Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/shaik-ghouse-vs-the-state-of-a-p-20260402/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Civil

Shaik Ghouse vs The State of A.p.

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Telangana High Court
Date
2 April 2026
Case No.
CRLA 683/2012
Result
Partly allowed
Bench
Tirumala Devi Eada
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

Filed under

Indian Penal Code, 1860

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

t34441 BAIL SLIP: The AppellanU Accused was directed to be released on bail by the order of the High Court dated 18-07-2012 in Crl.A.M.P.No.1473 of 2012 in Crl A.No 683 of 2012. IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THURSDAY, THE SECOND DAY OF APRIL TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 683 OF 2012 Appeal under Section 374(2) of the Cr P.C aggrieved by the Judgment dated 13-07 -2012 passed in S.C.No.367 of 201 '1 on the file of the Court of the I Additional Sessions Judge, Adilabad. Between: Shaik Ghouse, S/o Khaia, Aged 24 years, Occ: Kasab (Beef Seller), R/o Kolipura, Adilabad District. ...AppellanUAccused AND The State of A.P, through the Sub Divisional Police Offrcer, Adilabad, Adilabad District, Represented by its Public Prosecutor, High Court of Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad. ...RespondenUComplainant Counsel for the Appellant: Ms. S. Navya, counsel representing Sri S. Surender Reddy Counsel for the Respondent: Sri D. Arun Kumar, Additional Public Prosecutor The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT Crl.a.No.683 2012 lN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF'l' :LANGANA AT HYDERABAD THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE TIRUMALA t):VI EADA CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.583 OF 2012 Date: 02.04.2025 Between: Shaik Ghouse 46,1 ,s;;2n1 and The State of A P., through Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Adilabad, Adilabad District, rep. by Public Prosecutor, High Court of A P., Hyderabad. Res pondent :JUDGMENT: This criminal appeal is filed by the appe lant-Accused aggrieved by the judgment dated 13.01'.2A1: passed tn Sessions Case No.367 of 2011 by the learne: I Additional Sessions Judge, Adilabad (for short'the trial Courl ) 2. Vide the aforesaid judgment, the trial Cct rt found the appellant guilty of the charge under Section l)04-B of the lndian Penal Code (for short 'lPC') and accordingly, he ',r as convicted and sentenced him to undergo rigorous inrpris: rment for a c.l.,q-No,6E3-2012 period of 10 years and to pay a fine of Rs.2000/-, in defaultto undergo simple imprisonment for a period of three months 3. The case of the prosecution is that, on 25 12.2008, the marriage of accused was performed with the deceased, and that at the time of marriage, her parents presented an amount of Rs.40,000/- net cash, one tula of gold, and other household articles. After marriage, the accused and the deceased lived separately in a rented house at Kolipura locality of Adilabad They were blessed with one son, and the accused began to torture the deceased for want of an additional dowry of Rs.15,000/-. However, her parents expressed their inability, and the harassment continued. On 13.09.2010, the accused picked up a quarrel with the deceased over a petty issue and beat her, upon which the deceased, getting vexed with her life, committed suicide by hanging. Thus, the accused is facing charge under Section 304-8 of the IPC 4. After following due procedure, the case was committed to the Sessions Court, and the I Additional Sessions Judge, Adilabad heard the accused on the charge and conducted the trial arl,A.No.683 2012 5. During the trial, pWs. 1 to 12 were examin: J and Exs.p1 lo P14 and MOs 1 and 2 were marked on rehalf of the prosecution, whereas none were examine<i on :ehalf of the accused and no documents were marked. 6. Based on the evidence on record, thr: triel Court found the appellant - accused guirty of the charge r,der 304-8 of IPC and accordingly convicted and undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period sen.r nced him to of 1O ,ears and to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/-, in default, to unrl, rrgo simple imprisonment for three months. Aggrleved judgment of conviction and sentence, Section i y the said the Srresert appeal is preferred. 7. Heard the submissions of Ms.S.Navya, learrEd counsel representing Sri S.surender Reddy, rearned cour ser for the appellant and Sri D.Arun Kumar, learned t\ddit r nal public Prosecutor for the respondent_State. The learned counsel for the appellant has su: nitted that the prosecution could not prove the offence yainst ir the accused beyond reasonable doubt, and that all arer interested Crl.A,No 583-2012 is wltnesses who spoke with regard to the harassment' There no independent witness examined in this case to prove the offence against the accused, and that the accused never harassed the deceased for want of additional dowry' The parents of the deceased do not have such status to give any dowry, and the allegation of giving dowry itself is false There is no proof of harassment for want of dowry soon before her death, in the absence of which the ingredients under Section 304-8 of IPC are not made out Once the ingredients under 304-8 IPC are not made out, no presumption can be drawn underSection'113-BoftheEvidenceAct,andtheprosecution has utterly failed to prove the guilt of the accused under 304-8 of lPC. The presumption drawn by the trial Court cannot be sustained, as the foundational facts are not established by the prosecution. She, therefore, prayed to acquit the accused and set aside the judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the trial court. 9. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor has submitted that the evidence of PWs ,l to 3 and PW5 clinchingly proves the offence against the accused. PW5 is the house owner' who is crr.A.No 68:t 2012 a third party and is no way related to the dec. tsed, and his evidence itself shows that there was haras;nent by the accused for want of additional dowry. The tr.ial c,: trt has rightly appreciated the evidence on record and has r onvrcted the accused; hence, he prayed to confirm the same. 10 Considering the above submissions, 1:he gr.rints that fall for consideration in this appeal are: 1) Whether the charge under 304_8 >r lpC was proved by the prosecution beryonri reasonable doubt? 2) Whether the conviction an{J r;cntence of imprisonment recorded by the trial (l :urt against the appellant herein - accused ar€, sus:r inaOte] Ootn on facts and in law? 3) To what relief? 11 POTNT NO.1 a) PW1/Sulthana is the mother of the deceasec. lt is elicited from her that she performed the marriage of her d: r-rghter the accused in the year 200g by giving Rs.40,00Cr with as dowry, and presented one tura of gord, sirver, and other rrousehord articles. After the marriage, they lived happily for sc rne time at Kulipura locality of Adilabad. Out of the wecllock they were Cd-A.1,1o.683-20I2 blessed with a son, after which the accused started harassing the deceased, and he also kicked her out of the house with a demand for additional dowry of Rs.15,000/-. Since then, the deceased was forced to stay with them and she could not satisfy the demand of additional dowry by the accused. Later on, she convinced her daughter and sent her to the house of the accused. After 15 to 20 days, one Zameel made a phone call from Adilabad, informing that the deceased had committed suicide by hanging herself in the house of the accused. lt is further elicited that since they failed to satisfy the demand of the accused for additional dowry, he subjected the deceased to cruelty, and that is the reason she committed suicide. She gave the complaint under Ex.P1 b) She admitted that after the death of the deceased, their caste elders returned all the belongings of her daughter to her, from the accused. She stated that she does not know whether any money was paid by the accused on that day in the presence of the elders, and whether her husband received any amount from the accused. She denied the suggestion that the deceased suffered from stomach pain and, due to unbearable CrlA.No.683_2012 pain, committed suicide. She admitted that the rarents of the accused were not living with them at Kulipura c) PW2iTaslim is the sister of PW'l . Sl-re cc,r -oborated the evidence of PW1. She admitted that the lisl of pr:sentations is prepared at the time of marriage in their c:omnt tnity, but she does not know about the said list of presentatiorr; made in the marriage of the deceased with the accused. d) PW3/Jameel Ahmed is a relative of PW1 His evidence also corroborates the evidence of PW1 . lt is eli :ted from him that the deceased was sent to her parental horr: for want of additional dowry of Rs.15,000/- after the birlh of t re male child and before the Ramzan festival in the y,-.ar 2)10, i.e.. on 13.09.2010, she was sent back to the house of the accused after being convinced and after her parents ex rressed their inability to pay the additional dowry. On the :hird day of Ramzan, he heard the news of the decease,r committing suicide by hanging herself e) PW4/MA Hafeez is the sister-in-law of F,t/1 and her evidence corroborates the evidence of pW1 Cd.A.tlo.583 2012 PWS/Shami Khan is the house owner, where the accused used to live along with the deceased. His evidence reveals that the accused lived as a tenant along with his wife Once he noticed that there was a quarrel between both of them, and he warned them to vacate if they repeated such an incident. lt is elicited from him that the deceased died by committing suicide in the same house, in the portion of the accused. On the said day, he was not in Adilabad, and on learning about the incident, he returned and found the dead body of the deceased. Thus, the evidence of the house owner aids the case of prosecution to the extent that there were quarrels between the accused and the deceased, and that the deceased committed suicide in the house of the accused S) PW6/Md.Khaleel is the photographer. ln his evidence, Exs.P2 to P9 (the photographs) are marked h) PW7/Muneer Khan is the cable operator and a witness for the scene of offence Panchanama under Ex.P10, and MO'l/nylon rope and MO2/red-colour chunni were recovered from the scene of offence. Cd.A.No-681,2012 i) PW8/Sunil Kumar Masade, the TahsilCar c cnducted the inquest over the dead body of the deceased in ttr r presence of PW7, as recorded under Ex Pl 1. j) PW9/Dr B Shekar Rao is the doctor. He ,: rnducted the autopsy over the dead body of the deceased er d issued the PME under ExP12. His evidence reveal; tha there were antemortem ligature marks measuring 25 cnrs in ength, with a width of 1 to 1.5 cms, present over the front anc sides of the neck, running obliquely just above the thyroi,l cart lage with the knot just below the right mastoid process. lt is alr; > elicited that the thyroid cartilage and hyoid were intact. k) PW1O/Ch Natesh, PW11/AR Dlramo lhar, and PW12lL.Satish Kumar are the investigating < fficers, who deposed with regard to the mode of investigaton done by them PW10 issued the FIR under Ex.P13. Ex.P'4, the rough sketch, is marked in the evidence of PW11. l) Thus, the evidence of PWs 1 to ti sh:ars that the deceased was subjected to harassment by the accused for want of additional dowry and that she conrmittr; I suicide by C.l,A.No.6al 2012 t! hanging herself in the house of the accused. There is no explanation offered by the accused for the death of the deceased in his house, and the accused was the only person present in the house at the time of the alleged incident. When he cannot offer any explanation for the death of the deceased, and there is ample evidence to show that there was harassment by the accused for want of additional dowry, the only conclusion that can arise is that the deceased committed suicide due to unbearable harassment for want of additional dowry m) Section 304-8 of IPC is extracted hereunder for the sake of reference "3048. Dowry death.-(1)Where the death of a woman is caused by any burns or bodily injury or occurs otherwise than under normal circumstances within seven years of her mar age and rt is shown that soon before her death she was subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or any relative of her husband for, or in connection with, any demand for dowry, such death shall be called "dowry death", and such husband or relative shall be deemed to have caused her death. Explanation.-For the purposes of this sub-section, "dowry" shall have the same meaning as in section 2 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961 (28 of 1961 ). (2) Whoever commits dowry death shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than seven years but which may extend to imprisonment for life." Crl.A.No,683_2012 1t n) ln catena of cases viz., Kashmir Kaur v. State Punjabl and yogendra patsingh v. Raghvendri Prince and anothef, tne Apex Court essential rngredients to prove the Singh alias lras r:ld that the offence under r: -.ction 304_8 of IPC are as follows The main ingredient of the offence to be eslabtjs r ,ct is that :11 before , soon the death or tne oefeisel I )cted to cruelty and harassment in connection 'itn, tt'e o"mani"oi ,o*ry. b) The death of the deceased woman was caus€c cy any *0,,, inlury or some other circrrstanc-e"rltoi, ,". not ;# ;Xl; ::*":: c) Such death occurs within seven years marriage. d) from the d,t _. of her That the vrctim was subjected to cruelty or haras.; r_.nt by ot her husband her husband or any relative e) Such cruelty or harassment should be for or.in ccr rection with demand of dowry be established. that such cruelty ard .f] made l should harr isment was soon before her death g) The expression (soon before) would depend upon circumstances is a relativer tern and it of each case I cl no straightjacket formula can be laid down l-.' ,o"=ir.nri, ,or,o constitute a period of soon before the o."rii".I"l h) lt would be hazardous to indicate any fixed p()riod bflr,gs in the importance of a oroxtmity " r o that test both for the pro ) of an gffelce 9l !9wV death as wett as for raising a presu.nptio,r _rnder Section 1 138 of the Evidence Act. i) Therefore. the exoression ..soon before,, would .r ) llally not be much between the con: rrned .-, harassment and the death in qr"rion. inJl.l",.i ,t o" ::l]^".lyexrstence of a proxrmate or tife tink b.tu;;;l;; #.I","o,,. ,"rty br.:d gn dowry demand and the .";;;;";;;;;. rn )ther not be remore in port oi t_.'iioiilruty y$:i; r., ,ru it tmply that the interval should X#"r,o '20t3 (rj) scc olz '2025 INsc li67 of crl.a.No.583 2012 t2 j) However, the expression "soon before" should not be given a narrow meaning which would otheMise defeat the very purpose of lhe provisions of the Act and should not lead to absurd results. k) Section 3048 is an exception to the cardinal principles of criminal jurisprudence that a suspect in the lndian Law is entitled to the protection of Article 20 of the Constitution, as well as, a presumption of innocence in his favour. The concept of deeming fictron is hardly apphcable to criminal jurisprudence but in contradistinctron to this aspect of criminal law, the legislature applied the concept of deeming fiction to the provisions of Section l) Such deeming fiction resulting in a presumption is, however, a rebuttable presumption and the husband and his relatives, can, by leading their defence prove that the ingredients of Section 3048 were not satisfied. m) The specific srgnificance to be attached is to the time of the alleged cruelty and harassment to which the victim was subjected to, the time of her death and whether the alleged demand of dowry was in connection with the marriage. Once the said ingredients were satrsfied it wrll be called dowry death and by deemed fiction of law the husband or the relatives will be deemed to have commifted that offence." o) ln the present case, the marriage of deceased with the accused was performed on 25.12.2008, the death occurred on 13.09.2010 i.e. within seven years of marriage. There are incidents of harassment by the husband for want of additional dowry. The deceased was sent to her parental home for want of additional dowry. She was convinced by her parents and sent back to the matrimonial house, after which the said incident of committing suicide occurred. The cause of death is due to asphyxia from hanging, as elicited from the PME report given by PWg. thus, the death occurred under other than t1 Crl.A-No.683 2012 natural circumstances. Thus, all the circumstar :es prove the ingredients under Section 304-8 of lpC. p) Hence, the prosecution could prove the rffence under Section 304-8 of lPC, and a presumption under iection 113-B of the Evidence Act is raised against the accuser lt is for him to rebut the presumption, but no evidence u/as e( duced by the accused in his defence. However, the appellarr counsel has argued that the harassment soon before her Ceath is not proved by the prosecution. There is no streright j tcket formula as to what would constitute the period of .sort r before her death". There is ample evidence on recorrj to s row that the deceased was driven out of the house for wan: of addiilonal dowry, for which reason she was staying at lrer p,a.ents, house. The evidence of PWs 1 to 4 shows that she vyas er1 her parental house, as she was necked out by the accused, tnd that she was convinced by her parents and sent back to the rnatrimonial home. After sending her back to the matrimr:nial rome, within 15 to 20 days, they received a call thrat th r deceased committed suicide by hanging. crl.A.No.683_2012 q) The evidence of PW5, the house owner, also throws light upon the fact that there was a quarrel between the wife and husband, and that he warned the accused that they had to vacate the house in case such an incident was repeated r) There is no explanation offered by the accused for the death of the deceased, in his own home, and there is ample evidence regarding the harassment made by the accused for want of additional dowry. There was no other person at home apart from the accused and their infant son at the relevant time. It is also evident that she was driven out of the house and sent back to her parental home and that she was sent back to the accused just 15 days prior to her death. Thus it is proved that she was subjected to cruelty for want of additional dowry. Hence, the offence under Section 304-8 of IPC against the accused is proved beyond reasonable doubt by the prosecution. Point No.1 is answered accordingly 12. POINT NO.2: a) ln view of the finding arrived at point No.1, it is held that the trial Court has rightly convicted the accused. Crl.A.No.58l 2012 b) With regard to sentence, the learned ccrr I'lSel for the appellant has submitted that the appellant ir; mitl lie aged and has prayed to consider his case in a len ent v ay so as to reduce the quantum of sentence. He also proint<: I out that the appellant has been roaming around the Cotrrts fc'.the past 15 years and therefore, he has been facing mental t carcerate for 15 years. c) Considering the above said submissiors, it s opined that the sentence can be reduced to seven years to I eet the ends of justice. Point No 2 is answered accordingly 13. POINT NO.3: ln the result, the Criminal Appeal is partly , rllowed. The conviction of the appellant - accused for the < ffence under Section 304-8 of IPC is confirmed. Howt:ver he sentence imposed for the offence under Section 304-Ei of lr C is modified and reduced to seven years of rigorous irnprisc nment, while confirming the fine amount with default se'l ence. The appellant - accused shall be entitled to set-off t nder Section 428 Cr.P.C. for the period of detention, if any, already undergone. Crl.A.No.6a3-2012 l6 As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any filed in this appeal, shall stand closed. SD/. M.MANJULA JOINT REGISTRAR G //TRUE COPY// SECTION OFFICER To, '1 . The I Additional Sessions Judge, Adilabad.(with records, if any) 2. The Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Adilabad. 3. The Superintendent, Central Prison, Warangal, Warangal District. 4. Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT] 5 One CC to Sri S. Surender Reddy, Advocate [OPUC] 6. Two CD Copies KAM/PSL AW HIGH COURT DATED: 0210412026 (i JUDGMENT i'- 1EI..,i, )' 't!" CRLA.No.683 of 2012 t o LL \.^k (\ S\ .t, 'i-.\ )t i nI .(! ^! H iil PARTLY ALLOWING THE CRIMINAL APPEAL q \b 4. th *

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Telangana HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →