Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010625412018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3566]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY,THE ELEVENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2561/2018
Between:
SHAIK NAGOOR SHAREED @ SHAREEF, OCC - HOME GUARD
R/O. 24TH WARD, MACHERLA, GUNTUR DISTRICT, A.P.
...APELLANT
AND
STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep by Public Prosecutor High
Court at Hyderabad.
...RESPODENT
Counsel for the Appellant:
1.Dr CHALLA SRINIVASA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1.PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT : (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K.Suresh Reddy)
Sole accused in Sessions Case No.19 of 2016 on the file of the
Court of X Additional District and Sessions Judge, Gurazala, is the
appellant. He was tried by the learned Additional Sessions Judge
under two charges.
2.
The 1st charge was under Section 302 IPC and the 2nd charge
was under Section 498-A IPC.
3.
Substance of the charge is that the accused used to harass his
wife Shaik Jani Begam (hereinafter referred to as ‘the deceased’) by
subjecting her to cruelty both physically and mentally suspecting her
fidelity and on 28.03.2015 at about 9.00 P.M. he quarreled with the
deceased for not serving meals and beat her with belt and stick and
unable to the bear the harassment, the deceased poured kerosene on
herself and set fire to herself, causing her death, thereby committed
offences punishable under Sections. 302 and 498-A IPC.
4.
After completion of trial, the learned Additional Sessions Judge
convicted the accused under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to
suffer imprisonment for ‘LIFE’ and also to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/-.
The learned Additional Sessions Judge also convicted the accused
under Section 498-A IPC and sentenced him to suffer Imprisonment for
a period of three (03) years and also to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/-. Both
the substantive sentences were directed to run concurrently. Aggrieved
by the same, the accused/appellant filed the present appeal.
5.
Case of prosecution, as per the allegations made in the charge
sheet, briefly, is as follows:-
(i)
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
The accused and the material prosecution witnesses are
residents of Macherla Town. The deceased was also resident of
Macherla Town. P.Ws.1 and 2 are parents, P.Ws.3 and 4 are brothers,
P.Ws.5 to 9 are relatives and P.Ws.10 and 11 are sons of the
deceased respectively. The marriage between the accused and the
deceased was performed about fifteen years prior to the date of
incident.
The accused used to work as Home guard in the police
department. The couple blessed with two sons i.e., PWs.10 and 11.
The accused and the deceased were residing along with their two sons
in a house situated in the next line of the houses where P.Ws.1 and 2
were residing. It is alleged that the accused used to harass the
deceased both physically and mentally by suspecting her fidelity.
Unable to bear such harassment, the deceased used to go frequently
to her parents’ house. On such occasions, her parents used to console
her and send her back to matrimonial home. P.Ws.1 and 2 and other
elders advised the accused to mend his behaviour. Inspite of the same,
the accused did not change his attitude.
(ii)
While so, on 28.03.2015 at about 9.00 p.m., the accused
returned home and asked the deceased to serve meals. But, the
deceased replied that the meals was not yet ready. Enraged by her
reply, the accused took out his uniform belt and beat her
indiscriminately. He also beat her with a stick. Unable to bear the
harassment, the deceased went inside the house and poured kerosene
on herself and set fire to herself at about 11.00 p.m. On hearing her
cries, the neighbours gathered at the spot and put off the flames. On
receiving information from the neighbours, P.Ws.1 and 2 rushed to the
house of the deceased and noticed burn injuries on her body.
Immediately, they shifted her to the Government Hospital, Macherla,
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
and from there to the Government General Hospital, Guntur, for better
treatment.
(iii)
On the same day at about 11.45 P.M., P.W.14-Head constable,
Macherla
Police
Station
received
hospital
intimation-Ex.P21.
Immediately, P.W.14 proceeded to the hospital and recorded a
statement-Ex.P22 from the injured. He returned to the police station
and registered a case in Crime No.135 of 2015 under Section 498-A
IPC. He issued copies of FIR to all the concerned. Ex.P23 is the FIR.
(iv)
At about 4.15 A.M. on 29.03.2015, P.W.16-the learned Judicial
Magistrate of First Class, Special Mobile Court, Guntur, received
intimation-Ex.P29 from the hospital.
Having received the said
intimation, P.W.16 went to the hospital and recorded Ex.P30-statement
from the injured between 4.30 A.M. and 4.50 A.M.
(v)
On 29.03.2015 at about 8.00 A.M. P.W.14 visited the scene of
offence and prepared an observation report-Ex.P24 in the presence of
P.Ws.5 and 7. He also prepared a rough sketch-Ex.P25 at the scene
of offence. He seized M.Os.1 to 4 at the scene of offence under
Ex.P14-panchanama.
On 29.03.2015 P.W.14 once again visited
Government Hospital, Macherla and recorded another statement from
the injured. Of course, the said statement was not marked. While
undergoing treatment, the injured succumbed to injuries on 10.04.2015.
Having received the death intimation-Ex.P26, P.W.14 altered the
section of law from Section 498-A IPC to Section 306 IPC. Altered
memo is marked as Ex.P27. On 11.04.2015, P.W.14 visited mortuary
of the Government General Hospital, Guntur and held inquest over the
dead body in the presence of PWs.7, 8 and 12.
Inquest report is
marked as Ex.P19. At the time of inquest, he recorded statements of
P.Ws.1 to 4. He sent the dead body for post-mortem examination.
(vi)
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
P.W.13-Assistant Professor, Department of Forensic Medicine,
Guntur Medical College conducted autopsy over the dead body. He
opined the cause of death was due to complications of the burns. He
issued Ex.P20-post-mortem certificate.
(vii)
On 17.04.2015 P.W.14 apprehended the accused who was
remanded the judicial custody. On 18.04.2015, further investigation
was taken over by P.W.15-Sub Inspector of police, Macherla Urban
Police Station. On 19.04.2015, P.W.15 recorded statements of P.Ws.9
to 11 and 14. On 01.05.2015 he received dying declaration-Ex.P30
recorded by P.W.16. Having received the said dying declaration, he
altered the Section of law from Section 306 to Section 302 IPC.
Altered memo is marked as Ex.P28.
(viii) On 02.05.2015 P.W.17-Inspector of police, Macherla Town
Police Station took up investigation. He visited the scene of offence
and recorded statements of P.Ws.1 to 7. He also recorded statements
of P.Ws.9 to 11. After receiving all the documents and after completion
of investigation, P.W.17 filed charge sheet.
6.
In support of its case, prosecution examined P.Ws.1 to 17,
marked Exs.P1 to P30 and exhibited M.Os.1 to 4.
7.
When the accused was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., he
denied the incriminating evidence appearing against him.
8.
Accepting the two dying declarations-Exs.P22 and P30, the
learned Additional Sessions Judge convicted the accused as aforesaid.
9.
Heard Sri Challa Srinivasa Reddy, learned counsel for the
appellant and Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor for the respondent-State.
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
10.
We have carefully perused the entire evidence on record.
11.
P.Ws.1 and 2 are none other than the father and mother of the
deceased respectively. P.Ws.3 and 4 are the brothers of the deceased.
P.Ws.10 and 11 are sons of the deceased, P.Ws.5 to 9 are the
relatives of the deceased. All these material witnesses i.e., P.Ws.1 to
11 did not support the prosecution and they were declared as hostile.
As such, absolutely there is no evidence on record except the two
dying declarations-Exs.P22 and P30.
12.
As seen from the above material, all the material witnesses i.e.,
P.Ws.1 to 11 did not support the prosecution and they were declared
as hostile. Now the only material available on record is the two dying
declarations-Exs.P22 and P30 recorded by P.W.14 and P.W.16.
13.
We have carefully scrutinized both the dying declarations. In the
first dying declaration recorded by P.W.14, the deceased stated that
the accused used to harass her both physically and mentally by
suspecting her fidelity. She further stated that on 28.03.2015 at about
9.00 P.M., the accused picked up a quarrel with her alleging that she
was having illicit intimacy with others and thereafter beat her with a belt
and also with a stick. Unable to bear the harassment and torture, she
poured kerosene on herself and set fire to herself. She further stated
that the accused was the main cause for her attempting to commit
suicide. According to her, on hearing her cries, the neighbours came
there and shifted her to the Government Hospital, Macherla. The said
dying declaration was recorded by P.W.14 at about 11.50 P.M.
14.
In the early hours of 29.03.2015 at about 4.15 A.M., P.W.16-the
learned Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Special Mobile Court, Guntur,
recorded another dying declaration from the deceased, which is
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
marked as Ex.P30. The said dying declaration was recorded between
4.15 A.M. and 4.30 A.M. In the said statement, the deceased stated
that the accused used to beat her every day after coming home in an
inebriated condition and also used to suspect her fidelity. She further
stated that her in-laws owned a residential house and that she had
asked the accused to sell the said house and deposit the sale
proceeds in a fixed deposit in the names of their children, which led to
disputes between them. While so, at about 9.00 P.M., the accused
allegedly poured kerosene on her, set her on fire and left the house.
Thereafter, the in-laws of the deceased, along with her brother and
cousin, shifted her to the hospital.
15.
This version is reflected in the second dying declaration-Ex.P30
recorded by the Judicial Officer-P.W.16. However, in the first dying
declaration-Ex.P22, the deceased did not whisper anything about the
proposal to sell the house property and deposit the sale proceeds in
the names of the children. There is absolutely no reference to the said
aspect in Ex.P22. In Ex.P22, the deceased stated that the accused,
suspecting her fidelity, beat her with a belt and a stick and that, unable
to bear the torture, she poured kerosene on herself and set herself on
fire. However, in the second dying declaration-Ex.P30, the deceased
stated that it was the accused who poured kerosene on her, set her on
fire and left the house.
16.
Having examined both the dying declarations, i.e., Exs.P22 and
P30, we have no hesitation in holding that they are inconsistent with
each other. In the first dying declaration-Ex.P22, the version of the
deceased indicates that it was a case of suicide, as she stated that,
unable to bear the harassment meted out by the accused, she poured
kerosene on herself and set herself on fire. However, in the second
dying declaration-Ex.P30, the deceased stated that it was the accused
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
who poured kerosene on her and set her ablaze, thereby suggesting a
case of homicide.
17.
Further, in the first dying declaration, the deceased stated that on
an earlier occasion she had intended to commit suicide, but refrained
from doing so, for the sake of her children. As already pointed out,
except Exs.P22 and P30, there is no other material on record
corroborating either of the dying declarations. As already noticed, all
the material prosecution witnesses, namely P.Ws.1 to 11, did not
support the prosecution and were declared as hostile.
18.
In such circumstances, we are unable to place reliance on either
of the dying declarations, i.e., Exs.P22 and P30, as both are
inconsistent with each other and are mutually destructive in nature.
Further, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, at paragraph 41 of the
judgment, recorded a finding that the deceased committed suicide. For
better appreciation, paragraph 41 of the judgment is extracted
hereunder:
“41. From a conjoint reading of both the dying declarations,
both mental and physical harassment of accused to
deceased is in corroboration, it cannot be denied that by
mere considering the probability of tutoring and merely
because deceased stated in her dying declaration that
accused poured kerosene on herself is an improvement
and has to be discarded entirely. Accused by his conduct
subjected deceased to cruelty so as to drive her to commit
suicide.”
19.
The learned Additional Sessions Judge, having recorded a
finding that it was on account of the conduct of the accused in
subjecting the deceased to cruelty she was driven to commit suicide,
ought not to have convicted the accused for the offence under Section
302 IPC.
20.
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
So far as the offence under Section 498-A IPC is concerned, the
deceased has consistently stated in both the dying declarations that
the accused used to subject her to cruelty both physically and mentally.
She also stated that the accused beat her with a uniform belt and a
stick by suspecting her fidelity. Both the dying declarations-Exs.P22
and P30, are consistent with regard to the harassment meted out by
the accused to the deceased. In the first dying declaration, the
deceased has also stated that on an earlier occasion she intended to
commit suicide, but refrained from doing so for the sake of her children.
21.
In such circumstances, the ingredients of the offence under
Section 498-A IPC stand established from both the dying declarations.
Therefore, the conviction and sentence recorded by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge for the offence under Section 498-A IPC
requires no interference. However, the conviction and sentence
recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge for the offence
under Section 302 IPC are liable to be set aside.
22.
In view of the above facts and circumstances of the case, we are
inclined to allow the present appeal in part by setting aside the
conviction and sentence recorded against the appellant for the offence
under Section 302 IPC. However, the conviction and sentence
recorded against the appellant for the offence under Section 498-A IPC
is confirmed.
23.
aside
In the result, the Criminal Appeal is allowed in part by setting
the
conviction
and
sentence
recorded
against
the
appellant/accused in the judgment, dated 20.06.2018, passed in
Sessions Case No.19 of 2016 by the learned X Additional Sessions
Judge, Gurazala, for the offence under Section 302 IPC, and the
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
appellant/accused is acquitted of the said charge. The fine amount, if
any, paid by the appellant/accused for the offence under Section 302
IPC shall be refunded to him. However, the conviction and sentence
recorded against the appellant/accused for the offence under Section
498-A IPC is hereby confirmed. As the appellant has already served
the entire sentence of imprisonment awarded for the said offence and
was released on bail by order, dated 01.05.2024, in terms of the order
dated 02.11.2016 passed by the Combined High Court in Batchu
Rangarao
and
others
vs.
The
State
of
Andhra
Pradesh
(Crl.A.M.P.No.1687 of 2016 in Crl.A.No.607 of 2011), he shall
surrender before the concerned Magistrate for the purpose of
completing the formalities.
24.
Before parting with the case, we deem it appropriate to observe
that proper attention was not paid by the learned X Additional Sessions
Judge, Gurazala, who framed the charges and also conducted the trial.
This matter was not properly considered either at the stage of framing
of charges or at the time of disposal of the case. A reading of
paragraphs 41 and 42 of the trial Court judgment would clearly indicate
that the learned Additional Sessions Judge, having recorded a finding
that it was a case of suicide, erroneously proceeded to convict the
accused for the offence of homicide, which reflects non-application of
mind and lack of due care on the part of the learned Additional
Sessions Judge. For better appreciation, paragraphs 41 and 42 of the
judgment are extracted hereunder:
“41. From a conjoint reading of both the dying declarations,
both mental and physical harassment of accused to
deceased is in corroboration, it cannot be denied that by
mere considering the probability of tutoring and merely
because deceased stated in her dying declaration that
accused poured kerosene on herself is an improvement
and has to be discarded entirely. Accused by his conduct
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
subjected deceased to cruelty so as to drive her to commit
suicide.
42. In view of the above discussion prosecution has
established guilt of accused beyond all reasonable doubt,
evidence on record leads to conclusion of guilt of accused.
Hence, it is worthy and fit case to convict accused for the
charge under sections 498-A and 302 Indian Penal Code,
1860.”
25.
Further, though fine was imposed, the learned Additional
Sessions Judge failed to incorporate a default clause in the event of
non-payment of the fine amount. Such lapses on the part of an officer
in the cadre of a District Judge are not expected. Therefore, we deem
it appropriate that the said aspect may be considered on Administrative
Side. Accordingly, a copy of this judgment is marked to the Registrar
(Vigilance) for taking appropriate action in accordance with rules.
Consequently, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall
stand closed.
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
__________________________________
JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
Dt.11.03.2026
SAB
Crl.A.No.2561 of 2018
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
Criminal Appeal No.2561 of 2018
(Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K.Suresh Reddy)
Date: 11.03.2026
SAB
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review