applying for and granting
permits.(1)***
(2) A Regional Transport Authority, State
Transport Authority or any prescribed authority
referred to in sub-section (1) shall not ordinarily
refuse to grant an application for permit of any
kind made at any time under this Act.”
13.
Section 90 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, which confers
revisional jurisdiction upon the State Transport Appellate Tribunal,
reads thus:“90. Revision.-The State Transport Appellate
Tribunal may, on an application made to it, call
for the record of any case in which an order
has been made by State Transport Authority or
Regional Transport Authority against which no
appeal lies, and if it appears to the State
Transport Appellate Tribunal that the order
made by the State Transport Authority or
Regional Transport Authority is improper or
illegal, the State Transport Appellate Tribunal
may pass such order in relation to the case as
it deems fit and every such order shall be final.”
14.
Equally relevant is Rule 70-B of the Chhattisgarh Motor Vehicles
Rules, 1994, which regulates determination of timings of stage
carriage permits. Rule 70-B(1) provides that while considering and
determining the time-cycle on any route in relation to grant of a
new stage carriage permit or change of timings of an existing
permit, the permit granting authority shall pay special attention to,
inter alia, the following factors: (a) Benefit and convenience of the
travelling public; (b) Interlude between timings and timing clashes
with operators on overlapping routes; (c) Nature and distance of
service proposed; (d) Necessity of the proposed timings for the
travelling public, particularly in remote and backward areas; (e)
Coordination between road and rail transport and connectivity with
tourist, religious and industrial centres; (f) Guidelines issued by
superior Courts or authorities; and (g) Objections raised by
existing operators and suggestions from the public.
15.
Rule 70-B(4) prescribes the minimum permissible interlude
between timings of stage carriages on overlapping routes. The
Rule stipulates that the permit granting authority shall fix common
stoppages and halting times on routes which overlap partly or
wholly. The prescribed minimum time-gap is as follows:
Place
Ordinary
Service
District Headquarters
10 Minutes
Tehsil Headquarters
5 Minutes
Express/Deluxe
Service
5 Minutes
3 Minutes
Other Towns (Population
below 10,000)
Villages
16.
3 Minutes
1 Minute
2 Minutes
Nil
Rule 70-B(5) further prescribes the procedure for determination of
timings and mandates publication of the summary of the
application and invitation of objections.
17.
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions would indicate that
while the Motor Vehicles Act adopts a liberal approach towards
grant of permits, the same is nevertheless required to be
undertaken against the statutory procedure prescribed under the
Act and the Rules. The permit granting authority is obligated to
consider the application as presented before it, invite objections,
examine the issue of timing conflicts and overlapping routes, and
thereafter take a decision on the basis of the material available on
record.
18.
Once a statutory authority records a finding that an application is
incomplete
and
suffers
from
defects
going
to
its
very
maintainability, the rights of the parties are required to be
adjudged on the basis of the application as it existed on the date
of consideration. Permitting an applicant to subsequently cure
deficiencies after the matter has already undergone adjudication
would amount to allowing such applicant to improve upon his case
and fill up lacunae which existed on the relevant date. Such a
course not only militates against the principles of fairness and
transparency governing the grant of permits but also causes
prejudice to competing operators who had raised objections with
reference to the application in its original form. The legality of an
application has necessarily to be tested on the basis of the
material available when the competent authority undertakes
consideration thereof and not on the basis of material which may
subsequently be brought on record.
19.
This Court is also of the opinion that the learned Tribunal has not
rendered any conclusive finding on various issues specifically
raised before it by the petitioner, including the effect of the alleged
deficiencies in the application, the legal consequences flowing
therefrom, and the objections relating to overlapping routes and
timing conflicts. Instead of adjudicating the issues arising in the
revision petition on their own merits, the Tribunal has chosen to
remit the matter to the Regional Transport Authority after
permitting rectification of defects. Such a course has resulted in
failure to exercise the jurisdiction vested in the Tribunal in
accordance with law.
20.
Accordingly, and for the reasons recorded hereinabove, the writ
petition deserves to be and is hereby allowed. The impugned
order dated 24.02.2025 passed by the learned State Transport
Appellate Tribunal, Chhattisgarh, Raipur in Revision Case No.
06/2024 is hereby set aside. The matter is remanded to the
learned State Transport Appellate Tribunal for fresh adjudication of
the revision petition on its own merits.
21.
It is directed that the learned Tribunal shall reconsider and decide
the revision petition afresh strictly in accordance with law and on
the basis of the material which was available before the Regional
Transport Authority at the time of consideration of the application.
The Tribunal shall independently examine all contentions raised by
the parties, including the legal effect of the alleged incompleteness
of the application, the objections relating to overlapping routes and
timings, and all other issues arising from the record, without being
influenced by any observation contained in the earlier order. It is
further clarified that respondent No.3 shall not be permitted to
supplement, improve, rectify or fill up any alleged deficiency in the
original application for the purpose of adjudication of the revision
proceedings, and the matter shall be decided on the basis of the
record as it stood on the relevant date of consideration by the
Regional Transport Authority.
22.
Since this Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of
the rival claims of the parties, all questions of fact and law are left
open to be urged before and decided by the learned Tribunal. The
learned State Transport Appellate Tribunal shall make an
endeavour to decide the revision petition expeditiously, preferably
within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order.
Sd/-/- (Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Raghu Jat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review