Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NOTE:- The Accused was directed to be released on bail by the order of the
High Court dated 23-11-2018 in t.A.No.2 of 2018 in Crl.RC. No.
3176 of 2018.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 3'17 6 0F 20't8
Criminal Revision Case filed under Section 397 and 401 of CrpC against
the judgment dated 15.10.2018 in Crl. Appeal No. 77 of 2018 on the file of the
Court of the lV District and Sessions, Judge at (F T.C) Nagar Kurnool preferred
against the judgment dated 14-05-2018 in CC.No. 480 of 2O17 on the file of the
Court of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Special Mobile Court,
Nagarkurnool.
Between:
Shaik Dada Kalandar Vali, R/o. Door No-6-32 Opp. Sri Sathya Sai General
Hospital, Main Road, Puttaparthy, Ananthapoor District.
...PETITIONER/APPELLANT/ACCUSED
AND
I
. Kondur Alivelamma Wo Madhusudhan Shetty,
age
Nagarkurnool Village, and Mandal, Temporary R/o.
55 years,
Puttaparty,
Wanaparty
R/o.
and
...RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT
2. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor High Court, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
Counsel for the Petitioner: Sri S. M. Rafee
Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: Sri Venkatesh Ediga
Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: Sri Jithender Rao Veramalla, Addl. PP
The Court made the following: ORDER
EfO,J
J
Crl.R.C. No.3176 of 2016
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA
CRIMINAL REVIS!ON CASE No.3176 of 2018
Date:23.01.2026
Between:
Shaik Dada Kalandar Vali
.
Petitioner/AppellanUAccused
And
Kondur Alivelamma Wo.Madhusudhan Shetty,
and another
... Respondents
ORDER:
This Criminal Revision Case is filed by the petitioner aggrieved
by the ju,lgment dated '15.10.2018 passed in Crl.A. No.77 of 2018 by
the lV r\dditional District & Sessions Judge at Nagar Kurnool,
whereby the appeal is dismissed.
2. Heard Sri S.M. Rafee, learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri
Venkataiah Ediga, learned counsel for the respondent No.1 and Sri
Jithender Rao Veeramalla, learned Additional Public Prosecutor
appearirg for respondent No.2-State.
ETD,J
Crl.R.C. No.3176 of 2018
3. The case of the complainant before the trial court is that the
complainant and the petitioner-accused are acquainted with each
other and that the accused has approached the complainant and
borrowed an amount of Rs.17.00 lakhs for his business purpose by
mortgaging his immovable property and that, to avoid the stamp duty
on the mortgage deed, it was registered for Rs.4,76,000/- and for the
remaining amount of Rs.12,24,0001- , the accused has issued four
cheques bearing Nos.650414, dated 18.09.2009, 650415, dated
31.05.2010, 650416, dated 18.06.2010 for Rs.3.00 lakhs each and
cheque No.650417 dated 18.12.2010 for Rs.3,24,000/-. The said
details are narrated in an agreement dated 17.06.2009 executed by .
the accused. lt is the case of the complainant that the first cheque
bearing No.650414 for an amount of Rs.3.00 lakhs and the interest
over the total principle amount up to August, 2009 was realized and
thereafter the accused did not pay the amount. The cheque bearing
No.650416, dated 18.06.2010 was deposited by the complainant and
the same was returned by the bank for the reason 'funds insufficient'.
The cheque return memo was issued on 20.07.2010. Thus, the
complainant has issued legal notice dated 17.08.2010, which
was received by the accused and the accused has issued a
reg[_notice and denied the transaction with dishonest intention.
Therefore, the complaint under Section 138 of Nl Act has
EfD,J
ctl,R.c, No.3176 0l 20la
been filed by the complainant. The trial court, after a full-fledged
trial, has convicted the accused sentencing him to undergo simple
imprisonment for six months and to pay Rs.3.00 lakhs i'e the
cheque anlount as compensation and on payment of Rs'3'00 lakhs
by the acr:used, the same shall be paid to the complainant under
Section 357 Cr.P.C. Aggrieved by the said judgment of conviction,
the accus,=d has preferred an appeal vide Crl.A. No.77 of 2018 and
the appellate court dismissed the appeal, confirming the judgment of
convictior, delivered by the trial court. Aggrieved by the said
judgment of the appellate court, the present revision case is filed'
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that there
are man)/ discrepancies in the cheque put forth by the complainant
and that Ex.P1 is signed in Telugu, but all the contents are filled in
English, which means to say that the contents are filled subsequently
by the complainant. He further submitted that the accused has taken
loan of fts.4.00 lakhs from the husband of the complainant and has
repaid the same. But, misusing the cheque given by him' the present
case has been filed by the complainant. He further submitted that
the conrplainant is a housewife and a housewife lending an amount
of Rs.1-2.00 lakhs is highly improbable. He further submitted that he
issued a cheque only for Rs.3.00 lakhs but not for Rs.'17.00 lakhs.
ETD,J
Crl.R.C. No.3176 ol 2018
The registered mortgage deed under Ex.D1 also does not mention
the amount of Rs.17.00 lakhs, and therefore issuance of cheques for
Rs.17.00 lakhs would not arise. lf Ex.p5 i.e. agreement executed by
the accused is considered, it would be proved that there is no legally
enforceable debt to be paid by the revision petitioner. lf the
executant of the agreement under Ex.ps has denied its very
execution, then it was the duty of the complainant to examine the
witnesses, but the here the cornplainant failed to get them examined.
Therefore, an adverse inference must have been drawn by the trial
court holding that Ex.PS is not proved. Though the accused has
admitted the signature on the cheque, it is his case that he has
repaid the amount under the cheque, but the husband of the de facto
complainant has failed to return him the cheque. He further argued
that the accused has given four cheques, one of which was
honoured and he has also produced rebuttal evidence of pw.1 and
has also got marked Ex.D1. Thus, through the rebuttal evidence of
PW.1 and Ex.D1 he could prove his case before the trial court, but
the trial court failed to apply the legal principles and has convicted
the accused. Even the appellate court failed to consider the merits
in the case of the accused and has erroneousry confirmed the
judgment of the trial court. He, therefore, prayed to set aside the
judgment of conviction passed against the revision petitioner by the
A
ETD,J
ctl.R-c. No.3176 oI 201E
trial court, which was confirmed by the appellate court' He
relied
upon the follcwing decisions:
i. Avon Organics Limited, Hyderabad v' Pioneer Products
Limited New Delhi and othersr;
ii. Rosammal lssetheenamma! Fernandez v' Joosa
Mariyan Fernandez and others2 and
iii. M.S. Narayana Menon v. State of Kerala3
5. t.earned counsel for the respondent No'1 has submitted
that the trial court as well as the appellate court has rightly
appreciatec the evidence on record and have convicted the accused.
The accusied having received the amount and having issued the
cheques, 'ailed to honour them. Further, he has also executed the
agreement and is speaking against the agreement, which is bad in
the eye of law. When the cheque issued by the accused got
dishonoured, the complainant got issued a legal notice to which the
accused has responded with a reply notice, but failed to pay the
amount. Therefore, the ingredients under Section 138 of Nl Act got
proved before the trial court and hence, the trial court has rightly
convicter! the accused and the same was rightly confirmed by the
appellate court and therefore, he prayed to uphold the judgment of
' 2oo3 (2)AL) (crr.(2ig (aP)
' (2ooo) 7 scc t8g
' (2006) 6 scc a9
(
ETD,J
Crl.R.C. No.3176 ot 2O1A
conviction passed by the trial court, which was confirmed
by the
appellate court by dismissing the petition.
6. Perused the record
7. The case of the complainant is that she has lent an amount
of Rs.17 -00lakhs to the accused, in pursuance of which the accused
has issued four cheques and has arso executed an agreement
dated
17.06.2009. one of the cheques was honoured and remaining three
cheques were dishonoured. The present case is filed owing to
the
dishonour of the cheque bearing No.650416 dated 1g.06.2010
issued for Rs.3.00 lakhs. when the said cheque was presented
in
the bank, it was dishonoured for the reason ,funds insufficient' and
a
cheque return memo was issued by the Bank on zo.ol.2o1o,
pursuant to which the complainant has issued a legat notice
on
17.08-2010. lnspite of receiving the notice, the accused has failed
to
pay the amount under the cheque. Therefore, the complainant
filed
the present case vide CC No.4g0 of 2017.
8. Before the trial court, the complainant got examined as
PW.1. she has reiterated the contents of complaint in her chief
examination. she was cross-examined at length. The only points
whr$ are relevant for consideration in the cross-examination of
EfO,J
Cd.R.C. No.3176 ol m18
PW.1 are ttrat she has admitted that Ex.PS discloses that she has
received inlerest and that the accused has executed a mortgage
deed in her favour vide document No.879 of 2009, dated 07'03'2009
in the office of Sub-Registrar, Bukkapatnam, for an amount of
Rs.4,76,000/-. She denied the suggestion that except receiving the
loan under the above said mortgage, the accused has not obtained
any other trand loan from her. lt is elicited from her that the alleged
amount was given by her from the savings of their joint family
tncome.
9. During the course of arguments, the counsel for the
revision petitioner has vehemently argued that the accused has
denied execution Ex.P5 and that the complainant failed to bring the
evidence of the attesting witnesses, as such, Ex.PS is not proved.
But, in the cross-examination of PW.1, a suggestion is made by the
defence counsel that the accused did not repay the amount of
Rs.4.76,000/- as such for a period of two years along with interest,
the total amount is calculated to Rs.17.00 lakhs and that forcibly
PW.1 got executed Ex.P5 in her favour. The said suggestion was
denied by PW.1. Thus, indirectly, the accused is admitting execution
of Ex.P€,, but denies the purpose for which it was executed. The
l0
ETD.J
Ctt.RC. No.31t6 of z|;s
above said suggestion made by the counsel
for the petitioner to
PW.1 defeats the said contention
10. Further, it is pertinent to observe here that
his evidence as DW.1 has admitted issuance
of cheque under Ex.p1
and also stated that he has received Rs.4.00
from the husband of the complainant and
the accused in
lakhs towards roan
that on 10.01 .2oog in his
account of state Bank of Hyderabad, Nagarkurnoor
husband of the complainant has deposited
Rs.4.00 lakhs and that he
has withdrawn the said amount from his bank
stated that on 07.03.200g he has mortgaged
account. He has arso
the property for a tune
of Rs.4,76,000/- in favour of the comprainant and
principle amount and also interest of
Branch, the
that it incrudes the
Rs.76,000/-. lt is further elicited
from his evidence that Ex.p5 was executed
on 17.06.2009 towards
the interest on the amount of Rs.4,76,000/- and
agreement arso discroses that another two years
given for repaying the loan amount. Further,
the amount mentioned in Ex.ps incrudes the
that the said
time period was
DW.1 has added that
toan amount, its interest
and also the rents in advance which is payable
by him to pw.1 for
occupying the property of the husband of pw.1.
DW.1 has admitted
that in Ex.Dl it is mentioned that for his
famdy needs, he has obtained the loan.
business purpose and for
He further admitted that on
t.
/
ll
ETO,J
Cd.R.C. No.3176 ol 201E
the second page of Ex.P5 agreement dated 17.06.2009, it is clearly
mentioned that a loan of Rs.17.OO lakhs is received and under the
guise of m,:rtgage deed, the amount is reduced to Rs.4,76,000/- only
to avoid tl^re registration fees and also for the remaining amount of
Rs.12,24,000/- four cheques are being issued. The numbers of the
said checlues are also mentioned as Cheque No.650414 for
Rs.3,00,000/-, Cheque No.650415 for Rs.3,00,000/-, Cheque
No.65041,3 for Rs.3,00,000/- and cheque No.650417 for
Rs.3,24,000/- and that in the agreement itself, it is clearly mentioned
as to when the above cheques have to be presented in the bank.
Though he stated that in his bank statement-Ex.D2, his name is not
reflecting, he added that the statement stands on his bank account
number.
11. DW.1 has also admitted that he has received Ex.P3 by
acknowledging the same under Ex.P4. Ex.P3 is nothing but the legal
notice and Ex.P4 is its acknowledgment. Though he stated that he
has issued a reply notice, he has not filed the same before the trial
court. ,A perusal of the agreement under Ex.PS reveals that the
accusecl has taken a loan of Rs.17.00 lakhs and that the mortgage
deed is executed only for Rs.4,76,000/- to avoid registration charges
and that apart from the amount mentioned under the mortgage
l2
ETO,J
Crl.R.C. No.3tt6 of 2O1A
deed, he is due to an amount of Rs.12,24,000/issued cheques bearing Nos.650414,6s0415,
and that he has
650416 and 6so411
to realize the same. Further, as discussed supra,
he has indirecfly
admitted execution of Ex.p5 agreement. Nowhere
in his cross_
examination, the accused denied execution
of Ex.p5 but has
admitted its recitars. Therefore, it is proved
by the comprainant
before the trial court that the accused has issued
a cheque and on
its presentation, the cheque was returned due to
insufficient funds
and though a statutory notice was issued to the
accused, he has
failed to repay the amount under the said cheque.
ingredients under section 13g of the Nr Act
Therefore, the
are satisfied and it is
proved that the cheques were issued towards
legaily enforceable
debt. DW.l having admitted that he has taken .loan and issued
cheques in discharge of the said loan, he cannot
say that there was no regaily enforceabre debt and
turn around and
further he cannot
doubt the source of funds and the capacity of the
comprainant to
extend the hand roan. once the ingredients of section
13g of Nr Act
are satisfied, a presumption under section 13g of Nl
involved in favour of the comprainant. sections 13g
Act gets
and 139 of the
Nl Act are extracted hereunder for the sake of reference:
"138. Dishonour of cheque for insufficiency, etc., of funds
in the account.-
\..
ri
t3
ETO,J
Crl.R.C. No.3176 of 2018
Wherer any cheque drawn by a person on an account
maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of
moner/ to another person from out of that account for the
disch;rrge, in whole or in part, of any debt or other liability, is
returned by the bank unpaid, either because of the amount of
money standing to the credit of that account is insufficient to
honour the cheque or that it exceeds the amount arranged to be
paid lrom that account by an agreement made with that bank,
such person shall be deemed to have committed an offence
and shall, without prejudice to any other provisions of this Act,
be punished with imprisonment for a term which may be
exterded to two years, or with fine which may extend to twice
the amount of the cheque, or with both:
Provided that nothing contained in this section shall apply
unless(a) the cheque has been presented to the bank within a period
of si;< months from the date on which it is drawn or within the
peric,d of its validity, whichever is earlier;
I
(b) the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque, as the
I
c?S€, ffioy be, makes a demand for the payment of the said
amount of money by giving a notice in writing, to the drawer of
the oheque, [within thirty days of the receipt of information by
him from the bank regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid;
and
(c) the drawer of such cheque fails to make the payment of the
said amount of money to the payee or, as the case may be, to
the holder in due course of the cheque, within fifteen days of
the receipt of the said notice.
139. Presumption in favour of holder.-
It shall be presumed, unless the contrary is proved, that the
holrler of a cheque received the cheque of the nature referred
J
:
!
I
I
l4
ETD.J
Crl.R.C. No.3tt6 ot 20ia
to in section 13g for the discharge, in whore
or in part, of any
debt or other liability.',
12. since ail the above ingredients under
Act are fulfiiled as per the evidence adduced
burden shifts to the accused to rebut
complainant. The accused got examined
marked Exs.Dl and D2. As discussed
by the comprainant,
the evidence of the
himself as DW.1 and got
supra, DW.1 has admitted
the issuance of cheque under Ex.pl, agreement
also receipt of legal notice by him under
under Ex.Dl shows that he has obtained
business and famity needs. Therefore,
section 13g of Nr
under Ex.p5 and
Ex.p3. The document
loan for the purpose of his
the accused courd not prove
that it is not a regaily enforceabre debt. Thus,
the presumption under
Section 139 of Nl Act stood unrebutted.
13- Learned counser for the petitioner has reried
decision of the High court of Judicature
upon the
of Andhra pradesh at
Hyderabad in Avon organics Limited, Hyderabad
v. pioneer
Products Limited New Derhi and others (1
supra), wherein the
High court has held that if a person delivers
the cheque without
putting the actuar amount payabre, it
does not constitute a cheque
within the meaning of Section 5 and 6 of the
Nl Act and that if
consent is not given for which the amount was
being drawn, it
t
t5
ETD,J
Crl.R.C. No.3176 ol 2018
amounts to material alteration and cannot be enforced even though if
it is issued for legal liability.
14. llelying on the said citation, the learned counsel for the
petitioner has contended that it is borne out by record that the
cheque is signed by the accused in Telugu while the recitals are in
English, hence it should be inferred that the contents were filled up
later on, by the complainant and so the blank cheque does not
constitute ar cheque within the meaning of Section 5 and 6 of Nl Act.
ln the presr:nt case, accused got examined himself as DW.1 and has
admitted the issuance of cheque and also execution of agreement
under Ex.F'S with regard to loan taken from the complainant. Having
admitted the issuance of cheque and the details of loan taken, now
he cannot deny his liability under the cheque. Therefore, the above
cited decision cannot be applied to the present case.
15. Learned counsel for the petitioner has further relied upon
the deci:;ion of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Rosammal
lssetheenamma! Fernandez v. Joosa Mariyan Fernandez and
others (2 supra) wherein it was held that when an execution of
document is specifically denied, the finding must be reached after
taking intc, consideration the pleadings of the parties and that such a
finding must be clear and specific and should not be drawn vaguely,
,/
t6
ETD,J
Cd.F-C. No.3176 ot ZO|O
negatively or casually. The contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioner is that the accused denied the execution of Ex.p5 and
that
the trial court and the appellate court failed to appreciate the same.
ln the present case, the accused himself has admitted the execution
of Ex.P5. Therefore, there exists no doubt on its execution.
Therefore, the above case law does not apply to the case on hand.
16. He further has relied upon the decision of the M.s.
Narayana Menon v. state of Kerala (3 supra), wherein it was held
that for rebutting the presumption under section 139 read with 11g of
Nl Act what is needed is to raise a probable defence and for the said
purpose even the evidence adduced on behalf of the comptainant
can be relied upon and the standard of proof would be
preponderance of probabilities. ln the present case, the accused
failed to discharge the burden even on preponderance of
probabilities. His defence is that he has issued a btank cheque and
that it is not at all a cheque under the Nt Act, but he has admitted the
issuance of cheque and also the details of the loan taken by him, its
purpose and further the agreement under Ex.ps, in his evidence.
Therefore, the said contention raised in his defence is not proved.
Another contention is that he has not executed Ex.p5 which is an
agreement wherein the details of the loan taken and the cheques
I
,/
EfD,J
t7
C .RC. No.3176 oI 2018
issued by the accused in favour of the complainant are mentioned.
The defendant has admitted the execution of the said document in
his evidence. Once he has admitted the issuance of cheque and
also the existence of loan under Ex.PS, he could not discharge his
burden under 139 under 118 of the Nl Act. ln other wards he has
strengtherred the case of the complainant satisfying all the
ingredient:; of Section 138 of Nl Act. Therefore, the revision
petitioner could not make out any grounds to throw away the case of
the complainant-respondent No.1 herein. Hence, the revision petition
lacks merrt and the same is liable to be dismissed
17. ln the result, the Criminal Revision Case is dismissed
confirminJ; the judgment dated 15.10.2018 passed in Crl.A. No.77 of
2018 by the lV Additional District & Sessions Judge at Nagar
Kurnool, lMahabubnagar District.
Mis;cellaneous Petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.
SD/. N.CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy ro the Hon,ble SMT. JUSTICE TIRUMALA
DEVI EADA
(Forher Ladyships kind
perusal)
-- --'-'t
To,
1. The lV District and Sessions, Judge at (F.T.C) Nagar Kurnool
2- The Judk;ial Magistrate of First crass, speciar Mobire court, Nagarkurnoor
3. 11 LR Cc.pies
i/
4. The Under Secretary, Union of lndia Ministry of Law, Justice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi
5. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association Library, High Court for the
State of Telangana, High Court Buildings at Hyderabad.
6. Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderabad [OUT]
7. One CC to Sri S. M. Rafee, Advocate tOpUCI
B. One CC to Sri Venkatesh Ediga, Advocate tOpUCl
9. Two CD Copies
VH/PSL
w
I
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2310112026
I
\
rr'-i SI
aft
I
a.
o
()
[?
*
ORDER
CRLRC.No.3176 ot 2018
DISMISSING THE CRL.R.C.
b
,18
d\
te
AT
lt,i$ fllh
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review