Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
APHC010776282017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
MONDAY,THE NINETEENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 479/2018
Between:
1. SHAIK
SUMIYA
AND
OTHERS,
RIYAZ,R/O.TAILORS
COLONY,KOTHURU
RURAL MANDAL,SPSR NELLORE DISTRICT
W/O.LATE
SHAIK
VILLAGE,NELLORE
2. SHAIK AZEEZ, S/O.LATE SHAIK RIYAZ,AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS,
3. SHAIK MOBEENA, D/O.LATE SHAIK RIYAZ
4. SHAIK MASTHAN, F/O.LATE SHAIK RIYAZ,
5. SHAIK FAREEDA, M/O.LATE SHAIK RIYAZ, ALL ARE R/O.TAILORS
COLONY,KOTHURU VILLAGE, NELLORE RURAL MANDAL,SPSR
NELLORE DISTRICT(APPELLANTS 2 AND 3 ARE MINORS REP BY
THEIR MOTHER AND NATURAL GUARDIAN 1 ST APPELLANT
SHAIK SUMIYA)
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. S GANGADHAR REDDY AND ANOTHER, S/O.GANGI REDDY,
OWNER OF SCORPIO CAR BEARING NO.AP 26 AF 114,BEHIND LLF
SCHOOL,VEDAYAPALEM,NELLORE
TOWN,SPSR
NELLORE
DISTRICT
2. THE
DIVISIONAL
MANAGER,
UNITED
INDIA
INSURANCE
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
CO.LTD,BRINDAVANAM,NELLORE,SPSR NELLORE DISTRICT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal Under Section_____against ordersCMA against the order passed
in Order in EC.Case No.11/2011,dated 28-12-2016 passed by the
Commissioner for Employees Compensation Act 1923-cum- Assistant
Commissioner of Labour,Nellore
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
To condone the delay of 205 days in filing the appeal against the order passed
in EC.Case No.11 of 2011 dated 28-12-2016 on the file of the Commissioner
for Employees Compensation Act,1923-cum-Assistant Commissioner of
Labour,Nellore and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 211 days in representation of the above
CMA.SR.No.33524 of 2017 and pass
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. MADHAVA RAO NALLURI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GUDI SRINIVASU
2.
The Court made the following:
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
JUDGMENT:
This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under Section 30 of the
Employees Compensation Act, 1923, by the appellants/applicants challenging
the order dated 28.12.2016 passed on the file of the Court of the
Commissioner for Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923 – cum – Assistant
Commissioner of Labour, Nellore in E.C.Case No.11 of 2011, whereby the
Court
below
awarded
a
compensation
of
Rs.5,50,315/-
to
the
appellants/applicants against the claim of Rs.5,00,000/-, but directed the 1st
respondent alone to pay the same to the appellants/applicants.
2.
Brief facts of the case are as under:
(a)
For the sake of convenience, the parties will hereinafter be
referred to as they are arrayed before the Court below. The applicants filed a
case before the Court below claiming an amount of Rs.5,00,000/- towards
compensation for the death of Shaik Riyaz while working as a driver of the
Car bearing No.AP-26-AF-1114 which belongs to the 1st opposite party. The
1st applicant is the wife, 2nd and 3rd applicants are son and daughter, 4th and
5th applicants are father and mother of the deceased workman Shaik Riyaz.
The deceased workman was employed by the 1st opposite party as Driver of
the vehicle bearing No.AP-26-AF-1114. The 2nd opposite party is the insurer
of the car belonging to the 1st opposite party.
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
(b)
On 29.01.2010, at about 07.00 p.m., while the deceased
workman was proceeding from Nellore to Tirupati in the car of the 1 st opposite
party, collided with a vehicle (TVS-50) bearing No.AP-03-AK-4598, coming in
the opposite direction, lost control over the car and as a result, the car turned
turtle; with grave injuries, the workman died on the spot. Accordingly, the
incident was report to the Station House Officer, Renigunta Police Station and
a case has been registered in Crime No.11 of 210 under Section 304-A and
337 of the Indian Penal Code. It was contended that the deceased workman
was earning Rs.4,000/- per month in addition to a batta of Rs.100/- per day
and that he is aged about 28 years.
(c)
In the said case, the 1st opposite party was set exparte on
04.07.2012. The said case was contested by the 2nd opposite party – insurer
of the subject car. The 2nd opposite party filed a counter affidavit denying the
contentions of the applicants and stated that the accident occurred due to the
negligence of the rider of TVS-50 and that the 2nd opposite party is not liable
to pay compensation to the applicants in any manner. It is further contended
that the deceased does not possess a valid driving licence to drive the
vehicle.
(d)
After considering the submissions of either side, the Court below
framed the following points for consideration:
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
1. Whether Employee – Employer relationship is there and the
applicants are entitled for compensation as claimed by the
applicants?
2. To what relief the applicants are entitled to?
3. Who are liable to pay compensation?
(e)
During the course of trial, on behalf of the applicants, A.W-1 was
examined and got marked Exs.A1 to A5. On behalf of the 2 nd opposite party,
the insurance policy was marked as Ex.B1.
(f)
The
Court
appellants/applicants,
below,
having
considered
awarded
a
of
sum
the
claim
of
the
Rs.5,50,315/-
to
the
appellants/applicants. Further, it observed that the deceased workman was
not possessing a valid driving license at the time of accident and that the
appellants/applicants have not submitted any document relating to the driving
license, as such, it fixed the entire liability on the 1st opposite party and thus,
dismissed the case against the 2nd opposite party.
3.
Heard
Sri.
N.
Madhava
Rao,
learned
counsel
for
the
appellants/applicants and Sri. M. Sai Teja, learned counsel for the 2nd
respondent.
4.
During the course of arguments, learned counsel for the appellants has
argued that the Court below ought not to have fixed the entire liability on the
1st respondent to pay the awarded amount to the appellants, on the sole
ground that the appellants have not produced the driving license of the
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
deceased workman. The burden of proof for establishing the driving license of
the deceased workman lies on the 2nd respondent and as the 2nd respondent
has not established that the deceased workman was not holding a driving
license, the 2nd respondent shall be made liable to pay the awarded amount to
the appellants. In support of his case, learned counsel for the appellants relied
upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Rishi Pal Singh
Vs. New India Assurance Co.Ltd.&Ors.,1 and also the judgment of the High
Court of Punjab and Haryana, in New India Assurance Company Limited
Vs. Anita Sharma and another (FAO No.458 of 2014, dated 24.09.2014). He
further contended that when there is a breach of conditions of the policy by
the insured, no fault can be found with the insurance company and therefore,
the principle of ‘pay and recover’ would apply, whereby, the insurance
company first pays the compensation awarded to the claimants but has a right
to recover the amount from the insured when there is no liability falling on the
insurance company. He contended that the same principles ought to have
been applied by the Court below in the instant case. Hence, learned counsel
requested this Court to allow this appeal.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the 2nd respondent contended
that the deceased workman was not at all an employee of the 1st respondent
and that no such employee-employer relationship was established with an
2022 LiveLaw (SC) 646
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
acceptable evidence. He further contended that the appellants failed to
produce valid driving license of the deceased workman and that the deceased
was not holding a driving license at all, as on the date of the accident. The
Court below, has rightly considered the said fact and has fixed the entire
liability of paying compensation on the 1st respondent. He further contended
that, when the employee-employer relationship itself was not established, the
principle of ‘pay and recover’ would not come into play. As the award passed
by the Court below dated 28.12.2016 is on reasonable basis, learned counsel
for the 2nd respondent requested this Court to dismiss this appeal.
6.
Perused the entire material available on record. The Court below,
having considered the rival contentions of the appellants and the 2nd
respondent, held that the deceased workman died on 29.01.2010, while he
was discharging his duties as driver of the vehicle belonging to the 1 st
respondent and has established the employee-employer relationship between
the deceased workman and the 1st respondent.
7.
Due to absence of any material evidence with regard to the salary
drawn by the deceased workman, the Court below, considered the monthly
salary of the deceased workman as Rs.5,177/- as per G.O.Ms.No.90, Labour,
Employment, Training and Factories (Lab-II), department, dated 29.09.2007.
With regard to quantum, the Court below observed that as per Section 4(a)(i)
of the Employees Compensation Act, the compensation payable to the
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
dependents of the deceased workman is equivalent to the multiple of half
monthly wages and the relevant factor. As the deceased workman was aged
28 years as on the date of accident, the Court below took the relevant factor
as 211.79 and concluded that Rs.5,48,218.00/- [Rs.5,177/- X 211.79 X 50/100
= Rs.548218.41/- which is rounded to Rs.5,48,218/-] is the amount liable to be
paid to the appellants. In addition, Rs.1,097/- was awarded towards Court fee
stamps and Rs.1,000/- towards costs of the application, to the appellant. In
total, Rs.5,50,315/- was awarded to the appellants.
8.
With regard to liability, the Court below, held that the appellants have
not filed driving license of the deceased workman and relying upon the
Ex.A4/MVI report, wherein it is stated that the particulars of the driver license
are not available, the Court below came to a conclusion that in the absence of
driving license, liability cannot be fixed on the insurer i.e., the 2 nd respondent.
Hence, the 1st respondent was made liable to pay compensation amount to
the appellants, as he failed to fulfill the conditions of the insurance policy
obtained from the 2nd respondent. Accordingly, the Court below dismissed the
case against the 2nd respondent and directed the 1st respondent to deposit an
amount of Rs.5,50,315/- before it within thirty days.
9.
It is a well settled principle of law that under Employees Compensation
Act, the initial burden of proof lies on the applicants to establish employeeemployer relationship existed at the time of accident and in case of driver, it is
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
to be established that he was possessing a valid driving license. In general,
when a driver is appointed by an employer, the driving license and its validity
would be ascertained at the first instance. In the case on hand, the driving
license of the deceased workman was not produced by the appellants. Even
the report submitted by the Motor Vehicles Inspector, which is marked as
Ex.A4 would show that the particulars of the driving license of the deceased
workman are missing. When employee-employer relationship between the
deceased workman and the 1st respondent itself was doubtful, the decisions
relied upon learned counsel for the appellants would not be of any help. As
per the conditions of the insurance policy, the liability may be fixed on the 2 nd
respondent only if employee-employer relationship is established and a valid
driving license is proved beyond any doubt. In the case on hand, no driving
license of the deceased was produced and the employee employer
relationship between the deceased and the 1st respondent is doubtful, in such
a case, the Courts are bound to fasten the liability against such employer who
permitted the deceased to drive the vehicle and the liability should not be
fastened against the 2nd respondent herein. This Court is of the opinion that
the Court below, has rightly computed the compensation to be awarded to the
appellants and has rightly fastened the liability of paying such compensation
on the 1st respondent.
VS,J
C.M.A.No.479 of 2018
10.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no error in the
impugned order dated 28.12.2019, passed on the file of the Court of the
Commissioner for Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923 – cum – Assistant
Commissioner of Labour, Nellore in E.C.Case No.11 of 2011. Accordingly,
this civil miscellaneous appeal is hereby dismissed. No costs.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications, pending, if any, shall also
stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date:19.01.2026.
Gss
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review