Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
APHC010647102022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
TUESDAY,THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NOs: 24 & 32/2023
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 24/2023
Between:
1. SHAIK HASEEN, W/O. KALESHA@ KALESHAVALI, AGED 27 YEARS,
R/O. VELURU VILLAGE AND POST, PODILI MANDAL, PARKAS
DISTRICT.
2. SHAIK MAHABOOB SUBHANI,, S/O. KALESHA@ KALESHAVALI,
AGED 9 YEARS,R/O. VELURU VILLAGE AND POST, PODILI
MANDAL, PARKAS DISTRICT.
3. SHAIK SHAFI,, S/O. KALESHA@ KALESHAVALI, AGED 07 YEARS
R/O. VELURU VILLAGE AND POST, PODILI MANDAL, PARKAS
DISTRICT.
4. SHAIK PEDDA MASTAN,, S/O. PAKIR SAHEB (DIED) AGED 50
YEARS,
5. SHAIK MASTAN BEE,, W/O. PEDDA MASTAN, AGED 50 YEARS,
R/O. VELURU VILLAGE AND POST, PODILI MANDAL, PARAKASAM
DISTRICT. ( PETITIONER NO.4 DIED ON 21-01-2019. HIS LRS ARE
ALREADY ON RECORD)
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
1. A P STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION, REPRESENTED
BY ITS VICE CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR, OWNER OF
THE BUS BEARING NO. AP 26 Z 0172, BUS BHAVAN,
MUSHEERABAD, HYDERABAD.
2. A P STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION, REPRESENTED
BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER, REGIONAL OFFICE, RTC BUS
STAND COMPLEX, ONGOLE,PARKAS DISTRICT.
3. SHAIK SULTHAN, S/O MASTAN, AGED37 YEARS, MUSLIM, APSRTC
DRIVER, SUJATHANAGAR COLONY OPPSITE TO ELEMENTARY
SCHOOL, VINJAMUR VILLAGE AND POST VINJAMUR MANDAL,
SPSR NELLORE DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtaggrieved by
the order and decree passed in M.V.O.P No.377 of 2016 dated17- 08-2022 ,
on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal - cum -1 Addl. District and
Sessions Judge, Ongole Parkas District
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. NUTHALAPATI KRISHNA MURTHY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. ARAVALA RAMA RAO(SC FOR APSRTC KKAC)
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 32/2023
Between:
1. A.P.S.R.T.C., REPRESENTED BY VICE CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING
DIRECTOR, BUS BHAVAN, MUSHEERABAD, HYDERABAD,
PRESENTLY AT PNBS, VIJAYAWADA.
2. APSRTC,, REP. BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER, REGIONAL OFFICE,
RTC BUS STAND COMPLEX, ONGOLE, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
1. SHAIK HASEENA, W/O KALESHA @ KALESHAVALI, AGED 33
YEARS, R/O VELURU VILLAGE, PODILI MANDAL, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT.
2. SHAIK MAHABOOB SUBHANI, S/O KALESHA @ KALESHAVALI,
AGED 15 YEARS, R/O VELURU VILLAGE, PODILI MANDAL,
PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
3. SHAIK SHAFI, S/O KALESHA @ KALESHAVALI, AGED 13 YEARS,
R/O VELURU VILLAGE, PODILI MANDAL, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
4. SHAIK PEDA MASTHAN, S/O PAKIR SAHEB ( DIED).
5. SHAIK MASTAN BEE, W/O LATE PEDA MASTHAN, AGED 56
YEARS, R/O VELURU VILLAGE, PODILI MANDAL, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT. (RESPONDENTS 2 AND 3 BEING MINORS REP. BY
THEIR MOTHER CUM NATURAL GUARDIAN 1ST RESPONDENT)
6. SHAIK SULTHAN, S/O MASTHAN, AGED 43 YEARS, APSRTC
DRIVER, R/O SUJATHA NAGAR COLONY, OPP ELEMENTARY
SCHOOL, VINJAMUR VILLAGE, VINJAMUR MANDAL, SPSR
NELLORE DISTRICT. (RESPONDENT NO 6 IS NOT A NECESSARY
PARTY)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtbegs to prefer
this memorandum of of being aggrieved by the decree and judgment passed
in M.V.O.P No. 3)7 of 2 dated 17.08.2022, on the file of Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal -am- I District Judge, Ongole
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 64 days in filing the above MACMA in MVOP
No. 377 of 2016, dt. 17-08-2022 on the file of Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal
cum I Addl. District Judge, Ongole
IA NO: 2 OF 2023
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to grant stay of operation of Decree and Order dt. 17-08-2022 passed
in MVOP No. 377 of 2016 on the file of Motor Vehicles Accidents Claims
Tribunal cum I Addl. District Judge, Ongole
IA NO: 3 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
Pleased to vacate the interim order dated 03-02-2023 passed in IA No. 2 of
2023 in MACMA 32 of 2023 on the file of this Hon'ble Court and pass
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. ARAVALA RAMA RAO(SC FOR APSRTC KKAC)
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. NUTHALAPATI KRISHNA MURTHY
The Court made the following:
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
COMMON JUDGMENT:Both the appeals are filed against the same judgment dated
17.08.2022 passed by the Motor Vehicle Accidents Claims Tribunal –
cum – I Additional District Judge, Ongole in M.V.O.P.No.377 of 2016.
Hence, I feel it appropriate to decide these appeals by way of a common
Judgment.
2.
M.A.C.M.A.No.24 of 2023 is filed by the claimants seeking
enhancement of the compensation of Rs.5,19,450/- which is awarded by
way of the impugned judgment and M.A.C.M.A.No.32 of 2023 is filed by
APSRTC challenging the quantum of compensation.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal. The claimant No.1 is the wife, claimant
Nos.2 and 3 are sons and claimant Nos.4 and 5 are parents of one Shaik
Kalesha
@
Kaleshavali
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
‘deceased’).
Respondent Nos.1 and 2 are officials of APSRTC and the 3rd respondent
is the driver of the bus bearing No.AP-26-Z-0172. The deceased was a
welding worker and on 02.02.2016, at about 08.10 p.m., while he was
returning from Darsi on a motorcycle after purchase of few articles along
with one Gone Srinivasa Rao (pillion), at a petrol bunk near Rajampalli
village situated opposite to Brick Lin, the bus bearing No.AP-26-Z-0172
(hereinafter referred to as ‘bus’) coming in opposite direction in a rash
and negligent way on the wrong side of the road, dashed the motorcycle
of the deceased, as a result of which, the deceased sustained injuries
and died on the spot. Seeking compensation of Rs.10,00,000/- for the
death of the deceased, the claimants have filed a petition before the
Tribunal under Sections 166(1)(c) and 168 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988
read with Rule 455 of Andhra Pradesh Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989.
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
4.
The 1st respondent contested the petition by filing a written
statement wherein it was contended that the accident took place due to
the rash and negligent driving of the deceased and that the same is also
reflected in the FIR filed by the Police against the deceased. Hence, the
respondent corporation is not liable to pay any compensation to the
claimants and requested to dismiss the petition.
5.
Basing on the above pleadings, the Tribunal framed the
following issues for trial:
1)
Whether the deceased Shaik Kalesha @ Kaleshavali died in a road
accident which took place on 02.02.2016 at about 08.10 pm., at Bricks Kiln
near Rajampalli village on Darsi-Podili road due to rash and negligent
driving of APSRTC Bus bearing No. AP 26 Z 0172 by its driver?
2)
Whether the petition is bad for non joinder of necessary parties?
3)
Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation? If so, to what
amount and against whom?
4)
To what relief, the petitioners are entitled?
6.
During the course of trial, the 1st claimant got herself examined
as P.W.1 and two others were examined as P.Ws.2 and 3. Exs.A1 to A7
were marked on behalf of the claimants whereas no documentary
evidence was marked on behalf of the respondents, however, R.W.1 was
examined.
7.
The Tribunal, after considering all the facts and material
available before it, came to a conclusion that the accident occurred due to
the rash and negligent driving of the deceased as well as the driver of the
bus and hence, the Tribunal fastened 50% responsibility against the 3rd
respondent and 50% against the deceased. Further, the Tribunal
computed the amount of compensation as Rs.10,38,900/- and after
deducting 50% of the same towards contributory negligence on the part of
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
the deceased, it directed the respondents to pay Rs.5,19,450/- to the
claimants vide its judgment dated 17.08.2022. Aggrieved by the said
compensation, the claimants have approached this Court on the ground
that the Tribunal erred in fixing 50% responsibility on the part of the
deceased and that the Tribunal had not considered notional monthly
income of the deceased as per minimum wages act. The APSRTC
approached this Court on the ground that the Tribunal erred in taking the
monthly income of the deceased as Rs.4,500/- in the absence of any
cogent evidence; that the deceased while riding the motorcycle hit a
stone resulting in loss of balance and dash to the bus, thus holding
APSRTC liable for paying compensation to an extent of 50% is
completely contrary to law; that no criminal case was filed against the
driver of the bus and as such the APSRTC is not liable to pay any
compensation to the claimants.
8.
Heard Sri. Nuthalapati Krishna Murthy, learned counsel for the
claimants and Sri. Aravala Rama Rao, learned Standing Counsel for
APSRTC.
9.
Perused the entire material available on record. It is the case of
the 1st claimant that the deceased went to Darsi to purchase welding
articles and on his return along with Gone Srinivasarao (P.W.2) on a
motorcycle being driven by the deceased, near petrol bunk situated at
Rajampalli village, at about 08.10 p.m., the bus belonging to the
respondents was coming in an opposite direction on wrong side of the
road and dashed the motorcycle of the deceased resulting in the
spontaneous death of the deceased. In support of her case she got
marked on FIR as Ex.A1, inquest report (Ex.A2), postmortem certificate
(Ex.A3), rough sketch of the scene of offence (Ex.A4), scene observation
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
report (Ex.A5), proceedings of Sub-divisional police officer, Darsi (Ex.A6).
However, it is very clear that P.W.1 is a hearsay witness and is not an
eye witness. P.W.2, the pillion rider of the motorcycle, who is an eyewitness to the accident had stated that on the fateful day, while they were
returning from Darsi, after crossing Kothareddipalem, near petrol bunk
situated at Rajampalli village, the bus driven by the 3rd respondent in a
rash and negligent manner came in opposite direction on the wrong side
of the road dashed the motorcycle and as a result of the same, the
deceased sustained multiple injuries and died on the spot. He
categorically stated that the accident occurred due to the rash and
negligent driving of the 3rd respondent.
10.
R.W.1 – Superintendent and Legal Officer, Regional Manager
Officer (Ongole), APSRTC, in his chief affidavit has stated that on the
date of accident due to dazzling of the head lights of the bus, the
deceased hit a big stone kept on the left side of the road and dashed
against the right side corner of the bus resulting in fatal injuries and he
succumbed to injuries. It was further stated that the accident occurred
due to the negligence of the deceased and that FIR was filed by the
Police against the deceased.
11.
It is evident from the impugned judgment that the Tribunal had
observed that the deceased lost control of his motorcycle as he hit a
stone placed on the side of the road, which in fact is due to dazzling of
the head lights of the bus; it observed that in general, when vehicles
travel head to head during night, dim light should be given by the drivers
of the vehicles including bus, lorries etc, which cautions the other vehicle.
It is clear that the mistake is crept on the part of the bus driver for not
dimming the lights as it might enable the deceased or any oncoming
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
person to pass by safely. The Tribunal, though has pointed out the
mistake committed by the driver of the bus, fixed 50% responsibility on
the part of the deceased for occurrence of the accident, which in the
considered opinion of this Court is untenable. P.W.2, who was the pillion
as on the date of accident had categorically stated that driver of the bus
drove the same in rash and negligent manner. He had deposed that the
deceased lost control of his motorcycle after hitting a stone lying on the
left side of the road resulting in a dash to the side corner of the bus.
Merely because P.W.2 had not stated about hitting the stone in his chief
affidavit, the Tribunal disbelieved his evidence and observed that P.W.2
stated thus in order to help the claimants get compensation. Ultimately,
the Tribunal erroneously fixed 50% responsibility against the 3rd
respondent and 50% against the deceased.
12.
While awarding quantum of compensation, relying on Ex.A2 –
inquest report and Ex.A3 – postmortem certificate, the Tribunal
considered the age of the deceased as ‘29’; though the claimants
contended that the deceased used to earn Rs.15,000/- per month, no
documentary evidence was put forward by the claimants due to which,
the Tribunal relying upon a judgment of the Apex Court, took the notional
monthly income of the deceased as Rs.4,500/- which computes to an
annual income of Rs.54,000/-. Furthermore, 40% over the annual income
was added towards future prospects as per National Insurance
Company Vs. Pranay Sethi 1 , which computes to Rs.75,600/[Rs.54,000/- + Rs.21,600/- (40% of Rs.54,000/-)]. As per Sarla Verma
and Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and another2, the proper
multiplier applicable to the deceased is ‘17’. The amount of compensation
(2017) 16 SCC 680
AIR 2009 SCC3104
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
under the head of loss of dependency was computed by the Tribunal as
Rs.12,85,200/- [Rs.75,600/- X 17] and as the 4th claimant died pending
the claim petition, considering claimant Nos.1 to 3 and 5 as dependents,
the Tribunal reduced 1/4th of such amount towards personal expenses
and the amount thus computed is Rs.9,63,900/- [Rs.12,85,200/- - 1/4th].
13.
In addition, Rs.15,000/- for funeral expenses, Rs.40,000/-
towards loss of consortium and Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate and
Rs.5,000/- towards transport charges, which are just and reasonable in
the opinion of this Court. In total, the Tribunal assessed the compensation
payable to the claimants as Rs.10,38,900/- and directed the respondents
to pay Rs.5,19,450/- to the claimants as it held 50% responsibility on the
part of the deceased, which is untenable as discussed hereinabove.
14.
In view of the above discussion, the claimants are entitled to be
paid the entire amount of Rs.10,38,900/- as compensation. It can also be
seen that the Tribunal had awarded only Rs.40,000/- as consortium to the
claimant No.1 but had not awarded any amount to claimant Nos.2, 3 and
5 under the said head. Thus, in addition Rs.1,20,000/- (Rs.40,000/- each
to claimant Nos.2, 3 and 5) is hereby awarded under the head of
consortium. In total the claimants are liable to be paid Rs.11,58,900/[Rs.10,38,900/- + Rs.1,20,000/-] by respondent Nos.1 to 3.
15.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the compensation awarded
by the Tribunal under different heads and amounts would now become as
under:
S.
No
Head of the claim
Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal in Rs.
Amounts now
altered by this
Court
1.
Loss of dependency
Rs.9,63,900/-
Rs.9,63,900/-
VS,J
MACMA_24 & 32 of 2023
2.
Funeral Charges
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
3.
Loss of estate
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
4.
Loss of Consortium
Rs.40,000/-
Rs.1,60,000/-
5.
Transport charges
Rs.5,000/-
Rs.5,000/-
6.
Amount deducted
towards contributory
negligence
Rs.5,19,450/-
-
Total
16.
[Rs.10,38,900/- /
2]
Rs.5,19,450/-
Rs.11,58,900/-
In the result, M.A.C.M.A.No.32 of 2023 filed by APSRTC is
dismissed and M.A.C.M.A.No.24 of 2023 is allowed by enhancing the
compensation from Rs.5,19,450/- to Rs.11,58,900/-. The respondent
Nos.1 to 3 in the claim petition shall pay Rs.11,58,900/- to the claimants
with interest @7.5% per annum. The enhanced amount shall be
apportioned amongst the claimants as was apportioned before the
Tribunal. No costs.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date:17.03.2026.
Gss
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review